Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 15/11/2026 04:44

Nothing could change my mind. You might as well as ask what could change my mind about the world being round!

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:48

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 15/11/2026 04:44

Nothing could change my mind. You might as well as ask what could change my mind about the world being round!

I agree, but it is good to try to strengthen your arguments about what a woman/man is.

OP posts:
DotDotDoorDash · 15/11/2026 04:51

Your last point is extremely odd - what do male suicide rates have to do with it? Apart from anything else, women attempt suicide at a higher rate than men, so that would be less suicide. I don’t think that’s what you’re saying though is it? is it? I’m genuinely confused

Tears0fTheMushroom · 15/11/2026 04:55

A lobotomy.
Nothing else would do it.

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:56

DotDotDoorDash · 15/11/2026 04:51

Your last point is extremely odd - what do male suicide rates have to do with it? Apart from anything else, women attempt suicide at a higher rate than men, so that would be less suicide. I don’t think that’s what you’re saying though is it? is it? I’m genuinely confused

The theory that transgender people are X brain in Y body would be borne out in the data. So I selected a group of well-known differences between males and females as examples.

Men die by suicide at a higher rate than women. Therefore, it would be expected that the demographic of fatal suicide attempts among transmen would be the same as that of men.

OP posts:
TangledUpDown · 15/11/2026 04:58

I would want to see two things - firstly some reliable and accurate diagnostic test, not just "because I say so". Secondly, I'd want the evidence to suggest that men don't pretend to be trans for their own gain. For example I wouldn't expect to see huge numbers of trans identifying men imprisoned for sexual offences.

2021x · 15/11/2026 05:09

TangledUpDown · 15/11/2026 04:58

I would want to see two things - firstly some reliable and accurate diagnostic test, not just "because I say so". Secondly, I'd want the evidence to suggest that men don't pretend to be trans for their own gain. For example I wouldn't expect to see huge numbers of trans identifying men imprisoned for sexual offences.

I agree about the diagnosis. One of the things I hate is "affirmation therapy". Affirmation requires no skill and is the complete opposite of therapy.

I also agree that I would like more discussion on what factors contribute to a person becoming trans. I suspect that sexual obsession will be a major factor. Maybe not for transmen, but for transwomen I think it would be.

OP posts:
SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 15/11/2026 05:14

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:48

I agree, but it is good to try to strengthen your arguments about what a woman/man is.

I really don't think anyone needs to strengthen their argument on this matter. Any debate around the edges just gives legitimacy to the idea that being a man or a woman is a complicated and hard to define state and it's not.

2021x · 15/11/2026 05:20

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 15/11/2026 05:14

I really don't think anyone needs to strengthen their argument on this matter. Any debate around the edges just gives legitimacy to the idea that being a man or a woman is a complicated and hard to define state and it's not.

OK thanks for the input.

OP posts:
Mapletree1985 · 15/11/2026 05:21

If people could in fact literally change sex.

2021x · 15/11/2026 05:26

Mapletree1985 · 15/11/2026 05:21

If people could in fact literally change sex.

I'm not worried about that much. It looks like, apart from a small number of Redditors, TG people accept that they cannot change sex.

What they're arguing now is that they have an X brain in a Y body. I think if that was the case, then there would be data in the behaviour of people that would back that up.

If people want to be accepted as the opposite gender, I think we should be clear about what that means within ourselves. The examples I gave are what I would think, and I am interested to hear if there is anything I have missed

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 15/11/2026 05:49

Mapletree1985 · 15/11/2026 05:21

If people could in fact literally change sex.

^^ This.

Because when you strip away all the philosophising, the significant point remains that single sex provision is based on the legitimate discrimination based on sex category.

There is no definition for gender identity that is not referenced by sex category, that doesn’t have sex category at its core. It is likely that anything that people will list will reference sex category in some way. Eg, using female people as the comparison.

Unless someone can physically change sex it is not a meaningful change in my opinion. The person is simply changing the outward appearance.

I would also further, even to the point of being able to remove all their previous conditioning and development and reloading that so no male person who has a transgender identity has any memory of interacting with society as a male person. That all their development has been as a female person with the experiences of interacting with society and navigating every situation they have been in as a female person.

quixote9 · 15/11/2026 05:50

2021x · 15/11/2026 05:26

I'm not worried about that much. It looks like, apart from a small number of Redditors, TG people accept that they cannot change sex.

What they're arguing now is that they have an X brain in a Y body. I think if that was the case, then there would be data in the behaviour of people that would back that up.

If people want to be accepted as the opposite gender, I think we should be clear about what that means within ourselves. The examples I gave are what I would think, and I am interested to hear if there is anything I have missed

I didn't know transwomen have worked their way around to realizing they can't change sex. (I get the distinct impression transmen have always known that. Another count against transwomen actually having an X brain?)

Let's say, for the sake of argument, they've really done that. Then, as was also said upthread, you'd expect female pattern criminality, female pattern (lack of) violence, female patterns of putting others ahead of themselves. If transwomen had X brains, I'd expect more of them to be a lot more reluctant to butt in where nobody wants them. (Yes, women insist on getting into corporate offices and male universities and parliaments and so on. But that's a case of social power excluding them from benefits, not a case of men trying to find a bit of refuge from potentially predatory women.)

So, anyway, if transwomen have X brains they're doing an amazing job of hiding that.

Shedmistress · 15/11/2026 05:51

If the trans activists could stop being the most deranged people on the planet and let everyone else make their own minds up, voice their opinions and accept that we have rights to various spaces without men in them, then maybe id discuss moving forward.

