Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
ReCentre · Yesterday 17:28

The word ‘Apodictic’ is appropriate here. It describes a truth so undeniable, absolute and self evident that it leaves no room for debate or contradiction.

These truths are how we search for meaning in every day life. Transgenderism cuts right across this and demands that we deny the reality of biological sex, despite knowing it to be apodictic. It can be described as coercive control.

I have some empathy for people who think they should be the opposite sex, even for the many (mostly male) who are compelled to alter their appearance for sexual reasons. To go through life with the express desire and intention of deceiving others must surely be difficult. Making bodily changes does not make them the opposite sex and they have no right to take away the rights of natal women.

Most of the Samoan Faʻafafine do not regard themselves as biological women. They are accepted as a type of third sex. If this were adopted by trans identified men here perhaps they would have greater acceptance. There is an integrity about this which doesn’t exist when the target is ‘passing’ in order to deceive.

GriseldaandMike · Yesterday 17:32

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 16:30

I don't care about the science, I want men-free spaces.

Those man can have as many other spaces as they want, I hope they have a lovely time in them. I'm not setting myself on fire to keep them warm.

Especially as always: activists require that women do all the labour of changing, sacrificing, learning, sucking up the disadvantages, and the men in this situation? Plan to do fuck all but take.

When THEY do a bit more learning and find a bit of tolerance for women needing single sex spaces, and are ready to find solutions that work equally for everyone, I might get a bit more interested.

Edited

Our current (usual?) Self declared 'passing' transwoman contributor stated on another thread that if women don't give things up for trans people no one will - so he doesn't want to work to make the world more trans inclusive just for us to shut up and shove up.
Women wouldn't have any rights for men to steal if we had had that attitude.

2021x · Yesterday 17:55

maureenponderosa · Yesterday 16:57

The thing that makes me female isn’t my brain. It’s literally my body that makes me female, and the reproductive potential/reality that comes with that . I don’t think that because of my reproductive system I have the same thought patterns as every other female human. What a peculiar idea.

I find the idea of gender offensive and sexist.

Why do you care so much? Just wear what you want. Pay for whatever cosmetic surgeries you like. I don’t care what you do. But I won’t think that males are females anymore than I could be persuaded that a dog could transform into a cat just because in its brain, it likes to sit in a box more than it likes to chase a ball.

That is exactly my point.

TRAs are now saying “we never said you could change sex; being transgender means that you have a female brain in male body” which I think is bollocks.

To prove that I listed sociological factors that I would have to see begin considering that gender is an “internal experience”
rather than a result of external environmental and physiological factors. Being critical of your own opinions is a good way to strengthen them

Everyone on this thread is so angry and reactive that they are constantly misunderstanding what I am saying.

Men die from suicide more often than women. This is a fact. Therefore if a transman was really a man in the body of a
woman their suicide rate would be the same as men not of women.

OP posts:
nutmeg7 · Yesterday 18:07

I find it a nonsensical notion that the brain is not part of the body, and can therefore “be the wrong sex”.

It is pseudo science developed to explain why someone feels a particular way.

2021x · Yesterday 18:12

ReCentre · Yesterday 17:28

The word ‘Apodictic’ is appropriate here. It describes a truth so undeniable, absolute and self evident that it leaves no room for debate or contradiction.

These truths are how we search for meaning in every day life. Transgenderism cuts right across this and demands that we deny the reality of biological sex, despite knowing it to be apodictic. It can be described as coercive control.

I have some empathy for people who think they should be the opposite sex, even for the many (mostly male) who are compelled to alter their appearance for sexual reasons. To go through life with the express desire and intention of deceiving others must surely be difficult. Making bodily changes does not make them the opposite sex and they have no right to take away the rights of natal women.

Most of the Samoan Faʻafafine do not regard themselves as biological women. They are accepted as a type of third sex. If this were adopted by trans identified men here perhaps they would have greater acceptance. There is an integrity about this which doesn’t exist when the target is ‘passing’ in order to deceive.

This is what I agree with. The Samoan sports minister queried why Laurel
Hubbard was in the female competition.

I have compassion for people suffering, but just passing that on for others to manage is wrong and unsustainable

OP posts:
2021x · Yesterday 18:25

nutmeg7 · Yesterday 18:07

I find it a nonsensical notion that the brain is not part of the body, and can therefore “be the wrong sex”.

It is pseudo science developed to explain why someone feels a particular way.

Great point. The genetic markers in the brain cells would still be XX and XY, and every other variation?

Then how can we challenge effectively the idea of “I think therefore I am?”

OP posts:
2021x · Yesterday 18:27

GriseldaandMike · Yesterday 17:32

Our current (usual?) Self declared 'passing' transwoman contributor stated on another thread that if women don't give things up for trans people no one will - so he doesn't want to work to make the world more trans inclusive just for us to shut up and shove up.
Women wouldn't have any rights for men to steal if we had had that attitude.

My response for that is “why should we?”.

What have trans people done for women?

OP posts:
FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 18:30

nutmeg7 · Yesterday 18:07

I find it a nonsensical notion that the brain is not part of the body, and can therefore “be the wrong sex”.

It is pseudo science developed to explain why someone feels a particular way.

I think it's the same thought process as sympathic magic. If one thing seems a bit like a different thing in some way, there must be some type of esoteric connection between them.

GriseldaandMike · Yesterday 18:30

2021x · Yesterday 18:27

My response for that is “why should we?”.

What have trans people done for women?

Apart from the viaducts? 😉

Pretty much the square root of fuckall.

BlueLegume · Yesterday 19:47

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 16:57

Very true. Everyone knows that sex is binary with the exception of some of the young who have yet to engage in critical thinking about it and of course the "malign actors" intent on transitioning other people's children and accessing girls and women undressing.

As a general point, I suspect a deep dive into hard drives of many pushing queer theory would find a swamp of porn and fetish content. Not necessarily illegal but very relevant in terms of motivation.

Motivation to promote the transitioning of even the youngest of children.
Motivation to insist that women and girls must accept the presence of certain men in places where they undress.
Motivation to erode parent child relationships by throwing around spurious accusations of transphobia to scare parents out of safeguarding their children.

Tbh, we don't speak about this often enough for fear of deletion or offence. But i fear that porn is a massive motivation for too many. Especially when it comes to minimising safeguarding of the young and vulnerable.

Absolutely to the issue of porn. I do get that some confused young men and women, possibly labelled as autistic are not motivated by sex/porn to think they can feel happier by declaring they are the opposite sex. They are simply awkward people.

Retired from a career in education but around 2013/14 I had kids watching porn on their phones. Year 9 ish in UK.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page