Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law" - Telegraph article share

290 replies

singthing · Yesterday 07:46

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

Baroness Cass has turned against Labour’s plans for a new conversion therapy law, warning that it would have a “chilling effect” on doctors.

Lady Cass, who led a review of the treatment of children with gender dysphoria, previously backed the Conversion Practices Bill but said she had only been given an hour to read the draft legislation before providing a supportive comment for a government press release in June.

On Monday, she told MPs that she regretted backing it, and having read it through now thought it could have “serious unintended consequences”.
...

Continues at:
^Original: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/16/baroness-cass-turns-against-chilling-trans-law/^
Gift: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2
^Archive: https://archive.ph/rP3Np^

Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 17:38

Emilesgran · Yesterday 17:21

But maybe not a medical trial where all the subjects were going to be given the treatment being tested, just at different times in their lives?

Oh don’t. You’ll just go round and round in circles with that one. So tedious.

(eta - the person you’re replying to I mean. You’re not tedious, you’re sensible!)

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 17:39

BettyBooper · Yesterday 17:38

I thought they were to be given the medication, but a year later?

The ones enrolled in the trial are, there’s a control group outside of the trial in a separate study.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 17:51

@BettyBooper The so-called “control” group is not a control group - they are not a group of children with gender dysphoria who are not being given blockers. They are intended to be a matched group of children who do not have gender dysphoria. There’s a loooooong thread about this - I’ll see if I can find the link…

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 17:55

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 17:51

@BettyBooper The so-called “control” group is not a control group - they are not a group of children with gender dysphoria who are not being given blockers. They are intended to be a matched group of children who do not have gender dysphoria. There’s a loooooong thread about this - I’ll see if I can find the link…

This may be the thread I was thinking of:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5552735-hilary-cass-sent-a-document-to-every-single-mp-and-peer-justifying-and-defending-the-puberty-blockers-trial

Hilary Cass sent a document to every single MP and Peer, justifying and defending the puberty blockers trial | Mumsnet

[[https://x.com/JamesEsses/status/2075512549248745744?s=20 https://x.com/JamesEsses/status/2075512549248745744?s=20]] There are ten images on X, sorr...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5552735-hilary-cass-sent-a-document-to-every-single-mp-and-peer-justifying-and-defending-the-puberty-blockers-trial

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 17:58

Alternatively it might be this one. Worth noting that in this thread we discover that the designers of the PB study make it clear that it is not a clinical trial but a pragmatic one, meaning that the conclusions that can be drawn from it will be much narrower and much less strong:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womensrights/5558686-pathways-puberty-blocker-trial-high-court-proceedings-start-27th-july

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 18:01

Oh, I dont know. I think we can draw some pretty strong conclusions on the people pushing ahead with this trial.

DrBlackbird · Yesterday 18:34

BlueLegume · Yesterday 11:23

Olivia Bailey MP was pretty rattled yesterday. She proposed the bill and also sounds like she somewhat mislead Baroness Cass which prompted the original backing of the bill by Cass. I am really heartened that Cass has now reconsidered her initial response, has laid out clearly why she responded as she did - pressure from Bailey - and has clearly laid out the reality of this bill where children are involved.

My knowledge of Bailey is scant and frankly I find her insufferable but I would be interested to know who got to her and thought this bill was good. I am assuming Stonewall but am happy to be educated.

They could have had things going ok for them but they brought children into this.
I suspect Baileys passive aggressive questioning of Cass will be hailed as great debating by some. for me she behaved like a petulant child.

All too often our ambitious MPs look to find ‘their’ campaigning issue to make a name for themselves. The ambition can easily override any critical thinking. Especially for a hard of thinking MP of which we seem to have an annoying surplus.

Perhaps this was meant to be Olivia’s moment in the sun hence really pushing Baroness (?) Cass hard for a supportive statement. Though the fact that Cass was given so little time to read it suggests Bailey knew it was a poisoned chalice.

I did wonder if it was the potential trouble for doctors specifically that has led to her speaking out ie other medics have spoken to her, but I don’t care about the motivation as long as this helps either kill or permanently stall the bill.

