Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
LizzieSiddal · 15/11/2026 08:29

Borrowing from JKR: trans people can crack on with dressing how they like, having consensual sex with whoever they like etc etc but they must acknowledge they do not belong and are not welcome in opposite sex spaces/sports/jobs etc etc.

Simple!

TheKeatingFive · 15/11/2026 08:29

Nothing, because humans can’t change sex and women’s single sex rights are there for a reason.

Its no more complicated than that

BlueLegume · 15/11/2026 08:34

PermanentTemporary · 15/11/2026 08:20

Oh my God. There we go - a ‘risk assessment’ that refuses to acknowledge the single biggest risk, that of male sex in the context of an extensive offending history; and a refusal to challenge someone who blasts through boundaries, because the leaders are afraid, because of the single biggest risk, which nobody is allowed to mention. FFS. I mean, and they are breaking the law, but who cares, amirite? Hope Claire goes on with sobriety despite all of that.

Yes I hope Claire continues to recover as well @PermanentTemporary Claire is on X as Artemispat2 - Nick Wallis had praised her and promoted the link -which is usually a good hunch.

Interestingly her post on X with the link to her Substack article she tagged some big names in keen on fighting the gender wang nonsense.

Alcohol and drugs hub for women are so drunk on gender that they've given full access to a dangerous man @bindelj @Glinner @JamesEsses @thirdsectorSEEN @IsntWorkingPod @ForWomenScot @ripx4nutmeg
@jk_rowling @OnChairs @RoisinMichaux

I hope that the young women en thrall to all this see what could happen to them. So many seem blind to the reality to the extent they defend these men.

NorthXNorthWest · 15/11/2026 08:41

Surely the aim is respect and tolerance on both sides. Which means respecting that some spaces/ choices are for biological women only.

Surely it’s no more complicated than that.

BlueLegume · 15/11/2026 08:45

NorthXNorthWest · 15/11/2026 08:41

Surely the aim is respect and tolerance on both sides. Which means respecting that some spaces/ choices are for biological women only.

Surely it’s no more complicated than that.

I think most people agree with that @NorthXNorthWest but sadly the TRAs and allies approach is not so accommodating.

We do not ‘hate’ people and issue threats of violence towards their community. But some, not all of that community seem hellbent on convincing us to say 2+2=5

Women and children need to know they have women only spaces and that excludes all men and children need to be safeguarded and parents to parent - not be criminalised for being good caring parents.

Shedmistress · 15/11/2026 08:46

PermanentTemporary · 15/11/2026 08:20

Oh my God. There we go - a ‘risk assessment’ that refuses to acknowledge the single biggest risk, that of male sex in the context of an extensive offending history; and a refusal to challenge someone who blasts through boundaries, because the leaders are afraid, because of the single biggest risk, which nobody is allowed to mention. FFS. I mean, and they are breaking the law, but who cares, amirite? Hope Claire goes on with sobriety despite all of that.

Throughout all of this shitshow, risk assessments put 'no risk' down on their forms as 'trans women ARE women'. So no risk.

The Welsh Government literally hid theirs when asked for it.

BiologicalRobot · 15/11/2026 08:49

Define issues first.

If you mean biological men in biological womens spaces, whether single sex for changing or prisons, sport etc then I'm never going to change my mind. They can fuck off to the far side of fuck and then fall off the edge.

If you mean biological men wearing dresses and/or makeup then I grew up in the era of glam rock, New Romantics, Punk and out the other side with David Beckham. It's nothing new.

Pingponghavoc · 15/11/2026 08:50

Are you thinking along the lines of if an individual male has enough female traits he can be seen as a woman, or if the class of TW have, on average, female traits, TWAW?

For example, if we sample enough TW and see that their upper body strength is on average within female range, or their crime profile is the same as females, every TW becomes a woman be default.

The first is impractical- men can fake strength tests, and most individuals dont have a criminal profile.

The second will let a lot of very strong male sex offenders be women.

TheHereticalOne · 15/11/2026 08:54

I'm glad you've asked this - it's important to know what would change your mind about anything to avoid just being a fundamentalist! The following for me:

For anyone born male to be classed as a woman:

  1. If it were discovered that human beings could in fact swap between reproductive sex classes and this could be demonstrated objectively using blind testing; and
  2. Those who had previously been male but are now objectively female show the same relevant statistical profile as those who have always been female in a given situation (offending rates when considering access to spaces, average strength and power when considering sports etc.)

There is no other basis for categorising someone as the opposite sex than point 1, because in any other scenario they are simply not. It is falsifying data.

Point 2 is important for checking that risk profile data are not skewed by including data for those who have changed sex at some point in their life with the data for those who have never been any other sex so that policy and safeguarding can be handled accordingly.

For establishing that there is such a thing as being transgender where that means anything other than, "I really wish I were or believe as a subjective article of faith that I am the opposite sex":

  1. an objective test for transgenderism that allows scientifically blind identification of the condition. Level of accuracy required for that test tbc but I don't think it's an unreasonable starting position to say that the level of accuracy for such a blind test should be at least the level of accuracy we can achieve for the method of sex-testing by a glance at the anatomy of a newborn baby (i.e. higher than 99%).

For establishing that there is such a thing as being transgender where that simply means someone wishes they were or fervently believes - in absence of objective testing - that they are the opposite sex:

I already believe this to be the case for some people. I am sorry for them and wish them appropriate support of it causes them distress, but it has no effect on their actual sex class, nor how or whether it is sometimes sensible to separate by sex class.

Snorlaxo · 15/11/2026 08:57

Define issues first.

Excellent point.

When people were fighting for gay rights, they could name actual issues like gay people not being able to get married or inherit from their partners like straight people. If there’s anything that the law has forgotten like that then there would be lots of support as people are rational and reasonable in the face of facts.

Unfortunately trans activism seems to be about feelings (including sexual) rather than facts and wanting preferential treatment rather than equal treatment so it’s hard to everyone else to understand.

Seymour5 · 15/11/2026 09:03

I have no problem with anyone dressing how they want, or even adopting a name that very obviously does not align with their sex. But there’s the sporting issues, the changing and loo facilities, and the men who suddenly decide to present as women for very unwholesome reasons. So in answer to the OP, I won’t change my mind. Seems one judge felt the same.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5599484-safiya-haverty-sentenced-to-10-years?reply=155935034

teawamutu · 15/11/2026 09:03

Proof that every cell had actually changed the sex encoded within them, that strength and musculature etc had reached female levels, and anatomy had been surgically tweaked into a version of the real thing.

And even then I'd be playing along rather than believing it.

Basically, magic. I'd need magic.

MarieDeGournay · 15/11/2026 09:08

I'm trying to work out at what age this happens - maybe around age 8? - when children become argumentative, not in a 'No, won't!' kind of way, but in an excessively persistently logical kind of way:

'Put on your shoes quickly, we're going to be late for school!'
'Yeah but we might not be late, there might not be any other cars on the road and we'll get there in minutes'
'Of course there are going to be other cars on the road, now put your shoes on please!'
'Yeah but how do you KNOW there'll be other cars on the road?'
'Because people will be going to school and work '
'Yeah but supposing they all decided to take a day off? Then there wouldn't be any other cars on the road.'
'Don't be silly and just get your shoes on, now, please!'
'It's not silly... maybe all the other cars apart from our car won't start this morning and...'.................
....
'Yeah but I don't HAVE to wear shoes to school, there's no LAW that says you have to wear shoes to school...'

and so ad infinitum. I heard somebody saying the other day calling it
'The stage at which your child becomes a scale model of a barrister'😁

That's what these 'Yeah but X brain in Y body' and 'Yeah but phenotype' posts remind me of

'What you're doing is called reductio ad absurdum, sweetheart, that's very clever. Now put your shoes on, please! Now!'🙄

Meadowfinch · 15/11/2026 09:09

There is nothing. The vast majority of humans have either XX or XY chromosomes, and nothing can alter that fact.

There are extremely rare individuals with chimerism or mosaicism but otherwise, there is no grey area.

How people to choose to live in their personal lives is up to them, but transition is not possible.

Perenelle · 15/11/2026 09:26

I believe it is possible and even normal to be a "gender-nonconforming" person. Everyone feels more or less "feminine" or "masculine". And society absolutely could be more tolerant towards gender-nonconformism.

But all of that has no impact on a persons sex. Sex is an immutable fact and there are some situations where it matters, even in a modern and liberal society.

The problems start as soon as "transgender" does not simply entail transcending superficial gender-stereotypes but the conflation of gender and sex.

Pingponghavoc · 15/11/2026 09:28

Everything we understand scientifically and socially about women is because of our sex.

If men can become women, it changes everything about what a women is. Women is not female but an identity with a little bit of gatekeeping.

Why do we need to create this class of people?

We are ignoring all of the reasons men want to be seen as women and forcing women to be part of a newly created male defined class. The traits cannot be anything exclusively female and will have to be what men can achieve.

But for what end?

The reason men want to be seen as women is so they can be treated as women - pronouns, in women's spaces and opportunities, to be alone with women and girls, to make women what they want women to be.

The control of women is a fundamental part of what trans is - its ignoring our fertility and reproduction role and making women what others see and what men can become. Then forcing us to play along.

cryupmykingdom · 15/11/2026 09:31

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 15/11/2026 05:14

I really don't think anyone needs to strengthen their argument on this matter. Any debate around the edges just gives legitimacy to the idea that being a man or a woman is a complicated and hard to define state and it's not.

