Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law" - Telegraph article share

290 replies

singthing · Yesterday 07:46

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

Baroness Cass has turned against Labour’s plans for a new conversion therapy law, warning that it would have a “chilling effect” on doctors.

Lady Cass, who led a review of the treatment of children with gender dysphoria, previously backed the Conversion Practices Bill but said she had only been given an hour to read the draft legislation before providing a supportive comment for a government press release in June.

On Monday, she told MPs that she regretted backing it, and having read it through now thought it could have “serious unintended consequences”.
...

Continues at:
^Original: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/16/baroness-cass-turns-against-chilling-trans-law/^
Gift: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2
^Archive: https://archive.ph/rP3Np^

Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 15:05

singthing · Yesterday 14:48

@Datun "But Hilary Cass isn't Jill on the street. That's my worry.
She has been subjected to all the misogyny, but she doesn't appear to be connecting the dots between that, and this bill."

I would pay excellent money to witness a debate between Germaine Greer (or any of the indefatigable women who have been publicly fighting this), Hillary Cass and Margaret Atwood. The latter two are sooooo close to it yet still a chasm away. But I think the scales would fall in real time. And that would be something to see.

Hell, even throw in India or some other activist of choice if you want. Let's get it all out for everyone to see.

Do you recall those After Midnight open ended debates late night/early hours on C4?
Where a subject would be taken, a broad panel would be convened, endless bar tab, and the verbal jousting would entail. It could be hugely entertaining.
Rather than all these quick fire interviews, neutered Womans Hour "debates", and carefully choreographed QT shows.
We could do with all sorts of experts, pro and con, locked in a room 24/7 and subjects thrashed out.
From Brexit, open borders, NEETs...to gender ideology and stuff like the Conversion Practices Bill.
Can you imagine how the scales would fall from the public's eyes as gender ideologues would spin their wheels in the mud if the likes of Greer, Joyce, Dawkins, Winston had unlimited time to argue.

SchoolOfCool · Yesterday 15:17

Can't believe Stonewall are admitting out loud that trans ideology converts lesbians.

What happened to "some people are gay, get over it"?

BlueLegume · Yesterday 15:19

I posted this message ( below) on the thread about ‘What would it take to change your mind…’ but think it also deserves a repeat on here as it is more relevant here as it relates to the Baroness Cass reaction at the select committee yesterday…..

It very much came across from Baroness Cass, albeit in a very professional manner, that she had been hoodwinked/ rushed by Olivia Bailey to get on board with the draft bill. Even very smart intelligent people can fall foul of ‘malign’ ministers such as Bailey.
The more I watch the ‘handmaidens’ of trans - Bailey, Nadia Whittome, Kate Nevens in the MSP and also Holly Bruce, the more I see them as very similar types. They are not persuasive they are faux intellectuals who think a serious face and wide eyed faux innocence will make their point more valid. I see each of them as a puppet of a trans activist behind the scenes. En thrall to them rather than actually agreeing. They have to some degree been groomed themselves.

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 15:22

Imnobody4 · Yesterday 12:45

And India Willoughby's deranged contribution on X.

Hillary Cass is a ‘gender critical’ lesbian. Recruited by Kemi Badenoch specifically because of her anti-trans views to write an ‘independant’ study on trans healthcare. Nobody else was interviewed for the gig. She binned 90% of existing studies, which confirmed gender AFFIRMING care had a 99% success rate.
I mean, just look at her. Feel the energy. QUACK.
As with all things ‘gender critical’ and Right Wing, fixed from the start. Aye, hacker @KemiBadenoch #EVIL

Helpfully illustrating the sentiments that might be expressed by a malign actor.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 15:26

BlueLegume · Yesterday 15:19

I posted this message ( below) on the thread about ‘What would it take to change your mind…’ but think it also deserves a repeat on here as it is more relevant here as it relates to the Baroness Cass reaction at the select committee yesterday…..

It very much came across from Baroness Cass, albeit in a very professional manner, that she had been hoodwinked/ rushed by Olivia Bailey to get on board with the draft bill. Even very smart intelligent people can fall foul of ‘malign’ ministers such as Bailey.
The more I watch the ‘handmaidens’ of trans - Bailey, Nadia Whittome, Kate Nevens in the MSP and also Holly Bruce, the more I see them as very similar types. They are not persuasive they are faux intellectuals who think a serious face and wide eyed faux innocence will make their point more valid. I see each of them as a puppet of a trans activist behind the scenes. En thrall to them rather than actually agreeing. They have to some degree been groomed themselves.