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 18:35

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 17:51

@BettyBooper The so-called “control” group is not a control group - they are not a group of children with gender dysphoria who are not being given blockers. They are intended to be a matched group of children who do not have gender dysphoria. There’s a loooooong thread about this - I’ll see if I can find the link…

Not sure where you are getting your information from, but the control group of children are attending the gender clinic for gender incongruence. They are a subgroup of the Horizon study into children with gender incongruence.

"The study will follow and compare young people enrolled in the PATHWAYS TRIAL, who are offered puberty suppressing hormones either immediately or after one year, and young people from PATHWAYS HORIZON INTENSIVE, who are not receiving puberty suppressing hormones. It will not follow everyone in these studies but a group from each."

"To understand whether puberty suppressing hormones affect brain development, a research study needs to be done to compare young people receiving puberty blockers to those who do not. PATHWAYS CONNECT is the first study to explore this among young people with gender incongruence."

https://www.kcl.ac.uk/research/pathways-study-connect

KCL

PATHWAYS CONNECT | King's College London

PATHWAYS CONNECT will look at young people’s thinking and brain development and will follow both those who are and are not, taking puberty suppressing hormones

https://www.kcl.ac.uk/research/pathways-study-connect

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 19:09

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 18:35

Not sure where you are getting your information from, but the control group of children are attending the gender clinic for gender incongruence. They are a subgroup of the Horizon study into children with gender incongruence.

"The study will follow and compare young people enrolled in the PATHWAYS TRIAL, who are offered puberty suppressing hormones either immediately or after one year, and young people from PATHWAYS HORIZON INTENSIVE, who are not receiving puberty suppressing hormones. It will not follow everyone in these studies but a group from each."

"To understand whether puberty suppressing hormones affect brain development, a research study needs to be done to compare young people receiving puberty blockers to those who do not. PATHWAYS CONNECT is the first study to explore this among young people with gender incongruence."

https://www.kcl.ac.uk/research/pathways-study-connect

Apologies - you are correct: the non-randomised observational comparison group will consist of children with gender incongruence. They are not a clinical control however, and they will not be receiving a placebo drug.

Also, does anyone else remember a discussion when this first came up about whether there would be issues in matching this comparison group with the test group? To do with the fact that by default all of the children (and their families) in the test group must want puberty blockers, while at least some of the comparison group are likely to be children/families that do not want puberty blockers. Does that ring a bell with anyone?

DrBlackbird · Yesterday 19:15

SchoolOfCool · Yesterday 15:17

Can't believe Stonewall are admitting out loud that trans ideology converts lesbians.

What happened to "some people are gay, get over it"?

"Every day another middle aged lesbian is coming out against it. They are frightened their dating pool will get even smaller."

I didn’t even get this so-called joke. First, the comment was ageist homophobic misogyny. I guess we’re used to from Stonewall and TRAs. It was also a shocking direct insult to Cass. But it also didn’t make sense in that the conversion bill, I thought, was meant to address conversion attempts against the whole of the LBGQT+ groups. And not just the TQ groups.

So making a quip implying that lesbians are currently being subjected to conversion therapy to stop them from becoming transmen… is a weird claim and not remotely funny. I find it breathtaking that MPs or anyone would laugh at this ‘joke’. What is the fucking matter with people?

At least it makes clear they don’t give a shit about those who are LGB.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 19:43

Olivia Bailey asks whether if the two points that Cass raised as especially problematic (healthcare workers not having adequate description of threshold, and parents ditto, roughly) would satisfy her and if she could then support the Bill.

Cass says 'the devil is in the detail'. (about 16.34 minutes in)

I don't think she'll be inclined to give Bailey the benefit of the doubt again.

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 19:44

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 19:09

Apologies - you are correct: the non-randomised observational comparison group will consist of children with gender incongruence. They are not a clinical control however, and they will not be receiving a placebo drug.

Also, does anyone else remember a discussion when this first came up about whether there would be issues in matching this comparison group with the test group? To do with the fact that by default all of the children (and their families) in the test group must want puberty blockers, while at least some of the comparison group are likely to be children/families that do not want puberty blockers. Does that ring a bell with anyone?

