Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend with two estranged children

206 replies

Whattodooing · Today 10:42

I have a friend who I have known for many years. She has a bit of a tendency to be a bit dramatic but other than that she is a nice person. Her health is very bad.

Without going into too much detail she has 4 children and is estranged from two. She has been estranged from her daughter for many years. She became estranged from her son about a year ago. The two had nothing to do with each other. Completely separate situations. She blames his wife for the estrangement. Her son has recently announced he’s having a baby and she’s very upset.

I’ve tried hard not to comment too much on the situation or get too involved but I feel like it’s what most of our convos revolve around now. On one hand she is in and out of hospital and I feel awful for her because she doesn’t have anyone. She still has other children who aren’t no contact but they don’t live near and offer her no support. On the other hand I think if she has two children who have cut her off there must be a reason and she needs to look deeper than blaming everyone else.

I really want to support my friend and her son announcing a pregnancy has made her so focused on this that I don’t know how to help her through it or what to say. She has no support health wise and has been essentially left to rot.

OP posts:
Ilady · Today 14:18

Your friend has had years of poor behaviour towards her now adult children. Her kids did not go NC or LC for no reason. The LC don't want to listen to her complaining about there siblings and her life in general. I think her lack of friends now is due to poor behaviour with other people in the past also.

My feeling is that she told social services she has adult kid's and social services think her adult kids can help out. Meanwhile her adult kids are not going to do this. Her not drinking and ending up dehydrated and in hospital is not going to bring her kids around to care for her.

Her ringing ect her adult kids that are currently expecting a baby needs to stop and you need to tell her this.
You need to tell her to use pip to get extra care or various aids to help her live independently. She needs a lifeline as well. She needs to be willing to listen to health professionals advice about drinking, eating and taking tablets. I would ring her gp and see if an occupational therapist could call out to her home. Tell your friend you will be there when they call. They can advise her on aids that would help her or get rails ect in her home.
She either does this or you step right back.

The reality is that you can't move in and care for her and her adult kids can't or won't put there lives on hold to mind her either. If she wants your help she needs to be willing to help herself now. I would also decide now how much your willing to do or how many phone calls or visits you will have each week. My feeling with her is that the more you help her the more she will expect you to do. Tell her as well that you don't want to hear about her kids either. If you don't do this she will become very mentally draining on you.

I have a friend whose mother seems good to the outside world. Nothing is to much for her golden children.
Meanwhile she has left my friend to deal with several difficult situations on her own. She has told her she just have to put up with these or sort them out. Along with this she has been verbally nasty to my friend for years.
She has never helped my friend out financially.
She has moaned anytime she was asked for the smallest amount of help or to mind her grandkids despite knowing there parents needed help.

At this stage my friend and other sibling have had enough of her and her behaviour. They are spending less time with her and cutting down on the phone calls. One of them got a job about 6 months ago that's going well. My friend has decided to change jobs next year. She wants more money and has gone as far as she can in her current role.
Both siblings have decided that the golden sibling adults can step up to help and sort out care and be a taxi service.

Isittimeformynapyet · Today 14:21

AnswerIsNo · Today 12:16

word salad??? 😄

I'm sorry you're unable to digest a healthy mix of metaphor and wide-angle lens discussion on nature-nature, dysfunctional upbringings, life trajectories, adverse health impacts and choices made from self-empowerment

maybe get a better intellectual diet?

I understood it, but it was a word salad. This isn't the Oxford Union you know 😄

Leafle · Today 14:26

The narrative that the parent is always to blame is rubbish: There are plenty of adult children who are narcisists too.

I worked with someone who 'went no contact' with his parents less than a month after forcing them to gift him £100k for a house deposit. The man worked in a bank, wasn't poor. He couldn't fathom why his parents weren't into being bullied to handing over their money so decided it must be because they had never loved him! They were of course more devastated at losing him than the £100k, but he got a thrill of hurting them. Wicked man.

bigboykitty · Today 14:26

Isittimeformynapyet · Today 14:21

I understood it, but it was a word salad. This isn't the Oxford Union you know 😄

I don't think you know what word salad means...