Yes, I think that's right.

And we are dealing with a stupid, but very manipulative argument.

Imagine this argument as a person. It would be something like Russell Brand.

Stupid, but very cunning.

I wouldn't give it much wriggle room.

cryupmykingdom · 15/11/2026 09:32

MarieDeGournay · 15/11/2026 09:08

I'm trying to work out at what age this happens - maybe around age 8? - when children become argumentative, not in a 'No, won't!' kind of way, but in an excessively persistently logical kind of way:

'Put on your shoes quickly, we're going to be late for school!'
'Yeah but we might not be late, there might not be any other cars on the road and we'll get there in minutes'
'Of course there are going to be other cars on the road, now put your shoes on please!'
'Yeah but how do you KNOW there'll be other cars on the road?'
'Because people will be going to school and work '
'Yeah but supposing they all decided to take a day off? Then there wouldn't be any other cars on the road.'
'Don't be silly and just get your shoes on, now, please!'
'It's not silly... maybe all the other cars apart from our car won't start this morning and...'.................
....
'Yeah but I don't HAVE to wear shoes to school, there's no LAW that says you have to wear shoes to school...'

and so ad infinitum. I heard somebody saying the other day calling it
'The stage at which your child becomes a scale model of a barrister'😁

That's what these 'Yeah but X brain in Y body' and 'Yeah but phenotype' posts remind me of

'What you're doing is called reductio ad absurdum, sweetheart, that's very clever. Now put your shoes on, please! Now!'🙄

Let them go to school without shoes for a day. Unlikely to repeat the experiment.

Pingponghavoc · 15/11/2026 09:39

The idea that the word female is enough for feminism, and that women and presumably girl can be given away as a compromise is naive.

Why arent we questioning why the words woman and girl are so important for these men? Queer theory comes up with new words all of the time, but cannot find a new word for 'men who dont want to be men'?

FrippEnos · 15/11/2026 09:42

2021x

The first thing that would have to happen is for the trans lobby to actually put in solod definitions of what they are, what they mean and what they are actually after that they don't already have.

They would also have to abide by definitions in law and not put out statements such as "its no workable", when the only reason for it not being workable is that they refuse to abide by the law.

BackToLurk · 15/11/2026 09:44

I can’t think of anything that would convince me that some men require the same sex-based, or single-sex, protections, services and access to spaces as women do based on the way those men identify.

DeanElderberry · 15/11/2026 09:46

The built in misogyny of the whole trans edifice is shown by how many respondents are talking about transwomen and the challenge to women's rights without also talking about transmen.

I was shifted from 'be kind, nothing to see here' by seeing what had happened to a clever, troubled, autistic girl I knew, how her family had been forced into accepting a lie about everything they had experienced for decades, the sadness that lie caused. The shift was completed by realising the massive danger she would be put into if she was drugged or mutilated into premature menopause.

And then seeing the trans advocates insist none of that damage to troubled young women should be talked about. Anorexia was bad enough, so was cutting. This new way of punishing bodies for being female is appalling.

Even if there were no fetishist paraphiliac men involved, trans would be a nightmare.

Error404FucksNotFound · 15/11/2026 10:02

What would convince me that someone who is biologically one sex is actually the other sex simply because that's what they feel they are, and not because of any physical cause?

Nothing will ever convince me of that.

If scientists ever identify a gene or genes that make you feel male or female regardless how your entire body is, I would accept that.

If it is discovered that it is a form of chimerism, I would accept that. I read about a woman that is genetically herself in every part of her except her blood, she has her twin brothers blood. If evidence is found that chimerism causes sex identity confusion, I could accept that.

Hell, if evidence is found that it is linked to absorbing your twin in the womb, I could get behind that if the science is there.

I still would not accept male bodied people in female spaces or vice versa or that trans people should be prioritised over everyone else at all times, but I could get behind the science if it was strong enough.

AlexandraLeaving · 15/11/2026 10:22

I'm not sure I could be convinced to change my mind. But if it was going to happen the first step in that direction would need to be a non-circular and clear definition of what the categories 'man' and 'woman' were (which were not simply rooted in regressive and sexist stereotypes), clarity over what the new-approved terms were for the human sex classes formerly known as 'men' and 'women' and confirmation that there remained adequate protection for the latter (sex classes). I'd also want there to be clarity over what 'trans' meant [gay/bi/lesbian are all very clear terms] and, as others have said, clear, objective diagnostic criteria.

nutmeg7 · 15/11/2026 10:28

Being in a different universe where sexual reproduction didn’t evolve?