Well no, they aren't randomised because they aren't in the trial, and it would be pointless giving a placebo in a trial that can't be blinded due to the effects of the drug being rapidly obvious.

The delayed treatment arm of the trial are randomised though so there will be comparator data from the delayed treatment arm, and from the sister study who aren't getting the medication at all.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 19:46

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 19:09

Apologies - you are correct: the non-randomised observational comparison group will consist of children with gender incongruence. They are not a clinical control however, and they will not be receiving a placebo drug.

Also, does anyone else remember a discussion when this first came up about whether there would be issues in matching this comparison group with the test group? To do with the fact that by default all of the children (and their families) in the test group must want puberty blockers, while at least some of the comparison group are likely to be children/families that do not want puberty blockers. Does that ring a bell with anyone?

Vague memories. I remember digging into all the trial criteria and published documents. I think part of the problem is that you can't really do a 'controlled' test because it will be very obvious whether a child has had their puberty stopped or not.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 19:52

Cass is doing a LOT of 'both sides' in discussion of protection and risk, and I guess the general temperature of the debate.

On the TRA side there are of course BashBack and others who have committed crimes, vandalised, terrorised, attacked, doxxed, swatted, etc.

Who does she mean on the 'gender critical' side? She references Trump, which does seem odd and completely besides the point. There surely isn't anyone who has done anything other than write letters, campaign, and peaceful protest?

16.42 she talks about Sam Hall/WellBN, for the pp who was asking.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 20:15

Cass describes WPATH as 'more affirmative' than her approach.

So she really doesn't seem to have grasped the issues, then.

EricTheHalfASleeve · Yesterday 21:44

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 19:44

Well no, they aren't randomised because they aren't in the trial, and it would be pointless giving a placebo in a trial that can't be blinded due to the effects of the drug being rapidly obvious.

The delayed treatment arm of the trial are randomised though so there will be comparator data from the delayed treatment arm, and from the sister study who aren't getting the medication at all.

It's a junk comparator group unfortunately. The children on the immediate access to puberty blockers path will have different exposure to psychological support than the delayed blockers pathway. There is also such a wide age range allowed into the trial that once the group is broken down by age/sex/stage of puberty (which they'll have to, it's meaningless to compare a female put on puberty blockers at 12 with a male starting them at 15 years) their subgroups will be so tiny there will be no meaningful findings.

The rule with science is that if you put junk in you get junk out. Pathways is a junk trial.

I wonder how their recruitment will go - is there still a big number of children where the parents are willing to let them have puberty blockers?

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 22:09

EricTheHalfASleeve · Yesterday 21:44

It's a junk comparator group unfortunately. The children on the immediate access to puberty blockers path will have different exposure to psychological support than the delayed blockers pathway. There is also such a wide age range allowed into the trial that once the group is broken down by age/sex/stage of puberty (which they'll have to, it's meaningless to compare a female put on puberty blockers at 12 with a male starting them at 15 years) their subgroups will be so tiny there will be no meaningful findings.

The rule with science is that if you put junk in you get junk out. Pathways is a junk trial.

I wonder how their recruitment will go - is there still a big number of children where the parents are willing to let them have puberty blockers?

I mean, this is all addressed in the protocol, but are you saying that when the results come out and show significant decline in IQ/impact on brain development/bone density reduction and no significant impact on anxiety/depression compared to the control, will you still be rejecting it as a junk trial with junk results?

Tears0fTheMushroom · Yesterday 22:20

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 09:57

I suppose my issue with the way she has approached this, is that it is her job to "look under the bonnet" before she opens her mouth and issues a statement about said subjects. If people didn't want her professional opinion, they wouldn't ask her. And, to my mind, her response was not "professional" - it was rushed and unconsidered.

I hope she has not approached the puberty blockers clinical trial in the same way.

ed. sp. pubert? who's Pubert?

