Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend with two estranged children

206 replies

Whattodooing · Today 10:42

I have a friend who I have known for many years. She has a bit of a tendency to be a bit dramatic but other than that she is a nice person. Her health is very bad.

Without going into too much detail she has 4 children and is estranged from two. She has been estranged from her daughter for many years. She became estranged from her son about a year ago. The two had nothing to do with each other. Completely separate situations. She blames his wife for the estrangement. Her son has recently announced he’s having a baby and she’s very upset.

I’ve tried hard not to comment too much on the situation or get too involved but I feel like it’s what most of our convos revolve around now. On one hand she is in and out of hospital and I feel awful for her because she doesn’t have anyone. She still has other children who aren’t no contact but they don’t live near and offer her no support. On the other hand I think if she has two children who have cut her off there must be a reason and she needs to look deeper than blaming everyone else.

I really want to support my friend and her son announcing a pregnancy has made her so focused on this that I don’t know how to help her through it or what to say. She has no support health wise and has been essentially left to rot.

OP posts:
Maritimemadness · Today 16:04

eatreadsleeprepeat · Today 15:53

Has she been offered any help that she has turned down? In particular has she been offered any help wearable alarm to use if she falls? If not she should approach her gp and ask about this. She can request an evaluation of her needs. Is the reason for falls something that can be helped medically? If so has she consulted the gp about it? Has she complied with all medical advice? You are close to her and her situation, what is it that should have been done but hasn’t.
In your position I would concentrate on practicalities getting any aids installed, getting any care help in place, getting things like dosette box for her medication, investigating whether any technology would help.

All of that help needs to be paid for, which is a common reason why people turn it down. They then rely on friends and relatives to do it for free, while claiming they have been 'abandoned' by the state/nhs etc

Tinaforshort · Today 16:06

OP I’m disabled and was moved due to my issues into a bungalow. When we were moved I was seen, and under, my local councils occupational therapy team to ensure the bungalow was adapted to my needs. Has she been assessed by the OT’s? In my experience, which I’m aware won’t be the same for everyone, everything I needed was done incredibly quickly - for me this included having a driveway fitted. It was a complete whirlwind.

Whattodooing · Today 16:06

eatreadsleeprepeat · Today 15:53

Has she been offered any help that she has turned down? In particular has she been offered any help wearable alarm to use if she falls? If not she should approach her gp and ask about this. She can request an evaluation of her needs. Is the reason for falls something that can be helped medically? If so has she consulted the gp about it? Has she complied with all medical advice? You are close to her and her situation, what is it that should have been done but hasn’t.
In your position I would concentrate on practicalities getting any aids installed, getting any care help in place, getting things like dosette box for her medication, investigating whether any technology would help.

She says she hasn’t turned any down but obviously I’m not sure. As I said previously she had a fall alarm she wore around her neck but returned it as she said the cost was too high.

Her social services assessment said she needs a wet room fitted as she cannot get in and out of the bath. This was last year but has not been fitted yet so she is currently showering in her neighbours house as they have a wet room.

She has a rollator but still falls when she is out with this. She had fractured her pelvis multiple times and her last fall out with it led to a fractured collar bone and two black eyes. She falls due to her condition but I think her frailness makes it worse as she’s even more wobbly on her feet and she’s so delicate any fall injures her.

I think main issue is her nutrition as several feeding tubes have failed and I know she was prescribed drinks to help gain weight but she said those made her feel sick so stopped drinking. Posters are correct that she needs to help her self because nobody else can. I do often wonder if there is some mental health or learning need going on with her or if it is just learned helplessness on her part. But she hasn’t been diagnosed with anything as far as I’m aware

OP posts:
marbIes · Today 16:08

eatreadsleeprepeat · Today 15:53

Has she been offered any help that she has turned down? In particular has she been offered any help wearable alarm to use if she falls? If not she should approach her gp and ask about this. She can request an evaluation of her needs. Is the reason for falls something that can be helped medically? If so has she consulted the gp about it? Has she complied with all medical advice? You are close to her and her situation, what is it that should have been done but hasn’t.
In your position I would concentrate on practicalities getting any aids installed, getting any care help in place, getting things like dosette box for her medication, investigating whether any technology would help.

OP said she had a lifeline alarm and sent it back claiming she couldn’t afford it.

