Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
ChequerToRed · 15/11/2026 10:29

Even if a study showed that TWs brains skewed towards female traits (which the much vaunted small, single, problematic study does not show, despite what those with a vested interest say) I’d then consider it might be a neurological problem, as has been suggested of the surprisingly similar Body Integrity Identity Disorder.
It still wouldn’t make males entitled to female spaces just because their brain wiring is janky.

user293948849167 · 15/11/2026 10:33

Nothing, I used to be “be kind” but I never actually believed TWAW/TMAM. So nothing would make me believe it because it’s impossible. Humans can’t change sex

Shortshriftandlethal · 15/11/2026 10:34

Nothing can change the fact that males are not female no matter how they 'identify' or what they imagine. Sex is a biological category which has consequences at many levels and in many ways - both physically and socially.

Women, in our society, have won the right to certain protections and accommodations that recognise these facts. We have certain spaces and categories set aside for female people only to offer a level of dignity and privacy and a measure of safeguarding.

This is not about individuals, but about human groupings. Not everything in society is arranged around us as individuals.

FoodoftheDog · 15/11/2026 10:34

Men who have the belief they are women or women who have the belief they are men are entitled to believe what they want but I believe they are suffering from a damaged psyche because clearly that is a false belief.

I believe it is a fad, a social contagion to encourage people that these beliefs are a “thing”. I think it is an extremely damaging fad at that.

History has taught us that because people are social creatures and relationships matter to us much more than facts or reality, as a species we are incredibly susceptible to ideas that take hold among our tribe. Many of the most damaging ideologies that have taken hold have come from very damaged psyches. This is just one of many toxic ideologies that has taken hold and some of them go on for extended periods of time.

There have been thousands of gods throughout the history of humanity many of them very damaging, as an example, but some of them have really captured the human psyche.

My hope is this ideology soon begins to fade sooner rather than later.

In short nothing would make me believe a man can be a woman or vice versa.

viques · 15/11/2026 10:38

I think the only thing that would change my mind is a globally televised broadcast by God, complete with attending angels, other religious leaders and possibly the Virgin Mary , during which appearance he admits that in certain circumstances he is willing to give up the claim to being infallible , sincerely apologises for killer diseases, war, pestilence, floods, hurricanes, tsunamis and mosquitos, promises to bring back the dodo and explains that if the world really wants a third sex then he will accept a majority version from the seven billion people on the planet but only if TIM agree to wear proper womens clothing in the day, not party clothes, and keep out of womens spaces. Oh, and we all clean up the oceans.

MarieDeGournay · 15/11/2026 10:38

AlexandraLeaving · 15/11/2026 10:22

I'm not sure I could be convinced to change my mind. But if it was going to happen the first step in that direction would need to be a non-circular and clear definition of what the categories 'man' and 'woman' were (which were not simply rooted in regressive and sexist stereotypes), clarity over what the new-approved terms were for the human sex classes formerly known as 'men' and 'women' and confirmation that there remained adequate protection for the latter (sex classes). I'd also want there to be clarity over what 'trans' meant [gay/bi/lesbian are all very clear terms] and, as others have said, clear, objective diagnostic criteria.

I agree, but that's never going to happen, is it?
Circular arguments and lack of clarity 'r'Us as far as TRAs are concerned.
If they did what you suggest, they'd dematerialise in a puff of smoke.

That's why I made the humorous comparison with children relentlessly pursuing less and less likely scenarios [I left out 'Yeah but some cars can fly!'] to get out of doing something they don't want to do.

They also apply this to the law - yeah but some men present as women yeah but some men have always used the ladies yeah but intersex yeah but the SC ruling only applies to EA2010 yeah but yeah but yeah but...

Coconutter24 · 15/11/2026 10:43

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:48

I agree, but it is good to try to strengthen your arguments about what a woman/man is.

Why does anyone need to strengthen their argument? XY you’re a male XX you’re a woman

FancyLilacHare · 15/11/2026 10:48

Reputable scientists would have to identify the locus of gender identity in the human body and demonstrate the process by which it ends up in the wrong one.

