Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law" - Telegraph article share

290 replies

singthing · Yesterday 07:46

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

Baroness Cass has turned against Labour’s plans for a new conversion therapy law, warning that it would have a “chilling effect” on doctors.

Lady Cass, who led a review of the treatment of children with gender dysphoria, previously backed the Conversion Practices Bill but said she had only been given an hour to read the draft legislation before providing a supportive comment for a government press release in June.

On Monday, she told MPs that she regretted backing it, and having read it through now thought it could have “serious unintended consequences”.
...

Continues at:
^Original: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/16/baroness-cass-turns-against-chilling-trans-law/^
Gift: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2
^Archive: https://archive.ph/rP3Np^

Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Mountainlarch · Yesterday 14:03

BlueLegume · Yesterday 14:01

My goodness…all they have is ‘transphobe bigoted fascist’.

With regards to the aspect of children being involved I recall a conversation a couple of years ago with a very ‘be kind’ relative who was absolutely adamant children were no where near anything trans. She also was very dismissive towards me when I brought up AGP and fetish. She shut me down with a withering comment that my views said more about me than the harmless and minute trans community.

Be interesting to see if she reflects on our conversation in the light of this and convictions of Stephen Ireland and the information about Sam Hall off the Sarah Redvers tribunal.

I found it quite telling that Baroness Cass dropped the Sarah Redvers/Sam Hall bomb into the committee yesterday.

I won't have time to listen to yesterday's debate any time soon, what did Dr Cass say about Sam Hall?

singthing · Yesterday 14:07

Imnobody4 · Yesterday 12:45

And India Willoughby's deranged contribution on X.

Hillary Cass is a ‘gender critical’ lesbian. Recruited by Kemi Badenoch specifically because of her anti-trans views to write an ‘independant’ study on trans healthcare. Nobody else was interviewed for the gig. She binned 90% of existing studies, which confirmed gender AFFIRMING care had a 99% success rate.
I mean, just look at her. Feel the energy. QUACK.
As with all things ‘gender critical’ and Right Wing, fixed from the start. Aye, hacker @KemiBadenoch #EVIL

I always get that really cringy, second hand embarrassment when people bustle aggressively into topics where the grownups experts are talking on matters that right in their domain and put forward quite gobsmackingly ignorant commentary as if they are in fact the specialist here and the expert has just completely missed the point or not read the bustler's wisdom and opinions on it?

You see it in many subjects, not just this where it has actual consequences, but the toe curling is the same.

India is the perfect example of it. His male entitlement is gushing over the sides as he rushes to show off how his dearth of actual knowledge is no hindrance whatsoever when you have heavily biased manly thoughts to force on bystanders.

OP posts:
BlueLegume · Yesterday 14:08

Mountainlarch · Yesterday 14:03

I won't have time to listen to yesterday's debate any time soon, what did Dr Cass say about Sam Hall?

I am not able to quote her verbatim so probably best you listen when you have the time.

The relevance was more referencing the Sarah Redvers situation as a safeguarding GP and concerns around whistleblowers and the draft bill.

BlueLegume · Yesterday 14:10

singthing · Yesterday 14:07

I always get that really cringy, second hand embarrassment when people bustle aggressively into topics where the grownups experts are talking on matters that right in their domain and put forward quite gobsmackingly ignorant commentary as if they are in fact the specialist here and the expert has just completely missed the point or not read the bustler's wisdom and opinions on it?

You see it in many subjects, not just this where it has actual consequences, but the toe curling is the same.

India is the perfect example of it. His male entitlement is gushing over the sides as he rushes to show off how his dearth of actual knowledge is no hindrance whatsoever when you have heavily biased manly thoughts to force on bystanders.

Same.

That post by a 60 pluses year old sounds more like 14 year old mean girl distracting from the fact she failed to complete her French homework and slagging off the French teacher for her looks. Utterly unhinged.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 14:13

BlueLegume · Yesterday 14:01

My goodness…all they have is ‘transphobe bigoted fascist’.