She’s had help. Social services aren’t obliged to keep forcing help on someone who is declining it

OneNewEagle · Today 16:11

This sounds very complex, I’m estranged from my family.

what are the reasons her daughter is estranged from her and for so long?

as she was a good friend and took you in after domestic violence in that way she is one hundred percent a good person at heart. I went through similar no one ever helped me. So she has good traits but maybe not so much as a mother. I would always help a friend who did that for me in my hour of need.

as she helped you did she also suffer domestic violence in her past? And that’s caused the problems over years with her kids? therapy could be available if she’s suffered trauma herself , I had talking therapy with the nhs.

as a friend I would try to change the conversation around to different things. Help her navigate some carers as she obviously needs them and a warden assisted bungalow. I would just see her as my friend who helped me when no one else did but not want to be involved in her family dynamics.

Boomer55 · Today 16:11

She could have help, healthwise, if she chooses to take it.

Not sure what’s going on with her children, but she can get more support here:

www.gransnet.com/forums/estrangement

ContraryNoodle · Today 16:21

She very much sounds like someone who is unwilling to make any effort to sort her life out herself. I have known people like that and have protected my boundaries to not be drawn into their drama. They are unwilling to 'adult' and infantalise themselves, so that others pick up the problems and resolve them for them. Basically, they are lazy cu*ts. It can be very tiring to call around and sort out one's issues but tough titties, it is still on her. She needs to get off her arse and sort out her own shit. End of.

SusieSussex · Today 16:23

HardShoulders · Today 10:49

You can’t help because you don’t have anywhere near all the information. You may think your friend is a ‘nice person’, but you didn’t experience her as a parent. None of her children are supporting her, and two are estranged. Perhaps with good reason.

My mother is invariably described as ‘lovely’. She presents as a sweet, desperate-to-please elderly woman who would give you her last penny. Yet she knew two of her children were being sexually abused in childhood (one of them told her) and not only did nothing to stop it at the time because it would have involved ‘making a fuss’, but has never acknowledged it since or apologised. Both children have suffered lifelong impact, and have tried to raise the subject gently in their 40s /50s, but she thinks ‘it wasn’t that bad’.

I offer this as an example.

I agree. My mum has a Jekyll and Hyde personality. Abusive behind close doors, sweet as pie in public.

Slightyamusedandsilly · Today 16:24

AnswerIsNo · Today 13:45

Let's see... post includes alarmist hyperbole

"Epidemic of judgement and estrangement of family members, 'some' of course will be justified"

followed by

"search Mumsnet to find examples of draconian and self righteous witchhunting of parents of adult children (often with children of their own, and no self awareness of the idea of what they are modelling to their own children), as a result, you will encounter a range of responses here, including some wilful misunderstandings"

Nice to see someone has decided to become arbiter of which of the 'small' (aka (minority number) of estrangements are justified, while mentioning judgement in the same sentence 😆

I think the text quotes in bold speak for themselves

No further comments, your honour

Edited

The size adjective is yours, not mine.

Canitrustagain · Today 16:26

She blames his wife for the estrangement. Her son has recently announced he’s having a baby and she’s very upset.

Her son sounds like one of the very rare men who chooses to support his partner when his mum is being nasty/crosses boundaries.

thisismeithinkorisit · Today 16:33

op WHO has left her to rot? when you say she's left on the floor for so many hours that she's hospitalised dehydrated, do you mean whoever she's calling won't help or it's often hours before she calls for help?

you need to seperate the two things.
estrangement.
turn it back to her. well what do you plan to do about it? do you think that will help? why don't you think they'll let you see the baby? but do you understand that it's because you.....
It'll be a tedious conversation but it might be worth having it out properly once and seeing if they helps, cos it sounds like you currently tip toe around her behaviour.
or, dismiss and move on. yes I know it's hard. anyway, did you see X on the news last night. uh huh, yes that sounds very frustrating. guess what I'm having for tea tonight?
or, be blunt. look Mary, I know you're upset but we both know it's because you did X. you'll never fix it if you can't accept that and try to change / apologise etc

health
she's very young to be so poorly so I'm assuming she has something overriding medically going on. does she still have the SW? It sounds like she needs to talk to them and say I have this chronic condition, I'm not capable of living independently, what help. an you give? if she's not accepting interventions, again go blunt. I know Mary but you need to do X or it won't improve

Marieb19 · Today 16:49

There are two separate issues; the NHS and her children.
Would she let you accompany her to GP/social services visits where you can discuss her health issue and get social services to provide a wrist call alarm? This could get her help quickly in the event of a fall
As many have already said, her son may have deliberately cut contact and her fixation is likely to make it worse. Do you know her son and coukd you speak to him? I fear yoh may be going where angels fear to tread but you aren't likely to make it worse and you may understand why her children are estranged.

veggie50 · Today 17:01

Whattodooing · Today 16:06

She says she hasn’t turned any down but obviously I’m not sure. As I said previously she had a fall alarm she wore around her neck but returned it as she said the cost was too high.

