Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
user1471538275 · 15/11/2026 11:56

The biological profile of men would have to change so that:

They had the same average height and strength as women.

They evolved to give birth to children and do the lion's share of caring for them .

Socially
They did exactly the same amount of caring, cleaning and emotional management as women.

They committed the same number and profile of crimes as women.

When that happens I might rethink my absolute denial of all things gender ideological.

cryupmykingdom · 15/11/2026 12:13

>>Queer theory comes up with new words all of the time, but cannot find a new word for 'men who dont want to be men

For the same reason they won't use unisex toilets. No validation!

ChilliFire · 15/11/2026 12:26

Nothing would ever make me change my mind about the legitimacy of TWAW/TMAM because to believe that I would need to believe lies.

MissFancyDay · 15/11/2026 12:32

I don't, and will never, really care what people see or believe themselves to be. Unless I know them of course and then I would have respectful conversations about it. I don't think that others personal views on themselves should affect anything at all in how the rest of us live our lives.

Sometimes we humans need to be separated on the basis of sex, by law. That is all.

Mapletree1985 · 15/11/2026 12:50

2021x · 15/11/2026 05:26

I'm not worried about that much. It looks like, apart from a small number of Redditors, TG people accept that they cannot change sex.

What they're arguing now is that they have an X brain in a Y body. I think if that was the case, then there would be data in the behaviour of people that would back that up.

If people want to be accepted as the opposite gender, I think we should be clear about what that means within ourselves. The examples I gave are what I would think, and I am interested to hear if there is anything I have missed

I'm guessing they went with the "I have female brain in male body" argument because they knew there was no way they could win the "I have literally changed sex" argument. But there is no such thing as a female brain, any more than there is a female lung or a female liver.

I mean, I'm sure that if you averaged the weight of any given organ, the average male heart or liver might weight a little bit more than the average female heart because men are, on average, bigger, but it doesn't logically follow that any heart over X weight must be a male heart. OMG what if I had a male small intestine in my female body, what would I do?

SockPlant · 15/11/2026 12:59

Cheese55 · 15/11/2026 11:50

TRA's would say this means you want them dead. You have to be fully on-board else you're wanting them to come to harm.

and that's on them. I literally don't care if someone calls me transphobic - i am not transphobic by any normal definition. They can say that as loudly and as publicly as they like and make themselves look more deranged in the process. The more people that see/hear the absolute tripe they spout, the better.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 15/11/2026 12:59

Nothing could alter my knowledge (not just my opinion) that sex is binary & immutable.

Regarding suicide. All people who consider themselves trans by definition have a mental disorder & are at increased rate of suicide pre-transition & no lesser (possibly even higher) rate of suicide after drugs & surgery.

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 15/11/2026 13:06

Fairly simple: you'd have to stop seeing trans people as entities, and get to know them as individual human beings.

Same way a child gets to see a stranger, brought into their lives as their mum's boyfriend, as their dad.

theilltemperedmonster · 15/11/2026 13:08

I'm never going to accept TWAW or TMAM because it's intrinsically wrong, like 2+2=5. Sex is physiological, not psychological.

I cautiously and provisionally accept the existence of gender incongruence, and the decision of the state to formally acknowledge the existence of transsexuals and to protect them from arbitrary discrimination.

I'm of the opinion that early medical transition will always be wrong because it affects sexual and reproductive function and general health to an extent to which no child has sufficient self-knowledge to give consent. But this is an opinion based on facts, not a fundamental belief, so I suppose my mind could be changed by new evidence, difficult to imagine though that is.

The area where I'm going to be most (albeit not very!) amenable to persuasion, and tbh the only (non-medical) area that is really worth debating in my view, relates to the proposition, that it is a human right for transsexuals to be treated, by law and custom, exactly as if they were of the opposite sex. This doesn't contain a logic trap in the same way as TWAW: it's practically attainable and therefore can be debated in terms of the cost/benefit analysis vis-a-vis the comfort of transsexuals and the effects on wider society including on the human rights of everyone as to other protected characteristics such as sex and sexual orientation.

Even TRAs don't believe the above proposition completely unadorned – there's a silent "as far as is practicable" in there. So maybe you could change my mind about what is practicable and fair.

