Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Snorlaxo · 15/11/2026 06:42

You can’t change peoples minds about some things. For example I don’t believe in God but I respect that some people do. I live and let live.

If activists had gone for TWATW and TMATM then that would be more reasonable and there’d be fewer posts on GC issues imo.

Alisonsy · 15/11/2026 07:14

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:48

I agree, but it is good to try to strengthen your arguments about what a woman/man is.

Why?

There already is a clear and simple definition of what a woman/man is!!!

This thread is unnecessary

CorvusPurpureus · 15/11/2026 07:18

Helleofabore · 15/11/2026 06:14

Ahh but how do you then reset the brain to remove all the sexed conditioning for responses of everyday life?

Well I couldn’t - which is why it would be an interesting thought experiment, but is, well, bollocks.

I’d like to imagine I would be a nice chap. Sex would be interesting - I’m bi, but a bit meh about the whole thing, so it wouldn’t be my first priority.

Age & privilege would DEFINITELY be a consideration if I ended up gallivanting about with a 20yo male body powered by a mid 50s female billionaire brain!

I’d be rather curious as to how happy my hypothetical male counterparts (middle aged men having their brains moved into a young female body) would be with the outcome. I suspect their pornified ideas might wear off quite quickly & they’d be fairly outraged by reality.

Alisonsy · 15/11/2026 07:18

People cannot change sex, so nobody can ‘experience’ life as the opposite sex. It’s simply not possible. End of discussion imo.

DramaAndBullshit · 15/11/2026 07:22

I’ll change my mind when TRA’s can define what it is to be a woman without mentioning hair length, clothes, colour preferences, make up, hobbies/interests, or any other gender stereotypes with no basis in biology.

TheBafflingIsGenerallyComplete · 15/11/2026 07:25

Tears0fTheMushroom · 15/11/2026 04:55

A lobotomy.
Nothing else would do it.

I was going to say exactly the same thing.

Iheartmysmart · 15/11/2026 07:31

Nothing. It is not possible to change sex and anyone who thinks you can is a bit dim in my view.

I’m female but I like classic cars, real ale, a good action film and tend to live in jeans, hoodies and DMs. None of which means I have a male mind in a female body. I just don’t have stereotypical female interests.

Coatsoff42 · 15/11/2026 07:38

@Tears0fTheMushroom

If I had a lobotomy and lost the ability to think, lost all my knowledge of history, forgot what being a woman had been like, believed everything I was told. I’d also believe in Santa, dragons, fairies, Pokémon, magical powers, the Easter bunny, teachers are always right, adults never lie etc etc…

Basically I’d be a child, and that’s why transitioning children is wrong.

IGuessIllbetheFirst · 15/11/2026 07:44

Nothing. Because imagine if science managed to reverse cell ageing so an 80 year could have the life expectancy of a 20 year old - but the “young” 80 year old would not be an actual 20 year old, they would be still be an 80 year old whose cells had reversed to be at the level of a 20 year old with the life experience of an 80 year old whose cells had been reversed. So TWATW no matter what.

PermanentTemporary · 15/11/2026 07:46

I don’t know what changing my mind would look like.

I do feel sympathetic to people who feel compelled to make their lives more difficult - after all I felt physically driven to have a child and it was much more about feeling miserable if I didn’t rather than happy if I did. I don’t think the people I have watched transitioning seem to have happier lives, though presumably they do think that. I feel a bit sad that they couldn’t just change the things that made them feel unhappy without using a schema that is so sexist and problematic. Also in at least half the cases I wish they’d had better access to support for absolutely obvious neurodivergence, less homophobic environments to live in, or just that modern life wasn’t so inflexible for them. I worry more about their children and partners than about them though. I don’t think it’s easy being the adolescent daughter of a transitioned father. I’d rather pay attention to her than to him.

