Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
thirdfiddle · Yesterday 12:17

"pre reflective cognition"

This is stealing terminology from neuroscience to try to validate what is simply a category error. Sex is about bodies not brains, woman is a word that describes a sex, nobody has come up with any kind of coherent definition that says otherwise even if women were willing to cede the word that describes their reality. Which we are not.

BlueLegume · Yesterday 13:03

Lacksie · Yesterday 12:14

I am just out but will respond to this later .

Ah back to the old ‘got to do the school run/prepare a work presentation/make the kids dinner’ @Lacksie

Seen this on previous threads.🙄

Lacksie · Yesterday 14:16

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 11:54

‘Phantoms in The Brain’, using a series of case histories, introduces strange and unexplored mental worlds. Ramachandran, through his research into brain damage, has discovered that the brain is continually organising itself in response to change. A woman maintains that her left arm is not paralysed, a young man loses his right arm in a motorcycle accident, yet he continues to feel a phantom arm with vivid sensation of movement. In a series of experiments using nothing more than Q-tips and dribbles of warm water the young man helped Ramachandran discover how the brain is remapped after injury. Ramachandran believes that cases such as these illustrate fundamental principles of how the human brain operates. The brain ‘needs to create a “script” or a story to make sense of the world, a unified and internally consistent belief system’.

So your argument is that trans people are brain damaged?

The relevance isn't clear. People who continue to feel a missing limb still have a missing limb.

So your argument is that trans people are brain damaged?

No. The relevance is understanding how body recognition works. It's not a type of conscious reasoning/ knowing, it's pre-reflective/ automatic and happens in a different part of the brain.

The examples in that book are cases that illustrate/ demonstrate how the cognition of body recognition works - which structures of the brain are involved etc. It works like this in everyone - it's not suggesting that that's only how it works in brain damaged people.

Helleofabore · Yesterday 14:18

BackToLurk · Yesterday 11:58

I've seen phantom limbs (and indeed xenomelia) used before. Surely all they illustrate is that the mind can believe things that aren't true. Like you are the opposite sex.

Also, that it will mostly impact people who had a body part that their brain is not recognising as now missing because of all the built up experience of navigating life with that body part.

Which is nothing comparative to a person who believes they are something they are not and never have been and have no reference at all in experience that would allow them to accurately categorise their experiences as being in any way the opposite sex.

There is not even logic to support this philosophical theory about gender identities.

Pingponghavoc · Yesterday 14:23

PleaseDontStepOnTheDaisies · Yesterday 11:27

To answer the original question in the OP: What would change my mind?

If the political pursuit of trans rights had been less aggressive and frankly, totalitarian. If the whole "TWAW, get over it", "No Debate" "Die TERF" stuff, plus sending death threats to JK Rowling had simply never happened - and they had simply gone with "Hayley from Corrie" - I think I'd have had sympathy.

In fact, I did have sympathy back in the early 2000s - I remember when the Big Brother audience shouted "Nadia's a man" - and at the time I thought that was nasty. I hadn't thought deeply about it, and I would've accepted Nadia as "a woman." I never would have batted an eyelid back then at Nadia using women's spaces.

What changed was the movement towards 'self ID' and the realisation that this would mean the end of all women's spaces, and even the meaning of the word "woman" in law. The trans movement shot itself in the foot - by doing everything they did. From violently resisting women-only groups like A Woman's Place, to belittling and denying that women had been sexually assaulted in prisons & hospital wards. Everything the TRAs did from about 2015 onwards just confirms the fact that trans women are men, and that most behave exactly like men.

Nothing can change my mind on the fact that humans cannot change their sex, because they can't, and now nothing can change my mind that trans activists are aggressive & violent - because they have been for the past decade.

I dont think its really self id that has changed opinions, its having more exposure to the realities of trans.

Corries Hailey was a fictional character, BB Nadia was heavily edited. TW, despite what they claim, were rarely in the womans toilets in debenhams, but perhaps in the women's toilets at gay nights in clubs.

The majority of women werent in close contact with trans identifying men. Only their wives and children and they werent given a voice. Many assumed they were happy simply because they remained married.