You'd also think after the car crash of awfully worded/vaguely conceptualized/open to malign consequences mix that was the Assisted Dying Bill, that these trans ideologues and easily flattered ministers re the Conversion Practices Bill would learn from that previous debacle.
No, in fact the wording of this Bill is actually worse, more vague, more totalitarian, more likely to create worst outcomes.
Actions like this are the worst of politics, but the principled reaction to them is the best of politics.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Yesterday 15:28

I wish more and more that Thatcher had not done away with the government department whose entire business was to draft laws so that they were coherent and did what they were supposed to do. They knew what they were doing; whoever is doing that job now appears to have not the foggiest idea how to go about it.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 15:28

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 15:22

Helpfully illustrating the sentiments that might be expressed by a malign actor.

Himdia is getting that itch that's familiar to men when they sit in a crowded tube carriage, their anger making their underpants to tight, the sweat dripping into their eyes and stinging them so they can't see straight.

BettyBooper · Yesterday 15:30

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 14:40

It annoys me that she keeps referring to "malign" actors on "both sides" when the most obvious malignant actions arise from trans activists - even in her own examples.

Edited

Absolutely.

And her example of 'both sides' was 'Donald Trump is hostile to trans people '.

Hardly relevant or representative of the arguments / behaviour of the sex realist side in the UK.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 15:39

BettyBooper · Yesterday 15:30

Absolutely.

And her example of 'both sides' was 'Donald Trump is hostile to trans people '.

Hardly relevant or representative of the arguments / behaviour of the sex realist side in the UK.

I don't think Cass has had her full awakening yet. If she still thinks it's "toxic" on "both sides" then she's either been living in a hole, or deliberately burying her head in the sand. If the Bill passes, she will soon understand what we've been saying.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 15:47

Here's the rub. Those opposing now include Cass. The main teaching union. Doctors. Therapists. The CoE.
Yes, these organisations have often been frustratingly weak tea in the broader culture war against TRA (BeKind etc).
But the law is where the rubber hits the road, and even pro trans useful idiots heading these organisations can see the risks of litigation for their members, and need to protect them.
Are MPs <really> going to go against these bodies and more in some deluded belief they are on the right side of history and making Britain more civilized a la Same Sex Marriage, or are they gonna for once apply some critical thinking?

Abitofalark · Yesterday 16:24

After Dark was the Channel 4 programme Marc mentioned above. They were compelling but you'd be up half the night. The high point for C4. Look at it now and weep. Wiki has a list of the sessions and who participated in them. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_After_Dark_editions

BlueLegume · Yesterday 16:32

Not sure how familiar people are about the work of Mia Hughes? On X she is Crymiariver. I like her she has definitely contributed to me ‘educating myself’ on the whole trans debate.

Mia has posted in the past 24 hours on X a reply to a well known trans person Brianna Whu who has said it is time trans men and women are treated differently as the outcomes each group wants is very different and the journey each group takes arriving at ‘I am trans’ is poles apart. If you can read the post do.

Mia has responded with this….which I like.

Naturally I take this one giant step further. What actually needs to happen is the medical world needs to rid itself of "trans" as a concept.
Stop medicalising a political fiction. Stop treating a category of person that does not exist.
Take all the individuals who show up seeking these drastic medical treatments and find out why each one believes they need to destroy their healthy body.
If he's an autogynephilic man, try to help him manage his sexual urges.
If the person is a gender-nonconforming homosexual, help them find ways to cope that doesn't involve having body parts chopped off as a way to blend into society and be invisible.
If it's one of the ROGD (rapid onset gender disphoria )cohort, give them the time and space they need to grow and mature and figure out who they are.
The medical world needs to face up to the fact that they were duped by a bunch of fanatics who created an alternate reality where the whole world had to live inside their mental disorder.
It's long past time for a return to actual reality.

FedUpCelery · Yesterday 16:47

Seriestwo · Yesterday 08:04

I think she believed the activists were acting in good faith. And then got scared by their threats. And now thinks “both sides”

she is a disappointment, but I’m going ahead killed the bill yesterday.

If she loses credibility as a professional then no one listens to her.
What she said yesterday was understated and careful and because of her approach, she will be listened to. When she said that she has been called a conversion therapist it shines light on the fact that if even her very moderate approach can be called conversation therapy then anything can. This was a very important point that she made and I think it came across beautifully how high the stakes are if this bill passes.

BettyBooper · Yesterday 16:49

BlueLegume · Yesterday 16:32

Not sure how familiar people are about the work of Mia Hughes? On X she is Crymiariver. I like her she has definitely contributed to me ‘educating myself’ on the whole trans debate.

