Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend with two estranged children

206 replies

Whattodooing · Today 10:42

I have a friend who I have known for many years. She has a bit of a tendency to be a bit dramatic but other than that she is a nice person. Her health is very bad.

Without going into too much detail she has 4 children and is estranged from two. She has been estranged from her daughter for many years. She became estranged from her son about a year ago. The two had nothing to do with each other. Completely separate situations. She blames his wife for the estrangement. Her son has recently announced he’s having a baby and she’s very upset.

I’ve tried hard not to comment too much on the situation or get too involved but I feel like it’s what most of our convos revolve around now. On one hand she is in and out of hospital and I feel awful for her because she doesn’t have anyone. She still has other children who aren’t no contact but they don’t live near and offer her no support. On the other hand I think if she has two children who have cut her off there must be a reason and she needs to look deeper than blaming everyone else.

I really want to support my friend and her son announcing a pregnancy has made her so focused on this that I don’t know how to help her through it or what to say. She has no support health wise and has been essentially left to rot.

OP posts:
AnswerIsNo · Today 12:16

Additup · Today 12:12

That's a big helping of word salad to tell @nearlylovemyusername you disagree with her.

@nearlylovemyusername I agree with you. Some children just grow up to be awful for whatever reason so I wouldn't automatically blame the parent for estrangement either. Also the issue with her son is more to do with the DIL and OP said her friend gets on well with her other 2 children but they live far away.

word salad??? 😄

I'm sorry you're unable to digest a healthy mix of metaphor and wide-angle lens discussion on nature-nature, dysfunctional upbringings, life trajectories, adverse health impacts and choices made from self-empowerment

maybe get a better intellectual diet?

marbIes · Today 12:16

Whattodooing · Today 12:15

Because I’ve been supporting her for years. Her behaviour around the estrangement is impacting how much I feel I can support her and is pushing me away. I don’t want to take a step back because she is being failed. But I don’t know how to handle her behaviour.

So she is exhibiting difficult behaviours?

Then surely you can maybe appreciate why her children backed off then so tis not quite fair to say she's been "left to rot"

TorroFerney · Today 12:18

AnnaBelIa · Today 11:31

You can be a supportive friend without becoming an unpaid therapist, social worker and family mediator.

100% this - why do you have to take on all her problems op and solve them all for her? What happened to you to make you think that's your role?

Whattodooing · Today 12:19

bigboykitty · Today 12:03

OP your idea of getting your friend into therapy is a complete fantasy. She has zero insight and there is no chance she wants to develop any. She just thinks that if she falls over enough then her children should help her. It's interesting that you say she is completely penniless. That obviously isn't true if she gets benefits including PIP. Is this what she tells you? It seems to me that she presents herself as utterly helpless and with zero support. I can hear that you are trying to hold some boundaries, but the other side of that coin is that she is trying to shift 100% responsibility on literally anyone else who will listen. People who literally won't do anything to help themselves are very hard to help and usually manage to alienate everyone. The PIP money is literally to buy aids or support to enable her to live with her health issues. What does she do with this money? I think you're going to have to give her some tough love if you really want to help her. Ask her what she's willing to do to start to help herself. It sounds like her whole approach to life is about manipulating others and doggedly refusing to take any responsibility for herself or her choices.

I obviously don’t know her entire in and outgoings but I know she says she has no money. The majority of her money seems to go on topping her gas and electric up all the time because she has the heating on 24/7. She’s always cold because she weighs so little and taxis as transport as she cannot use the bus as this would require walking to the stop and being stable enough on her feet to get on and off.

She just thinks that if she falls over enough then her children should help her

this has stuck out to me.

Her daughter was estranged before she got sick and her son after and he gave her a lot of support before the estrangement. It seems that she thinks they should get over whatever has happened in their relationship because she’s sick though. When she contacts them it seems to be about her health and how poorly she is. People are right that she won’t take any accountability and I genuinely don’t know if she sees it at all. I hope she isn’t declining help hoping one of her children will come and save her though.

OP posts:
bigboykitty · Today 12:20

It's a misuse of NHS resources for her to intentionally put herself at risk of falls, refuse to spend her PIP to protect herself and increase her own safety, then to spend a week in hospital for dehydration after she chose to allow that to happen.

Bigpuffycushions · Today 12:20

Netcurtainnelly · Today 11:26

Typical judgemental post where you know nothing.
This is definitely a post that comes under the tell me you know nothing about estrangement without telling me you know nothing about estrangement.