I can’t really imagine not feeling angry at the damage the incredibly poor UK lawyers in the Goodwin case, and the stupidity of the whole International Olympic Committee decisions in 2003 and even worse 2015. The people who fought for those things scare me. Those decisions were actively mad, homophobic and gynophobic to a frightening degree if you read them now, and those apparently far off decisions resulted in a cascade of fights to make legal principles and absolutes out of things that are about human psychology, sex and fluctuating emotion. So is marriage, I suppose, but at least everyone knows that marriages are complicated, not some kind of scientific medical essential, that they originate in quite problematic views, and there are routes out of them.

Since the Supreme Court decision I don’t campaign any more or worry very much. People will go on transitioning in some cases and living the lives they want to, but there seems to be much less cultural promotion of transitioning as a desirable process to children, which I’m pleased about. I keep an eye out for attempts to change the Equality Act - my MP, who I think is good overall, would be one of the leading lights in that so I believe I would hear about it. I don’t mind if toilets get turned into all-use single stalls, and I don’t mind sport organisations having moved to Open plus Female categories as most have. That all seems fine to me and promotes us all getting along.

But if anyone asks me my actual opinion, it hasn’t changed an iota. I just want to live in a way where I don’t have to talk about it.

DistantEarlyWarning · 15/11/2026 07:50

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:48

I agree, but it is good to try to strengthen your arguments about what a woman/man is.

I don’t think these points are really about what a man or woman is though.

I appreciate you’re trying to challenge your ideas, but fundamentally anyone who has (or has ever had) testes is male and anyone who has (or has ever had) ovaries is a woman.

The existence of DSDs which place a small number of people in an uncertain category does not change that. It just means that those people in the “uncertain” category take a little longer to sort appropriately into either the male or female category.

I think you’re asking “how can we make sex not matter”? But I don’t think that is possible, aside from introducing, enforcing and facilitating compliance with sex-discrimination laws. Society could make gender not matter. Wear what you like, perform “masculinity” or “femininity” as you please etc.

But sex is real and does matter.

anyolddinosaur · 15/11/2026 07:53

Suspect this is designed to show that being gender critical is not a "belief" and therefore not WORIADS - so no comment.

LeftieRightsHoarder · 15/11/2026 07:55

What they're arguing now is that they have an X brain in a Y body.

If that was true, they would be less likely to commit sexual offences than other men. In reality they’re more likely to. Which makes sense, as they tend to be sex fetishists.

I think it’s a mistake to debate this on the genderists’ terms, ie that there are traits that make people less or more female or male. They rely on confusing the issue.

In reality, we are all born male or female, including those few who have DSDs that may disguise their sex until puberty. Our individual traits, preferences, behaviours etc are irrelevant.

Soontobe60 · 15/11/2026 07:57

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:48

I agree, but it is good to try to strengthen your arguments about what a woman/man is.

Why would anyone need to ‘strengthen their arguments’ as to what a man / woman is? It’s very simple. A man is an adult human male and a woman is an adult human female. Everything else is superfluous to the definition.

BlueLegume · 15/11/2026 08:04

Shedmistress · 15/11/2026 05:51

If the trans activists could stop being the most deranged people on the planet and let everyone else make their own minds up, voice their opinions and accept that we have rights to various spaces without men in them, then maybe id discuss moving forward.

But that will be about accommodations suited to their sex, not their made up gender bollocks.

Agree - that and also them defending men entering women’s spaces….great piece here

clairepberry.substack.com?utm_source=navbar&utm_medium=web

TidyDancer · 15/11/2026 08:07

I really don’t think there is anything that could make me change my mind on this. I have thought a lot about it over the years but it comes back to the so-called gender critical position being the factual one. This isn’t a situation where it’s a mere difference of opinion. One side of this is based in fact, the other in fantasy. I have huge sympathy for people who have distress over their sex and they should get better mental health support than there is currently available in many areas. But since changing sex isn’t possible, there is nothing that could make me believe that men can be women and vice versa.

Pingponghavoc · 15/11/2026 08:11

Its acknowledging female as a class, but redefining women as the average of female?

So males who fit these averages become women and females who dont become men?

What would the use of this be?

PersephoneParlormaid · 15/11/2026 08:13

Nothing would change my mind. You’re male or female, that’s that. Trans is MH.

