Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law" - Telegraph article share

290 replies

singthing · Yesterday 07:46

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

Baroness Cass has turned against Labour’s plans for a new conversion therapy law, warning that it would have a “chilling effect” on doctors.

Lady Cass, who led a review of the treatment of children with gender dysphoria, previously backed the Conversion Practices Bill but said she had only been given an hour to read the draft legislation before providing a supportive comment for a government press release in June.

On Monday, she told MPs that she regretted backing it, and having read it through now thought it could have “serious unintended consequences”.
...

Continues at:
^Original: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/16/baroness-cass-turns-against-chilling-trans-law/^
Gift: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2
^Archive: https://archive.ph/rP3Np^

Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
ArabellaScott · Today 16:43

The study details some distressing abuse.

Physical assault, rape, threats, are all already illegal, yet there is not a single mention of anyone suggesting that Galop advised to report them. It's a bit odd, really. Did they not advise all their clients that they could go to police? Did they say 'there isn't a law calling it conversion practise, so nothing we can do, soz'.

61% is described as emotional/psychological abuse. That's tricky terrain.

Control and coercion is already illegal, of course.

https://www.cps.gov.uk/prosecution-guidance/controlling-or-coercive-behaviour-intimate-or-family-relationship

I really don't see how cases like the one with the haircut pressure I quoted above can be prosecuted.

But what is very clear and what I hadn't realised is that this is a bill aimed squarely at parents.

Vast majority of people accused of conversion practise would be parents.

This bill looks like a wedge.

ArabellaScott · Today 16:45

Oh, I just found this bit:

'Rape and sexual assault are already criminal offences. However, these
findings, alongside existing research from Galop and others,33 suggest
existing protections are not sufficient for capturing the complexity
of conversion practices or the totality of harms caused.'

Doesn't explain why they aren't sufficient.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Today 16:45

ArabellaScott · Today 16:15

"A higher proportion of trans respondents (13%), compared to non-trans respondents (7%), said they had been offered or subjected to conversion practices."

Yes, but how is trans being defined? The trans umbrella has been said to include gay, lesbian, bi, non-bi, drag artists, the undecided, the questioning, and scads of other undefined or ill-defined groups. Saying "more trans people are subjected to conversion therapy than non trans people" is meaningless without any definition of who is in which group. And we also need to define conversion therapy: why is conversion therapy being offered to people who are none of these things? Conversion from what? (Vegetarianism and being a Moonie seem possible but unlikely to be what they are talking about.)

And then there is "Conversion practices include all behaviours towards someone that have the intention to change, ‘cure’ or suppress a person’s sexual or romantic orientation and/or gender identity. "

How do you know what the intention of someone else's behaviour is? If they ask you why you have decided that you are non-binary, is that attempted conversion or just normal human curiosity? If they suggest you look silly in a bad wig, short skirt and fishnets, is that attempted conversion or merely a statement about your lack of fashion sense?

ArabellaScott · Today 16:47

Conclusion:

'The cases analysed here indicate that conversion practices can take
multiple forms and often occur alongside other forms of abuse.
They can involve a range of formal and informal actions which, as
this study shows, rarely consist of a single incident or a single kind
of practice.36 Some of the conversion practice behaviours evidenced
in the analysed cases align with existing offences, including actual
bodily harm, rape and sexual assault, forced marriage, and coercive
control, among others.
While existing laws cover these forms of abuse, they fail to capture
conversion practices in their entirety – especially those that do not
involve physical or sexual violence and therefore do not address the
full scope of their distinct harms. Current UK law does not adequately
recognise the nuanced (and often ”covert and insidious“)37 nature of
conversion practices, thereby ”leaving a significant gap in protection
for LGBT+ individuals”'

I don't know much about law, but I don't see why existing laws plus hate crime laws aren't adequate to cover this.

ArabellaScott · Today 16:48

I assume in traditional genderist fashion, a trans person is 'anyone who says so'.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · Today 16:53

ArabellaScott · Today 16:48

I assume in traditional genderist fashion, a trans person is 'anyone who says so'.

Which is a completely meaningless category. After all, because I have been sterilised and thus had an operation that changed my sexuality under some definition or other I forget, I am technically trans according to that definition. I was startled to discover this, and can't think of any way I can make practical use of it, but there it is.

The definition also includes a few people who emphatically deny that they are trans and wish to have nothing to do with it, but get dragged in anyway as a gotcha.

ScrollingLeaves · Today 17:00

ArabellaScott · Today 16:32

'Client is frequently told by his parents to cut his hair, that his sexuality is just a phase, and [is] pressured to marry a woman or have children. Client disclosed that this abuse is continuous. Client’s family have passed around his phone number trying to match-make him, they pray for him and try to emotionally blackmail and manipulate him. At a family event, Client’s mother and uncle/family friends were trying to set him up with a woman and encouraging him
to marry a woman.'