There all sorts of reasons for estrangement that's nothing to do with the parent.
The child might meet a partner who dosent like the parents and the son/daughter support their partner and estrange from parents. Parents then can miss out on grandchildren.

Some adult children estrange through parental alienation or mental health.Not all adopted children stay in touch with their adoptive parents when they reach adulthood either.
Be educated instead of being judgemental and assuming.

There might be parents that have little contact with adult children in the circumstances you list, but they are rare and in most cases some contact is maintained, even if it's very limited.

It might be uncomfortable for estranged parents to admit, but there is usually only one reason why adults make the voluntary decision to completely estrange from parents. It's because the parent is toxic.

Adults do not completely cut off from parents without a good reason. In fact, adults will put up with a lot of abuse, and selfish and toxic behaviour from their parents before they make the very difficult decision to completely cut them off. Some adult children never do, hoping in vain that the parent can change, or convincing themselves that parents love them despite the abuse.

The adult children of toxic parents will often make the decision to break the cycle of family dysfunction when they start their own families, because the toxic grandmother can be an even more terrible monster than the toxic mother.

It's common for estranged parents to pretend they don't know why they've been cut off by their children. Probably because it's easier to plead innocent ignorance than to admit they are shit parents.

ClarasSisters · Today 12:21

Whattodooing · Today 11:34

She had one but she said she needed to pay for it as it was a subscription and she couldn’t afford it so gave it back?

That's what her PIP is for though, the extra costs of disability. If she's choosing to spend her money elsewhere it's kind of on her that she doesn't get help when she falls. As a minimum she needs a lanyard for her phone so it's on her at all times if she won't pay for the falls alarm.

I'd be wary of social services expecting you to step in too.

bigboykitty · Today 12:22

Whattodooing · Today 12:19

I obviously don’t know her entire in and outgoings but I know she says she has no money. The majority of her money seems to go on topping her gas and electric up all the time because she has the heating on 24/7. She’s always cold because she weighs so little and taxis as transport as she cannot use the bus as this would require walking to the stop and being stable enough on her feet to get on and off.

She just thinks that if she falls over enough then her children should help her

this has stuck out to me.

Her daughter was estranged before she got sick and her son after and he gave her a lot of support before the estrangement. It seems that she thinks they should get over whatever has happened in their relationship because she’s sick though. When she contacts them it seems to be about her health and how poorly she is. People are right that she won’t take any accountability and I genuinely don’t know if she sees it at all. I hope she isn’t declining help hoping one of her children will come and save her though.

I'm really glad you started this thread. It's very easy to get drawn into a narrative like this, even when you're trying hard not to.

ClarasSisters · Today 12:22

Bigpuffycushions · Today 12:20

There might be parents that have little contact with adult children in the circumstances you list, but they are rare and in most cases some contact is maintained, even if it's very limited.

It might be uncomfortable for estranged parents to admit, but there is usually only one reason why adults make the voluntary decision to completely estrange from parents. It's because the parent is toxic.

Adults do not completely cut off from parents without a good reason. In fact, adults will put up with a lot of abuse, and selfish and toxic behaviour from their parents before they make the very difficult decision to completely cut them off. Some adult children never do, hoping in vain that the parent can change, or convincing themselves that parents love them despite the abuse.

The adult children of toxic parents will often make the decision to break the cycle of family dysfunction when they start their own families, because the toxic grandmother can be an even more terrible monster than the toxic mother.

It's common for estranged parents to pretend they don't know why they've been cut off by their children. Probably because it's easier to plead innocent ignorance than to admit they are shit parents.

"It's common for estranged parents to pretend they don't know why they've been cut off by their children. Probably because it's easier to plead innocent ignorance than to admit they are shit parents."

This, absolutely.

Additup · Today 12:23

marbIes · Today 12:14

Did you miss this part:

She’s hounded her poor son and his wife since they announced the pregnancy and they haven’t replied.

She doesnt sound like some innocent victim here at all. Not even slightly.

I didn't say she was an innocent victim, but there are always 2 sides to every story. IMO automatically blaming the parent for estrangement is wrong because the reasons are often much more complex.

Additup · Today 12:25

ClarasSisters · Today 12:22

"It's common for estranged parents to pretend they don't know why they've been cut off by their children. Probably because it's easier to plead innocent ignorance than to admit they are shit parents."