Edited

The 3rd Addams child I believe

"Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law" - Telegraph article share
EricTheHalfASleeve · Yesterday 22:28

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 22:09

I mean, this is all addressed in the protocol, but are you saying that when the results come out and show significant decline in IQ/impact on brain development/bone density reduction and no significant impact on anxiety/depression compared to the control, will you still be rejecting it as a junk trial with junk results?

I doubt if they'll get enough numbers to draw any statistically significant conclusions on IQ (very difficult to study, changes somewhat over childhood and hugely influenced by education). Bone density - is the follow-up long enough to be expected to show anything?
They still haven't started recruiting yet, very unlikely to complete by 2028. I suspect it will be a very hard trial to recruit to - if the parents support blockers they won't want to be randomised to waiting, and if they don't support blockers they can simply refuse consent.

Tears0fTheMushroom · Yesterday 22:32

I'd agree with those saying that she should have been more careful before her intital endorsement of the bill, but actually, the fact that she's so publicly changed her mind and highlighted the devious methods used to obtain her endorsement has made her objection into far bigger news than it would have been. And it's shown Olivia Bailey up as a treacherous fool so that's a bonus

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 23:01

EricTheHalfASleeve · Yesterday 22:28

I doubt if they'll get enough numbers to draw any statistically significant conclusions on IQ (very difficult to study, changes somewhat over childhood and hugely influenced by education). Bone density - is the follow-up long enough to be expected to show anything?
They still haven't started recruiting yet, very unlikely to complete by 2028. I suspect it will be a very hard trial to recruit to - if the parents support blockers they won't want to be randomised to waiting, and if they don't support blockers they can simply refuse consent.

They already had 17 patients lined up when the appeal to stop the trial was in court in July. I agree recruitment will be slow (and I was surprised by the 17 lined up), but it wouldn't be the first trial to need longer.

Re IQ - they have a clause in the protocol to stop the drug if there is a >10 point drop in IQ that they attribute to the drug, so they must be reasonably confident of validity.

Bone density - previous studies have shown changes during treatment and a recovery after treatment so I guess they can see the impact in real time.

BettyBooper · Yesterday 23:09

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 18:35

Not sure where you are getting your information from, but the control group of children are attending the gender clinic for gender incongruence. They are a subgroup of the Horizon study into children with gender incongruence.

"The study will follow and compare young people enrolled in the PATHWAYS TRIAL, who are offered puberty suppressing hormones either immediately or after one year, and young people from PATHWAYS HORIZON INTENSIVE, who are not receiving puberty suppressing hormones. It will not follow everyone in these studies but a group from each."

"To understand whether puberty suppressing hormones affect brain development, a research study needs to be done to compare young people receiving puberty blockers to those who do not. PATHWAYS CONNECT is the first study to explore this among young people with gender incongruence."

https://www.kcl.ac.uk/research/pathways-study-connect

I'm interested that 'gender incongruence' is still being banded about as if it has any proper scientific basis, tbh.

I understand that some people desperately wish not to be the sex they were born and I have huge sympathy for that, but that is not what 'gender incongruence' implies: it implies that you somehow don't behave in a 'gender congruent' way.

BettyBooper · Yesterday 23:13

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 23:01

They already had 17 patients lined up when the appeal to stop the trial was in court in July. I agree recruitment will be slow (and I was surprised by the 17 lined up), but it wouldn't be the first trial to need longer.

Re IQ - they have a clause in the protocol to stop the drug if there is a >10 point drop in IQ that they attribute to the drug, so they must be reasonably confident of validity.

Bone density - previous studies have shown changes during treatment and a recovery after treatment so I guess they can see the impact in real time.

A 10 point drop in IQ! They think it's acceptable to put kids into a trial of a drug that they'll stop if... it gets to more that a 10 point drop in IQ??!

What parent would agree to this?

Hindsight101 · Yesterday 23:30

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 11:50

@noblegiraffe

Unlike you, I wouldn’t be sure of the best way to treat that sort of child either, even if removed from their parents.

I would have no idea what to do with that child either. But I do think that deciding that any child could never be reconciled with their natal body (and should therefore be medicalised for life) is an extreme position to take, and one that isn’t supported by child development research.

Hard agree