From afar, its easy to imagine TW as anything you want them to be. Allies will often give different theories about trans ideology to what trans people say. Its so we could reassure ourselves that we were helping vulnerable and harmless people who dont want anything from us. Now we can see how they speak about women on forums or how they react to women saying no, and the reality are conflicting with that imagined trans person.

Self id has always been here. No one can stop a man changing his name and appearance. A GRC is self id with a waiting time.

Its the exposure thats changed. Now we can see that the lie has always been that they are a special type of men, when they are just men.

Lacksie · Yesterday 14:32

BackToLurk · Yesterday 11:55

@Lacksie are you suggesting transwomen are a type of female and transmen are a type of male, or something else?

If you are having issues understanding the question, do let me know.

No - I'm saying something else. The premise of your question is flawed because it assumes “male” and “female” are two boxes with clear edges, and that everyone can be sorted into one by a single test. They can’t.

Sex is a developmental process with several strands — chromosomes, gonads, hormones, the body’s response to those hormones, the resulting anatomy — and in most people they line up, so any one of them will do to assign a label. When they don’t line up, you have to choose which strand you mean, and that choice is a judgement, not a fact nature hands you.

Take a woman with complete androgen insensitivity: XY chromosomes, internal testes, no eggs. If you define “female” by chromosomes or by gonads (the organs that could produce gametes), she’s male.
If you go by phenotype and hormonal action — the far more meaningful classification — she’s female.
Women with CAIS are registered female at birth and almost always identify as female; on the Supreme Court’s own "biological sex" = “sex at birth” definition, they are female.

So what makes a person’s sex isn’t chromosomes, or gametes, or any single factor. It’s the whole developmental process.

Calling trans women “a type of female” or trans men “a type of male” is beside the point. It assumes the box comes first, when what comes first is the development; the box is where we file the result. Which box you file them in is simply a matter of which definition you choose to apply — it tells you nothing about what body a person has, how it developed, or what should follow for social policy. The 'filing'/categorisation is a social and legal act, and a matter of judgement.

Lacksie · Yesterday 14:33

Helleofabore · Yesterday 14:18

Also, that it will mostly impact people who had a body part that their brain is not recognising as now missing because of all the built up experience of navigating life with that body part.

Which is nothing comparative to a person who believes they are something they are not and never have been and have no reference at all in experience that would allow them to accurately categorise their experiences as being in any way the opposite sex.

There is not even logic to support this philosophical theory about gender identities.

because of all the built up experience of navigating life with that body part

No! That's not how it works. Read the science!

BlueLegume · Yesterday 14:43

Lacksie · Yesterday 14:33

because of all the built up experience of navigating life with that body part

No! That's not how it works. Read the science!

Thread after thread @Lacksie same old same old. Read the science and the usual word salads and verbal gymnastics. We understand that people/humans have different personalities but that does not make them a different sex other than male or female. Trans is such an overvalued belief these days. You are the sex you were born end of story. How you present is up to you but please stop forcing other people to believe a delusion. Anyway back to the science ….ok what about this scientist…….

Helleofabore · Yesterday 14:44

Lacksie · Yesterday 14:33

because of all the built up experience of navigating life with that body part

No! That's not how it works. Read the science!

And how can a male person know that he is accurately referencing what a female person experience is when he ‘recognises’ himself as female and not just another male experience?

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 14:46

Lacksie · Yesterday 14:32

No - I'm saying something else. The premise of your question is flawed because it assumes “male” and “female” are two boxes with clear edges, and that everyone can be sorted into one by a single test. They can’t.

Sex is a developmental process with several strands — chromosomes, gonads, hormones, the body’s response to those hormones, the resulting anatomy — and in most people they line up, so any one of them will do to assign a label. When they don’t line up, you have to choose which strand you mean, and that choice is a judgement, not a fact nature hands you.

Take a woman with complete androgen insensitivity: XY chromosomes, internal testes, no eggs. If you define “female” by chromosomes or by gonads (the organs that could produce gametes), she’s male.
If you go by phenotype and hormonal action — the far more meaningful classification — she’s female.
Women with CAIS are registered female at birth and almost always identify as female; on the Supreme Court’s own "biological sex" = “sex at birth” definition, they are female.