Onbdy · Today 14:28

Netcurtainnelly · Today 11:57

This as I've already said.
Also if you estranged from your parents because your a shit, you are teaching any kids if yours to do the same to you.

Because in this case it’s 2 estranged children and the other two with very low contact. There’s a common denominator here…
I know someone similar and she’s definitely the problem! She also doesn’t seem remotely bothered which I cannot comprehend. I’d be devastated if my DC were no contact with me. It’s all a bit cold and callous. She is also now starting to poison the mind of her newish husband against his own family, 2 are already blocked and relationships are strained with a few others. All instigated by her due to ridiculous false allegations she has made up.

YouSleepWithMayors · Today 14:34

I’ve got an aunt who is estranged from her adult children, both for separate reasons. She also blames everyone else but it was her own doing. She wanted to be as in charge of them as adults as she was when they were children. They have been estranged for over two decades and now she has fallen out with my mother too.

Isittimeformynapyet · Today 14:35

bigboykitty · Today 14:26

I don't think you know what word salad means...

It means what the user intends.

It can mean a jumble of disjointed, incorrectly used words that make no grammatical sense, but in the case of the pp who used it I took it to mean a lot of very intellectual words that would probably go over the heads of the audience they're directed at, and might have been designed to do just that.

AyeUpChuck · Today 14:35

If mutiple people choose to distance themselves from someone it's usually that person's fault.

MsPrufrockk · Today 14:36

Whattodooing · Today 14:04

I have tried telling her that her behaviour is very counter productive and she isn’t helping the situation. She just ends up getting upset and saying she is confused.

I am finding the situation very draining to be honest and I’m finding my visits beginning to get shorter and shorter and I’m beginning to feel guilty about it.

I know I shouldn’t but I do. She’s still been my friend and she was a good one. I’ve been able to separate the estrangement from our friendship and keep my opinions on that separate but she’s making it incredibly difficult to do so and I’m not sure what to to anymore. Obviously her unreasonable behaviour isn’t towards me; but she’s still telling me and it’s dominating all of our conversations.

Please understand that you don't owe her anything at all. You don't owe her visits at all, let alone twice weekly. You don't even owe her friendship!

I know you feel guilty because she was there for you in the past, but I promise you that doesn't mean you have to be there for her. I know (knew) a woman who went over the top doing things for friends and family, but she is the biggest emotional vampire I've ever met. Everyone also felt so beholden to her because of everything she did for us, but it's not worth your mental health or peace of mind, I promise.

I eventually broke away and wish I'd have done it sooner!

squarecrow · Today 14:36

bigboykitty · Today 14:13

I think you have the patience of a saint. Anyone would struggle. I think it's okay to say 'I'm going to head home now. I don't like hearing you talk like this about other people and I don't think it's helping you at all to dwell on things and blame others. I'll see you on Friday'.

This might be the quickest way to show her she needs to reflect on her behaviour - just showing zero support or sympathy for it but also without dissecting or putting energy into trying to talk to her about it.

Have you read about narcissistic personality types Op? I know you are grateful for her support years ago, but what if she only did that to make herself look or feel good? Would you still feel in debt to her and continue trying to rescue her from herself?

Blueseaurchin · Today 14:38

SkateHaddockCod · Today 10:50

She hasn't been left to rot, she's dealing with the consequences of past actions.

You have no right to judge her children as you really don't know their side of the story.

Using such hyperbole is buying into the victim narrative. Suggest you dial that down or you'll be sucked in to the situation more than you might like.

This.

I would say if someone is estranged from two adult children and seems to have little contact with the other two (who chose to live at a distance from her) to me sounds like there is real back story here.

Her reaction to her DIL pregnancy has been to 'hound' her son when the son had chosen to go no contact and to 'blame' his wife for the estrangement. Which again suggest this woman has no respect for other people boundaries and is hard to deal with.

Frankly OP you might be well intended but it sounds like she is a difficult woman and not a great parent.

She is in her 50s so should be able to advocate for herself with health and social services and make it clear she has no support and needs an assessment of her care needs. You can support her if you decide to but her children do not have any obligation to stay in contact with her or get involved in her care and you should stay out of the family 'drama'.

Dressingupforhalloween · Today 14:39

Whattodooing · Today 10:48

I said she has no support health wise.

I don’t mean her children. I mean she needs professional support in my opinion but social services push her back. I want to help support her with her health and getting her out and about but difficult when I know her relationship with her children isn’t not her fault and it’s taking over everything.

She has a few acquaintances but no real support anywhere and I think people are scared to get involved. Especially because she can be very full on, I think she is lonely too.

Edited

You are eroding your own boundaries here. Centering her and her needs in your life. Tripping over yourself to do what's right for her whilst struggling to maintain your own boundaries because the two things are incompatible. It's ok to center yourself in your own life. If you can't help someone else without damage to yourself, it's ok to choose to save yourself.

Your skewing the past with the present. She may have been a good friend to you in the past but she isn't being one now. She refuses counselling because in her eyes she doesn't need it. Yet she's offloading onto you day in day out! Of course she doesn't need counselling, she's got no interest in changing herself, her mindset or her behaviour and she's got you to vent to endlessly. That isn't being a good friend, that's toxic behaviour.

You feel sorry for her because she's got nobody except you, pretty much. That's her own fault. If she had equal relationships with people then firstly her DC may not have cut her off or moved far away and gone low contact and secondly she may have some friends. She's driven everyone away with her behaviour.

Of course people don't want to get too close to someone who they can see likes to play victim, doesn't accept responsibility for her own actions, dominated relationships and makes them one-sided and has actually started displaying stalking behaviour towards someone who has decided to distance themselves (her DS with the baby). Any healthy minded person is going to back away from that! You have to ask yourself why you haven't.

I think you're experiencing the shock that comes from growing up in a world where you believe there's a safety net for the sick and disabled, then discovering that it doesn't really exist. Social services fobbing her off is normal. If she's not mentally impaired then she can advocate for herself regarding having nobody to help her. Even if she can't advocate for herself, if you don't want to take on the job of doing that, it's ok, you can decide not to help with that.

Being left for hours after a fall is normal. Even where people have an alarm, ambulances take so long now. Many people don't have daily visitors and would take ages to be found. It's shocking that this is the society we live in but it is the reality and you need to accept it or be the change you want to see, visiting her daily to check on her if that makes you feel better.

People don't generally get daily carers until they're wheelchair bound and can't get themselves into or out of it, or if they can't wash and dress or make a sandwich by themselves, or if they're incontinent and can't change their own nappies. They don't provide care to give people quality of life, they provide care to stop them being admitted to hospital. That's how bad things have to be before they'll step in.

If she keeps falling they'll look at mobility aids, adaptations to the property, eventually a wheelchair. They'll provide carers not out of the kindness of their hearts but to put off paying for space in a care home. When the carers keep finding her in the type of state that needs a hospital visit then she'll eventually end up in the position she was in recently, where they can't safely discharge her to go home even with 4x carer visits daily, so a social worker will allocate her a care home place.

Your friend has got a choice. She can either accept whatever help and support you're willing to provide her with, be glad of your friendship and be a good friend to you. Or she can try to turn you into her personal support human and emotional dustbin to offload into and end up driving you away. It's up to her and there's nothing you can really do about it. Except maintain your boundaries and not being sucked into the latter role.

Likeawaterfallflowingtothesea · Today 14:40

I would simply be the friend you have the capacity to be, and then leave the rest of it. You can't solve her health problems or her family problems. Even if you had more capacity.

I agree most people don't cut off loving great parents, but some do and there's no reason to think adult children can't be difficult, dysfunctional or have personality issues too, sometimes it's a combination of both. I've known absolutely lovely adult children, lovely parents who have been great and everything in between; it's not true, it's a last resort for all to go no contact.

It's a bit of a vicious circle: your friend has a lot of health issues and may be in pain, and that doesn't help, and then she's difficult and demanding as a consequence, and people draw away from that. I've seen it happen in my own family.

Decide what you have to offer (e.g. coffee every two weeks, phone call weekly, the odd help with NHS letters) and stop there, don't even comment on her relationship with others except to sympathise, you are not her life fixer.