Maybe I could accept 'trans-inclusive' educational establishments and associations, provided that enough single-sex alternatives also exist? Maybe I could stretch that same principle to services and sports at the less physically dangerous end of things?? Participation would be voluntary and the effects of trans 'inclusion' relatively dilute. It would be secular pluralism in action.

(The same doesn't apply to positive action or occupational requirements, where swapping out the sex undermines the entire purpose.)

The above debate will never happen though, because TRAs are stuck on 'if you don't force everyone to behave as if I have changed sex, you are denying my existence'. It suits them for us to waste our time debating the psychology or metaphysics, instead of the practicalities of accommodating both believers and non-believers in transgenderism.

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 15/11/2026 13:09

Until you stop seeing trans people in the abstract and setting conditions for them to be allowed to exist, you won't view them as human individuals.

Trans people owe you nothing.

SockPlant · 15/11/2026 13:13

how does me, for eg, saying "you can't change sex" stop someone existing?

That is a very odd thing to say. Keep saying it: louder, in more places.

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 15/11/2026 13:14

theilltemperedmonster · 15/11/2026 13:08

I'm never going to accept TWAW or TMAM because it's intrinsically wrong, like 2+2=5. Sex is physiological, not psychological.

I cautiously and provisionally accept the existence of gender incongruence, and the decision of the state to formally acknowledge the existence of transsexuals and to protect them from arbitrary discrimination.

I'm of the opinion that early medical transition will always be wrong because it affects sexual and reproductive function and general health to an extent to which no child has sufficient self-knowledge to give consent. But this is an opinion based on facts, not a fundamental belief, so I suppose my mind could be changed by new evidence, difficult to imagine though that is.

The area where I'm going to be most (albeit not very!) amenable to persuasion, and tbh the only (non-medical) area that is really worth debating in my view, relates to the proposition, that it is a human right for transsexuals to be treated, by law and custom, exactly as if they were of the opposite sex. This doesn't contain a logic trap in the same way as TWAW: it's practically attainable and therefore can be debated in terms of the cost/benefit analysis vis-a-vis the comfort of transsexuals and the effects on wider society including on the human rights of everyone as to other protected characteristics such as sex and sexual orientation.

Even TRAs don't believe the above proposition completely unadorned – there's a silent "as far as is practicable" in there. So maybe you could change my mind about what is practicable and fair.

Maybe I could accept 'trans-inclusive' educational establishments and associations, provided that enough single-sex alternatives also exist? Maybe I could stretch that same principle to services and sports at the less physically dangerous end of things?? Participation would be voluntary and the effects of trans 'inclusion' relatively dilute. It would be secular pluralism in action.

(The same doesn't apply to positive action or occupational requirements, where swapping out the sex undermines the entire purpose.)

The above debate will never happen though, because TRAs are stuck on 'if you don't force everyone to behave as if I have changed sex, you are denying my existence'. It suits them for us to waste our time debating the psychology or metaphysics, instead of the practicalities of accommodating both believers and non-believers in transgenderism.

Trans people existing doesn't affect your life in the slightest.

Minorities don't owe you an obedient, grateful performance before you grant them basic respect.

Trans people - every one of them an individual with a different background, a tiny minority among a huge global cis population - will keep being born, living, getting jobs, having kids and enduring violence for simply being themselves. Without needing to consult you first.

SockPlant · 15/11/2026 13:15

you keep banging your head against this wall that doesn't exist.

We KNOW trans people exist. They make themselves heard very very very much.

They don't owe us anything? why not? We don't owe them anything either. And yet the demands keep coming.

Try to behave, stop screaming and shouting and act like a regular member of society. Then I'll try listening. But the shouting and screeching renders words inaudible.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 15/11/2026 13:16

theilltemperedmonster · 15/11/2026 13:08

I'm never going to accept TWAW or TMAM because it's intrinsically wrong, like 2+2=5. Sex is physiological, not psychological.

I cautiously and provisionally accept the existence of gender incongruence, and the decision of the state to formally acknowledge the existence of transsexuals and to protect them from arbitrary discrimination.

I'm of the opinion that early medical transition will always be wrong because it affects sexual and reproductive function and general health to an extent to which no child has sufficient self-knowledge to give consent. But this is an opinion based on facts, not a fundamental belief, so I suppose my mind could be changed by new evidence, difficult to imagine though that is.