So what makes a person’s sex isn’t chromosomes, or gametes, or any single factor. It’s the whole developmental process.

Calling trans women “a type of female” or trans men “a type of male” is beside the point. It assumes the box comes first, when what comes first is the development; the box is where we file the result. Which box you file them in is simply a matter of which definition you choose to apply — it tells you nothing about what body a person has, how it developed, or what should follow for social policy. The 'filing'/categorisation is a social and legal act, and a matter of judgement.

Edited

Take a woman with complete androgen insensitivity: XY chromosomes, internal testes, no eggs. If you define “female” by chromosomes or by gonads (the organs that could produce gametes), she’s male.
If you go by phenotype and hormonal action — the far more meaningful classification — she’s female.

Women with CAIS are registered female at birth and almost always identify as female; on the Supreme Court’s own "biological sex" = “sex at birth” definition, they are female.

If it were not straightforward to classify sex there would be no diagnosis of CAIS. However, we are sophisticated enough to be able to deal with people whose sex is male but who are phenotypically female.

On the other hand no amount of surgery or hormones will create a phenotypical female.

So what makes a person’s sex isn’t chromosomes, or gametes, or any single factor. It’s the whole developmental process.

Using this analysis trans women are still men.

Which box you file them in is simply a matter of which definition you choose to apply — it tells you nothing about what body a person has, how it developed, or what should follow for social policy.

I really hope you aren't involved in health care.

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 14:48

Lacksie · Yesterday 14:33

because of all the built up experience of navigating life with that body part

No! That's not how it works. Read the science!

I think it's you that might be misunderstanding the science.

BackToLurk · Yesterday 14:49

Lacksie · Yesterday 14:32

No - I'm saying something else. The premise of your question is flawed because it assumes “male” and “female” are two boxes with clear edges, and that everyone can be sorted into one by a single test. They can’t.

Sex is a developmental process with several strands — chromosomes, gonads, hormones, the body’s response to those hormones, the resulting anatomy — and in most people they line up, so any one of them will do to assign a label. When they don’t line up, you have to choose which strand you mean, and that choice is a judgement, not a fact nature hands you.

Take a woman with complete androgen insensitivity: XY chromosomes, internal testes, no eggs. If you define “female” by chromosomes or by gonads (the organs that could produce gametes), she’s male.
If you go by phenotype and hormonal action — the far more meaningful classification — she’s female.
Women with CAIS are registered female at birth and almost always identify as female; on the Supreme Court’s own "biological sex" = “sex at birth” definition, they are female.

So what makes a person’s sex isn’t chromosomes, or gametes, or any single factor. It’s the whole developmental process.

Calling trans women “a type of female” or trans men “a type of male” is beside the point. It assumes the box comes first, when what comes first is the development; the box is where we file the result. Which box you file them in is simply a matter of which definition you choose to apply — it tells you nothing about what body a person has, how it developed, or what should follow for social policy. The 'filing'/categorisation is a social and legal act, and a matter of judgement.

Edited

If there are only two sexes, as you have acknowledged (unless you want to backtrack), then by definition every person must be either male or female. A transwoman must be either male or female. A transman must be either male or female. However you 'sort' them. I'm not sure why you can't answer the question regarding which you believe they are.

You've introduced DSDs, but that is of no relevance to the overwhelming majority of transpeople is it? It's an attempt to muddy the waters.

And where does this leave non-binary people. Male? Female? Some blurry middle ground that you have acknowledged doesn't exist outside male and female?

None of it of course has anything to do with the reality around the necessity and utility of single-sex spaces and services. There is no 'filing' of transwomen that adequately explains why they should be accommodated within the female prison estate for example or within women's sports, or that justifies them providing intimate care to a female person who has requested same-sex care. All of your attempts to suggest there is some incredible complexity that others just can't understand are centred upon the transperson's perception of themselves and have nothing to do with reality, particularly the reality experienced by all the other people using the services you are trying to crowbar transpeople into.

