Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law" - Telegraph article share

290 replies

singthing · Yesterday 07:46

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

Baroness Cass has turned against Labour’s plans for a new conversion therapy law, warning that it would have a “chilling effect” on doctors.

Lady Cass, who led a review of the treatment of children with gender dysphoria, previously backed the Conversion Practices Bill but said she had only been given an hour to read the draft legislation before providing a supportive comment for a government press release in June.

On Monday, she told MPs that she regretted backing it, and having read it through now thought it could have “serious unintended consequences”.
...

Continues at:
^Original: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/16/baroness-cass-turns-against-chilling-trans-law/^
Gift: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2
^Archive: https://archive.ph/rP3Np^

Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Imnobody4 · Yesterday 12:40

Tweet by Kate Harris
https://x.com/Kathari17674744/status/2122612152284426388?a=zPzYEW8jZ7QdkEGI7mg&s=09
At a Stonewall reception in parliament last night on the draft Bill on Conversion Practices a speaker said:

"Every day another middle aged lesbian is coming out against it. They are frightened their dating pool will get even smaller." Everyone laughed uproariously at this.

Is it funny Stonewall that a generation of young lesbians have been told that they are in fact trans and need to destroy their healthy bodies and minds? Is it funny that middle-aged lesbians want to warn against this?

When was it exactly that you lost your moral compass?Is there any lower for you to go? How dare you pretend this Bill would protect young homosexuals - all you want is to destroy them.

Kate Harris profile picture

Kate Harris (@Kathari17674744) on X

At a Stonewall reception in parliament last night on the draft Bill on Conversion Practices a speaker said: "Every day another middle aged lesbian is coming out against it. They are frightened their dating pool will get even smaller." Everyone laughe...

https://x.com/Kathari17674744/status/2122612152284426388?a=zPzYEW8jZ7QdkEGI7mg&s=09

HannahinHampshire · Yesterday 12:42

Discussing on Jeremy Vine (radio 2) now.

Imnobody4 · Yesterday 12:45

And India Willoughby's deranged contribution on X.

Hillary Cass is a ‘gender critical’ lesbian. Recruited by Kemi Badenoch specifically because of her anti-trans views to write an ‘independant’ study on trans healthcare. Nobody else was interviewed for the gig. She binned 90% of existing studies, which confirmed gender AFFIRMING care had a 99% success rate.
I mean, just look at her. Feel the energy. QUACK.
As with all things ‘gender critical’ and Right Wing, fixed from the start. Aye, hacker @KemiBadenoch #EVIL

KTheGrey · Yesterday 12:50

BlueLegume · Yesterday 08:20

No one wants conversion therapy because we know it is wrong. Pondering the title of the new draft bill I wonder if whoever proposed it thought the title would immediately garner support purely because it is something we all agree is wrong. It really is a Trojan Horse for me to bring in very sinister ideas and very much detrimental to good parents and caregivers.

The most chilling aspect of it is the threats to freedom of speech and belief and to family/private life. I struggle to believe that anybody in a position of power does not see and understand this, although tunnel vision is a great way of blinding people to unintended consequences.

Cantunseeit · Yesterday 12:52

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 11:23

Well that’s what I mean. If parliamentarians are telling you that an anti-conversion bill is needed to stop gay children being abused into thinking they’re straight, and that other countries are also implementing this, you would kind of think they know what they are talking about, wouldn’t you? Because it would be super weird to be fighting to introduce a wholly unnecessary bill.

I think it is fine for your first instinct to be ‘yes, that sounds like something that children need protection from’ rather than ‘that sounds like an evil plot OR you don’t know what you’re talking about’

And then it’s also fine to change your mind after hearing from people who do know what they’re talking about. We can’t all be experts on everything and we can’t always do everyone else’s jobs for them.

And having no trust in any public institution or children’s charity is the sad state of affairs many people find themselves living in as a direct result of trans activism.

It is on the one hand a bit crap to feel like I need to research topics and organisations thoroughly myself before placing any credence in what they are saying. On the other hand I am glad that I am no longer credulous about anything- it’s actually quite useful.

I am surprised Baroness Cass was hoodwinked so successfully regarding the wording of this bill given her prior experience. However I’m glad she stood her ground yesterday

Fidgetbreak · Yesterday 13:08

I'll commend her for publicly admitting to the mistake. However, it was very naive to agree to speak at a press conference supporting a policy she hadn't even seen yet.

It reveals how chaotic and manipulative these campaigns can be. I expect a lot of important decisions like this are made with a similar lack of scrutiny, and a desire to be seen to do the right thing, rather than put in the hard work to actually do it.

Maybe she'd like to have another look at the puberty blocker trial.

ScrollingLeaves · Yesterday 13:14

ItsCoolForCats · Yesterday 12:55

Now reported in the Guardian

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2026/nov/17/expert-nhs-gender-review-cannot-back-conversion-practices-ban

Cass's intervention has been really important for this bill getting wider attention. The government can't ignore this.