The area where I'm going to be most (albeit not very!) amenable to persuasion, and tbh the only (non-medical) area that is really worth debating in my view, relates to the proposition, that it is a human right for transsexuals to be treated, by law and custom, exactly as if they were of the opposite sex. This doesn't contain a logic trap in the same way as TWAW: it's practically attainable and therefore can be debated in terms of the cost/benefit analysis vis-a-vis the comfort of transsexuals and the effects on wider society including on the human rights of everyone as to other protected characteristics such as sex and sexual orientation.

Even TRAs don't believe the above proposition completely unadorned – there's a silent "as far as is practicable" in there. So maybe you could change my mind about what is practicable and fair.

Maybe I could accept 'trans-inclusive' educational establishments and associations, provided that enough single-sex alternatives also exist? Maybe I could stretch that same principle to services and sports at the less physically dangerous end of things?? Participation would be voluntary and the effects of trans 'inclusion' relatively dilute. It would be secular pluralism in action.

(The same doesn't apply to positive action or occupational requirements, where swapping out the sex undermines the entire purpose.)

The above debate will never happen though, because TRAs are stuck on 'if you don't force everyone to behave as if I have changed sex, you are denying my existence'. It suits them for us to waste our time debating the psychology or metaphysics, instead of the practicalities of accommodating both believers and non-believers in transgenderism.

Indeed. When a group adopts bullying and intimidation as their modus operandi to get their own wishes granted, passivity and pandering never works.

A simple no (or no thak you) will suffice while society continues to safeguard the young and the vulnerable and leave the shouty, emotionally incontinent transactivists to roar into the wind.

BlueLegume · 15/11/2026 13:16

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 15/11/2026 13:06

Fairly simple: you'd have to stop seeing trans people as entities, and get to know them as individual human beings.

Same way a child gets to see a stranger, brought into their lives as their mum's boyfriend, as their dad.

Edited

But they are lying about who they really are and expect us to believe them when our eyes can see they are male or female, nothing else. If they will lie about that why would I trust anything else they say. Go ahead , be a feminine man or a butch woman but do not expect me to go along with a delusion.

As for entering woman’s spaces….why are they so insistent on this?

MarieDeGournay · 15/11/2026 13:21

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 15/11/2026 13:09

Until you stop seeing trans people in the abstract and setting conditions for them to be allowed to exist, you won't view them as human individuals.

Trans people owe you nothing.

You've put your finger on something interesting there: there's a discussion going on about issues, principles, patterns, and all you can talk about are individuals.

Trans individuals have the same rights as anyone else in this society, so what's your point?

Helleofabore · 15/11/2026 13:25

How remarkable is it that a group of people demanding that the areas of the world that uses the English language are not impacted in any way by their demand to change the language and change the definitions of everyday reference terms such as 'female.'

This over generalisation and hyperbole really only amounts to a cognitive distortion that feeds into emotional manipulation for a group to get their demands met.

And that everyone in their country acts as if their subjective reality is the universal, and proven by science and millennia of knowledge, material reality. When not one person has any obligation to act as if they believe someone's subjective belief, yet the group are told the very opposite and that it is in fact a human right, which is of course a falsehood.

Pingponghavoc · 15/11/2026 13:31

I'm not worried about that much. It looks like, apart from a small number of Redditors, TG people accept that they cannot change sex.

Lots of TRA and allies will say this, but its with the assumption that sex either undefinable or unknown.

They say we cannot change sex, but also say that single sex spaces arent really single sex but single gender. And always have been.

So they are acknowledging they havent changed sex, but saying that gender is what makes men, men and women, women. Sex is irrelevant, gender is important.

TRA will say that its 'cis' men who rape, not TW and 'cis' men wouldnt use women's spaces, only TW would. (They also say a sign doesnt stop abusers, contradicting their point).

All the time never having or being able to define what this gender is. We cannot know who is trans to analyse the population. Who can stop eddie izzard identifying as trans, can someone be diagnosed as trans before they identify as such?

On one hand trans is anyone who identifies as such, but on the other everyone else is supposed to see it. Its totally self determined, but they can be embraced into socially defined single sex spaces?

Its liberal and progressive for trans people and enforced on everyone else.