I mean, this might be annoying or unpleasant or even upsetting. May well be an unhealthy of dysfunctional family dynamic. But should it really be criminal for a parent to tell a child to cut his or her hair?

This sounds cultural. There are all sorts of expectations people have for their children, foremost among them that they should have children, especially among some ethnic/religious communities. Wading in to criminalise it all will not work.

Bit by bit the children rebel and the mores change. Unless they are being honor killed or forced into marriage, which are already rightly crimes.

alcovecupboards · Today 17:07

ScrollingLeaves · Today 17:00

This sounds cultural. There are all sorts of expectations people have for their children, foremost among them that they should have children, especially among some ethnic/religious communities. Wading in to criminalise it all will not work.

Bit by bit the children rebel and the mores change. Unless they are being honor killed or forced into marriage, which are already rightly crimes.

So fine to pressure a young woman to marry her cousin from a foreign land? After all that's cultural.

ScrollingLeaves · Today 17:10

What do you want to do about it Alcove? Only help her if she is a lesbian? Or if she identifies as a transman?

I do not know for sure, but think there is already a law to protect all females from forced marriages.

MrsOvertonsWindow · Today 17:26

ScrollingLeaves · Today 17:10

What do you want to do about it Alcove? Only help her if she is a lesbian? Or if she identifies as a transman?

I do not know for sure, but think there is already a law to protect all females from forced marriages.

It's been taken seriously in this country for many years - there's a special home Office Unit devoted to supporting young women and intervening before they're taken out of the country:

https://www.gov.uk/stop-forced-marriage

Forced marriage

What to do if you or someone you know is being forced into getting married, how you can try to stop the marriage from taking place, and what to do if you want to leave a forced marriage

https://www.gov.uk/stop-forced-marriage

ArabellaScott · Today 17:27

https://www.gov.uk/stop-forced-marriage

'You have the right to choose who you marry, when you marry or if you marry at all.
Forced marriage is when you face physical pressure to marry (for example, threats, physical violence or sexual violence) or emotional and psychological pressure (for example, if you’re made to feel like you’re bringing shame on your family).
If you’re under 18 any marriage is considered a forced marriage, even if there is no physical or emotional pressure involved.'

{except in Scotland, fact fans!}

Forced marriage

What to do if you or someone you know is being forced into getting married, how you can try to stop the marriage from taking place, and what to do if you want to leave a forced marriage

https://www.gov.uk/stop-forced-marriage

ArabellaScott · Today 17:27

cross post, Mrs O.

ArabellaScott · Today 17:29

'Forcing someone into a marriage or civil partnership is a crime in Scotland. This includes:

  • using emotional or physical pressure to force them into marriage
  • taking someone abroad to force them to marry – whether the forced marriage takes place or not
  • marrying someone who cannot understand or agree to the marriage – whether they’re pressured or not
The pressure to marry can be:
  • physical – such as threats or violence
  • emotional and psychological – such as being made to feel you're bringing shame on your family'

www.mygov.scot/forced-marriage

Emilesgran · Today 18:14

noblegiraffe · Today 09:46

It's not GC women who are sending death threats, it's only from one side and it's about time she was honest about that too.

Thing is, there are definitely transphobes out there. I've seen some fairly horrendous comments on twitter (and on MN too tbh) targeting trans people. There was that video of that guy harassing that trans woman who was just sat on a bench (condemned on MN but that doesn't mean it didn't happen). Are you sure that there aren't any transphobes aren't out there sending death or rape threats? It seems vanishingly unlikely to me given how many death and rape threats are sent to women for merely existing in a public space.

I'm not saying that it's GC women who are sending them, but if there are 'two sides' in this debate, then there is clearly poor behaviour on 'both sides' even if a subgroup condemns and distances itself from that behaviour.

"Are you sure that there aren't any transphobes aren't out there sending (transphobic) death or rape threats?"

Ermm, I'm sure there are - but that wasn't the question. Unless they are GC women. And I'm sure they aren't.

For one thing, men fairly frequently send rape or death threats - women, vanishingly rarely.

Is this going to become a trans remake of that other thread where an "I'm as feminist as they come but..." poster is complaining about people saying that rapists are generally men not women? 🙄

noblegiraffe · Today 18:37

Emilesgran · Today 18:14

"Are you sure that there aren't any transphobes aren't out there sending (transphobic) death or rape threats?"

Ermm, I'm sure there are - but that wasn't the question. Unless they are GC women. And I'm sure they aren't.

For one thing, men fairly frequently send rape or death threats - women, vanishingly rarely.

Is this going to become a trans remake of that other thread where an "I'm as feminist as they come but..." poster is complaining about people saying that rapists are generally men not women? 🙄

No, I’m saying that the ‘side’ that Cass is referring to is bigger than just GC feminists.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page