Thank you for this link.

I note that for balance against her stance they say,

Last week, Dr Igi Moon, a psychologist representing a coalition of more than 25 health, counselling and psychotherapy organisations that have signed a memorandum of understanding to end conversion practices, spoke in support of the bill.

They do not also quote the doctor who wrote in the Times saying the opposite.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 13:15

Imnobody4 · Yesterday 12:40

Tweet by Kate Harris
https://x.com/Kathari17674744/status/2122612152284426388?a=zPzYEW8jZ7QdkEGI7mg&s=09
At a Stonewall reception in parliament last night on the draft Bill on Conversion Practices a speaker said:

"Every day another middle aged lesbian is coming out against it. They are frightened their dating pool will get even smaller." Everyone laughed uproariously at this.

Is it funny Stonewall that a generation of young lesbians have been told that they are in fact trans and need to destroy their healthy bodies and minds? Is it funny that middle-aged lesbians want to warn against this?

When was it exactly that you lost your moral compass?Is there any lower for you to go? How dare you pretend this Bill would protect young homosexuals - all you want is to destroy them.

Yet another reason to hate Stonewall and everything they stand for and do. Well done, Simon.

(Come onto FWR, Simon, and deny this was said, if you dare. I know your foot soldiers read this forum. If they don't, they should. Know thy enemy, and all that...)

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 13:21

SchoolOfCool · Yesterday 11:06

Yes I agree with this.

I don't agree with her stance on true trans children (I think the root is always societal homophobia / sexist stereotypes; developmental environment; trauma; neurodiversity; etc) but I can accept her current opinion is held in good faith.

Tbh, the distinction between Cass's beliefs and mine is similar to the "nature Vs nurture and don't forget epigenetics" discussions around many mental health diagnoses.

but I can accept her current opinion is held in good faith.

From personal experience, this is the last, desperate fallback for those who have a trans-identified family member. It must be assumed that some of those who identify as trans are "true." The alternative is too horrific, and no parent, grandparent, or even aunt or uncle would want to admit that this is a fallacy and that they are somehow complicit. I count myself among those numbers. The fact that I could do nothing helpful, once I realized the perniciousness of this ideology, does not negate the fact that we all, in my family, started out as "kind."

Datun · Yesterday 13:21

“I was trying to be as helpful as I could to the then minister. I had said I wouldn’t comment until I’d seen it. It was sent to me an hour before they wanted a press release and 15 minutes before I walked on the platform to give a talk.

“So I tried to give the quotes based on the principles that I’ve been told about but without seeing the bill as drafted, and maybe I shouldn’t have done that.”

It does worry me that she appears unaware of the extent of the activism behind the push for this bill.

Anyone, anyone at all, even peripherally related to this issue, much less neck deep in it, would be deeply suspicious of being asked to quote on a bill that you were only given an hour to review.

Not only that, if she felt under pressurise, that's another issue. Gender Ideology is all about the pressure, there's nothing else to it.

Hopefully, like every single other person, the more she's exposed to this activism, the more she realises the lack of rationality and the great danger to children. She also needs to understand that it is a mens sexual rights movement. The children are being used. It doesn't mean they're not suffering, it does mean they are being encouraged to suffer.

Personally, given the nature of her job, I would've thought that enlightenment would have come long before this tho.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Yesterday 13:23

@Fidgetbreak

Maybe she'd like to have another look at the puberty blocker trial.

Now that, that I would put good hard cash towards, if it were even a glimmer of a possibility.

Datun · Yesterday 13:24

“I was trying to be as helpful as I could to the then minister. I had said I wouldn’t comment until I’d seen it.

Just rereading this. This means that she was asked to comment on it without ever having read it at all!

Giving her an hour was a reluctant concession.

Ffs.

it certainly looks like that was a massive scale falling exercise.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 13:25

Datun · Yesterday 13:21

“I was trying to be as helpful as I could to the then minister. I had said I wouldn’t comment until I’d seen it. It was sent to me an hour before they wanted a press release and 15 minutes before I walked on the platform to give a talk.

“So I tried to give the quotes based on the principles that I’ve been told about but without seeing the bill as drafted, and maybe I shouldn’t have done that.”

It does worry me that she appears unaware of the extent of the activism behind the push for this bill.

Anyone, anyone at all, even peripherally related to this issue, much less neck deep in it, would be deeply suspicious of being asked to quote on a bill that you were only given an hour to review.

Not only that, if she felt under pressurise, that's another issue. Gender Ideology is all about the pressure, there's nothing else to it.

Hopefully, like every single other person, the more she's exposed to this activism, the more she realises the lack of rationality and the great danger to children. She also needs to understand that it is a mens sexual rights movement. The children are being used. It doesn't mean they're not suffering, it does mean they are being encouraged to suffer.

