Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law" - Telegraph article share

290 replies

singthing · Yesterday 07:46

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

Baroness Cass has turned against Labour’s plans for a new conversion therapy law, warning that it would have a “chilling effect” on doctors.

Lady Cass, who led a review of the treatment of children with gender dysphoria, previously backed the Conversion Practices Bill but said she had only been given an hour to read the draft legislation before providing a supportive comment for a government press release in June.

On Monday, she told MPs that she regretted backing it, and having read it through now thought it could have “serious unintended consequences”.
...

Continues at:
^Original: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/16/baroness-cass-turns-against-chilling-trans-law/^
Gift: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2
^Archive: https://archive.ph/rP3Np^

Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
noblegiraffe · Yesterday 10:17

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 10:10

"She doesn't want appalling conversion therapy practices to be legal"

Which "conversion therapy practices" are actually legal?

You would assume that if there is a proposed bill saying that emotionally abusing a gay child until they say that they are straight should be illegal, then it isn’t already, wouldn’t you?

TheKeatingFive · Yesterday 10:24

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 10:04

I can't see how the Bill can survive her withdrawing support, surely? She has to be one of the pre eminent people whose views hold sway?

I hope you are right

singthing · Yesterday 10:29

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 09:57

I suppose my issue with the way she has approached this, is that it is her job to "look under the bonnet" before she opens her mouth and issues a statement about said subjects. If people didn't want her professional opinion, they wouldn't ask her. And, to my mind, her response was not "professional" - it was rushed and unconsidered.

I hope she has not approached the puberty blockers clinical trial in the same way.

ed. sp. pubert? who's Pubert?

Edited

I also wonder if she is now looking more closely at the trial as well. She got hoodwinked on the Bill, so who's to say she wasn't equally deceived as to the purpose or details on the latter as well.

(aside from the fact as you state, it is her actual JOB to look closely at everything here)

OP posts:
ScrollingLeaves · Yesterday 10:31

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 10:09

I agree that Cass is coming from the premise that there are a tiny number of 'true trans' children. I can even countenance that being true. But the issue is that the number would be so very fucking tiny that it would not in a million years justify having whole services set up to deal with the - what, 80%? - of gender incongruent children who are going through a phase, who are autistic, gay/lesbian, abuse victims, or just plain gender non-conforming, who then desist.

The thought that children will be sterilised, maimed, mutilated, and have co morbidities brushed aside and ignored, in order to ensure that the absolutely miniscule number of 'true trans' children are given puberty blockers, when this may not even be the best choice for those 'true trans' chidlren, given what we have seen with other people who were treated in or during puberty, is just mental. Absolutely mental.

You cannot cause that much potential harm in order to potentially ameliorate that little amount of harm.

Strength of feeling does not strengthen an argument, no matter how much trans activists would like to think it does.

And, that hypothetical little boy, hypothetically transed by his parents when extremely young, who now aged 12 with puberty hitting him was hiding in his room, and had no way forward she suggested but to be given puberty blockers, might well in her mind be ‘true trans’.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 10:35

Yes, sure. The premise is horribly flawed. I think it's sick, in fact. But that is the story that has been spun, by innumerable activists, backed by well funded organisations, underwritten by the quacks and worse at WPATH.

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 10:39

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 10:17

You would assume that if there is a proposed bill saying that emotionally abusing a gay child until they say that they are straight should be illegal, then it isn’t already, wouldn’t you?

As someone who grew up gay with very anti-gay parents who thought being gay was awful and shameful, it's still not clear to me what you actually mean. Can you give some examples of "emotional abuse"? Why is it even a "conversion practice"? A parent who reacts negatively to his or her child coming out as gay may not necessarily be trying to convert the child to being straight. In fact, is unlikely to be. You have to show how "emotional abuse" - whatever that may be - is actually an attempt to change someone's sexuality.

Please - eventually! - give some actual, clear and specific examples of conversion practices that actually occur today. "Emotional abuse" is such a subjective concept. It would be rather extreme to send someone to prison for saying "I don't like gays" - which, again, isn't the same as trying to change someone's sexuality.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 10:42

There are many layers to uncover and look closely at. 'TWAW' is a lie wrapped up in many various stories that all need to be carefully examined and considered.

Sexism, greed (for profit and possibly for worse things), political ambition, social conditioning, blurring of boundaries, postmodern theory, a piggybacking on LGB issues and other movements (see 'intersectionalist feminism' as another movement co-opted by trans activists), jobsworths and other bureaucrats, emotional manipulation, disordered people, predators, misogynists, well meaning but unaware people, confused people, relatives of confused people.

And we have the Denton's document to see how they set out to do this and in many cases succeeded.

Strategy, longterm strategy.

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 10:45

BunnyBunbunbun · Yesterday 10:39

As someone who grew up gay with very anti-gay parents who thought being gay was awful and shameful, it's still not clear to me what you actually mean. Can you give some examples of "emotional abuse"? Why is it even a "conversion practice"? A parent who reacts negatively to his or her child coming out as gay may not necessarily be trying to convert the child to being straight. In fact, is unlikely to be. You have to show how "emotional abuse" - whatever that may be - is actually an attempt to change someone's sexuality.