If they could also explain why this doesn't happen to other organs like livers, hearts and kidneys, that would be a bonus.

Quercus5 · 15/11/2026 10:51

I think a more helpful question is: What would it take for you to believe that we don’t need single sex spaces?

I can’t see that I would ever believe that TWAW because it is fact, not opinion, that TWAM.

But it IS important to question ourselves on when and why it matters. Eg I don’t believe we need single sex education, but I do believe we need access to single sex changing rooms, because of male violence against women and girls. If male violence against women and girls stopped then I would reconsider.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 15/11/2026 10:56

TheBafflingIsGenerallyComplete · 15/11/2026 07:25

I was going to say exactly the same thing.

Me too!

Helleofabore · 15/11/2026 10:58

Is there a fear of seeming to be ‘fundamentalist’ about sex categories? Is that why we keep getting asked what would change our minds when it is impossible for humans to change sex?

It is like asking ‘if sex cannot change, will you accept that sometimes gender identity can replace sex categories as the priority’, despite sex category always being the meaningful discriminator when sex discrimination is allowed.

I have no fear about believing in material reality. But it does seem some people are uncomfortable with it.

Cheese55 · 15/11/2026 10:59

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:56

The theory that transgender people are X brain in Y body would be borne out in the data. So I selected a group of well-known differences between males and females as examples.

Men die by suicide at a higher rate than women. Therefore, it would be expected that the demographic of fatal suicide attempts among transmen would be the same as that of men.

Men die of suicide at a higher rate because they communicate distress by violence so use more violent methods. Women OD at a much higher rate than men. Transwomen will never have the emotional intelligence of a woman

Cheekycekyh · 15/11/2026 10:59

Mapletree1985 · 15/11/2026 05:21

If people could in fact literally change sex.

This

Cheese55 · 15/11/2026 11:03

Pingponghavoc · 15/11/2026 09:28

Everything we understand scientifically and socially about women is because of our sex.

If men can become women, it changes everything about what a women is. Women is not female but an identity with a little bit of gatekeeping.

Why do we need to create this class of people?

We are ignoring all of the reasons men want to be seen as women and forcing women to be part of a newly created male defined class. The traits cannot be anything exclusively female and will have to be what men can achieve.

But for what end?

The reason men want to be seen as women is so they can be treated as women - pronouns, in women's spaces and opportunities, to be alone with women and girls, to make women what they want women to be.

The control of women is a fundamental part of what trans is - its ignoring our fertility and reproduction role and making women what others see and what men can become. Then forcing us to play along.

Thats an interesting view. Why do you think women want to be seen as men, is it to try and stay safe from men.

GintyMcGinty · 15/11/2026 11:04

I used to believe that. I was a fully bought in ally.

But threads on MN changed my mind.

I would say it was thoughtful reasoned arguments that persuaded me.

Before that all I’d come across was people being extreme and hateful on social media. And those people came across as bigots. Much like back in the day and they sounded very similar to those people arguing for the retention of section 28 and against equalising the age of consent for homosexuality. So I thought that GC people were bigots.

Also trans people changed. They used to want to pass. Now it’s men in beards wearing lipstick calling themselves Susan who want into women’s spaces.

But back to your question- thoughtful reasoned arguments changed my mind and now I’m fully GC.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 15/11/2026 11:08

Sorry, OP, I'm not really sure what the question is. You say
I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women

but later on you say
I agree, but it is good to try to strengthen your arguments about what a woman/man is.

and then
If people want to be accepted as the opposite gender, ..

Are you saying that 'woman' is not the same as 'female'? Do you not subscribe to woman = adult, human female or do you think woman = experiencing life as a woman? Or are you talking about gender, instead of sex? In which case, what do you mean by gender?

It's hard to have a useful discussion with unclear terms!