GriseldaandMike · 15/11/2026 13:32

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 15/11/2026 13:06

Fairly simple: you'd have to stop seeing trans people as entities, and get to know them as individual human beings.

Same way a child gets to see a stranger, brought into their lives as their mum's boyfriend, as their dad.

Edited

And how often it is to a childs detriment that a new 'daddy' is brought into their lives? There are wonderful stepfathers but there are also abusive ones, neglectful ones and even murderous ones.

We can't get to know and love everything single trans person- I know several and just like other men and women some are lovely and some aren't. The horrible sexist self centred man I used to try to avoid hasn't magically become lovely now he is called Shirley, in fact he is worse than when he was just an unpleasant man because now he is 'one of girls' it's almost impossible to stop him talking about sex (as in fucking rather than 'gender') because he thinks he can get away with it in a way he couldn't tell his mates wife about his latest conquest in graphic detail when he was called Alan.

MissFancyDay · 15/11/2026 13:36

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 15/11/2026 13:14

Trans people existing doesn't affect your life in the slightest.

Minorities don't owe you an obedient, grateful performance before you grant them basic respect.

Trans people - every one of them an individual with a different background, a tiny minority among a huge global cis population - will keep being born, living, getting jobs, having kids and enduring violence for simply being themselves. Without needing to consult you first.

You are right, a trans person existing does not affect me at all and I certainly don't desire to have anyone "erased" or have how they feel about themselves policed in any way. I just require them to act within the law and for my rights as a female to have single sex spaces respected. THAT IS ALL.

Your definition of basic respect is being treated as somehow special enough to have the law, and science, not apply to them.

BlueLegume · 15/11/2026 13:43

MarieDeGournay · 15/11/2026 13:21

You've put your finger on something interesting there: there's a discussion going on about issues, principles, patterns, and all you can talk about are individuals.

Trans individuals have the same rights as anyone else in this society, so what's your point?

This is what I never get an answer to. Trans rights are covered under general human rights aren't they? I am coming to assume the trans rights they seek are free access to affirmative medical treatment such as getting a double mastectomy which presumably they feel they have aright to on the NHS (first do no harm) or through medical insurance.

Trans rights activists-please spell out what rights you seek.

Shedmistress · 15/11/2026 13:51

BlueLegume · 15/11/2026 13:43

This is what I never get an answer to. Trans rights are covered under general human rights aren't they? I am coming to assume the trans rights they seek are free access to affirmative medical treatment such as getting a double mastectomy which presumably they feel they have aright to on the NHS (first do no harm) or through medical insurance.

Trans rights activists-please spell out what rights you seek.

Also, what exactly IS 'TRANS'?

BlueLegume · 15/11/2026 13:54

Shedmistress · 15/11/2026 13:51

Also, what exactly IS 'TRANS'?

Good point. As a kid growing up in the 70s we knew there were transvestites and transsexual people. Those words meant something but trans just does not.

Gender is a social construct-goodness me what a lame argument-which to me is just word salad.

Cheese55 · 15/11/2026 14:00

BlueLegume · 15/11/2026 13:54

Good point. As a kid growing up in the 70s we knew there were transvestites and transsexual people. Those words meant something but trans just does not.

Gender is a social construct-goodness me what a lame argument-which to me is just word salad.

Tbf gender is a social construct, not fitting into the construct does not make you a woman/man. It makes a variation of your sex

PriOn1 · 15/11/2026 14:00

I’m never going to believe people are the opposite sex.

But if there was incontrovertible medical proof that “trans” was a genuine medical condition, with clearly defined parameters for who was affected, and that patients truly benefited from transition, including a clinical benefit from being in opposite sex spaces, then I would conclude that we had a genuine clash of rights, based on real need.

Then I would accept we had a near impossible debate about how those rights might be balanced properly. I suspect it would still come down to alternative, separate spaces.

I’m not sure I can ever go back to believing that again though. It’s pretty much what I used to think, but now I have grave doubts about anyone genuinely benefiting from transitioning, and the societal complications it causes should also be considered when deciding whether it’s a reasonable treatment for the individual, when it entirely disrupts society, creating huge costs.

Ironically, of course, women are currently being blamed for those costs. Not that it was us that created the problem.