But that will be about accommodations suited to their sex, not their made up gender bollocks.

Helleofabore · 15/11/2026 06:06

How many suggestions from people will be changeable over time which will make them not a usable guide?

Physical features can change. Such as the studies show that if a male person ceases aiming for their body to be appearing female, they can simply change their training to again regain strength, fitness etc.

Behaviour can also change over time.

What use is having check lists relating to an individual or a group collectively that may only be true for a moment in time and that can be change year on year? That then is unfair on those who no longer meet the current checklist but did meet the last checklist condition.

It is also unfair to those who miss out by a small margin from meeting the conditions. Because are they really not as ‘female’ or ‘male’ as the person who got the pass mark? As it is an arbitrary decision for most of the time, who then arbitrates?

It is like this whole discussion about the ‘near enough is good enough’. Who decides that a man fits in the female gender identity box or not? And if someone passed the criteria once, how often is this rechecked?

Seems far more prone to discrimination and harm than basing it on an unchangable material fact that has been scientifically proven over many generations.

CorvusPurpureus · 15/11/2026 06:06

If full body transplants were possible.

Say I was a billionaire who really didn’t want to die, so after a terminal diagnosis I arranged to have my brain transferred to a donor body - which happened to be male. Let’s assume science is now able to do that & I survive, memory & personality intact.

Legally let’s say I stay ‘me’ - I get to keep my ID, my wealth etc etc - but the body I’m inhabiting is now that of a 20yo man.

At that point I’d argue I should be allowed (compelled?) to change my official ID to male to reflect that sex is your body, not your brain.

I can’t see this being a problem I’d ever need to contend with outside of an Anne Rice novel, mind you.

DeanElderberry · 15/11/2026 06:07

You'd have to start by convincing me that this new (1990s niche academia invention that didn't get noticed until 2010ish) theory that humans can have a 'unique gender identity' is anything other than the same old misogynist (and often homophobic) shit the world has grappled with since the dawn of time.

The packaging for the shit is obviously very profitable for the pharmaceutical industry and the huge crowd of quacks and hangers-on who promote it in so many ways, but it's still shit, however glossy the box.

I don't need repackaged shit.

I feel rather sorry for young people who have adopted repackaged shit as a shiny new toy.

I despise people who use repackaged shit to abuse women, including the duped women who are self-harming with it.

Helleofabore · 15/11/2026 06:12

“I didn't know transwomen have worked their way around to realizing they can't change sex.”

I don’t believe they have. Because as we have seen from a series of male posters, including one this week. those male people philosophise their being ‘female’ in some way. Or they, like another poster has tried to convince us, have recognised themselves as somehow being female based on their own personalised definition of what is female.

I think some people don’t believe they have changed sex. I think some people do believe they have through philosophising their personal situation.

Helleofabore · 15/11/2026 06:14

CorvusPurpureus · 15/11/2026 06:06

If full body transplants were possible.

Say I was a billionaire who really didn’t want to die, so after a terminal diagnosis I arranged to have my brain transferred to a donor body - which happened to be male. Let’s assume science is now able to do that & I survive, memory & personality intact.

Legally let’s say I stay ‘me’ - I get to keep my ID, my wealth etc etc - but the body I’m inhabiting is now that of a 20yo man.

At that point I’d argue I should be allowed (compelled?) to change my official ID to male to reflect that sex is your body, not your brain.

I can’t see this being a problem I’d ever need to contend with outside of an Anne Rice novel, mind you.

Ahh but how do you then reset the brain to remove all the sexed conditioning for responses of everyday life?

Igneococcus · 15/11/2026 06:15

Convincing evidence that someone can change from making one type of gamete to the other (without surgically transferring entire reproductive systems). I'm a biologist, gametes are all that matter to me in this respect, everything else is decoration.

Toodarktooearly · 15/11/2026 06:16

What will make me believe the Earth is flat? Or that Norway is made up? That transwomen are women? Nothing, nothing will make me believe anything ridiculous.

CohensDiamondTeeth · 15/11/2026 06:17

What I would need to see to believe that TWAW - not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women?

Sorry but this is a nonsensical premise IMO.
If trans identified men aren't female, then they cannot experience life as if they were women. Same goes for trans identifying females.

So my answer is that unless human beings somehow gain the ability to change sex (and I highly doubt that will ever happen), nothing will make me believe that TW are anything other than men.

Helleofabore · 15/11/2026 06:23

CohensDiamondTeeth · 15/11/2026 06:17

What I would need to see to believe that TWAW - not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women?

Sorry but this is a nonsensical premise IMO.
If trans identified men aren't female, then they cannot experience life as if they were women. Same goes for trans identifying females.

So my answer is that unless human beings somehow gain the ability to change sex (and I highly doubt that will ever happen), nothing will make me believe that TW are anything other than men.

Yep.

Gender identity references being female as its conceptual premise.

RichPetuniaAgain · 15/11/2026 06:31

Nothing whatsoever

Tiddlywinks63 · 15/11/2026 06:41

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:48

I agree, but it is good to try to strengthen your arguments about what a woman/man is.

Why the heck should I?
It’s blatantly obvious to anyone that you cannot change your genetic makeup from male to female or vice versa. If you’re incapable of understanding that basic premise then I feel sorry for you.
Men masquerading as women are fooling nobody other than themselves, ditto the women thinking they’re now male.