With regards to the aspect of children being involved I recall a conversation a couple of years ago with a very ‘be kind’ relative who was absolutely adamant children were no where near anything trans. She also was very dismissive towards me when I brought up AGP and fetish. She shut me down with a withering comment that my views said more about me than the harmless and minute trans community.

Be interesting to see if she reflects on our conversation in the light of this and convictions of Stephen Ireland and the information about Sam Hall off the Sarah Redvers tribunal.

I found it quite telling that Baroness Cass dropped the Sarah Redvers/Sam Hall bomb into the committee yesterday.

Continuous references to self ID and trans conversion bans in other countries.
Well, Germany has these. Together with the most draconian fines and custodial sentences for even the least dissent. And is a big fan of mega brothels and a sex work ethos that would make your eyes water.
Despite the UK having umpteen economic issues, I know between us and Germany which country is safer for women and kids.
The way I see it, other countries can carry out an existential social experiment, the receipts will come in, be very long and very expensive. I'll settle on the UK not adopting Self ID or this Conversion Practices Bill.
Just as Britain was at the forefront of pushing to end the slave trade, Britain will be at the forefront of the rearguard against the anti human and anti Enlightenment trans ideologues.

BiologicalRobot · Yesterday 14:16

(Still reading)

The more I get to read about academics and those in positions of power (MPs, Councillors, Police Chiefs) the more I think how thick and stupid they actually are.

Who puts their name to something they haven't read or understood? Who?? Perhaps I can slip a new will amongst her papers and get her to sign her savings over to me. I mean.. that's entirely within the realms of possibility with some of these idiots.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 14:19

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 13:54

100%.

It's hard to talk about children being sterilised in the services of an ideology that also supports men self castrating for sexual kicks, you sound like a raving lunatic.

But it's true.

https://www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/nhs-scotland-apologises-for-saying-eunuch-should-be-gender-identity-z8jcvrr6m

I remember when I was in school in the 70s, "you absolute eunuch!" was one of the more brainy outré insults you could hand anyone, and it really stung.
Today? It's been seriously attempted to be classified on the Gender Alphabetti Spaghetti.
Someone has been watching <way!> too many WPATH seminars online.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 14:23

BiologicalRobot · Yesterday 14:16

(Still reading)

The more I get to read about academics and those in positions of power (MPs, Councillors, Police Chiefs) the more I think how thick and stupid they actually are.

Who puts their name to something they haven't read or understood? Who?? Perhaps I can slip a new will amongst her papers and get her to sign her savings over to me. I mean.. that's entirely within the realms of possibility with some of these idiots.

She didn't read it.
Or she read it but didn't understand it.
Or she read it and understood it, but couldn't be bothered to contradict it.
Or she read it but disagreed with it, but didn't feel ready or able to contradict it.
Or she read it and agreed with it, but now she has changed her mind, because...?

....

All we know is that she has told the committee that she didn't have time to read it all. And that she made a statement previously that was based on one, or none, of the above.

Shabby at best. D+ for effort.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 14:24

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 13:15

Yet another reason to hate Stonewall and everything they stand for and do. Well done, Simon.

(Come onto FWR, Simon, and deny this was said, if you dare. I know your foot soldiers read this forum. If they don't, they should. Know thy enemy, and all that...)

That joke re lesbians and their shrinking dating pool is the kind of shit Brand and Walliams would come up with in the era we've all been discussing over the last week.
The only thing that needs to shrink here is the outsize influence that Stonewall and other genderist ideologues have over policy and discourse.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 14:26

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 14:24

That joke re lesbians and their shrinking dating pool is the kind of shit Brand and Walliams would come up with in the era we've all been discussing over the last week.
The only thing that needs to shrink here is the outsize influence that Stonewall and other genderist ideologues have over policy and discourse.

I'd like to see quite a few of them in prison. A girl can dream...

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 14:26

Imnobody4 · Yesterday 12:45

And India Willoughby's deranged contribution on X.

