Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law" - Telegraph article share

290 replies

singthing · Yesterday 07:46

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

Baroness Cass has turned against Labour’s plans for a new conversion therapy law, warning that it would have a “chilling effect” on doctors.

Lady Cass, who led a review of the treatment of children with gender dysphoria, previously backed the Conversion Practices Bill but said she had only been given an hour to read the draft legislation before providing a supportive comment for a government press release in June.

On Monday, she told MPs that she regretted backing it, and having read it through now thought it could have “serious unintended consequences”.
...

Continues at:
^Original: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/16/baroness-cass-turns-against-chilling-trans-law/^
Gift: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2
^Archive: https://archive.ph/rP3Np^

Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
singthing · Yesterday 07:48

Shocking railroading behaviour by the Minister:

“I was trying to be as helpful as I could to the then minister. I had said I wouldn’t comment until I’d seen it. It was sent to me an hour before they wanted a press release and 15 minutes before I walked on the platform to give a talk.

“So I tried to give the quotes based on the principles that I’ve been told about but without seeing the bill as drafted, and maybe I shouldn’t have done that.”

OP posts:
Emilesgran · Yesterday 07:54

I knew there’d be a thread about this! Thanks @singthing

I can’t work out what Baroness Cass is playing at - she seems to be all over the place on this.

Did she think she could find a middle of the road position that would placate the TRAs while remaining scientifically and intellectually honest? (I think we all knew that couldnt be done)

Or was she so intimidated by their fury at the Cas review that she then spent the next months trying to row back a bit, in particular by approving the trial and also the anti conversion bill?

And if so, how much will she be able to hold the line now?

Seriestwo · Yesterday 08:04

I think she believed the activists were acting in good faith. And then got scared by their threats. And now thinks “both sides”

she is a disappointment, but I’m going ahead killed the bill yesterday.

BlueLegume · Yesterday 08:20

No one wants conversion therapy because we know it is wrong. Pondering the title of the new draft bill I wonder if whoever proposed it thought the title would immediately garner support purely because it is something we all agree is wrong. It really is a Trojan Horse for me to bring in very sinister ideas and very much detrimental to good parents and caregivers.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · Yesterday 08:23

She was on the Today programme on Radio 4 this morning saying the same. Cass had to correct Nick Robinson when he mixed up sex & gender identity & he apologised for the mistake after the interview.

I think that she believes there are a small number of "true trans" children with persistent gender dysphoria who might benefit from medical & surgical transition. That belief is not inconsistent with opposition to the Conversion Practices Bill.

Chersfrozenface · Yesterday 08:25

On the BBC News site as well.

"Cass report author says she does not support draft conversion practices bill"

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6m25vd2yxgdo

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 08:26

singthing · Yesterday 07:48

Shocking railroading behaviour by the Minister:

“I was trying to be as helpful as I could to the then minister. I had said I wouldn’t comment until I’d seen it. It was sent to me an hour before they wanted a press release and 15 minutes before I walked on the platform to give a talk.

“So I tried to give the quotes based on the principles that I’ve been told about but without seeing the bill as drafted, and maybe I shouldn’t have done that.”

Anyone else think she's unhappy at having been put in this position? I wonder if she will ever learn how underhand and dishonest trans activists can be.

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 08:28

Emilesgran · Yesterday 07:54

I knew there’d be a thread about this! Thanks @singthing

I can’t work out what Baroness Cass is playing at - she seems to be all over the place on this.

Did she think she could find a middle of the road position that would placate the TRAs while remaining scientifically and intellectually honest? (I think we all knew that couldnt be done)

Or was she so intimidated by their fury at the Cas review that she then spent the next months trying to row back a bit, in particular by approving the trial and also the anti conversion bill?

And if so, how much will she be able to hold the line now?

Or maybe she isn't playing at anything and is simply stating what happened?

She doesn't want appalling conversion therapy practices to be legal and when she was presented the bill she wasn't given enough time to read it properly? On the face of it it says it will only criminalise abuse but it takes a closer reading to realise that abuse is not actually defined and then further thought to consider what bad faith actors will do with the bill.

BlueLegume · Yesterday 08:32

Good for her. It is perfectly acceptable to do further research at the draft stage of a bill and come back with a more educated opinion.

She has seen the reality.

Shedmistress · Yesterday 08:38

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 08:26

Anyone else think she's unhappy at having been put in this position? I wonder if she will ever learn how underhand and dishonest trans activists can be.

You'd think the death threats might have sharpened her senses but no.

And who produces an official comment after 15 minutes of reading a new bill that could become law? A new fucking law! That could literally put herself in jail!

Fucking awesome work.

BlueLegume · Yesterday 09:29

You can watch the meeting on parliamentlive.tv

Draft Conversion Practices Bill (Joint Committee)
Monday 16 November 2026 Meeting started at 4.18pm, ended 5.56pm

Worth looking at.

https://www.parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/639bab90-c676-40d1-b822-8590848568e3

singthing · Yesterday 09:30

BlueLegume · Yesterday 08:32

Good for her. It is perfectly acceptable to do further research at the draft stage of a bill and come back with a more educated opinion.

She has seen the reality.

I would love to see her in a discussion with Professor Sir Robert Winston. That would be fascinating, educational and highly qualified commentary.

OP posts:
Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 09:31

Emilesgran · Yesterday 07:54

I knew there’d be a thread about this! Thanks @singthing

I can’t work out what Baroness Cass is playing at - she seems to be all over the place on this.