Please - eventually! - give some actual, clear and specific examples of conversion practices that actually occur today. "Emotional abuse" is such a subjective concept. It would be rather extreme to send someone to prison for saying "I don't like gays" - which, again, isn't the same as trying to change someone's sexuality.

I'm not sure what you think I've said that means I'm an expert who can be questioned on this?

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 10:48

ScrollingLeaves · Yesterday 10:31

And, that hypothetical little boy, hypothetically transed by his parents when extremely young, who now aged 12 with puberty hitting him was hiding in his room, and had no way forward she suggested but to be given puberty blockers, might well in her mind be ‘true trans’.

Or, more honestly, she genuinely doesn't know what might be the best way to proceed for that poor child?

asert · Yesterday 10:48

she needs to stick to the science and stop trying to appease an impossible group of activists who will always want more, bigger best in their unquenchable thirst for validation.

Cantunseeit · Yesterday 11:05

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 10:17

You would assume that if there is a proposed bill saying that emotionally abusing a gay child until they say that they are straight should be illegal, then it isn’t already, wouldn’t you?

You know what they say about assuming- never do it, it makes an ass out of u and me

Dennis Kavannagh’s video provides a great summary of the existing law that already protects children from this type of practice

No one seems able to provide examples of any other acts that are currently legal and would become illegal because of this bill

So I think the saying holds true here - assuming anything of the kind would be unwise

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5599461-conversion-practices-video-guide-to-responding-before-deadline-on-monday?utm_campaign=thread&utm_medium=app_share

Conversion Practices Video Guide to responding before deadline on Monday | Mumsnet

Hey Mumsnet I've done a video guide with legal help for responding to the pre legislative scrutiny committee's call for evidence which closes Monday...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5599461-conversion-practices-video-guide-to-responding-before-deadline-on-monday?utm_campaign=thread&utm_medium=app_share

SchoolOfCool · Yesterday 11:06

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · Yesterday 08:23

She was on the Today programme on Radio 4 this morning saying the same. Cass had to correct Nick Robinson when he mixed up sex & gender identity & he apologised for the mistake after the interview.

I think that she believes there are a small number of "true trans" children with persistent gender dysphoria who might benefit from medical & surgical transition. That belief is not inconsistent with opposition to the Conversion Practices Bill.

Yes I agree with this.

I don't agree with her stance on true trans children (I think the root is always societal homophobia / sexist stereotypes; developmental environment; trauma; neurodiversity; etc) but I can accept her current opinion is held in good faith.

Tbh, the distinction between Cass's beliefs and mine is similar to the "nature Vs nurture and don't forget epigenetics" discussions around many mental health diagnoses.

DavyCrockettsWildFrontEar · Yesterday 11:07

I think @ArabellaScott is being characteristically generous and fair-minded. 😁Although I share other PP's frustration - whatever her motivation Cass should have been more bloody careful about commenting until she'd read the small print, FFS.

I really, really hope this kills the bill. I'm pessimistic, but I'd love someone to convince me I'm wrong...

BlueLegume · Yesterday 11:23

Olivia Bailey MP was pretty rattled yesterday. She proposed the bill and also sounds like she somewhat mislead Baroness Cass which prompted the original backing of the bill by Cass. I am really heartened that Cass has now reconsidered her initial response, has laid out clearly why she responded as she did - pressure from Bailey - and has clearly laid out the reality of this bill where children are involved.

My knowledge of Bailey is scant and frankly I find her insufferable but I would be interested to know who got to her and thought this bill was good. I am assuming Stonewall but am happy to be educated.

They could have had things going ok for them but they brought children into this.
I suspect Baileys passive aggressive questioning of Cass will be hailed as great debating by some. for me she behaved like a petulant child.

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 11:23

Cantunseeit · Yesterday 11:05

You know what they say about assuming- never do it, it makes an ass out of u and me

Dennis Kavannagh’s video provides a great summary of the existing law that already protects children from this type of practice

No one seems able to provide examples of any other acts that are currently legal and would become illegal because of this bill

So I think the saying holds true here - assuming anything of the kind would be unwise

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5599461-conversion-practices-video-guide-to-responding-before-deadline-on-monday?utm_campaign=thread&utm_medium=app_share

Well that’s what I mean. If parliamentarians are telling you that an anti-conversion bill is needed to stop gay children being abused into thinking they’re straight, and that other countries are also implementing this, you would kind of think they know what they are talking about, wouldn’t you? Because it would be super weird to be fighting to introduce a wholly unnecessary bill.

I think it is fine for your first instinct to be ‘yes, that sounds like something that children need protection from’ rather than ‘that sounds like an evil plot OR you don’t know what you’re talking about’

And then it’s also fine to change your mind after hearing from people who do know what they’re talking about. We can’t all be experts on everything and we can’t always do everyone else’s jobs for them.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 11:27

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 10:48

Or, more honestly, she genuinely doesn't know what might be the best way to proceed for that poor child?

She lied about the “poor child” - it didn’t exist.