Hillary Cass is a ‘gender critical’ lesbian. Recruited by Kemi Badenoch specifically because of her anti-trans views to write an ‘independant’ study on trans healthcare. Nobody else was interviewed for the gig. She binned 90% of existing studies, which confirmed gender AFFIRMING care had a 99% success rate.
I mean, just look at her. Feel the energy. QUACK.
As with all things ‘gender critical’ and Right Wing, fixed from the start. Aye, hacker @KemiBadenoch #EVIL

What the fuck has Cass' putative sexuality got to do with the price of cheese?!

Since when did these grotty old men decide 'lesbian' was a derogatory term? The absolute misogynist contempt is astonishing.

Leave women alone, you fucking oddbod.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 14:27

I mean Stonewall can fuck off, too. How dare they, the bunch of entitled pricks. It's just a stupid, self satisfied boys club.

I think I'd better go and have a cup of herbal tea, they really fuck me right off, this lot.

Datun · Yesterday 14:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I agree about Jack and Jill on the street. They have absolutely no idea of the misogyny underpinning this.

Germaine Greer said about women in general, that they have no idea how much men hate them.

Well this ideology nails it to a 10 ft wall surrounded with fireworks. But as Germaine Greer said people still have no idea.

But Hilary Cass isn't Jill on the street. That's my worry.

She has been subjected to all the misogyny, but she doesn't appear to be connecting the dots between that, and this bill.

That's the mistake, in my opinion. She thinks it's something that is happening elsewhere, online, on the edges of society. And this bill, surrounded by ministers and civil servants is somehow detached from the rampant ideology. When in fact, it's a desperate, raging attempt by these very same ideologues to get self ID in by the back door.

She's a very clever woman, so I'm assuming that the now obvious tactic of getting her to approve something she hadn't read will start flicking the light bulb on.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 14:28

singthing · Yesterday 07:48

Shocking railroading behaviour by the Minister:

“I was trying to be as helpful as I could to the then minister. I had said I wouldn’t comment until I’d seen it. It was sent to me an hour before they wanted a press release and 15 minutes before I walked on the platform to give a talk.

“So I tried to give the quotes based on the principles that I’ve been told about but without seeing the bill as drafted, and maybe I shouldn’t have done that.”

To my eternal shame as a GC, I'd been seriously considering wandering back to voting Labour. And then behaviour like this by the minister shocks me back to reality.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 14:33

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 14:27

I mean Stonewall can fuck off, too. How dare they, the bunch of entitled pricks. It's just a stupid, self satisfied boys club.

I think I'd better go and have a cup of herbal tea, they really fuck me right off, this lot.

Peppermint if you have a bad stomach.
Jasmine if you have a headache.
Avoid chamomile unless you want a nap at 3pm.

Or is that just if you are in your mid... ok, late 60s?

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 14:38

Mountainlarch · Yesterday 14:03

I won't have time to listen to yesterday's debate any time soon, what did Dr Cass say about Sam Hall?

Nothing directly, but she did bring up the case in relation to the safeguarding doctor who effectively lost her job for whistleblowing on Hall's prescription of puberty blockers. She was trying to give an example of how doctors could fall foul of poorly defined 'conversion' or 'abusive' practices.

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 14:40

Datun · Yesterday 13:21

“I was trying to be as helpful as I could to the then minister. I had said I wouldn’t comment until I’d seen it. It was sent to me an hour before they wanted a press release and 15 minutes before I walked on the platform to give a talk.

“So I tried to give the quotes based on the principles that I’ve been told about but without seeing the bill as drafted, and maybe I shouldn’t have done that.”

It does worry me that she appears unaware of the extent of the activism behind the push for this bill.

Anyone, anyone at all, even peripherally related to this issue, much less neck deep in it, would be deeply suspicious of being asked to quote on a bill that you were only given an hour to review.

Not only that, if she felt under pressurise, that's another issue. Gender Ideology is all about the pressure, there's nothing else to it.