Mia has posted in the past 24 hours on X a reply to a well known trans person Brianna Whu who has said it is time trans men and women are treated differently as the outcomes each group wants is very different and the journey each group takes arriving at ‘I am trans’ is poles apart. If you can read the post do.

Mia has responded with this….which I like.

Naturally I take this one giant step further. What actually needs to happen is the medical world needs to rid itself of "trans" as a concept.
Stop medicalising a political fiction. Stop treating a category of person that does not exist.
Take all the individuals who show up seeking these drastic medical treatments and find out why each one believes they need to destroy their healthy body.
If he's an autogynephilic man, try to help him manage his sexual urges.
If the person is a gender-nonconforming homosexual, help them find ways to cope that doesn't involve having body parts chopped off as a way to blend into society and be invisible.
If it's one of the ROGD (rapid onset gender disphoria )cohort, give them the time and space they need to grow and mature and figure out who they are.
The medical world needs to face up to the fact that they were duped by a bunch of fanatics who created an alternate reality where the whole world had to live inside their mental disorder.
It's long past time for a return to actual reality.

This was the whole problem with Cass for me. She started with holding as true a debatable (imo false) premise that there is medical reality to trans beyond a held belief.

Mia Hughes has been great in pushing this.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 16:50

BlueLegume · Yesterday 16:32

Not sure how familiar people are about the work of Mia Hughes? On X she is Crymiariver. I like her she has definitely contributed to me ‘educating myself’ on the whole trans debate.

Mia has posted in the past 24 hours on X a reply to a well known trans person Brianna Whu who has said it is time trans men and women are treated differently as the outcomes each group wants is very different and the journey each group takes arriving at ‘I am trans’ is poles apart. If you can read the post do.

Mia has responded with this….which I like.

Naturally I take this one giant step further. What actually needs to happen is the medical world needs to rid itself of "trans" as a concept.
Stop medicalising a political fiction. Stop treating a category of person that does not exist.
Take all the individuals who show up seeking these drastic medical treatments and find out why each one believes they need to destroy their healthy body.
If he's an autogynephilic man, try to help him manage his sexual urges.
If the person is a gender-nonconforming homosexual, help them find ways to cope that doesn't involve having body parts chopped off as a way to blend into society and be invisible.
If it's one of the ROGD (rapid onset gender disphoria )cohort, give them the time and space they need to grow and mature and figure out who they are.
The medical world needs to face up to the fact that they were duped by a bunch of fanatics who created an alternate reality where the whole world had to live inside their mental disorder.
It's long past time for a return to actual reality.

The trouble, I would say, is that 'the medical world' includes the plastic surgery industry, which sees 'gender affirming care' as a fantastic money spinner and a growth market.

https://www.researchandmarkets.com/reports/6168609/gender-reassignment-surgery-market-report

'The gender reassignment surgery market size has grown strongly in recent years. It will grow from $1.93 billion in 2025 to $2.11 billion in 2026 at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 9.3%. The growth in the historic period can be attributed to increasing recognition of gender dysphoria, expansion of specialized surgical expertise, growing acceptance of gender-affirming healthcare, availability of advanced surgical techniques, rising awareness through advocacy and education.'

Gender Reassignment Surgery Market Report 2026 - Research and Markets

The Gender Reassignment Surgery Market, valued at USD 2.11B in 2026, is projected to reach USD 2.97B by 2030, growing at a 8.9% CAGR.

https://www.researchandmarkets.com/reports/6168609/gender-reassignment-surgery-market-report

BettyBooper · Yesterday 16:52

FedUpCelery · Yesterday 16:47

If she loses credibility as a professional then no one listens to her.
What she said yesterday was understated and careful and because of her approach, she will be listened to. When she said that she has been called a conversion therapist it shines light on the fact that if even her very moderate approach can be called conversation therapy then anything can. This was a very important point that she made and I think it came across beautifully how high the stakes are if this bill passes.

I do agree. But I also think Cass has now realised the impact the bill could have on the PB trial and the fallout for clinicians involved.

ghostofadog · Yesterday 16:52

I respect her for admitting that she made a mistake, that seems to be a very rare thing among public figures. Also, it's good that she actually reversed her opinion having read the bill as it shows just how bad it is, and much more headline grabbing than if she'd not said anything at first.

BettyBooper · Yesterday 16:54

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 16:50

The trouble, I would say, is that 'the medical world' includes the plastic surgery industry, which sees 'gender affirming care' as a fantastic money spinner and a growth market.

https://www.researchandmarkets.com/reports/6168609/gender-reassignment-surgery-market-report

'The gender reassignment surgery market size has grown strongly in recent years. It will grow from $1.93 billion in 2025 to $2.11 billion in 2026 at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 9.3%. The growth in the historic period can be attributed to increasing recognition of gender dysphoria, expansion of specialized surgical expertise, growing acceptance of gender-affirming healthcare, availability of advanced surgical techniques, rising awareness through advocacy and education.'