Did she think she could find a middle of the road position that would placate the TRAs while remaining scientifically and intellectually honest? (I think we all knew that couldnt be done)

Or was she so intimidated by their fury at the Cas review that she then spent the next months trying to row back a bit, in particular by approving the trial and also the anti conversion bill?

And if so, how much will she be able to hold the line now?

Yes, she's very confused:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6m25vd2yxgdo

Hilary Cass looks directly into the camera. She is wearing blue glasses and a blue necklace and has dark curly hair

Cass report author says she does not support draft conversion practices bill

The gender care review author says the bill’s wording risks "serious unintended consequences" for parents and therapists.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6m25vd2yxgdo

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 09:32

Shedmistress · Yesterday 08:38

You'd think the death threats might have sharpened her senses but no.

And who produces an official comment after 15 minutes of reading a new bill that could become law? A new fucking law! That could literally put herself in jail!

Fucking awesome work.

My thoughts exactly.

teawamutu · Yesterday 09:44

Seriestwo · Yesterday 08:04

I think she believed the activists were acting in good faith. And then got scared by their threats. And now thinks “both sides”

she is a disappointment, but I’m going ahead killed the bill yesterday.

Killed the bill?

Imnobody4 · Yesterday 09:47

I think she's very naive about politicians. She trusted what they claimed about the bill. She seems pretty angry about the fact they railroaded, her basically lied to her.
I hope she's killed the damn thing.

Iamnotalemming · Yesterday 09:47

I am pleased that she has seen the light (on this at least) and corrected the record. Her initial support on the principle of "conversion practices are bad", and then change of heart when seeing the actual draft and thinking about it, reflects where most people are on this. Her high profile increases the sunlight.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 09:47

Well, I think she is brave. I think she's doing her best to be fair, while getting grief from all sides. And I think she is doing what she thinks right. It is VERY hard to hold to that while under pressure.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 09:51

To err is human, and it has taken courage to say in public, on record, when it matters, that the bill is not good and she can't support it. The fact that she is so honest actually helps our case, too - she can't be accused of being partisan or having a knee jerk reaction. She thought she would support it, until she looked carefully at the detail and considered it.

I think that's a good metaphor for how many people think about 'gender' issues.

On the face of it they seem sort of reasonable, because activists have been careful to present the easiest arguments couched in rainbow flags, emotive language, and truisms. As soon as anyone actually looks under the bonnet, it becomes apparent that the problems are rife and the glaring holes in the logic are actively dangerous.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 09:57

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 09:51

To err is human, and it has taken courage to say in public, on record, when it matters, that the bill is not good and she can't support it. The fact that she is so honest actually helps our case, too - she can't be accused of being partisan or having a knee jerk reaction. She thought she would support it, until she looked carefully at the detail and considered it.

I think that's a good metaphor for how many people think about 'gender' issues.

On the face of it they seem sort of reasonable, because activists have been careful to present the easiest arguments couched in rainbow flags, emotive language, and truisms. As soon as anyone actually looks under the bonnet, it becomes apparent that the problems are rife and the glaring holes in the logic are actively dangerous.

I suppose my issue with the way she has approached this, is that it is her job to "look under the bonnet" before she opens her mouth and issues a statement about said subjects. If people didn't want her professional opinion, they wouldn't ask her. And, to my mind, her response was not "professional" - it was rushed and unconsidered.

I hope she has not approached the puberty blockers clinical trial in the same way.

ed. sp. pubert? who's Pubert?

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 10:00

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 08:26

Anyone else think she's unhappy at having been put in this position? I wonder if she will ever learn how underhand and dishonest trans activists can be.

According to the Times she was pissed off with the government citing her support as reasons to dismiss all the hazards. So presumably felt she had to go on record. And good for her. So many of us got caught up in supporting seemingly reasonable demands only to discover the crock of shit underneath,

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 10:04

I can't see how the Bill can survive her withdrawing support, surely? She has to be one of the pre eminent people whose views hold sway?

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 10:09

I agree that Cass is coming from the premise that there are a tiny number of 'true trans' children. I can even countenance that being true. But the issue is that the number would be so very fucking tiny that it would not in a million years justify having whole services set up to deal with the - what, 80%? - of gender incongruent children who are going through a phase, who are autistic, gay/lesbian, abuse victims, or just plain gender non-conforming, who then desist.

The thought that children will be sterilised, maimed, mutilated, and have co morbidities brushed aside and ignored, in order to ensure that the absolutely miniscule number of 'true trans' children are given puberty blockers, when this may not even be the best choice for those 'true trans' chidlren, given what we have seen with other people who were treated in or during puberty, is just mental. Absolutely mental.

You cannot cause that much potential harm in order to potentially ameliorate that little amount of harm.

Strength of feeling does not strengthen an argument, no matter how much trans activists would like to think it does.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · Yesterday 10:10

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 10:04

I can't see how the Bill can survive her withdrawing support, surely? She has to be one of the pre eminent people whose views hold sway?

If the Bill had a carve out so healthcare professionals & parents could not be criminalised it could still go ahead but the sort of practises indulged in by religious nutjobs who attempt to convert gay people are already illegal so this Bill is redundant.

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 10:10

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 08:28

Or maybe she isn't playing at anything and is simply stating what happened?

She doesn't want appalling conversion therapy practices to be legal and when she was presented the bill she wasn't given enough time to read it properly? On the face of it it says it will only criminalise abuse but it takes a closer reading to realise that abuse is not actually defined and then further thought to consider what bad faith actors will do with the bill.

"She doesn't want appalling conversion therapy practices to be legal"

Which "conversion therapy practices" are actually legal?