LadyinPainting · 15/11/2026 08:15

I think it is a useful thought experiment because it shows what your current thinking is based on. A gametes answer for example is useful because it clarifies what male and female actually is.

I think the first step that I would need to view transwomen as anything other than just the same as any other man would be a biological marker that they all share and no non-transwomen men share. It wouldn’t mean I thought transwomen were women, but I may believe it might be possible that they were a discreet sub set within men. If it were true, then this would be the ‘true transwomen’ type argument.

However, I don’t see how you could get there. Because within transwomen at the moment there are, in my opinion, many variables including the ‘true’ ones (if there is a biological marker, which personally I doubt but am prepared to be open minded about) and the ‘clearly trying it on’ ones. And so the attempt to find such a marker would actually be strongly resisted.

BlueLegume · 15/11/2026 08:17

PersephoneParlormaid · 15/11/2026 08:13

Nothing would change my mind. You’re male or female, that’s that. Trans is MH.

Agreed @PersephoneParlormaid it would be really sensible to repatholgise trans/gender identity as a mental health issue OR find out why it was depatholgised as it seems to have been done very slyly.

The Pope entered the conversation yesterday saying ‘there are men and there are women, nothing else”

Let’s see how the media deliver that message and the reactions. Caveat to add I am not religious but do believe faith is real just not God.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · 15/11/2026 08:19

Nothing.

You might as well ask me , what would make you believe the person who is 6'2" is actually 5ft 3"
... Or what would convince you that this tabby cat is actually a tiger.

Myalternate · 15/11/2026 08:20

Can’t get ‘inside’ the minds of men who think they’re women but I’d like to understand what it is about being men that they find unacceptable.

PermanentTemporary · 15/11/2026 08:20

BlueLegume · 15/11/2026 08:04

Agree - that and also them defending men entering women’s spaces….great piece here

clairepberry.substack.com?utm_source=navbar&utm_medium=web

Oh my God. There we go - a ‘risk assessment’ that refuses to acknowledge the single biggest risk, that of male sex in the context of an extensive offending history; and a refusal to challenge someone who blasts through boundaries, because the leaders are afraid, because of the single biggest risk, which nobody is allowed to mention. FFS. I mean, and they are breaking the law, but who cares, amirite? Hope Claire goes on with sobriety despite all of that.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 15/11/2026 08:21

TidyDancer · 15/11/2026 08:07

I really don’t think there is anything that could make me change my mind on this. I have thought a lot about it over the years but it comes back to the so-called gender critical position being the factual one. This isn’t a situation where it’s a mere difference of opinion. One side of this is based in fact, the other in fantasy. I have huge sympathy for people who have distress over their sex and they should get better mental health support than there is currently available in many areas. But since changing sex isn’t possible, there is nothing that could make me believe that men can be women and vice versa.

Agreed.
Women are under constant pressure to capitulate, to agree, to stop safeguarding children in favour of transactivism. Nothing will ever be enough as from the outset this has never been a rational social justice movement based on harm. It's been a powerful, oppressive, anti democratic movement that's intimidated and coerced people into complying. They have specifically targeted the youngest and most vulnerable in society.

You can't pander to these people - they need firm boundaries that need enforcing, especially in relation to how they manipulate the young.

Remember their shifting theories are based on the fact that sex change is a fantasy, not reality. As each theory is discredited they produce another one in its place. Hence the incoherence of all their arguments.

We should all be more Mumsnet - NO is a complete sentence!

DotDotDoorDash · 15/11/2026 08:23

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:56

The theory that transgender people are X brain in Y body would be borne out in the data. So I selected a group of well-known differences between males and females as examples.

Men die by suicide at a higher rate than women. Therefore, it would be expected that the demographic of fatal suicide attempts among transmen would be the same as that of men.

Ok - but women attempt suicide at a higher rate. Men chose methods more likely to be fatal so if trans men suddenly start shooting themselves instead of taking an overdose you’ll be more likely to go “oh ok maybe they are really men after all”?

suicidality is an extremely odd measure to judge this by.