ApiratesaysYarrr · Today 14:50

Whattodooing · Today 11:06

She doesn’t have a penny. She was living in a council house that was unfit for her to be discharged to from the hospital so the hospital helped her to get a social worker who helped set up a bungalow for her but other than that she’s had very little support. They did a carer assessment on her but they fobbed her off and said oh she’s got children to help her.

It’s quite complicated but I don’t want to get involved with ringing services on her behalf because I had quite strong boundaries and I currently give her all I can.

I will have a Google about self referral for therapy though because I do think it’s the only way forward for her

Edited

I would not be surprised if your friend told social services that her children would help. It's amazing how many people say "oh yes, my wife/daughter/neighbour will do..." without actually asking the person concerned.

It sounds like she has had assessments - even with mitigation, you cannot prevent all falls, and the maximum care is 4 visits per day.

Mookie81 · Today 14:50

HorseandHeron · Today 11:08

Many people who are 'wonderful' to their friends are nighmarish parents - utterly self-absorbed, controlling and unable to see their children, even in adulthood, as anything other than an extension of themselves. If the children have gone no contact, that is likely to be why.

I have a lovely friend whose daughter is no contact. My friend's version make the daughter seem insane. But I can read between the lines. Much as I love her, I would hate to have my friend as a mother. Endless digs about weight to to a daughter with endometriosis and CPOS - both of which cause massive weight increase that no amount of starvation dieting can undo, while my friend is a very beautiful, tiny size 6.

Your friend isn't lovely, she's a piece of shit to her child. How cam you ignore that and be her friend?

Foundress · Today 14:52

KeepTellingYourselfThat · Today 12:05

They are usually either a one-off payment or about £11 pm. That’s what she gets PIP for, to use on things to help her.

Surely being stranded on the floor and in hospital for a week dehydrated would make her re-prioritise what she needs to have and what she could do without.

Maybe she wants to play the victim. Hoping her kids will come back if she can’t cope. Tbh, they are more likely to come back if they see she can cope.

Edited

Yes this. I will make no comment on the estrangement side of things as I think that has been covered very well by other posts.
I had a neighbour like this always asking for help. In and out of hospital. No family there to help.
He eventually got allocated a social worker due to someone getting in touch with Adult Social Care. Neighbour’s house was completely adapted for his needs and carers attended him three times a day. He eventually went into a care home.
This neighbour was always pleading poverty to anyone who would listen. It turned out he was receiving his disability benefits, pension + pension credit and his rent and Council Tax were being paid for. He was definitely comfortably off.
I very much doubt your friend is as poor as she makes out OP although I realise she is not at pension age yet.
Your friend is appropriately housed (bungalows are as rare as hen’s teeth) and in receipt of full benefits. If she won’t actually engage with services there is nothing you can do other than give Adult Social Care a ring and discuss your concerns? It could be that carers or other help has been suggested but your friend has refused? What I am trying to say in a roundabout way OP is that you don't have all the correct facts regarding your friend’s situation.
@Whattodooing take care of yourself and your family you seem like a kind and caring person.

AnswerIsNo · Today 14:53

Isittimeformynapyet · Today 14:35

It means what the user intends.

It can mean a jumble of disjointed, incorrectly used words that make no grammatical sense, but in the case of the pp who used it I took it to mean a lot of very intellectual words that would probably go over the heads of the audience they're directed at, and might have been designed to do just that.

Word salad does not mean distilling a number of complex themes relevant to the discussion of going no contact, including use of metaphor

The phrase has also further been bastardised into a dismissive, low-effort rebuttal for when people are often out-matched and have no further ammunition left than an off-target ad-hominem (look, they're doing "the metaphor thing" "again) 😆

as for "a lot of very intellectual words", I'll take that as a compliment while in playful, warm-up mode with the jump rope / still in 2nd gear

as for "It means what the user intends", no

words and phrases only have value within their contextual etymology or the most appropriately accepted understanding of it that still makes sense in wider settings, when compared to its original derivation

if words simply meant "what the user intends", instead of the wider agreement of shared grammar and language, then incorrectly labelling things as "word salad", is ironically, a component of the original meaning of word salad

Word Salad Days No More

The term "word salad" has a long history in the annals of psychiatry. It has been usurped recently by journalists and pundits.

https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-gravity-of-weight/202411/word-salad-days-no-more

Isittimeformynapyet · Today 15:00

AnswerIsNo · Today 14:53

Word salad does not mean distilling a number of complex themes relevant to the discussion of going no contact, including use of metaphor

The phrase has also further been bastardised into a dismissive, low-effort rebuttal for when people are often out-matched and have no further ammunition left than an off-target ad-hominem (look, they're doing "the metaphor thing" "again) 😆

as for "a lot of very intellectual words", I'll take that as a compliment while in playful, warm-up mode with the jump rope / still in 2nd gear

as for "It means what the user intends", no

words and phrases only have value within their contextual etymology or the most appropriately accepted understanding of it that still makes sense in wider settings, when compared to its original derivation

if words simply meant "what the user intends", instead of the wider agreement of shared grammar and language, then incorrectly labelling things as "word salad", is ironically, a component of the original meaning of word salad

Edited

I'm happy for you to take it as a compliment. As I said, I understood you. But when I read your first post I chuckled and thought "somebody's going to take issue with this", it being Mumsnet and all.

OtherKidsEh · Today 15:10

Whattodooing · Today 12:19

I obviously don’t know her entire in and outgoings but I know she says she has no money. The majority of her money seems to go on topping her gas and electric up all the time because she has the heating on 24/7. She’s always cold because she weighs so little and taxis as transport as she cannot use the bus as this would require walking to the stop and being stable enough on her feet to get on and off.

She just thinks that if she falls over enough then her children should help her

this has stuck out to me.

Her daughter was estranged before she got sick and her son after and he gave her a lot of support before the estrangement. It seems that she thinks they should get over whatever has happened in their relationship because she’s sick though. When she contacts them it seems to be about her health and how poorly she is. People are right that she won’t take any accountability and I genuinely don’t know if she sees it at all. I hope she isn’t declining help hoping one of her children will come and save her though.

An adult son with a child on the way should be protected from stress, not guilted into being more available.

Priorities are wrong.

ScottishEggs · Today 15:14

I echo everyone else- you only know your friend's side of the story, and she has an interest in making herself out to be a victim. There will be reasons for the estrangement. It may not be all on her of course, after all, we are all individuals, and her DCs may just nt get along with her for reasons an outsider might think are trivial, bt it's a big thing to be wholly NC with a parent. I doubt it's been done lightly.

I'm not estranged from my mother, but that is largely because I very deliberately moved across the world from her as soon as i was able and only return home every 12 months or so for a visit. I left my home country 27 years ago. She is a good loyal friend to other people, but she was a fucking nightmare as a mother. Abusive, violent, alcoholic. One version of her was presented to the world, another to me. She's better now that she has been largely and comprehensively medicated, but the damage was profound. I know she sobs on the shoulders of people bemoaning how heart-broken she is I live in the UK so far away from her. But when I am actually home for a visit she does a good line in telling me what a nasty fat bitch I am, ad what a disappointment I am. I let it wash over me mostly, but I do often wonder when her friends say how awful it is I continue to live in the UK and how much she wishes I lived in my home country what they would say if they saw and heard what she says to me

SylvanMoon · Today 15:25

A very difficult situation for you, @Whattodooing and I can appreciate how you feel torn as she was there for you when you needed support. But as others have said, there's really very little you can do to fix her current situation and all you can really be is a sympathetic friend (to whatever extent you're able to even be that while she's moaning about her children). And as others have also said, she needs to be her own advocate for her health. It's not your responsibility to worry about or try to find solutions to her frequent falls or lack of wetroom: it's hers. She has a voice and capability and can be chasing the council or SS or whoever to get the wetroom underway. She can also decide to use the PIP money for the purpose it's intended and buy a subscription for a falls monitor and a walker or whatever else might help her be independent. She can also advocate for help in getting better nutrition into herself, whatever that may entail. If you want to encourage her to do these things, that's your decision. But it really really isn't your responsibility to put any of it in motion. You sound like a kind person but it also sounds as if she's putting too much emotional dumping on you, and so I wouldn't blame you for stepping back a bit. In fact, that might even be good for her, especially if she's not got anyone else who's willing to listen to her woes. I suppose if I were you, I'd possibly risk angering her by saying that I didn't want to hear anything more about her son and the impending baby as there's nothing you can do to help her with that. And I'd also probably try reducing my visits to her after saying that. But I don't know how guilty you would feel about doing something like that. What I would strongly advise you not to do is to agree to be an attorney for her in terms of PoA for her health or finance should she ask you. That will get you really enmeshed in her life in a way that is not necessary.

PetulaGordeno · Today 15:52

SylvanMoon · Today 15:25

A very difficult situation for you, @Whattodooing and I can appreciate how you feel torn as she was there for you when you needed support. But as others have said, there's really very little you can do to fix her current situation and all you can really be is a sympathetic friend (to whatever extent you're able to even be that while she's moaning about her children). And as others have also said, she needs to be her own advocate for her health. It's not your responsibility to worry about or try to find solutions to her frequent falls or lack of wetroom: it's hers. She has a voice and capability and can be chasing the council or SS or whoever to get the wetroom underway. She can also decide to use the PIP money for the purpose it's intended and buy a subscription for a falls monitor and a walker or whatever else might help her be independent. She can also advocate for help in getting better nutrition into herself, whatever that may entail. If you want to encourage her to do these things, that's your decision. But it really really isn't your responsibility to put any of it in motion. You sound like a kind person but it also sounds as if she's putting too much emotional dumping on you, and so I wouldn't blame you for stepping back a bit. In fact, that might even be good for her, especially if she's not got anyone else who's willing to listen to her woes. I suppose if I were you, I'd possibly risk angering her by saying that I didn't want to hear anything more about her son and the impending baby as there's nothing you can do to help her with that. And I'd also probably try reducing my visits to her after saying that. But I don't know how guilty you would feel about doing something like that. What I would strongly advise you not to do is to agree to be an attorney for her in terms of PoA for her health or finance should she ask you. That will get you really enmeshed in her life in a way that is not necessary.

I agree about the PoA.
Sadly, it’s easy to become very inward-looking when you are a sick/frail. Even the nicest of people can become very difficult.
I wonder if this woman ever asks how OP is? Or shows any interest in her life?
Because it sounds like OP feels she owes her support after a good turn was done for her.
I have had to become my own advocate and it’s not easy at times, but there are limited resources.
I think OP knows there are probably good reasons why two of the DC have gone non-contact. However, someone isolated can become so low that they obsess over everything and can never see any part they’ve played.
It is very sad but also very common, ask anyone who works in healthcare or social services.

eatreadsleeprepeat · Today 15:53

Whattodooing · Today 10:55

She has absolutely been left to rot. The way she is being treated by services and by her children are two separate issues. Among many things she often falls over and is left on the floor of her home for hours. She ended up hospitalised for over a week with dehydration because nobody found her recently.

I haven’t included any issues of her health so I’m not sure how you can argue that that the NHS haven’t done this?

My post agrees she isn’t innocent in the estrangement of her children. I’m asking for advice in navigating the two issues separately. I want to support her in her health and as a friend but the estrangement is taking over everything and I don’t want to enable that either.

Has she been offered any help that she has turned down? In particular has she been offered any help wearable alarm to use if she falls? If not she should approach her gp and ask about this. She can request an evaluation of her needs. Is the reason for falls something that can be helped medically? If so has she consulted the gp about it? Has she complied with all medical advice? You are close to her and her situation, what is it that should have been done but hasn’t.
In your position I would concentrate on practicalities getting any aids installed, getting any care help in place, getting things like dosette box for her medication, investigating whether any technology would help.

godmum56 · Today 15:55

Arthurnewyorkcity · Today 11:23

As someone estranged, the insane amount of trauma i went through before ever cutting contact. Its not a light move. Secondly, if she qualifies for social care support as outlined in the care act, she must have declined it. You have a tonne of third party information and very little factual

this. If i had a quid for every person who has ever told me "oh I don't need help, my friends/neighbours/children will do it, I'd be a rich woman.

AnotherAnnie · Today 16:03

@Whattodooing Thank you for being such a good friend to her. As a disabled person, I feel that your rock-solid friendship without judgement is the best help she can have. I'm sorry you're having to watch her care failing without being able to fix it, but simply being her friend is helping.