Her social services assessment said she needs a wet room fitted as she cannot get in and out of the bath. This was last year but has not been fitted yet so she is currently showering in her neighbours house as they have a wet room.

She has a rollator but still falls when she is out with this. She had fractured her pelvis multiple times and her last fall out with it led to a fractured collar bone and two black eyes. She falls due to her condition but I think her frailness makes it worse as she’s even more wobbly on her feet and she’s so delicate any fall injures her.

I think main issue is her nutrition as several feeding tubes have failed and I know she was prescribed drinks to help gain weight but she said those made her feel sick so stopped drinking. Posters are correct that she needs to help her self because nobody else can. I do often wonder if there is some mental health or learning need going on with her or if it is just learned helplessness on her part. But she hasn’t been diagnosed with anything as far as I’m aware

Your friend's most pressing problem is her health, I'd put aside her issues with her children and focus on getting her somewhere safe to live. She had some fall resulting in serious injuries, this warrants a new assessment. As well as starting the process of switching her from her council flat to supported living (i.e. request a new care needs assessment), I'd also make sure she has a social worker assigned to her (her GP can refer her) to help her navigate this process.

While I haven't had any experience in this, I've googled and found the following which may help you get started.

To move from a council house into council-funded assisted living (often called Extra Care Housing or Supported Living in the UK), you must go through both a Care Needs Assessment and a housing transfer application with your local council.

1. Request a Care Needs Assessment
Before the council can fund assisted living, adult social care must officially confirm that you need on-site support.

  • Contact Adult Social Care. Ask your local council's adult social care team for a Care Needs Assessment.
  • Detail your daily struggles. Explain what you cannot do safely in your current home (e.g., stairs, personal care, cooking, or mobility).
  • Get a care plan. If you meet the national eligibility criteria, social care will approve a care package and recommend Extra Care or supported housing.

2. Complete a Financial Assessment (Means Test)
Council funding for assisted living is split into two parts: housing costs (rent/service charges) and care costs.

  • Care costs. The council will assess your income and savings to decide whether they will fund all, part, or none of your personal care.
  • Housing costs. If you are on a low income or claim benefits, Housing Benefit or the housing element of Universal Credit will usually cover your new rent and eligible service charges.

3. Apply for a Housing Transfer
Once your care and housing needs are established, you apply to move out of your current council property.

  • Apply through your local housing register.
  • Request medical/welfare priority. Submit your Care Needs Assessment, GP letters, or occupational therapist reports. Moving due to health or care needs puts you in a higher priority band for suitable flats.
  • Attend an allocation panel. For Extra Care housing, a joint panel of housing officers and social workers usually reviews your application to ensure the specific scheme can meet your care level.

4. End Your Current Tenancy Properly
When you are offered and accept an assisted living flat, you will need to formally hand back your council house.

  • Give formal notice. You usually need to give 4 weeks' written notice to end your council tenancy, though councils often allow a short overlap (up to 4 weeks) on Housing Benefit if you cannot move immediately due to health needs
  • Clear the property. Council houses must be left empty and clean—including removing carpets, curtains, and personal belongings—otherwise the council may charge a clearance fee
  • Notify utility providers and Council Tax. Inform your energy suppliers, water company, and the council tax department of your moving date so billing stops on your old home.
bigboykitty · Today 17:12

The friend has already moved to a bungalow because of her health. It's unclear why the bathroom hasn't been adapted, but it's possible she's refused the work. There is a potential grey area between her health/care needs and her unwillingness to take care of herself. She's entitled to make stupid or unwise decisions. Doesn't necessarily mean regular care is warranted. It does sound like a further assessment is needed. I would push to be included if I was OP, but I would be quite clear that there is nothing further I could do to help. I

JustaSongAboutPingPong · Today 17:14

Ah I see she had a Falls Alarm but she chose to end the contract. I get that she hasn’t got much money or any real earning potential but I think the alarms are around £15 a month. It doesn’t seem like a wise decision when she spends hours on the floor and ends up hospitalised? I wonder if she believes that her DC will feel guilty if she is hospitalised again.

