Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend with two estranged children

206 replies

Whattodooing · Today 10:42

I have a friend who I have known for many years. She has a bit of a tendency to be a bit dramatic but other than that she is a nice person. Her health is very bad.

Without going into too much detail she has 4 children and is estranged from two. She has been estranged from her daughter for many years. She became estranged from her son about a year ago. The two had nothing to do with each other. Completely separate situations. She blames his wife for the estrangement. Her son has recently announced he’s having a baby and she’s very upset.

I’ve tried hard not to comment too much on the situation or get too involved but I feel like it’s what most of our convos revolve around now. On one hand she is in and out of hospital and I feel awful for her because she doesn’t have anyone. She still has other children who aren’t no contact but they don’t live near and offer her no support. On the other hand I think if she has two children who have cut her off there must be a reason and she needs to look deeper than blaming everyone else.

I really want to support my friend and her son announcing a pregnancy has made her so focused on this that I don’t know how to help her through it or what to say. She has no support health wise and has been essentially left to rot.

OP posts:
AnswerIsNo · Today 12:42

Additup · Today 12:33

No, I'm not talking about scapegoating. I'm talking about 1 childs behaviour being so bad it makes the rest of the families (parents and siblings) lives miserable.

There are numerous threads on MN about this sort of thing. Desperate parents trying to protect other children from an abusive nightmare of a sibling.

please point out the numerous threads that outweigh the opposite scenario..

and after you've achieved that, please hyperlink the peer-reviewed science that supports your hypothesis

TigerFrogs · Today 12:45

Applewisp · Today 12:32

So many people replying here are completely without any sympathy or compassion. I had to go no contact with my mother, but it wasn’t easy on me and I knew it wasn’t easy on her. She also wasn’t left alone with no support. It absolutely is children’s responsibility to be their for parents, it’s always family responsibility to be there for family. I don’t have an answer for this situation, but it’s indicative of how warped society has become that people completely lack compassion. People are very self absorbed nowadays.

I’d say it’s you that are lacking sympathy and compassion. You have no idea what some people have endured from their parents, and expecting everyone to support their parents just because they’re in poor health is ridiculous. It’s very difficult to support someone without actively speaking to them/seeing them and being involved in their life. Just because someone is ill does not mean their personality has changed and they can still be just as abusive.

Bigpuffycushions · Today 12:47

Additup · Today 12:33

No, I'm not talking about scapegoating. I'm talking about 1 childs behaviour being so bad it makes the rest of the families (parents and siblings) lives miserable.

There are numerous threads on MN about this sort of thing. Desperate parents trying to protect other children from an abusive nightmare of a sibling.

This might happen in a normally functioning family, but it's very unusual and may be the result of mental illness or drug or alcohol abuse by the "difficult" sibling.

What you describe is more likely to be an extreme example of what can happen when a toxic parent makes a scapegoat of one of her children.

The problem is when the scapegoat leaves, the dysfunctional family needs a new scapegoat. Gradually, the toxic parent runs out of scapegoats as her other children estrange or go low contact.

Littlejellyuk · Today 12:50

Whattodooing · Today 12:15

Because I’ve been supporting her for years. Her behaviour around the estrangement is impacting how much I feel I can support her and is pushing me away. I don’t want to take a step back because she is being failed. But I don’t know how to handle her behaviour.

Because I’ve been supporting her for years. Her behaviour around the estrangement is impacting how much I feel I can support her and is pushing me away.

Do you need to be needed OP?
Are you the type of person who has to fix things? Like broken wing syndrome? Do you like to 'rescue' OP? 🤔

This type of friendship will drain you, as you will give and give and she will drain you, but not help herself.
I would be offering limited support and not trying to fix/rescue her.
I would also maintain clear boundaries, or else this relationship will lead to burn out. 😔

This is not your issue to fix.

She has already 'hounded' her son and his wife regarding a GC, and it sounds like she is very lax with boundaries and her sons response is to greyrock to re-establish those boundaries. 💯

Your pal needs a few home truths in regards to accepting responsibility for herself and her actions. She needs to lay down her victim card, take responsibility and be proactive in advocating for her own health. 🫤

ETA: In essence she needs a wake up call.
Are you going to be the one to tell her OP?
Or will you carry on and on, on this carousel?
That's your decision to make.
Best of luck in whatever decision you make.
@Whattodooing

nearlylovemyusername · Today 12:54

marbIes · Today 12:14

Did you miss this part:

She’s hounded her poor son and his wife since they announced the pregnancy and they haven’t replied.

She doesnt sound like some innocent victim here at all. Not even slightly.

Why? her crime is wanting to rebuild relationship and to see a grandchild?
Word "hounded" is a bit ambiguous here

marbIes · Today 12:57

nearlylovemyusername · Today 12:54

Why? her crime is wanting to rebuild relationship and to see a grandchild?
Word "hounded" is a bit ambiguous here

The word hounded is not remotely “ambiguous”. You know exactly what it means and it’s nothing good.

The OP would have said contacted if it had a different meaning.

nearlylovemyusername · Today 13:01

GrandmasCat · Today 11:45

It takes a lot to go no contact with a parent. Having all children being low contact or no contact… I can assure you she is the problem. Abusers are normally charming, that’s how they get away with murder but they are completely different behind open doors with people close to them.

Don’t let her take advantage of your good nature, trust doctors know what they are doing most of the times. She may not be as bad as she says she is and there is nothing you can do about her children.

It takes a lot to go no contact with a parent.

It really doesn't in many cases. Have you been on MN long enough?
Another post struck with me - poster visited parents of her boyfriend for the first time, felt they were very kind and friendly to her. Then by accident she overheard them saying that they are surprised about their son choice as he seemed to like slim girls, OP was overweight. So she went no contact and manipulated her bf to do the same. Poor parents weren't even given an explanation why. Half of posters supported her.

I would support my neighbor in their time of need, I can't comprehend going NC with poorly parent, unless they killed my DC.

TFImBackIn · Today 13:03

Nobody would have any money if they kept the heating on 24/7! Why doesn't she get an electric throw and use that rather than having the heating on so much?

bigboykitty · Today 13:08

nearlylovemyusername · Today 12:54

Why? her crime is wanting to rebuild relationship and to see a grandchild?
Word "hounded" is a bit ambiguous here

If they've told her to leave them alone, then it literally is a crime. There's nothing ambiguous about "hounded".

FirmSnake · Today 13:08

Applewisp · Today 12:32

So many people replying here are completely without any sympathy or compassion. I had to go no contact with my mother, but it wasn’t easy on me and I knew it wasn’t easy on her. She also wasn’t left alone with no support. It absolutely is children’s responsibility to be their for parents, it’s always family responsibility to be there for family. I don’t have an answer for this situation, but it’s indicative of how warped society has become that people completely lack compassion. People are very self absorbed nowadays.

You are no contact with your mother? But it self absorbed for other peope to do the same, and they must be responsible for their parents? How do you reason that out?

RogueFemale · Today 13:09

@Whattodooing Buy her a set of thermal underwear - leggings and long-sleeved top. Thermals are very effective at keeping you warm. If the friend refuses to wear them, then you have a clear indication that she is unwilling to help herself.

bigboykitty · Today 13:10

RogueFemale · Today 13:09

@Whattodooing Buy her a set of thermal underwear - leggings and long-sleeved top. Thermals are very effective at keeping you warm. If the friend refuses to wear them, then you have a clear indication that she is unwilling to help herself.

Don't buy her anything! She has money.

SterlingsGold · Today 13:10

My FIL is estranged from both my DH and DBIL, both completely separate incidents and reasons. I would imagine, like in FIL’s case, the fact that two children don’t want anything to do with her should tell you about her as a person/parent.

FergusFrogLovesParsnips · Today 13:10

Myself and my sibling are both no contact with our mother. We both have been for 10+ years

Our mother is very much like the friend you describe. A sweet, kind person who is usually engaging but very vulnerable and quite naive about the world. She has an undiagnosed learning difficulty.

If you asked her what happened with us and why we are no contact then she'd likely tell you it was all her ex-husband (our father's) fault. Actually the truth is far more complicated than that. But the long and short of it was that she (having no boundaries or much common sense) started a new relationship with a man she met through a pen-pal style column. Her decisions and choices after that lead to the complete breakdown of our family. She lost everything (including us, 3 future grandchildren that she's never met, her money, parents and home) because of him.

If she'd had the right support, diagnosis and help earlier than perhaps she wouldn't have fallen victim to that man. Maybe she would have had the strength to leave him. As it is she now lives alone with limited support from SS, is in poor health and has no family to fall back on

Maritimemadness · Today 13:11

Is she an alcoholic by any chance?

Franjipanl8r · Today 13:13

I think you need to decide whether you’re her friend or her carer. It sounds like you’re trying to be both. You can’t be responsible for her physical and emotional wellbeing, that’s too much to ask of you.

Whattodooing · Today 13:15

Maritimemadness · Today 13:11

Is she an alcoholic by any chance?

No she isn’t

OP posts:
pizzaHeart · Today 13:15

i think the best way is to separate the issues and to give her advice about referral to services, maybe suggest who can help her to fill in forms etc.
The issue with children is a very different one. You don’t know their side of the story. You don’t know all details. You are not an expert in these issues so no, you can’t help.
I can’t understand what exactly the problem for you? If she is excessively talking about problems with children while with you I think you need to tell her that you can’t comment on this and change the subject. If you think that children can help her with her problems suggest her to contact those she is in contact with and never mention the other two.

Whattodooing · Today 13:17

TFImBackIn · Today 13:03

Nobody would have any money if they kept the heating on 24/7! Why doesn't she get an electric throw and use that rather than having the heating on so much?