Personally, given the nature of her job, I would've thought that enlightenment would have come long before this tho.

Edited

Honestly, she strikes me as out of her depth.

Datun · Yesterday 13:26

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 13:25

Honestly, she strikes me as out of her depth.

Yes. The political, rights activism side to this is 99% of it. She's still operating in that 1%.

Datun · Yesterday 13:28

Hopefully, like very many women before her, this will be the turning point.

Shedmistress · Yesterday 13:30

Lets not forget that Russell Viner, who 3 years after Dr Cass left the position as President of RCPCH took over, he being the bloke that started the puberty blocker regime at GIDS and who had to go to several 'ethics' committees in order to find one which would approve his 'trial', and who then immediatley ignored his own guidelines.

They all swim in the same stream.

"Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law" - Telegraph article share
GreenAllOver · Yesterday 13:31

Fidgetbreak · Yesterday 13:08

I'll commend her for publicly admitting to the mistake. However, it was very naive to agree to speak at a press conference supporting a policy she hadn't even seen yet.

It reveals how chaotic and manipulative these campaigns can be. I expect a lot of important decisions like this are made with a similar lack of scrutiny, and a desire to be seen to do the right thing, rather than put in the hard work to actually do it.

Maybe she'd like to have another look at the puberty blocker trial.

This is how the Dept of Health originally published all the guidance that undermined single sex spaces - they either avoided senior and Ministerial scrutiny entirely or they pushed things through when Ministers were on leave or distracted. It’s the same playbook.

singthing · Yesterday 13:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 13:48

Good to see the Guardian reporting on Cass's reverse ferret.
We can't discount the fear of the number of extreme transactivists who are fully embedded in the NHS. They've been excitedly writing policies for the NHS wedging male sex offenders onto women's wards, presenting the male fetish for "feeding" babies with male secretions as socially acceptable while removng all accurate sex based accurate language from medical care.

Many of them are extremely powerful with considerable influence and I've no doubt Hilary Cass has had some scary times when they've confronted her.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 13:51

Imnobody4 · Yesterday 12:40

Tweet by Kate Harris
https://x.com/Kathari17674744/status/2122612152284426388?a=zPzYEW8jZ7QdkEGI7mg&s=09
At a Stonewall reception in parliament last night on the draft Bill on Conversion Practices a speaker said:

"Every day another middle aged lesbian is coming out against it. They are frightened their dating pool will get even smaller." Everyone laughed uproariously at this.

Is it funny Stonewall that a generation of young lesbians have been told that they are in fact trans and need to destroy their healthy bodies and minds? Is it funny that middle-aged lesbians want to warn against this?

When was it exactly that you lost your moral compass?Is there any lower for you to go? How dare you pretend this Bill would protect young homosexuals - all you want is to destroy them.

Men sneering at older women. Men sneering at lesbians.

Nothing new under the sun, is there?

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 13:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

100%.

It's hard to talk about children being sterilised in the services of an ideology that also supports men self castrating for sexual kicks, you sound like a raving lunatic.

But it's true.

https://www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/nhs-scotland-apologises-for-saying-eunuch-should-be-gender-identity-z8jcvrr6m

Verifying Device

https://www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/nhs-scotland-apologises-for-saying-eunuch-should-be-gender-identity-z8jcvrr6m

ItsCoolForCats · Yesterday 13:54

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 13:48

Good to see the Guardian reporting on Cass's reverse ferret.
We can't discount the fear of the number of extreme transactivists who are fully embedded in the NHS. They've been excitedly writing policies for the NHS wedging male sex offenders onto women's wards, presenting the male fetish for "feeding" babies with male secretions as socially acceptable while removng all accurate sex based accurate language from medical care.

Many of them are extremely powerful with considerable influence and I've no doubt Hilary Cass has had some scary times when they've confronted her.

Yes, I agree. As an example of what these people are like, look at the utterly unhinged claims on here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/transgenderUK/comments/1xyizs8/dr_cass_has_missed_the_facts/

BlueLegume · Yesterday 14:01

ItsCoolForCats · Yesterday 13:54

Yes, I agree. As an example of what these people are like, look at the utterly unhinged claims on here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/transgenderUK/comments/1xyizs8/dr_cass_has_missed_the_facts/

My goodness…all they have is ‘transphobe bigoted fascist’.

With regards to the aspect of children being involved I recall a conversation a couple of years ago with a very ‘be kind’ relative who was absolutely adamant children were no where near anything trans. She also was very dismissive towards me when I brought up AGP and fetish. She shut me down with a withering comment that my views said more about me than the harmless and minute trans community.

Be interesting to see if she reflects on our conversation in the light of this and convictions of Stephen Ireland and the information about Sam Hall off the Sarah Redvers tribunal.

I found it quite telling that Baroness Cass dropped the Sarah Redvers/Sam Hall bomb into the committee yesterday.