Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law" - Telegraph article share

290 replies

singthing · Yesterday 07:46

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

Baroness Cass has turned against Labour’s plans for a new conversion therapy law, warning that it would have a “chilling effect” on doctors.

Lady Cass, who led a review of the treatment of children with gender dysphoria, previously backed the Conversion Practices Bill but said she had only been given an hour to read the draft legislation before providing a supportive comment for a government press release in June.

On Monday, she told MPs that she regretted backing it, and having read it through now thought it could have “serious unintended consequences”.
...

Continues at:
^Original: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/16/baroness-cass-turns-against-chilling-trans-law/^
Gift: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2
^Archive: https://archive.ph/rP3Np^

Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
ArabellaScott · Today 13:26

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 13:23

Well, that's Cass pasted!

You can do a lot in 15 minutes. Make a cup of tea. Empty the dishwasher. Put a load of washing on. Review a 20-page draft law that proposes a maximum prison sentence of up to five years? Maybe not.

😬

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · Today 13:28

ArabellaScott · Today 12:19

If they create this third category, how would it impact on the Equality Act?

Nonbinaries are classed as having the pc of gender reassignment.

Nonbinaries are classed as having the pc of gender reassignment.

If you are NB then you do not benefit from the PC of gender reassignment because you aren't transitioning from one sex/gender/whatever to another. UK law doesn't recognise NB at all.

ArabellaScott · Today 13:32

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · Today 13:28

Nonbinaries are classed as having the pc of gender reassignment.

If you are NB then you do not benefit from the PC of gender reassignment because you aren't transitioning from one sex/gender/whatever to another. UK law doesn't recognise NB at all.

Incorrect. You can read the link I posted upthread.

ArabellaScott · Today 13:33

'Legal protection

In general terms, legal protection from discrimination is based upon having – or being perceived as having – a “protected characteristic”, as defined in the Equality Act 2010. In 2020, the Birmingham Employment Tribunal held that people who are gender fluid, non-binary or transitioning can have the protected characteristic of gender reassignment'

https://oldsquare.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/1304471.18-Ms-R-Taylor-v-JLR-Ltd..Final_.-Reasons.261120.pdf#page=46

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 13:33

ArabellaScott · Today 13:26

You can do a lot in 15 minutes. Make a cup of tea. Empty the dishwasher. Put a load of washing on. Review a 20-page draft law that proposes a maximum prison sentence of up to five years? Maybe not.

😬

I know no one in my professional life who wouldn't have said, "Yeah, you want a public, professional statement on this in 15 minutes? Not gonna happen. You're gonna have to give me at least overnight to look at it."

And that's after it's been given to the PA to triage. If Cass doesn't have a PA, then she needs to get one.

BlueLegume · Today 13:39

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 13:33

I know no one in my professional life who wouldn't have said, "Yeah, you want a public, professional statement on this in 15 minutes? Not gonna happen. You're gonna have to give me at least overnight to look at it."

And that's after it's been given to the PA to triage. If Cass doesn't have a PA, then she needs to get one.

I am very of the mind that Olivia Bailey leaned heavily on Baroness Cass in this instance. OB gives off very odd vibes to me - my personal view is she is quite out of her depth but compensates by this by wide eyed wilful ignorance of reality. She has smelt the money and funding around trans LGBTQIA+ and followed it. Possible because she is an advocate but for me because she sees herself as part of a civil rights movement and she has the ‘be kind’ lobby behind her.

Cass should have been stronger but she is human. She has also been very firm in her denouncement of the bill and OB seemed quite angry at her. Good.

We are talking about kids here. Adults - make your own decisions but children must be safeguarded and protected from all this gender nonsense.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Today 13:43

From Conservatives for Women on X - Cass is apparently now (or has just recently) spoken to the HoL:

Baroness Cass continues to make important interventions on the draft Conversion Practices Bill. Here, in HoL, she draws a very clear distinction b/t sexual orientation & gender identity. The latter is not fixed, origins are complex. We cannot create an assumption that it is wrong or harmful to challenge. #BinTheBill 1/

B. Cass points out again that majority of children & young people who go through period of gender incongruence grow out of it. How can we possibly support a Bill that calls any attempt to help a child be comfortable in their own sex 'a Conversion Practice'? The 'abuse' bar does not solve this problem.2/

spannasaurus · Today 13:45

ArabellaScott · Today 13:33

'Legal protection

In general terms, legal protection from discrimination is based upon having – or being perceived as having – a “protected characteristic”, as defined in the Equality Act 2010. In 2020, the Birmingham Employment Tribunal held that people who are gender fluid, non-binary or transitioning can have the protected characteristic of gender reassignment'

Theres been a more recent tribunal that found that non binary people dont have the pc of gr

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6926ec33a245b0985f0340aa/Haech_Lockwood_v_Cheshire_and_Wirral_NHS_Foundation_Trust_and_others_2401211_2024___2407178_2024.pdf

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6926ec33a245b0985f0340aa/Haech_Lockwood_v_Cheshire_and_Wirral_NHS_Foundation_Trust_and_others_2401211_2024___2407178_2024.pdf

nicepotoftea · Today 13:48

spannasaurus · Today 13:45

In practice many people will assume that they do have the PC of GR.

I assume that nobody would sincerely argue that the lack of clarity is helpful, but I think it's interesting that no lobby group seems to be pushing for clarity.

spannasaurus · Today 13:53

nicepotoftea · Today 13:48

In practice many people will assume that they do have the PC of GR.

I assume that nobody would sincerely argue that the lack of clarity is helpful, but I think it's interesting that no lobby group seems to be pushing for clarity.

There's always the possibility that a NB person could claim discrimination on the basis that they are perceived to have the PC of gr

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · Today 13:57

ArabellaScott · Today 13:32

Incorrect. You can read the link I posted upthread.

That is a non-binding decision from a first tier Employment Tribunal six years ago that got the law wrong.

A more recent non-binding decision from a first tier Employment Tribunal featuring the dreadful behaviour of Haeche Lockwood to all her co-workers decided that claiming to be NB did not give you the PC of GR.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 13:57

BlueLegume · Today 13:39

I am very of the mind that Olivia Bailey leaned heavily on Baroness Cass in this instance. OB gives off very odd vibes to me - my personal view is she is quite out of her depth but compensates by this by wide eyed wilful ignorance of reality. She has smelt the money and funding around trans LGBTQIA+ and followed it. Possible because she is an advocate but for me because she sees herself as part of a civil rights movement and she has the ‘be kind’ lobby behind her.

Cass should have been stronger but she is human. She has also been very firm in her denouncement of the bill and OB seemed quite angry at her. Good.

We are talking about kids here. Adults - make your own decisions but children must be safeguarded and protected from all this gender nonsense.

Yes, she is human. I don't blame her for being that. I don't, though, think much of her "professionalism" in this instance. However unhinged Olivia Bailey is, if Cass is unable to say no to a politician, then she has no business being in the HoL.

It seems that Cass is now speaking out. Perhaps this was the wake-up call she needed. I hope so.

MrsOvertonsWindow · Today 15:19

Going back to the dodgy data about conversion practices. The Telegraph reports that 4 years ago, a Cabinet Office tender for an official hotline to report conversion cases anticipated the number of callers could be as high as 15,000 call a year.
However, another tender put out this summer states that as few as 300 people a year are likely to call.
For some odd reason the govt won't release the actual stats, presumably as they'd expose the massive grift involved for the organisations wanting to run the hotline along with the fact that what the writers of the bill claim - that conversion practices are everywhere, is a lie.

www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/10/labour-accused-overestimating-scale-conversion-therapy/

borntobequiet · Today 15:29

ArabellaScott · Today 12:11

https://stonewall.org.uk/news/ban-conversion-practices-why-we-need-ban-no-exemptions-and-no-excuses

'Conversion practices in religious settings often involve a combination of processes that can range from private or public prayer, to laying of hands. The latter can include a practice described as “beating the homosexuality out of the persons”, often with the use of brooms. '

Is this happening in the UK?

'While not all forms of conversion practices involve violence, even talking therapies are a damaging and degrading practice that leave lasting scars on LGBTQ+ survivors.'

What, all therapies?! 😯

I wonder if “no exemptions” will backfire in a similar way to “no debate”. They’re not very bright.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Today 16:04

ArabellaScott · Today 12:08

https://stonewall.org.uk/get-involved/campaign-with-us/ban-conversion-practices

'The Draft Bill adds protections for individuals who identify “as neither male nor female or as not solely male or female” and people who do not have a sexual orientation. This would be the first instance of legal protections for non-binary and asexual people in England and Wales.'

This to me looks extra dodgy. Nobody has looked at it properly, have they?

Is this the first time non binary identity would be put into law?

Is there any evidence that anyone is trying to force people who are not interested in sex into having an interest in it? (Apart from the entirety of society, which much of the time seems to be completely preoccupied with the requirement that everyone should want to have sexual congress and is a weirdo if they don't, and I don't see prosecutions against "the whole of society" getting anywhere much.) I don't really see what protection asexual people need to have in law beyond what any person has already.

Ditto non-binary: what conversion therapy is being practised on them? Seriously. How do you convert someone from something so nebulous, and how do you know if you have or even if you are trying to? Does this include for instance mothers requiring their daughters to wear dresses if they are going to a wedding rather than wearing suits and ties, or requiring their sons to wear suits and ties rather than dresses? Is trying to persuade your child to dress at some family occasion in a way that won't stand out like a sore thumb, and make all their cousins giggle at them, also going to carry a penalty of up to five years imprisonment? (And where, for goodness' sake, are we going to find all the extra prison places needed? The system is already letting rapists out early because the prisons are too full to fit them.)