BackToLurk · Yesterday 14:50

Lacksie · Yesterday 14:33

because of all the built up experience of navigating life with that body part

No! That's not how it works. Read the science!

Your examples are examples of people mistakenly believing something that is not materially true - they have a limb they don't for example - is that really the point you wanted to make?

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 14:50

Lacksie · Yesterday 14:16

So your argument is that trans people are brain damaged?

No. The relevance is understanding how body recognition works. It's not a type of conscious reasoning/ knowing, it's pre-reflective/ automatic and happens in a different part of the brain.

The examples in that book are cases that illustrate/ demonstrate how the cognition of body recognition works - which structures of the brain are involved etc. It works like this in everyone - it's not suggesting that that's only how it works in brain damaged people.

Again, it sounds as though you have misunderstood. You seemed a bit unclear about babies and mirrors.

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 14:54

BackToLurk · Yesterday 14:50

Your examples are examples of people mistakenly believing something that is not materially true - they have a limb they don't for example - is that really the point you wanted to make?

I don't think I'm unusual in that I have had body parts removed for medical reasons. I can honestly say that I don't have any subconscious connection to them that goes beyond knowing/observing that I have had an operation.

tartyflette · Yesterday 15:11

It is well known that men are better at committing suicide than women.
I don't think it’s a settled fact that this is because they are more determined to succeed or because they tend to choose more drastic methods and thus are less likely to fail than women do.

thirdfiddle · Yesterday 15:27

Helleofabore · Yesterday 14:44

And how can a male person know that he is accurately referencing what a female person experience is when he ‘recognises’ himself as female and not just another male experience?

I think it's another TRA attempt to declare in different words "they just know okay, they have gendered souls, conscious thought or meaning of words is not required".

It's bollocks because however instinctive, there has to be some learned process of mapping feeling onto words. And because even if we had a head-sex stamped through us like a stick of rock, it's simply not relevant, we also have a physical sex and that is the reason for single sex facilities.

PleaseDontStepOnTheDaisies · Yesterday 15:28

Pingponghavoc · Yesterday 14:23

I dont think its really self id that has changed opinions, its having more exposure to the realities of trans.

Corries Hailey was a fictional character, BB Nadia was heavily edited. TW, despite what they claim, were rarely in the womans toilets in debenhams, but perhaps in the women's toilets at gay nights in clubs.

The majority of women werent in close contact with trans identifying men. Only their wives and children and they werent given a voice. Many assumed they were happy simply because they remained married.

From afar, its easy to imagine TW as anything you want them to be. Allies will often give different theories about trans ideology to what trans people say. Its so we could reassure ourselves that we were helping vulnerable and harmless people who dont want anything from us. Now we can see how they speak about women on forums or how they react to women saying no, and the reality are conflicting with that imagined trans person.

Self id has always been here. No one can stop a man changing his name and appearance. A GRC is self id with a waiting time.

Its the exposure thats changed. Now we can see that the lie has always been that they are a special type of men, when they are just men.

It was the campaign for self ID that changed my opinion - I can't speak for anyone else.

The OP asked a question "what would change your mind" - I answered personally.

cryupmykingdom · Yesterday 15:59

Lacksie · Yesterday 10:45

The thing is, you can't identify into a bodily existence that differs from your actual one. You are what you are.
What do you mean by "identify into a body?"

  • Note the misquote. Attemping to substitute 'body' for 'bodily existence'.
BlueLegume · Yesterday 16:06

What is generally the consensus on these threads @lacksie is that the majority of people contributing believe there are two sexes - male and female.

They believe you cannot change sex.

They believe there are multiple personalities and agree that old fashioned stereotypes around sex are not something we worry about in 2026.

They do not believe you can ‘feel’ a different sex. You might be an effeminate man - fine; you might be a butch woman - also fine. But you cannot change sex.

You can continue to cut this pie up as much as you want but I cannot fathom what your aim is.

The thread is asking us what could change our minds about transgender issues. I think if you read this thread, and the multiple ones many of us have been on and encountered your input, nothing will change our minds.

We are not bigoted. We do not wish trans people to be erased or dead. We do not want men in our spaces or sports.