This, absolutely.

How about when everyone else in the family (parents and children) is close and gets on really well, but one child is estranged ?
I've seen this happen.

marbIes · Today 12:26

Additup · Today 12:23

I didn't say she was an innocent victim, but there are always 2 sides to every story. IMO automatically blaming the parent for estrangement is wrong because the reasons are often much more complex.

The more detail the OP goes into, the more glaringly obvious it is that in this particular case, the issue is with her.

She hasn't been left to rot- she had a lifeline and deliberately sent it back as one example- thats someone deliberately self sabotaging for attention and pity and its controlling AF

TorroFerney · Today 12:27

AnswerIsNo · Today 12:16

word salad??? 😄

I'm sorry you're unable to digest a healthy mix of metaphor and wide-angle lens discussion on nature-nature, dysfunctional upbringings, life trajectories, adverse health impacts and choices made from self-empowerment

maybe get a better intellectual diet?

Indeed. The idea that there are swathes of adult children who have cut off their parents without a second thought is just rubbish and shows a complete lack of understanding about how children are absolutely hard wired to believe that if a parent treats them terribly it's their (the child's) fault.

Op what I would say is that having a friendship based on feeling sorry for someone is speaking to something missing in you. And I say that as someone whose relationship with my mother has been since I was about four, based on feeling sorry for her and being told how hard she had it and how she'd kill herself if it wasn't for me - so I speak with the gloomy voice of experience.

Octavia64 · Today 12:27

Whattodooing · Today 12:19

I obviously don’t know her entire in and outgoings but I know she says she has no money. The majority of her money seems to go on topping her gas and electric up all the time because she has the heating on 24/7. She’s always cold because she weighs so little and taxis as transport as she cannot use the bus as this would require walking to the stop and being stable enough on her feet to get on and off.

She just thinks that if she falls over enough then her children should help her

this has stuck out to me.

Her daughter was estranged before she got sick and her son after and he gave her a lot of support before the estrangement. It seems that she thinks they should get over whatever has happened in their relationship because she’s sick though. When she contacts them it seems to be about her health and how poorly she is. People are right that she won’t take any accountability and I genuinely don’t know if she sees it at all. I hope she isn’t declining help hoping one of her children will come and save her though.

Heating the house isn’t an effective way of keeping a person warm whether able bodied or disabled.

you can get electric heat pads (like electric blankets but can be used on sofa or similar). Thermal clothing and good thick socks help. I wear snow boots out and about in the winter.

blankets and oodies also good. Most charity shops have blankets. Duvets on the sofa also good.

people who can’t walk far usually use either wheelchairs or rollators. If she gets pip she can swop it for leasing a wheelchair which means she can get about. If the wheelchair breaks they’ll give you a loan one while they fix it.

there are charities that will help people get wheelchairs if she genuinely cannot afford to give up the pip for a wheelchair. Second hand rollators are about thirty quid on eBay/facebook.

PetulaGordeno · Today 12:27

Firstly OP you are a really lovely friend..
I am a few years older than your friend, no family now, no DC, and with health issues.
It can be a bloody nightmare so I understand your ‘left to rot’ comment.
However, I have also come to understand that I have to advocate for myself.
In a dark place, a good friend who is in a far worse physical state said to me…. nobody is coming to save you, Petula.
She has been re-housed in a bungalow which is a bit like a lottery win.
You have no idea what she’s saying in her assessments. No idea at all. You may read reports but they miss the nuance.
If you are lucky enough to access therapy, you take it.
If you need a falls alarm, you use your PIP to pay for it.
It sounds in many ways that she is letting herself rot by ruminating and putting issues with her DC onto others.
All of her DC know she is ill but none of them want to help. They may be traumatised by her. They may be entitled little shits who can’t be bothered.
But hounding the son is just making things worse and then you go round and she offloads onto you.
You have three choices:

  1. you keep visiting and coming away stressed and upset
  2. you tell it to her straight. Now I did not appreciate it when I got told, but it snapped me out of self pity.,
  3. you lose the friendship. I would go with 2 and if she kicks back, let her. I have some very good friends, I’m really lucky and now and again if I’m struggling I will discuss it but I want to spend my time with them feeling uplifted. And finally, local churches can be fantastic in supporting people like your friend.
marbIes · Today 12:28

Additup · Today 12:25

How about when everyone else in the family (parents and children) is close and gets on really well, but one child is estranged ?
I've seen this happen.