NoWordForFluffy · 15/11/2026 11:17

TheBafflingIsGenerallyComplete · 15/11/2026 07:25

I was going to say exactly the same thing.

Me too!

teawamutu · 15/11/2026 11:19

AlexandraLeaving · 15/11/2026 10:22

I'm not sure I could be convinced to change my mind. But if it was going to happen the first step in that direction would need to be a non-circular and clear definition of what the categories 'man' and 'woman' were (which were not simply rooted in regressive and sexist stereotypes), clarity over what the new-approved terms were for the human sex classes formerly known as 'men' and 'women' and confirmation that there remained adequate protection for the latter (sex classes). I'd also want there to be clarity over what 'trans' meant [gay/bi/lesbian are all very clear terms] and, as others have said, clear, objective diagnostic criteria.

On the 'TRA own goal' thread, the OP of the Reddit thread in question defines woman as 'go into the street, first ten people you see that you think are women, are women'.

He thinks this is the workable definition and anyone who disagrees is a horrible terf.

Absolutely fucking batshit.

Soontobe60 · 15/11/2026 11:22

I’ve been pondering on this question since I first commented a couple of hours ago. The whole transgender thing came into my sphere of awareness about 8 years ago when a friend of mine shared a post on FB about not placing transwomen in the male prison estate, that it was cruel and wrong. Before that, I had only really been aware of the terms transsexual, cross dressers or the more derogatory term of ‘tranny’.
Her post made me think it was indeed cruel to put women who were transsexual in the male prison estate - who in their right mind would do that? That’s because I assumed that a transwoman was a woman who wanted to be seen as a man. I’m guessing that many people also assumed - and probably still do - the same.
I knew a little bit about people with DSDs as a colleague had a baby at the same time as I did 40 years ago that was born with a DSD, although the medics used the term intersex, and she was advised to raise the baby as a girl as her genitals looked female.
Then along came lockdown and my journey into the whole gender identity theory began. I’m not generally one to jump on bandwagons and like to do my research before forming an opinion so that’s what I did.
My research totally changed my mind as it opened my eyes into the gaslighting world that transgenderism rests its case on.
I suspect the OP was expecting people to come up with reasons why to change their minds from being bigots who wish death on trans people rather than the opposite.

Thesillysocks · 15/11/2026 11:25

I would be more accepting of TW who present like an « ordinary » woman, for ex jeans/cardigan/light makeup instead of the sexualised and cliché of a woman that we often see heavy makeup/mini skirt/v high heels, etc.

LiftAndCoast · 15/11/2026 11:30

"I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women."

A woman by definition is a female human so this seems logically impossible, Like saying 'not females, but sheep who would experience life as if they were ewes.'

For me to take the narrative seriously I would need definitive proof that:

  • souls exist
  • every soul has a male or female quality
  • sometimes the soul is (observably, objectively) in a body that does not match

Currently I do not think any of that is true. And even if it were, it wouldn't justify letting male bodied people in sporting competitions or intimate spaces meant for people with female bodies, it would just change what I thought about the truth of trans people's claims about feeling like the opposite sex.

Perenelle · 15/11/2026 11:35

Thesillysocks · 15/11/2026 11:25

I would be more accepting of TW who present like an « ordinary » woman, for ex jeans/cardigan/light makeup instead of the sexualised and cliché of a woman that we often see heavy makeup/mini skirt/v high heels, etc.

And then there is also the demanding access to women only spaces and medicalisation and mutilation of children, both are unacceptable.

SockPlant · 15/11/2026 11:41

nothing. I'm a 2nd wave feminist. Life your life how you want, but you can't change sex.

Cheese55 · 15/11/2026 11:50

SockPlant · 15/11/2026 11:41

nothing. I'm a 2nd wave feminist. Life your life how you want, but you can't change sex.

TRA's would say this means you want them dead. You have to be fully on-board else you're wanting them to come to harm.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 15/11/2026 11:55

What a great thread!
Good to see so many clear thinking, determined women (and maybe some men).