I’ve actually purchased her one as a gift for Christmas before along side thermals and throws etc. Her house is always boiling. I cannot sit in there for long because it’s awful, she’d have the heating on in the height of summer. She wears fleece pyjamas, fuzzy socks and a dressing gown all the time in the house. I believe she’s just cold because she’s so underweight. I cannot put into words how frail she looks. She looks 30 years older than she is.

OP posts:
Whattodooing · Today 13:19

nearlylovemyusername · Today 12:54

Why? her crime is wanting to rebuild relationship and to see a grandchild?
Word "hounded" is a bit ambiguous here

I don’t mean to be ambiguous but hounded is the only word I can use to explain her behaviour. From what she’s said she’s contacting them several times a week and then getting incredibly upset when she doesn’t get the response she wants. And I’m very aware I won’t be getting the full story.

Ive told her that her behaviour is counter productive. Hence why I’ve started the thread because I’m struggling to support her with how her behaviour currently is.

OP posts:
Slightyamusedandsilly · Today 13:19

Unfortunately, @Whattodooing we are in the middle of an epidemic of judgement and estrangement of family members. Some of course will be justified. However, you've only got to search Mumsnet to find examples of draconian and self righteous witchhunting of parents of adult children (often with children of their own, and no self awareness of the idea of what they are modelling to their own children), as a result, you will encounter a range of responses here, including some wilful misunderstandings.

I think you have to consider how much support you are prepared to give. You're already being a very good friend to her. But decide ahead of time where your boundaries are. You've said that she lacks self awareness (e.g. hounding her estranged son and DiL) and that may well happen to you with her. If you decide ahead of time, you can almost have some of your responses pre-planned.

With all the best will in the world, you can't make up for her lack of familial / NHS / social care support. So in effect, any help you can give her is better than what she has now.

Lou2026 · Today 13:30

There are multiple sides to this story and you do not know any of them. You know what you perceive or think you see/understand.

If she is in that much of a state she can access a social worker who can help navigate the system and get her carers/residential home etc.

AnswerIsNo · Today 13:31

Applewisp · Today 12:32

So many people replying here are completely without any sympathy or compassion. I had to go no contact with my mother, but it wasn’t easy on me and I knew it wasn’t easy on her. She also wasn’t left alone with no support. It absolutely is children’s responsibility to be their for parents, it’s always family responsibility to be there for family. I don’t have an answer for this situation, but it’s indicative of how warped society has become that people completely lack compassion. People are very self absorbed nowadays.

Yours is definitely a post of 2 parts and follows a very familiar online formula that has become highly pronounced in recent years

i/agree with the premise to gain support - a sales pitch

So many people replying here are completely without any sympathy or compassion. I had to go no contact with my mother, but it wasn’t easy on me and I knew it wasn’t easy on her.

ii/then do a complete 180 degree and state the true agenda

She also wasn’t left alone with no support. It absolutely is children’s responsibility to be their for parents, it’s always family responsibility to be there for family.

No, it really isn't children's responsibility to be there for their parents - that's the attitude dysfunctional parents have towards their young kids.. which the toddlers in adult's bodies continue to demand from their adult children

furthermore, even the best parents don't automatically earn the right to be looked after by their adult children in later years.... because of one simple word

choice

Its not always family responsibility to be there for family, that's unquestioned social propaganda that does not stack when confronted by science and lived experience of probably approaching half a billion or more. People earn the right for others to be there be for them by their reciprocal/non-reciprocal behaviour patterns.

Having said all of that, the first part of your post stands out in stark contrast to what followed

Bollihobs · Today 13:32

Whattodooing · Today 12:15

Because I’ve been supporting her for years. Her behaviour around the estrangement is impacting how much I feel I can support her and is pushing me away. I don’t want to take a step back because she is being failed. But I don’t know how to handle her behaviour.

I think this is an important post - this is basically the crux of your dilemma. And it's been brought more to the fore than ever because of your friend now "hounding" her estranged son since news of the new baby emerged - you're seeing that and thinking "that's not how you should be interacting with them!" and it's focused your attention on her behaviour overall.

You cannot fit a square peg in a round hole - if your friend has the mindset to think that her son owes her contact because of the baby, and that repeatedly demanding this will achieve it then I think you have to accept that's her mental state, and maybe always has been, and you can't "fix" that, you cannot make her a different person.

Look at interactions with your friend when you visit- are they positive to some degree - "Oh lovely to see you Whattodoing how have you been, how's the family?" etc. or is it a catalogue of woe, self pity, victim mind set etc etc.? If the latter I would say realise that your friend is how she is and decide from there how much you want to give going forwards - maybe keep visiting but short timings, keep it to basics rather than long diatribes about what's wrong this week and keep pointing out any available help that she could benefit from. I get she's been kind to you so you don't want to abandon her but you cannot "fix" her, she is as she is.

TherapyName · Today 13:34

What is her medical condition? It would be helpful to know as some conditions have excellent charities offering very good support and advice. If it is a neurological condition or traumatic brain injury, unfortunately these can not only affect balance (making falls a risk) but also affect people's self-awareness, self-regulation and ability to maintain social connections, depending on the level of brain injury they have.