You've never heard of scapegoating?

its actually quite common that one child is subjected to abuse and scapegoated: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16402877/

https://richard-lewis.co.uk/scapegoating/

Tiptoethroughthehallway · Today 12:28

Your friend sounds like my mum. She tells people how cruel we are without taking any responsibility herself.
My mum is also very unwell and is now realising how lonely she is.

ClarasSisters · Today 12:31

Additup · Today 12:25

How about when everyone else in the family (parents and children) is close and gets on really well, but one child is estranged ?
I've seen this happen.

Well I guess in some cases there's trauma bonding and also that other siblings may not have been so poorly treated and/or aren't brave enough to stick up for themselves. Off the top of my head.

Applewisp · Today 12:32

So many people replying here are completely without any sympathy or compassion. I had to go no contact with my mother, but it wasn’t easy on me and I knew it wasn’t easy on her. She also wasn’t left alone with no support. It absolutely is children’s responsibility to be their for parents, it’s always family responsibility to be there for family. I don’t have an answer for this situation, but it’s indicative of how warped society has become that people completely lack compassion. People are very self absorbed nowadays.

bigboykitty · Today 12:32

Octavia64 · Today 12:27

Heating the house isn’t an effective way of keeping a person warm whether able bodied or disabled.

you can get electric heat pads (like electric blankets but can be used on sofa or similar). Thermal clothing and good thick socks help. I wear snow boots out and about in the winter.

blankets and oodies also good. Most charity shops have blankets. Duvets on the sofa also good.

people who can’t walk far usually use either wheelchairs or rollators. If she gets pip she can swop it for leasing a wheelchair which means she can get about. If the wheelchair breaks they’ll give you a loan one while they fix it.

there are charities that will help people get wheelchairs if she genuinely cannot afford to give up the pip for a wheelchair. Second hand rollators are about thirty quid on eBay/facebook.

Having the heating on 24/7 also isn't an alternative to eating food. She's doing nothing to help herself at all.

Additup · Today 12:33

marbIes · Today 12:28

You've never heard of scapegoating?

its actually quite common that one child is subjected to abuse and scapegoated: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16402877/

https://richard-lewis.co.uk/scapegoating/

Edited

No, I'm not talking about scapegoating. I'm talking about 1 childs behaviour being so bad it makes the rest of the families (parents and siblings) lives miserable.

There are numerous threads on MN about this sort of thing. Desperate parents trying to protect other children from an abusive nightmare of a sibling.

bigboykitty · Today 12:35

Additup · Today 12:33

No, I'm not talking about scapegoating. I'm talking about 1 childs behaviour being so bad it makes the rest of the families (parents and siblings) lives miserable.

There are numerous threads on MN about this sort of thing. Desperate parents trying to protect other children from an abusive nightmare of a sibling.

Please start your own thread and stop trying to derail this one.

Bigpuffycushions · Today 12:37

Additup · Today 12:25

How about when everyone else in the family (parents and children) is close and gets on really well, but one child is estranged ?
I've seen this happen.

The scapegoat sibling usually goes first.

The toxic parent will then rally the rest of the family round her for as long as she can.

Sometimes it works indefinitely, but usually the scapegoat's siblings slowly move towards estrangement or low contact from the toxic parent.

From the OP, it would appear this is what has happened to OP's friend's family.

marbIes · Today 12:37

Additup · Today 12:33

No, I'm not talking about scapegoating. I'm talking about 1 childs behaviour being so bad it makes the rest of the families (parents and siblings) lives miserable.

There are numerous threads on MN about this sort of thing. Desperate parents trying to protect other children from an abusive nightmare of a sibling.

Thats not the case here though is it?

OP has said two of this woman's children are NC and she's been "hounding them" and is difficult..... you dont have to be a psychologist to work out who the problem is in this scenario

Absobeautely · Today 12:40

ClarasSisters · Today 12:22

"It's common for estranged parents to pretend they don't know why they've been cut off by their children. Probably because it's easier to plead innocent ignorance than to admit they are shit parents."

This, absolutely.

Someone on here posted this article a while ago, it's excellent and says it all about toxic parents like OPs mate.

Hopefully OP can stop getting dragged into the woman's drama charade and impossible 'problems'.

https://issendai.com/psychology/estrangement/missing-missing-reasons/