Hopefully, like every single other person, the more she's exposed to this activism, the more she realises the lack of rationality and the great danger to children. She also needs to understand that it is a mens sexual rights movement. The children are being used. It doesn't mean they're not suffering, it does mean they are being encouraged to suffer.

Personally, given the nature of her job, I would've thought that enlightenment would have come long before this tho.

Edited

It annoys me that she keeps referring to "malign" actors on "both sides" when the most obvious malignant actions arise from trans activists - even in her own examples.

AudHvamm · Yesterday 14:42

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 14:26

What the fuck has Cass' putative sexuality got to do with the price of cheese?!

Since when did these grotty old men decide 'lesbian' was a derogatory term? The absolute misogynist contempt is astonishing.

Leave women alone, you fucking oddbod.

As @MarcTheGenderSkeptic says above its an a direct replication of the dynamic that used "comedy" to shut down women's objections to sexually exploitative behaviour. If you don't go along with it we'll insult you in ways that make it clear your sexual value is diminished because sexual value is the only value you have.

I was a overtly feminist young adult in the 2000s and regularly got called a "fucking/humourless d*ke" (among other insults) when I spoke to boys/men about sex-based oppression & exploitation.

The patriarchy is the ultimate shapshifting Hydra isn't it?

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 14:42

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 14:28

To my eternal shame as a GC, I'd been seriously considering wandering back to voting Labour. And then behaviour like this by the minister shocks me back to reality.

Do we know which minister this was?

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 14:45

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 13:23

@Fidgetbreak

Maybe she'd like to have another look at the puberty blocker trial.

Now that, that I would put good hard cash towards, if it were even a glimmer of a possibility.

She did mention she'd received phone calls from doctors at some of the new gender clinics ( which she named) expressing concern that their practice might be reported for being " abusive" or causing distress - should this draft version be made law.

CassOle · Yesterday 14:45

I did read Olivia Bailey MP's name in relation to this on the 'What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues' thread. Hopefully this link takes you to the post in question.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5599816-what-would-it-take-for-your-to-change-your-mind-for-transgender-issues?page=21&reply=155980829&utm_campaign=reply&utm_medium=share&utm_source=copylink

singthing · Yesterday 14:48

@Datun "But Hilary Cass isn't Jill on the street. That's my worry.
She has been subjected to all the misogyny, but she doesn't appear to be connecting the dots between that, and this bill."

I would pay excellent money to witness a debate between Germaine Greer (or any of the indefatigable women who have been publicly fighting this), Hillary Cass and Margaret Atwood. The latter two are sooooo close to it yet still a chasm away. But I think the scales would fall in real time. And that would be something to see.

Hell, even throw in India or some other activist of choice if you want. Let's get it all out for everyone to see.

OP posts:
MarcTheGenderSkeptic · Yesterday 14:48

Cass has been thrown into a total maelstrom with the most serious ramifications. I'm not sure she envisaged even 1% of this when she wrote her report. That created the most toxic backlash. She's to be commended for keeping her head despite all.the death threats. It's very possible she believes there's a very small but very troubled cohort of youth that would benefit from some medical intervention. Even as a GC, totally get how extreme body dysmorphia via the lens of gender would come across that way. Hence her limited support for the PB trial.
And now, this third massive event, this Conversion Practices Bill, and again she's personally under massive pressure, and maybe she naively waved it thru before properly being fully appraised. I can accept her 180. She's no politician, that's for sure.

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 14:51

CassOle · Yesterday 14:45

I did read Olivia Bailey MP's name in relation to this on the 'What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues' thread. Hopefully this link takes you to the post in question.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5599816-what-would-it-take-for-your-to-change-your-mind-for-transgender-issues?page=21&reply=155980829&utm_campaign=reply&utm_medium=share&utm_source=copylink

Thanks! That makes sense. She's the new chair of the Women and Equallities Committee isn't she?

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 14:57

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 14:42

Do we know which minister this was?

“Liv” Olivia Bailey