ArabellaScott · Today 16:12

Quite.

ArabellaScott · Today 16:15

MrsOvertonsWindow · Today 15:19

Going back to the dodgy data about conversion practices. The Telegraph reports that 4 years ago, a Cabinet Office tender for an official hotline to report conversion cases anticipated the number of callers could be as high as 15,000 call a year.
However, another tender put out this summer states that as few as 300 people a year are likely to call.
For some odd reason the govt won't release the actual stats, presumably as they'd expose the massive grift involved for the organisations wanting to run the hotline along with the fact that what the writers of the bill claim - that conversion practices are everywhere, is a lie.

www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/10/labour-accused-overestimating-scale-conversion-therapy/

Run by Galop.

https://www.conversiontherapysupport.org.uk/faqs/

FAQs - Conversion Practices Victim Support Service

Do conversion practices happen in the UK? Can I consent to conversion practices? Is the support service confidential?

https://www.conversiontherapysupport.org.uk/faqs/

ArabellaScott · Today 16:17

https://www.galop.org.uk/reports/still-not-illegal-evidence-of-modern-day-conversion-practices

'widespread' say Galop.

'In a world-first-study of conversion practices using frontline service data, "Still Not Illegal" reveals the stark reality of modern-day conversion practices in the UK.
Drawing on evidence from 195 cases across three years (2022-25), Galop's new research offers a unique insight into how conversion practices often intersect with or 'hide behind' other forms of abuse and violence, especially domestic abuse.
The report provides clear evidence that conversion practices remain a widespread and ongoing issue across the UK, with LGBT+ people experiencing covert and insidious forms of abuse in attempts to change, ‘cure’, or suppress their sexual orientation and/or gender identity.'

"Still Not Illegal": Evidence of modern-day conversion practices from Galop's frontline services | Galop

"Still Not Illegal": Evidence of modern-day conversion practices from Galop's frontline services

https://www.galop.org.uk/reports/still-not-illegal-evidence-of-modern-day-conversion-practices

ArabellaScott · Today 16:19

'Representative data from Galop and YouGov found
that nearly one in five (18%) LGBT+ people in the UK have been
subjected to conversion practices – far higher than the 2017 National
LGBT Survey’s estimates of 2.4% having undergone or 5% having
been offered so-called ‘conversion therapy’.7'

from the report above

ArabellaScott · Today 16:20

'This study is based on qualitative content analysis of anonymised
case notes, and began with a dataset of all cases supported through
Galop’s Advocacy & Support services in England and Wales between
November 2022 and November 2025 (over 13,500 clients and 14,800
cases). An initial sample of 371 cases involving conversion practices
was identified through a combination of flagged abuse types, abuse
sub-type variables and keyword searches of the case notes.'

ArabellaScott · Today 16:21

'In the vast majority of cases, the conversion practices were
perpetrated or initiated by family (n=149; 76%) – especially by a
parent/s (n=123; 63%)'

ArabellaScott · Today 16:23

Galop's study included around 200 people.

52% were British citizens.

[edit, I missed that 27% were 'missing information', so my assumption that 48% were not British citizens is not (necessarily) accurate]

ArabellaScott · Today 16:32

'Client is frequently told by his parents to cut his hair, that his sexuality is just a phase, and [is] pressured to marry a woman or have children. Client disclosed that this abuse is continuous. Client’s family have passed around his phone number trying to match-make him, they pray for him and try to emotionally blackmail and manipulate him. At a family event, Client’s mother and uncle/family friends were trying to set him up with a woman and encouraging him
to marry a woman.'

I mean, this might be annoying or unpleasant or even upsetting. May well be an unhealthy of dysfunctional family dynamic. But should it really be criminal for a parent to tell a child to cut his or her hair?

borntobequiet · Today 16:32

I’m sure that Galop is easily confused by some with Gallup, which is a well known and trusted polling/data analytics brand. The similarity is surely a coincidence, but probably doesn’t hurt Galop.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Today 16:36

ArabellaScott · Today 16:32

'Client is frequently told by his parents to cut his hair, that his sexuality is just a phase, and [is] pressured to marry a woman or have children. Client disclosed that this abuse is continuous. Client’s family have passed around his phone number trying to match-make him, they pray for him and try to emotionally blackmail and manipulate him. At a family event, Client’s mother and uncle/family friends were trying to set him up with a woman and encouraging him
to marry a woman.'

I mean, this might be annoying or unpleasant or even upsetting. May well be an unhealthy of dysfunctional family dynamic. But should it really be criminal for a parent to tell a child to cut his or her hair?

Let’s imagine the child was straight, but slovenly and dating someone abusive. Would it be abuse to suggest the child wash and cut their hair and additionally to pray that they make it safely out of the relationship?