It is not that difficult.

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 16:30

I don't care about the science, I want men-free spaces.

Those man can have as many other spaces as they want, I hope they have a lovely time in them. I'm not setting myself on fire to keep them warm.

Especially as always: activists require that women do all the labour of changing, sacrificing, learning, sucking up the disadvantages, and the men in this situation? Plan to do fuck all but take.

When THEY do a bit more learning and find a bit of tolerance for women needing single sex spaces, and are ready to find solutions that work equally for everyone, I might get a bit more interested.

Pingponghavoc · Yesterday 16:52

Even if sex is some pre-reflective idea, we wouldn't organise around this in any meaningful way.

It doesnt take into account body strength, or reproductive role or criminality. So would be useless for sports or healthcare or safeguarding.

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 16:57

BlueLegume · Yesterday 16:06

What is generally the consensus on these threads @lacksie is that the majority of people contributing believe there are two sexes - male and female.

They believe you cannot change sex.

They believe there are multiple personalities and agree that old fashioned stereotypes around sex are not something we worry about in 2026.

They do not believe you can ‘feel’ a different sex. You might be an effeminate man - fine; you might be a butch woman - also fine. But you cannot change sex.

You can continue to cut this pie up as much as you want but I cannot fathom what your aim is.

The thread is asking us what could change our minds about transgender issues. I think if you read this thread, and the multiple ones many of us have been on and encountered your input, nothing will change our minds.

We are not bigoted. We do not wish trans people to be erased or dead. We do not want men in our spaces or sports.

It is not that difficult.

Very true. Everyone knows that sex is binary with the exception of some of the young who have yet to engage in critical thinking about it and of course the "malign actors" intent on transitioning other people's children and accessing girls and women undressing.

As a general point, I suspect a deep dive into hard drives of many pushing queer theory would find a swamp of porn and fetish content. Not necessarily illegal but very relevant in terms of motivation.

Motivation to promote the transitioning of even the youngest of children.
Motivation to insist that women and girls must accept the presence of certain men in places where they undress.
Motivation to erode parent child relationships by throwing around spurious accusations of transphobia to scare parents out of safeguarding their children.

Tbh, we don't speak about this often enough for fear of deletion or offence. But i fear that porn is a massive motivation for too many. Especially when it comes to minimising safeguarding of the young and vulnerable.

maureenponderosa · Yesterday 16:57

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:56

The theory that transgender people are X brain in Y body would be borne out in the data. So I selected a group of well-known differences between males and females as examples.

Men die by suicide at a higher rate than women. Therefore, it would be expected that the demographic of fatal suicide attempts among transmen would be the same as that of men.

The thing that makes me female isn’t my brain. It’s literally my body that makes me female, and the reproductive potential/reality that comes with that . I don’t think that because of my reproductive system I have the same thought patterns as every other female human. What a peculiar idea.

I find the idea of gender offensive and sexist.

Why do you care so much? Just wear what you want. Pay for whatever cosmetic surgeries you like. I don’t care what you do. But I won’t think that males are females anymore than I could be persuaded that a dog could transform into a cat just because in its brain, it likes to sit in a box more than it likes to chase a ball.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 17:25

thirdfiddle · Yesterday 15:27

I think it's another TRA attempt to declare in different words "they just know okay, they have gendered souls, conscious thought or meaning of words is not required".

It's bollocks because however instinctive, there has to be some learned process of mapping feeling onto words. And because even if we had a head-sex stamped through us like a stick of rock, it's simply not relevant, we also have a physical sex and that is the reason for single sex facilities.

Honestly, even if it isn't, even if everything Lacks describes is 100% entirely true, so what?

All Lacks is doing is asserting the existence of something that isn't the 99.999999% of the time easily recognisable, has some pretty significant physical, economic and social consequences, quality of physical sex.

S/he isn't proving anything about the needs and protections that may reasonably pertain to physical sex at all because s/he isn't even talking about it.

So his/her points may hold water, who knows. But they simply aren't in any way a justification for undoing the recognition of sex is law, language or culture however much verbal flimflam s/he can spray around to try to hide it.