Not to mention the life-long health care needed in the aftermath...

BettyBooper · Yesterday 16:58

Cass also said about not being able to get 'both sides' together to discuss the issues because of the hostility.

I genuinely cannot believe that this refusal came from the SR side.

BlueLegume · Yesterday 16:58

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 16:50

The trouble, I would say, is that 'the medical world' includes the plastic surgery industry, which sees 'gender affirming care' as a fantastic money spinner and a growth market.

https://www.researchandmarkets.com/reports/6168609/gender-reassignment-surgery-market-report

'The gender reassignment surgery market size has grown strongly in recent years. It will grow from $1.93 billion in 2025 to $2.11 billion in 2026 at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 9.3%. The growth in the historic period can be attributed to increasing recognition of gender dysphoria, expansion of specialized surgical expertise, growing acceptance of gender-affirming healthcare, availability of advanced surgical techniques, rising awareness through advocacy and education.'

I definitely agree that the cosmetic/plastic/aesthetics world is used to back up any surgery. I had a conversation with a family member about this earlier this year who threw the line at me that trans surgery is ‘no different than plastic surgery/aesthetics’. Thankfully I also hold the line that whilst people can do what they want I personally do not condone all this fashionable surgery.

It does not mean I ‘hate’ on people who have it but I do think if they want to alter themselves so much they need to address why this is. I also think much of the plastic surgery /aesthetics is a much a social contagion as trans.

Just because we CAN do something medically does not make it right.

Do I look in the mirror and wonder if a few tweaks here and there might rejuvenate me - of course I do occasionally. But then I stop and realise my face tells the story of my real life and I like that.

And yes this is one massive money spinner . Capitalism at play yet most trans activists and allies seem to think they are left leaning socialists/marxists and hate capitalism. Oh the irony (lining the pockets of the very people you despise).

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 17:18

I fully agree. I also think the cosmetic surgery needs far greater regulation.

Disorders and fetishes plus 'post humanism' ideas are creating monstrous behaviour. It's not good for anyone, least of all the people embarking on extreme body mods.

This man seems to be in the grip of some terrible mania, to increase the size of his lips and balls.

https://www.youtube.com/@ViennaXtreme

Emilesgran · Yesterday 17:21

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 12:13

Of course that’s unacceptable, however that’s not what I meant.

If it is genuinely unclear whether one treatment option is better than another, evidence-based medicine practices would suggest a clinical trial. That’s the way medicine decides these things.

But maybe not a medical trial where all the subjects were going to be given the treatment being tested, just at different times in their lives?

UtopiaPlanitia · Yesterday 17:22

Emilesgran · Yesterday 07:54

I knew there’d be a thread about this! Thanks @singthing

I can’t work out what Baroness Cass is playing at - she seems to be all over the place on this.

Did she think she could find a middle of the road position that would placate the TRAs while remaining scientifically and intellectually honest? (I think we all knew that couldnt be done)

Or was she so intimidated by their fury at the Cas review that she then spent the next months trying to row back a bit, in particular by approving the trial and also the anti conversion bill?

And if so, how much will she be able to hold the line now?

She mentioned some of her thinking during the questioning in the Committee: she seems to have a belief that some children, who have long-term confusion/distress about their bodies from a young age, could benefit from medical and surgical intervention to alter their bodies, despite the physical risks from surgery/hormones/blockers. Whereas other children, she believes, are experiencing dysphoria as an expression of mental/emotional distress and need therapy rather than the risks involved in surgery/hormones/blockers.

She basically seems to have fallen for the 'Dutch Protocol Era' idea that some children are 'True Trans', that doctors can confidently identify these children, and that the only way to make these children happy is to medicalise them for life.

I agree that she is very unspecific when she talks about vexatious complaining/threatening activists - she is describing documented TRA behaviour but never actually comes clean and calls them out for harassing her.

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 17:36

Emilesgran · Yesterday 17:21

But maybe not a medical trial where all the subjects were going to be given the treatment being tested, just at different times in their lives?

There’s a matched control group who aren’t given the medication as a sister study. Quite a difficult trial to design tbh.

BettyBooper · Yesterday 17:38

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 17:36

There’s a matched control group who aren’t given the medication as a sister study. Quite a difficult trial to design tbh.

I thought they were to be given the medication, but a year later?