I’ve had a relative who has had a wet trim fitted after it was recommended by an OT. It was not an easy thing to navigate. I had to keep making phones calls and dealing with local government to achieve a common goal is part of my job. I don’t know how people go on who haven’t got anyone to help to navigate the process. Your DF does have a SW though, so she’s not alone.

Would she be better suited to Care Plus where she’d have a wet room and hopefully a falls cord?

I do totally get that you want to do your best for your DF but it does sound as though it’s now coming at the cost of your own health. I don’t think of anyone woukd criticise you if you wanted to reduce your visits or if you were to say to your DF, “I don’t want to talk about your family at the moment, let’s talk about something more cheery instead. Did you watch (whatever her favourite show is)”.

TightPants · Today 17:23

If your friend is as hard up as she says she is, then her care will be provided free via a social care assessment. She needs to arrange a visit from a social worker and be honest about her needs and her frequent falls.

She will also be entitled to an occupational therapy assessment via social care or the local NHS team. Her GP can refer her for this.

You sound like a lovely friend OP, please protect yourself. In my professional career I’ve encountered a good few people like your friend. What she’s telling you is probably very different to what she’s saying to social care and the NHS.

I don’t doubt she is struggling, but she really needs to start advocating for herself and stop playing the victim.

Incidentally, the fact that she was moved from a house to a bungalow was what so many people with illnesses and disabilities need. Someone worked very hard to facilitate that for her as it is sadly very rare.

Whattodooing · Today 17:24

bigboykitty · Today 17:12

The friend has already moved to a bungalow because of her health. It's unclear why the bathroom hasn't been adapted, but it's possible she's refused the work. There is a potential grey area between her health/care needs and her unwillingness to take care of herself. She's entitled to make stupid or unwise decisions. Doesn't necessarily mean regular care is warranted. It does sound like a further assessment is needed. I would push to be included if I was OP, but I would be quite clear that there is nothing further I could do to help. I

There’s a lot of things that I don’t know the truth about as I haven’t been present but the bathroom is one. I’ve even rang on her behalf.

They’ve just said she’s on the waiting list and the grant has been approved but that’s it.

OP posts:
BatchCookBabe · Today 17:34

You seem to know an awful lot about this friend @Whattodooing and are very involved in her life and her affairs.

Is this 'friend' actually you?

MsPrufrockk · Today 17:35

Whattodooing · Today 17:24

There’s a lot of things that I don’t know the truth about as I haven’t been present but the bathroom is one. I’ve even rang on her behalf.

They’ve just said she’s on the waiting list and the grant has been approved but that’s it.

And she won't be a priory because she's probably told them her children are caring for her. My dad is on the waiting list for a bathroom adaptation, and JK rur meantime he gets a strip wash every day from his carers. Carers that he has EVEN THOUGH he has two children who visit regularly and help as much as we can.

ScottishEggs · Today 17:39

Your friend seems very good at getting other people (i.e. you) to run around after her and to dance attendance on her trying to fix her life.

Some people are very skilled at that. We have a neighbour like that- people rush around him as he is so 'helpless'. (Helpless as a bloody ox, in reality).

Do you need to cast a more objective eye over things? Are you dropping everything when she asks you to jump? Does she have a history of working her way through friends an acquaintances and essentially using them and their good will up before they get sick of it and she gloms onto a new victim? Because it's all beginning to sound a bit familiar.

user49537 · Today 17:40

Some people are making assumptions that your friend has been abusive to her children. But going no contact with parents is a massive trend these days, and is encouraged online. In this case the mother is becoming older, has no money, has very bad health which is getting worse. She lives alone and desperately needs practical and emotional support, and is receiving little help from the state. No doubt she is getting "clingy" with her adult children. I suspect that the son in particular has ditched her because she now has little to offer him, and is at the stage where she needs him to support her, rather than the other way round. If she had enough money to pay for a home help to assist her, and had money in the bank her children were likely to inherit, it might well be a different story.

Everyone merrily says that her job was to give to her children, and she must expect nothing in return. That's the British way, isn't it? It's not like that in lots of other countries. If your friend lived in Italy or in China, her children would very probably be gathering around her to offer support.

It's an extremely difficult situation, but trying to change the son's mind is unlikely to work. It's better that she simply ignores him. I'm sure you're extremely important to your friend, OP, and I hope you can continue to help her, while also not letting the situation take over your own life. Are there any local charities that can help?

