Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Wishesandhorses · 15/11/2026 14:18

What would it take for me to believe that TWAW?

A severe enough sudden onset case of psycopathy that removed any memory empathy or understanding of women's needs and issues for single sex spaces, and then brain washing into being an MRA.

Quercus5 · 15/11/2026 14:21

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 15/11/2026 13:06

Fairly simple: you'd have to stop seeing trans people as entities, and get to know them as individual human beings.

Same way a child gets to see a stranger, brought into their lives as their mum's boyfriend, as their dad.

Edited

I’ve done that. I still don’t believe either of the TW I know are W.

Wishesandhorses · 15/11/2026 14:26

No matter how much I like a person as an individual, I will not agree that reality is something that it isn't to 'humour them' because it's 'kind' - I don't think it is. Why would I do that to someone I cared about?

I am absolutely not using my personal feelings for one person as a reason to harm, use and oppress others. Because it's very, very wrong.

bellinisurge · 15/11/2026 14:26

Nothing.

CassOle · 15/11/2026 14:27

Mapletree1985 · 15/11/2026 05:21

If people could in fact literally change sex.

Yes, this is spot on. All the rest is meaningless.

For a male-to-female sex change to occur, the following needs to happen:
A male human being (has a body that has developed to produce small gametes) goes through a natural metamorphosis (so no exogenous hormones needed, or surgery). Then, the same organism (so the very same human being, but now female) can no longer produce small gametes, but can now produce large gametes.

And vice versa for a female-to-male sex change:
A female human being (has a body that has developed to produce large gametes) goes through a natural metamorphosis (so no exogenous hormones needed, or surgery). Then, the same organism (so the very same human being, but now male) can no longer produce large gametes, but can now produce small gametes.

GriseldaandMike · 15/11/2026 14:38

CassOle · 15/11/2026 14:27

Yes, this is spot on. All the rest is meaningless.

For a male-to-female sex change to occur, the following needs to happen:
A male human being (has a body that has developed to produce small gametes) goes through a natural metamorphosis (so no exogenous hormones needed, or surgery). Then, the same organism (so the very same human being, but now female) can no longer produce small gametes, but can now produce large gametes.

And vice versa for a female-to-male sex change:
A female human being (has a body that has developed to produce large gametes) goes through a natural metamorphosis (so no exogenous hormones needed, or surgery). Then, the same organism (so the very same human being, but now male) can no longer produce large gametes, but can now produce small gametes.

But it can't just be the 'plumbing' that changes this magic would have to impact all the other stuff that makes men and women different - the average heights, the bone density, the lung capacity, the muscle type, the pelvis shape and so on and so forth. If all that happened was there a bigger stronger group of egg producers the original eggs producers would still be at risk from them.

But even then what about the socialisation issues? How do these new egg producers come to understand the reality of being female. How do they get the experience that 83% of women of this site have had of being sexually harassed while in school uniform.

lifeturnsonadime · 15/11/2026 14:40

It is literally impossible for humans to change sex.

Men can wear what they want & call themselves whatever they want but they will always be male even if they call themselves trans women. The only way to be a TW is by being a man.

TW will either say that this doesn't matter and that single spaces should be segregated on the basis of gender, even though this can't be defined and carries risk to actual women who don't, in the main, consent to this redefinition.

Or they will say, as some have done that they are biologically female, based on secondary sex traits. Or by an entire redefinition of the word female.

Nothing will make me change my view that they are not only wrong but are deliberately undermining the human rights of women and girls.

The fact that my mind won't be changed doesn't make me think that these men cease to exist. I know they exist because they are so aggressive in their action to remove the rights of females.

And before anyone says but trans men, they a can't change sex either, but generally speaking they, being female, do not try to boundary push or remove the rights of others.

Pingponghavoc · 15/11/2026 14:45

TRA want everyone else to be organised onto groups - but for them to opt in and out of these groups as they see fit. The sex and gender definitions and debate are smoke screens because, in reality, there cannot be rules around a self defined identity.

The argument is that so few would do this as to be irrelevant.

99% of the world can be organised around sex, and the 1% can transgress and will not effect the majority.

There's an imaginary room of 99 women and 1 man. What harm can the man possible do, especially when he really, really wants to fit in as a women?

But there is no limit to the number of men who can identify as women. That room could be 50 women, 50 men.

These men do not want to fit in as women, they want to define women into what they are - surgery, or drugs, or clothes, or a feeling. They arent unnoticed.

The imagined room is not reality, single sex spaces are 3 cubicle toilets, the opportunity is for one women, the sports team in for 12 women.

So it isnt 1% of men not making a difference to how women live, it could be one man in a group of 3 women, or one man taking the opportunity away from one woman.

ArabellaScott · 15/11/2026 14:55

When a man gets periods as a teen, and the potential of pregnancy/birth, etc, plus all the socialisation that a girl/woman gets, all his life, and when society is at the point that men are not a risk for women, and no longer abuse women, then I would reconsider.

thirdfiddle · 15/11/2026 15:14

Change my mind about what exactly? I'm not going to decide a person in a male body in fact has a female body because that is observably nonsense.

To decide that society should be organized and "woman" defined by a concept of gender and not sex?

Someone would have to exhibit a gender based definition of "woman" that does not lean on stereotypes and is not circular. This definition would have to give me a way to look at myself or another person and determine, without reference to stereotypes, whether they were a woman or a man.

And then they would need to convince me that that "gender" was a more relevant category for whatever we're classifying /for/ than sex. They'd also have to agree a different terminology that does still mean sex because there are plenty of times (I would argue all times but in a hypothetical where someone has convinced me otherwise) when we treat men and women differently which are unavoidably about sex not gender, like sports or medicine. Or indeed deciding whether someone is trans or not - if there is no sex, there is no trans.

CassOle · 15/11/2026 15:17

GriseldaandMike · 15/11/2026 14:38

But it can't just be the 'plumbing' that changes this magic would have to impact all the other stuff that makes men and women different - the average heights, the bone density, the lung capacity, the muscle type, the pelvis shape and so on and so forth. If all that happened was there a bigger stronger group of egg producers the original eggs producers would still be at risk from them.

But even then what about the socialisation issues? How do these new egg producers come to understand the reality of being female. How do they get the experience that 83% of women of this site have had of being sexually harassed while in school uniform.

The metamorphosis would indeed need to change the body right down to the skeleton. With the change in skull size, the brain would also need to change. I wonder if this process would result in a tabula rasa (in terms of memory)?

This is all science fiction of course, as mammals cannot change sex.

That is my honest answer to the OP, though. I never fell for TWAW/TMAM because mammals cannot change sex. So if I was to change my position, it would be because mammals (specifically human beings) could change sex. As I mentioned, this must be a natural metamorphosis, not a surgical one.

Dragonasaurus · 15/11/2026 15:21

I’m good at maths, spacial awareness, and chess. I can use power tools and fix my car/heating system. I’m competitive, at bit ‘get on with it’ and not always very empathetic. I don’t like make up, never wear skirts or dresses, don’t like ‘getting dressed up’. However, I carried and birthed children, and it’s me not my husband who has to plan a careful route if I go out running after dark. I’m a woman because my biology dictates that, not because I have some ‘lady brain feelz’. Nothing will ever convince me that a man belongs in women’s single sex spaces, sports or services

Wishesandhorses · 15/11/2026 15:37

And this is all supposing that the agenda of all trans identified men is entirely innocent, sincere, non sexual and without enjoyment of coercive control, harassment and abusve of women.

It's naive to deny that this plays a very signficant part for plenty of men who freely post on social media about it in their desire to get into women's spaces and enforce their access to those women's biology.

Dragonasaurus · 15/11/2026 15:40

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 15/11/2026 13:06

Fairly simple: you'd have to stop seeing trans people as entities, and get to know them as individual human beings.

Same way a child gets to see a stranger, brought into their lives as their mum's boyfriend, as their dad.

Edited

But even a child who loves their Mum’s boyfriend enough to call him Dad knows that the boyfriend isn’t their father. So when that doesn’t matter, stepchild calls that man ‘dad’ and equally people might be willing to call Shaun Shania. But when the biological facts do matter, the stepchild knows full well that mum’s boyfriend isn’t really their father, and people know that Shania is, in fact, a man.

amber763 · 15/11/2026 15:42

Nothing. Taking hormones, cutting off their willy or wearing a dress won't ever turn man a woman.

Lacksie · 15/11/2026 15:45

Very revealing thread

Helleofabore · 15/11/2026 15:50

"Same way a child gets to see a stranger, brought into their lives as their mum's boyfriend, as their dad."

This really is not a comparative situation at all. It is scraping the barrel.

CassOle · 15/11/2026 15:51

I've said all of this before. My biggest issue with the TWAW/TMAM mantra has always been that it is a lie. I have posted umpteen times on this forum that mammals cannot change sex (which is demonstrably true). Not sure what I am 'revealing'?

Beachtastic · 15/11/2026 15:51

I'd need the human body to be much less complex, more like a Barbie/Ken doll i.e. crudely determined by shape rather than complicated by silly extras like an endocrine system.

MissFancyDay · 15/11/2026 15:52

Maybe one day it will become clear to TAs that most so called TERFs don't think about them much at all at a personal level, they just want to preserve women's hard fought for rights. So I suppose that I agree with @TransParentlyAnnoyed on that one.

I, for one, am passionate about that but, to be frank, don't really worry about TW and their problems. Women have enough to worry about.

DeanElderberry · 15/11/2026 15:53

Lacksie · 15/11/2026 15:45

Very revealing thread

Good - I hope that means you have learned something.

Dragonasaurus · 15/11/2026 15:53

Lacksie · 15/11/2026 15:45

Very revealing thread

I’d love to think it was revealing to you that:

a) posters here don’t want to erase trans people, and they don’t have any problem with ‘gender-incongruent’ behaviour

b) sometimes sex matters, and trans people should respect that

i’m not holding my breath 😆

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · 15/11/2026 15:54

Lacksie · 15/11/2026 15:45

Very revealing thread

I don't think it's a revelation that you can't change sex 😂

Devonshireteas · 15/11/2026 16:00

Lacksie · 15/11/2026 15:45

Very revealing thread

Yup, the sEx iS rEaL faithful are tripling & quadrupling down on the strawmannirg. Must be the news cycle moving on from them that's got them 'spooked'.

Veilsofmorning · 15/11/2026 16:01

Tears0fTheMushroom · 15/11/2026 04:55

A lobotomy.
Nothing else would do it.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