Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend with two estranged children

206 replies

Whattodooing · Today 10:42

I have a friend who I have known for many years. She has a bit of a tendency to be a bit dramatic but other than that she is a nice person. Her health is very bad.

Without going into too much detail she has 4 children and is estranged from two. She has been estranged from her daughter for many years. She became estranged from her son about a year ago. The two had nothing to do with each other. Completely separate situations. She blames his wife for the estrangement. Her son has recently announced he’s having a baby and she’s very upset.

I’ve tried hard not to comment too much on the situation or get too involved but I feel like it’s what most of our convos revolve around now. On one hand she is in and out of hospital and I feel awful for her because she doesn’t have anyone. She still has other children who aren’t no contact but they don’t live near and offer her no support. On the other hand I think if she has two children who have cut her off there must be a reason and she needs to look deeper than blaming everyone else.

I really want to support my friend and her son announcing a pregnancy has made her so focused on this that I don’t know how to help her through it or what to say. She has no support health wise and has been essentially left to rot.

OP posts:
RVectensian · Today 11:25

She's only late 50-ies but already at the stage of falling not being able to get up?

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · Today 11:26

SkateHaddockCod · Today 10:50

She hasn't been left to rot, she's dealing with the consequences of past actions.

You have no right to judge her children as you really don't know their side of the story.

Using such hyperbole is buying into the victim narrative. Suggest you dial that down or you'll be sucked in to the situation more than you might like.

Agreed...

just read this nonsense youve written...

i feel awful for her because she doesn’t have anyone. She still has other children who aren’t no contact but they don’t live near and offer her no support

She has 2 children who want nothing to do with her and 2 that keep her at arms length.

4 kids and not one can be bothered isnt random.

Netcurtainnelly · Today 11:26

CarlyMarley · Today 11:12

My mum has an acquaintance whose children are NC with her.

my mum talks about how sorry she feels for her.

However I remind my mum that I’m pretty certain if she talked to them I’m sure their story would be very different to their mother’s as to what their relationship was like.

In my opinion it’s a very severe move to go NC with a parent and I don’t imagine many people do it without good reason.

Typical judgemental post where you know nothing.
This is definitely a post that comes under the tell me you know nothing about estrangement without telling me you know nothing about estrangement.

There all sorts of reasons for estrangement that's nothing to do with the parent.
The child might meet a partner who dosent like the parents and the son/daughter support their partner and estrange from parents. Parents then can miss out on grandchildren.

Some adult children estrange through parental alienation or mental health.Not all adopted children stay in touch with their adoptive parents when they reach adulthood either.
Be educated instead of being judgemental and assuming.

mindutopia · Today 11:28

I can guarantee you that the two estrangements absolutely did have to do with the same pattern of behaviour.

My mum and stepdad are estranged from all their children and grandchildren, 3 adult children and 5 grandchildren.

There is absolutely a reason and it’s the same reason (abuse and all of us safeguarding our children), but it’s definitely not the reason they tell people. I know because friends of theirs have gotten in touch with me to tell me how silly I have been for cutting my mum off for this ridiculous reason. I’ve even seen the emails she sent to them with this whole elaborate story about why I want no relationship with her. It bares no resemblance to the real reason we are no contact. 80% of her friends who learned the real reason have now cut her off too.

Tread very carefully here. You are almost certainly not being told the truth. You can choose how much of it you want to believe. But absolutely do not get drawn into trying to be a flying monkey for her. If her children wanted her involved with their families, they’d have her involved. They don’t, so you need to respect their rights to protect themselves.

Whattodooing · Today 11:28

Arthurnewyorkcity · Today 11:23

As someone estranged, the insane amount of trauma i went through before ever cutting contact. Its not a light move. Secondly, if she qualifies for social care support as outlined in the care act, she must have declined it. You have a tonne of third party information and very little factual

I’m not denying that her children haven’t been through trauma, hence why it’s been so difficult to navigate this friendship. I am attempting to separate the two things and support my friend.

Secondly, if she qualifies for social care support as outlined in the care act, she must have declined it

However this is categorically untrue. I’ve read the report. I also had to jump through hoops to get my own mother social care support because the support just isn’t there, social services do and say anything to not give the support, everyone knows this. They think it’s adequate that she has neighbours she’s friendly with and children who exist.

I actually thought about being present when she got assessed but I knew it would go against her as they’d try to say I could offer way more support than I can. I currently visit her twice a week and that’s all I am willing to do because I have my own children to look after.

OP posts:
AnnaBelIa · Today 11:31

You can be a supportive friend without becoming an unpaid therapist, social worker and family mediator.

CeeCeeDeeBee · Today 11:31

This could be about my MIL. She blames me too. But actually, we and her daughter cut her off because she is evil.

AnswerIsNo · Today 11:32

From the other side:

I had an abusive father from a young age, including physical violence

That upbringing fucked me up for years - which you don't realise for further years, especially when they are capable of switching into a half-decent parent from time to time and you obviously can't live a dual reality in a normal home..

Had to do the very long, hard yards in therapy - went full no contact in 2013 and with no hyperbole, 2013 was 10 years later than I ought.

He then delved as far as he could into the bottom of a whisky bottle, possibly looking for answers and absolvement.... or just the deepening of a more chronic and low-level version of addiction, where the markers of alcoholism were long evident....

Instead, found himself with ABRD and ended up in a dementia care home, with few visitors.

By all accounts, he could barely remember his life at that point, just moments of lucidity, then bang, gone. He went into hospital to rapidly fade into death from multiple systemic complications hitting his biological system all at once.

Before he died, I summoned the courage to visit the guy who'd regularly terrorised me when young - he was just an empty shell of a frail man in his mid-70s, in his final death throes, unable to speak and on oxygen.

He certainly had 'old friends' and even siblings who saw the expert scaffolding of a well-manicured image, but not the reality of person who abused their offspring from a position of choice and power

end of reality check

Absobeautely · Today 11:32

You're trying to solve problems that aren't yours.
The 'nice' woman is perfectly capable of fixing her problems, but enjoys playing the victim.
As PPs have said, even slightly shit parents adult children don't estrange themselves, it takes a lifetime of hell and trauma and repeat attempts to have a relationship for an adult child to prefer to have no mother at all.

My abuser is 'lovely'. Dainty, would 'do anything for anyone', but subjected her kids to trauma spanning decades, and has no one in her life.

Beware of 'lovely' poor little victims, heed the warning when literally no one on earth including their kids can stand to be around them. There's good reason for it.

Ohsleepdearsheep · Today 11:33

Why are you trying to figure out and solve her problems? You don’t have responsibility for them and anyway you can’t.

More to the point why isn’t she trying to figure out and solve her problems? She has responsibility for them and she can solve them.

This is all a boundary issue, yours and hers.

Whattodooing · Today 11:33

RVectensian · Today 11:25

She's only late 50-ies but already at the stage of falling not being able to get up?

Yes unfortunately and she will only continue to get worse and not better. I don’t believe she will still be here in the next 5-10 years. She ended up in critical condition in ICU 18 months ago.

I think this is a huge part of the issue. She needs therapy to deal with the estrangements but therapy to deal with her health deteriorating while so young and so fast. She also seems to think that her children should forget about being estranged because she is poorly and I don’t agree with that but I think she struggles to move past that.

OP posts:
Uricon2 · Today 11:33

She needs a falls alarm. Many come with a service that means someone will come out and get you up if required. Called different things in different areas but adult social services can advise. Has she had a needs assessment from them?

Whattodooing · Today 11:34

Uricon2 · Today 11:33

She needs a falls alarm. Many come with a service that means someone will come out and get you up if required. Called different things in different areas but adult social services can advise. Has she had a needs assessment from them?

She had one but she said she needed to pay for it as it was a subscription and she couldn’t afford it so gave it back?

OP posts:
SamphiretheTervosaur · Today 11:37

Take step back. Most people think my dad is a funny, generous, kind and caring man. Great help in resolving other people's issues, never asking for anything in return

But DSis and I are well estranged. Me because of our childhood, mostly never knowing when something I owned, had been given as a gift or saved for and bought myself, would be given to someone who would.be grateful - and the rage he showed when he realised I had a few hundreds saved.in a post office account he couldn't get his hands on when i was 16, the email claiming desperation, needing £20k or would lose everything, would kill himself, the week before we bought a house

Sister for the 10s of thousands he took from 2 house sales and the casual appropriation of yet more when a savings account they shared, to keep from HMRC, matured and he took the lot

Nobody has ever asked us why. They prefer to believe the stories he tells

Your friend will quite likely be as miserable a parent as my father has been

Whattodooing · Today 11:40

Ohsleepdearsheep · Today 11:33

Why are you trying to figure out and solve her problems? You don’t have responsibility for them and anyway you can’t.

More to the point why isn’t she trying to figure out and solve her problems? She has responsibility for them and she can solve them.

This is all a boundary issue, yours and hers.

I’m not trying to solve her problems. I’m asking for advice on how to help navigate my relationship with her and the support I want to give her with her health whilst the estrangement is beginning to take over her life. I don’t want to enable that behaviour she’s exhibiting either and I really don’t want to take a step back from her.

I don’t believe she’s an innocent party in the estrangement at all. But I also won’t leave her alone with no support especially from services. She took me in for months when I fled domestic violence and helped me get back on my feet and I won’t forget that. Regardless of what she was like as a mother.

OP posts:
whippersnapper55 · Today 11:40

Beyond sympathising with her situation, you can't help your friend with this. You can be honest if you think she is doing more harm than good by contacting her son repeatedly and warn her that she may end up being sanctioned for harassment if she continues. She is a grown woman and she will make her own choices. Don't get more involved, this is not your circus & not your monkeys.

alittlepieceofme · Today 11:42

It sounds like there are things that she can access but she doesn’t want to, you mentioned that she is reluctant to access the counselling and she gave back the falls alarm. You can help someone that doesn’t want to help themselves!

Littlejellyuk · Today 11:42

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · Today 11:26

Agreed...

just read this nonsense youve written...

i feel awful for her because she doesn’t have anyone. She still has other children who aren’t no contact but they don’t live near and offer her no support

She has 2 children who want nothing to do with her and 2 that keep her at arms length.

4 kids and not one can be bothered isnt random.

Edited

This 👆 💯 your 'friend' is the common denominator in all of this. To be estranged by 2 kids and 2 others that CBA is not a random occurrence.I feel awful for her because she doesn’t have anyone. She still has other children who aren’t no contact but they don’t live near and offer her no support. She has 2 children who want nothing to do with her and 2 that keep her at arms length. 4 kids and not one can be bothered isnt random.

Laurmolonlabe · Today 11:43

It's lovely you want to be supportive, but when someone is estranged from their children it is best not to get involved- there will be reasons and dynamics you are not seeing and you could easily damage your friendship , without realising what you have done.
My brother is estranged from his children- but there is nothing useful I can do.

nearlylovemyusername · Today 11:43

I wonder why it's always assumed that estranged children mean parents at fault.

Sometimes it's as simple as children being shits.

I remember a poster here asking how much to charge and which chores to give to her very elderly father who came to live with her. And hundreds of posters commented how much and which tasks and how she should maintain her boundaries.Her dad died a few days after moving in. She didn't have heart to feel that he came to die with her, not at home alone.

People are born with own personalities, some are great, some are shit. Upbringing can only do so much, as proven by extremely different outcomes of siblings, even twins. And yes, some parents really are awful, but equally many children need to look in the mirror.

FeelingD0wn · Today 11:44

Was she poorly when her children were young?
Were they having to care for her then?
Why does she think her children have cut her off?

GrumblingGeek · Today 11:44

she sounds like hard work.

so she doesn't believe shes done anything wrong so doesnt need counselling? well that’s the first red flag. most people estranged from family would do anything to get back in their good books. she won’t. what does that tell you. four kids are wrong? no. shes done somwthing wrong. no wonder they walked.

as for social work presuming her kids will help her, she needs to tell them she is estranged from her family and none live in the county so she has no help. it sounds like she needs carers or a falls alarm or both. if she makes it clear for example about the fall and dehydration they should take her seriously. she may have told ss that “my kids will just have to help me im sick” thinking it was true and subsequently found this was not the case.

we dont know what condition she has but there are charities so id contact the relevant ones if i were her and ask for help or support.

the more you get involved the more reliant she will be on you.

if it’s you and not your friend that this post is about, i think youve got a bit of thinking to do. get counselling to help process stuff.

Ohsleepdearsheep · Today 11:44

Whattodooing · Today 11:40

I’m not trying to solve her problems. I’m asking for advice on how to help navigate my relationship with her and the support I want to give her with her health whilst the estrangement is beginning to take over her life. I don’t want to enable that behaviour she’s exhibiting either and I really don’t want to take a step back from her.

I don’t believe she’s an innocent party in the estrangement at all. But I also won’t leave her alone with no support especially from services. She took me in for months when I fled domestic violence and helped me get back on my feet and I won’t forget that. Regardless of what she was like as a mother.

@Whattodooing honestly and I mean this supportively what is drawing you into this situation? Again I really think you are very lacking in friendship boundaries yourself but your focus is on the other person persistently.

There is a reason you are attracted to this chaos when nobody else is.

Your focus should be on yourself and what and why you are doing things, not on your friend.

GrandmasCat · Today 11:45

It takes a lot to go no contact with a parent. Having all children being low contact or no contact… I can assure you she is the problem. Abusers are normally charming, that’s how they get away with murder but they are completely different behind open doors with people close to them.

Don’t let her take advantage of your good nature, trust doctors know what they are doing most of the times. She may not be as bad as she says she is and there is nothing you can do about her children.

GrandmasCat · Today 11:47

ps. I would step back, you are next. She will turn abusive if you don’t allow her to continue manipulating you.