Furthermore she claimed that a child in that situation would be beyond psychological or psychiatric help - too far gone to persuade them that their parents’ abusive behaviour was in fact abusive.

I cannot imagine any other situation where a medical professional would simply throw their hands up and say “well, these parents have utterly broken this child’s mind, we may as well let them finish it by breaking their body too” instead of immediately removing the child from the parents’ care.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 11:29

SchoolOfCool · Yesterday 11:06

Yes I agree with this.

I don't agree with her stance on true trans children (I think the root is always societal homophobia / sexist stereotypes; developmental environment; trauma; neurodiversity; etc) but I can accept her current opinion is held in good faith.

Tbh, the distinction between Cass's beliefs and mine is similar to the "nature Vs nurture and don't forget epigenetics" discussions around many mental health diagnoses.

My view is that there is the possibility of extreme dysphoria akin to something like BIID or phantom leg syndrome. Because humans are infinitely curious.

I would note, though, that the BIID sufferers do seem disturbingly frequently, especially given how rare it is, to be fetishists.

I wonder how much surgeon Neil Hopper, with his links to the Eunuch maker etc, has enlightened people.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 11:30

https://www.bmj.com/content/393/bmj-2026-685412.full

We have this high profile case to illustrate a man who has a 'sexual interest in amputation'.

Anyone looking into body dysphoria should surely be aware of this case, and that of the Eunuch Maker.

And the WPATH links to the Eunuch Archive, etc.

ScrollingLeaves · Yesterday 11:32

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 10:48

Or, more honestly, she genuinely doesn't know what might be the best way to proceed for that poor child?

You are right we cannot know exactly what she thought other than, if I have remembered correctly, that it was for the child’s therapist to treat them not politicians (?).

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 11:36

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 11:27

She lied about the “poor child” - it didn’t exist.

Furthermore she claimed that a child in that situation would be beyond psychological or psychiatric help - too far gone to persuade them that their parents’ abusive behaviour was in fact abusive.

I cannot imagine any other situation where a medical professional would simply throw their hands up and say “well, these parents have utterly broken this child’s mind, we may as well let them finish it by breaking their body too” instead of immediately removing the child from the parents’ care.

I think she said it was not completely fictional but based on an amalgamation of several real stories?

It’s clear from the ‘living in stealth’ part of KCSIE that there are real children being brought to mind here.

Unlike you, I wouldn’t be sure of the best way to treat that sort of child either, even if removed from their parents.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 11:50

@noblegiraffe

Unlike you, I wouldn’t be sure of the best way to treat that sort of child either, even if removed from their parents.

I would have no idea what to do with that child either. But I do think that deciding that any child could never be reconciled with their natal body (and should therefore be medicalised for life) is an extreme position to take, and one that isn’t supported by child development research.

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 11:55

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 11:50

@noblegiraffe

Unlike you, I wouldn’t be sure of the best way to treat that sort of child either, even if removed from their parents.

I would have no idea what to do with that child either. But I do think that deciding that any child could never be reconciled with their natal body (and should therefore be medicalised for life) is an extreme position to take, and one that isn’t supported by child development research.

On the other hand we have people strongly arguing that taking that medical route literally saved their life so 🤷‍♀️

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 12:04

We have people argue all sorts of stuff. As Louis Appleby notes, suicidality is a complex subject.

I think conceding to 'I must have this or I'll kill myself' is a terrible way to approach evidence based medical treatment.

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 12:13

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 12:04

We have people argue all sorts of stuff. As Louis Appleby notes, suicidality is a complex subject.

I think conceding to 'I must have this or I'll kill myself' is a terrible way to approach evidence based medical treatment.

Of course that’s unacceptable, however that’s not what I meant.

If it is genuinely unclear whether one treatment option is better than another, evidence-based medicine practices would suggest a clinical trial. That’s the way medicine decides these things.

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 12:21

BlueLegume · Yesterday 09:29

You can watch the meeting on parliamentlive.tv

Draft Conversion Practices Bill (Joint Committee)
Monday 16 November 2026 Meeting started at 4.18pm, ended 5.56pm

Worth looking at.

https://www.parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/639bab90-c676-40d1-b822-8590848568e3

Edited

Yes, definitely worth watching.

The bill in its current form cannot be permitted to pass. That much is clear.
What is also clear is that it is the TQ+ that is presenting the unresolvable thorny issue in any measure which attempts to address abusive conversion practices. Everyone is agreed, and the parematers are far clearer, when it comes to abusive conversion practices related to sexual orientation.

Cass's difficulty, as far as I can see it, is that she professes to believe in some kind of 'true and genuine trans' whose suffering would be terrible if they were not facilitated to undergo medical and surgical transitioning, whilst also pointing out that therapeutic exploration is essential when trying to identify which candidates they might be, and which young people are presenting with dysphoria and distress which is simply another manifestation ( often in a series of manifestations) of a deeper distress.

Olivia Bailey was a token trans affirmative voice - but only had one question which she did not follow up on in the face of Cass's response.

I take issue with Cass and the other medical professional using the terms 'trans 'female/male' - which is not possible and not medically correct.