Of course, the same people on this thread who say that adult children owe their parents nothing are telling you to ditch your friend and "have fun". What a rubbish society we live in.

Whattodooing · Today 17:42

BatchCookBabe · Today 17:34

You seem to know an awful lot about this friend @Whattodooing and are very involved in her life and her affairs.

Is this 'friend' actually you?

No it isn’t, this thread is about my difficult relationship with my friend and how I am struggling to navigate it.

I’m not even sure what I would get writing a thread about myself in the way that I have if it was about me.

OP posts:
MsPrufrockk · Today 17:43

MsPrufrockk · Today 17:35

And she won't be a priory because she's probably told them her children are caring for her. My dad is on the waiting list for a bathroom adaptation, and JK rur meantime he gets a strip wash every day from his carers. Carers that he has EVEN THOUGH he has two children who visit regularly and help as much as we can.

I should have checked that within the time I had to edit it 😂

PRIORITY

and

IN THE MEANTIME

MixedFeelingsNoFeelings · Today 17:44

I see your dilemma OP. You sound like a really decent friend and person, who's trying to find path between loyalty to someone who was there for you when you needed her, and a clear-eyed assessment of that person's much less likeable traits (which you can only guess at, because one of those traits is defensive secrecy and self-delusion).

My feeling is that her mental, emotional and physical ill health are all bound up together... so it's just not possible for you to support her physical health while keeping her (probable) mental disorders at arm's length.

It must be very difficult for you to see her so frail and alone in the world, however much the situation might be of her own making. But a person can be genuinely vulnerable, while being sly, stubborn and manipulative at the same time, and acting against their own best interests; as with dementia.

Be aware that any deeper involvement with her will get you sucked into a mental, social and healthcare labyrinth. I'm not sure there's a right answer to your dilemma OP, it comes down to what you can live with. Personally I think I'd stay as a friend who offers tea and company, but not her carer in all but name. The NHS and social services will cling to you like drowning people, she'll continue to dig her heels in, and your life won't be your own. @veggie50 's to-do list is a sobering glimpse into the future. Her family will just have to step up. Would be good to have contact details for the ones still in contact.

I like @JustaSongAboutPingPong's suggestion to reduce your visits, and say to your DF, “I don’t want to talk about your family at the moment, let’s talk about something more cheery instead. Did you watch (whatever her favourite show is)”.

Whattodooing · Today 17:48

MixedFeelingsNoFeelings · Today 17:44

I see your dilemma OP. You sound like a really decent friend and person, who's trying to find path between loyalty to someone who was there for you when you needed her, and a clear-eyed assessment of that person's much less likeable traits (which you can only guess at, because one of those traits is defensive secrecy and self-delusion).

My feeling is that her mental, emotional and physical ill health are all bound up together... so it's just not possible for you to support her physical health while keeping her (probable) mental disorders at arm's length.

It must be very difficult for you to see her so frail and alone in the world, however much the situation might be of her own making. But a person can be genuinely vulnerable, while being sly, stubborn and manipulative at the same time, and acting against their own best interests; as with dementia.

Be aware that any deeper involvement with her will get you sucked into a mental, social and healthcare labyrinth. I'm not sure there's a right answer to your dilemma OP, it comes down to what you can live with. Personally I think I'd stay as a friend who offers tea and company, but not her carer in all but name. The NHS and social services will cling to you like drowning people, she'll continue to dig her heels in, and your life won't be your own. @veggie50 's to-do list is a sobering glimpse into the future. Her family will just have to step up. Would be good to have contact details for the ones still in contact.

I like @JustaSongAboutPingPong's suggestion to reduce your visits, and say to your DF, “I don’t want to talk about your family at the moment, let’s talk about something more cheery instead. Did you watch (whatever her favourite show is)”.

I agree I think her mental and physical are tightly entwined and I think being so poorly and so isolated is making her behave worse. But she is doing this to herself.

I’ve tried to get her to sign up to local befriending networks but she takes offence to this.

My own daughter is actually pregnant so in the coming months I won’t be as available so I will gently try to bring this up again to her, alongside any other charities that may be able to offer substantial support. I think my own daughter being pregnant has also opened my eyes a little to the situation. Luckily her mother in law has been amazing but I can imagine the stress it would be bringing if she was being hounded to the extent my friend is harassing her son and his wife.

OP posts: