Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend with two estranged children

206 replies

Whattodooing · Today 10:42

I have a friend who I have known for many years. She has a bit of a tendency to be a bit dramatic but other than that she is a nice person. Her health is very bad.

Without going into too much detail she has 4 children and is estranged from two. She has been estranged from her daughter for many years. She became estranged from her son about a year ago. The two had nothing to do with each other. Completely separate situations. She blames his wife for the estrangement. Her son has recently announced he’s having a baby and she’s very upset.

I’ve tried hard not to comment too much on the situation or get too involved but I feel like it’s what most of our convos revolve around now. On one hand she is in and out of hospital and I feel awful for her because she doesn’t have anyone. She still has other children who aren’t no contact but they don’t live near and offer her no support. On the other hand I think if she has two children who have cut her off there must be a reason and she needs to look deeper than blaming everyone else.

I really want to support my friend and her son announcing a pregnancy has made her so focused on this that I don’t know how to help her through it or what to say. She has no support health wise and has been essentially left to rot.

OP posts:
veggie50 · Today 13:38

If your friend has such serious health issues, your priority should be to help her find suitable accommodation such as assisted housing. If she's over 55, already in council housing, she may be eligible for some type of council funded flat with facilities? I'm afraid I don't have much information on this but hopefully someone on Mumsnet does. As for her children, once she's safely accommodated, she'll likely be less demanding / desperate and her children more inclined to reconnect with her. Good luck!

Bollihobs · Today 13:41

veggie50 · Today 13:38

If your friend has such serious health issues, your priority should be to help her find suitable accommodation such as assisted housing. If she's over 55, already in council housing, she may be eligible for some type of council funded flat with facilities? I'm afraid I don't have much information on this but hopefully someone on Mumsnet does. As for her children, once she's safely accommodated, she'll likely be less demanding / desperate and her children more inclined to reconnect with her. Good luck!

That's a really good point - supported housing with an integrated care line and on site staff may well be a better choice for her than her current, standard, bungalow.

And as a PP said, she needs a SW to be navigating these things for her, not you OP.

Takeapause · Today 13:42

As someone with a parent that is lovely to everyone else, and absolutely mad when you get to know her behind the scenes - it sounds like something has happened between her and her children. Also you said she has a tendency to over exaggerate, if she’s always been that way, I can only wonder what she’s been like as a mum. My mum is like that and as an adult we barely have a relationship, we are amicable.

It is a shame that one of her children won’t help her.

veggie50 · Today 13:42

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

AnswerIsNo · Today 13:45

Slightyamusedandsilly · Today 13:19

Unfortunately, @Whattodooing we are in the middle of an epidemic of judgement and estrangement of family members. Some of course will be justified. However, you've only got to search Mumsnet to find examples of draconian and self righteous witchhunting of parents of adult children (often with children of their own, and no self awareness of the idea of what they are modelling to their own children), as a result, you will encounter a range of responses here, including some wilful misunderstandings.

I think you have to consider how much support you are prepared to give. You're already being a very good friend to her. But decide ahead of time where your boundaries are. You've said that she lacks self awareness (e.g. hounding her estranged son and DiL) and that may well happen to you with her. If you decide ahead of time, you can almost have some of your responses pre-planned.

With all the best will in the world, you can't make up for her lack of familial / NHS / social care support. So in effect, any help you can give her is better than what she has now.

Let's see... post includes alarmist hyperbole

"Epidemic of judgement and estrangement of family members, 'some' of course will be justified"

followed by

"search Mumsnet to find examples of draconian and self righteous witchhunting of parents of adult children (often with children of their own, and no self awareness of the idea of what they are modelling to their own children), as a result, you will encounter a range of responses here, including some wilful misunderstandings"

Nice to see someone has decided to become arbiter of which of the 'small' (aka (minority number) of estrangements are justified, while mentioning judgement in the same sentence 😆

I think the text quotes in bold speak for themselves

No further comments, your honour

HortiGal · Today 13:46

I’m thinking your friend exaggerates her situation to you, it takes a lot for you to be rehoused; was her house a mess?
Shes hardly been left to rot, if she’s assessed as not needing carers it is not because she has children to help, that is asked at the assessment.
Hounding her son and DIL is awful behaviour and they will rightly cut her off.

BatchCookBabe · Today 13:46

You sound desperate to back up this woman and not put her in the wrong at all, but quite frankly, 2 adult children going no contact with a parent is not good, and in almost all the families I know who this has happened to, it's the parent at fault. Not all, and there are a few cases of the adult child being a bit of an arsehole, but for the most part it's the clingy, whiny, possessive, argumentative, have-to-be-right-at-all costs middle aged (and older) parents. It's often because the parents don't like their adult child's choice of partner, but is sometimes another reason... It is typically the mothers who fall out with the adult child(ren.) Not the fathers as much...

I have also known a few people who were just lousy parents, didn't care for their children much, had other relatives looking after them half the time, and who were abusive towards their children. Yet when you speak to some people, they're think they're nice people. One woman just recently had her 70th birthday, and on Facebook, one of her friends (15 years younger than her) put 'Happy birthday Jan, you're a star, and so many people love you!' Cue a bunch of posts from people (very few who know her properly, and have just met her a few times) saying 'what a legend you are Jan!' and 'what a woman!' and 'you rock girl, love ya loads!' and all manner of similar comments.

Jan has 2 children - a daughter now aged 48, and a son now aged 40, and she's never given a shit about either of them. Her mother raised the daughter from 9 months old, as Jan couldn't be arsed with her, as she got in the way of her social life, and cramped her style being there when she brought men back to her flat, so the girl's nan had her full time from when she was 9 months old. She then went on to be very abusive and aggressive to the child, (whenever she visited her mother) as she saw her as a mistake. She and the father - (who she had been with for one year when she fell pregnant) fell out when she was 8 months pregnant.

Similar story with the boy. Had him with another man who she'd been dating for a few months when she fell pregnant, then 3 of them stayed together in a 2 bed house until the lad was 2 and a half years old, then his father left her and the lad. So she asked her mum to have him for a while too while she 'sorts herself out,' and she never had him back.

The 2 children stayed with their gran. A woman in her mid 50s having to spend some 25 years raising her 2 young grandchildren after spending 25 years raising 2 of her own. 'Jan' was aggressive and abusive and angry all the time around the 2 children when she visited, and just shouted at them for nothing. They were both scared of her.

It makes my skin crawl when I see posts saying she's amazing, and 'a fucking legend.' Hmm I really feel like posting something .... like, the truth about her. But I will probably come out of it looking really bad. A few people do know the truth about her. She's a horrible cow who failed both of her children, and was aggressive and abusive.

tl;dr, I doubt this woman is as perfect as you're making her out to be @Whattodooing her children haven't gone no contact for no reason, and I'll bet my house that it's her fault.

HortiGal · Today 13:48

@Takeapause why is it a shame one of her kids won’t help her? She sounds awful; hounding her son and DIL, they clearly have good reason to distance themselves. Nobody is obliged to support their parents.

AnswerIsNo · Today 13:49

nearlylovemyusername · Today 13:01

It takes a lot to go no contact with a parent.

It really doesn't in many cases. Have you been on MN long enough?
Another post struck with me - poster visited parents of her boyfriend for the first time, felt they were very kind and friendly to her. Then by accident she overheard them saying that they are surprised about their son choice as he seemed to like slim girls, OP was overweight. So she went no contact and manipulated her bf to do the same. Poor parents weren't even given an explanation why. Half of posters supported her.

I would support my neighbor in their time of need, I can't comprehend going NC with poorly parent, unless they killed my DC.

I can't comprehend going NC with poorly parent, unless they killed my DC

That must be one of the most unhinged, all nor nothing takes I've read in a long time

I presume, for your sake, you're trolling,

or have limited capacity to understand others may have lived a different life to your own, while choosing only to go no contact with a parent if they killed your children - meaning everything else before that is acceptable

the low bar Olympic event has struck on this thread too

competitors are required to supply their own shovel

hot2trotter · Today 13:50

Sounds like a bad dose of karma to me.

TherapyName · Today 13:51

I will also add that while people can have very complex and valid reasons for estrangement from a parent, it can also simply be selfishness and an unwillingness to inconvenience themselves. So many families allow one sibling to become the default carer, especially when one sister steps up.

Many therapists are privately concerned about the appropriation of therapy speak online encouraging 18-30s to 'enforce boundaries' and 'protect their peace'. Too often it translates as 'My parents judge me for eating a junk food diet / challenge me to work hard / tell me to stop smoking weed and gaming all night so I'm cutting them off' etc. Being challenged is seen as abuse and confrontational.

Sometimes it really is distance and being part of the 'squeezed middle' generation who are working long hours in an expensive country while trying to care for children. They are at the limits of their capacity and naively think the social supports of past still exist and will pick up the slack.

Either way, look at your own reasons for moving into rescuer mode. It can be simple human kindness but it can also be a habit learned early on and can put us at risk of exploitation. Never set yourself on fire to keep someone else warm.

Whattodooing · Today 13:54

Bollihobs · Today 13:32

I think this is an important post - this is basically the crux of your dilemma. And it's been brought more to the fore than ever because of your friend now "hounding" her estranged son since news of the new baby emerged - you're seeing that and thinking "that's not how you should be interacting with them!" and it's focused your attention on her behaviour overall.

You cannot fit a square peg in a round hole - if your friend has the mindset to think that her son owes her contact because of the baby, and that repeatedly demanding this will achieve it then I think you have to accept that's her mental state, and maybe always has been, and you can't "fix" that, you cannot make her a different person.

Look at interactions with your friend when you visit- are they positive to some degree - "Oh lovely to see you Whattodoing how have you been, how's the family?" etc. or is it a catalogue of woe, self pity, victim mind set etc etc.? If the latter I would say realise that your friend is how she is and decide from there how much you want to give going forwards - maybe keep visiting but short timings, keep it to basics rather than long diatribes about what's wrong this week and keep pointing out any available help that she could benefit from. I get she's been kind to you so you don't want to abandon her but you cannot "fix" her, she is as she is.

I agree this is the crux and a helpful post.

I’ve been friends with her throughout the whole estrangement with her children and whilst it has obviously come up in conversation and she has been upset, our entire interactions haven’t revolved around it. I have been able to be her friend and offer her some support without really thinking about it.

I have always thought that she wasn’t as innocent as she made out but as I mentioned she was very good to me years ago when I needed a friend and now in her time of need I want to be hers, because it really isn’t my business.

Since finding out about her son’s pregnancy her behaviour is becoming more and more unreasonable and it’s only what she’s telling me. I’m not enjoying any interaction I’m having with her and I’m struggling. She is crying about it all the time and unable to take any responsibility for her behavior at all.

I really don’t want to withdraw the little support I do give her (I see her twice a week) but I am really struggling with how she is being. I am also seeing how much she thinks they owe her contact. Due to her health, due to the baby etc.

OP posts:
Cherrysoup · Today 13:58

KeepTellingYourselfThat · Today 11:05

She should get a ‘personal alarm’ plan set-up and a key safe to be used by those coming to assist, this will ensure she’s not left stranded.

Also if she’s falling a fair bit maybe she needs a walker / rollator for support.

Her local mobiity shop will be able to point her in the right direction for both the alarm and walker, or she can just google these products.

I organised this for my mum, although the cause of her falls was usually alcohol. The company charged about £35 a month, put in a call alarm, keysafe and came and sorted her out as required.

As she’s a friend who you see regularly, do you not know why she is estranged from 2 dc? I mean, her version, obviously?

I was taken aback at the compliments received from childhood friends about my mother when she died recently. This was not how I remembered her. Behind closed doors, she was alcohol dependent, we were neglected. She was in the pub when I broke my arm. She would no doubt give a very different story.

Whattodooing · Today 13:59

No the house was deemed as unsafe to discharge her to due to her health and having nobody at home to help. Access to the house was up steep steps she couldn’t access, it was a house with stairs and a bath etc. She thought they were going to fit a garden ramp/stair lift etc but she was moved instead.

Her bungalow still doesn’t have a wet room and only a bath but as part of her care plan they have said she needs one. This was last year and it hasn’t been fitted yet. She showers at her neighbours house.

OP posts:
AnswerIsNo · Today 13:59

TherapyName · Today 13:51

I will also add that while people can have very complex and valid reasons for estrangement from a parent, it can also simply be selfishness and an unwillingness to inconvenience themselves. So many families allow one sibling to become the default carer, especially when one sister steps up.

Many therapists are privately concerned about the appropriation of therapy speak online encouraging 18-30s to 'enforce boundaries' and 'protect their peace'. Too often it translates as 'My parents judge me for eating a junk food diet / challenge me to work hard / tell me to stop smoking weed and gaming all night so I'm cutting them off' etc. Being challenged is seen as abuse and confrontational.

Sometimes it really is distance and being part of the 'squeezed middle' generation who are working long hours in an expensive country while trying to care for children. They are at the limits of their capacity and naively think the social supports of past still exist and will pick up the slack.

Either way, look at your own reasons for moving into rescuer mode. It can be simple human kindness but it can also be a habit learned early on and can put us at risk of exploitation. Never set yourself on fire to keep someone else warm.

While "therapy speak" has infiltrated mainstream via TikTok etc

I am fairly certain that many therapists are not privately concerned about a large cohort of 18-30 going no contact because their parents criticised their food choices and general life advice, so its highly disingenuous to implicitly conflate the 2 scenarios.

Also, there's absolutely zero wrong with the 'woke 18-30s" establishing boundaries with domineering parents and this does not detract from them or any other generation from making the difficult decision to break off contact.

Are you a practising therapist?

if so, which modality?

Bababear987 · Today 14:00

Could you or have you just said very pointedly to her
"You need to back off they owe you nothing. Im telling you this as a friend but you are pushing them further away."

bigboykitty · Today 14:01

@Whattodooing Seeing her twice a week is A huge amount of support! I don't imagine you come away feeling lifted or that you've done a good thing. Have you ever tried having a firm word with her? Not advocating that you do this, just wondering if you've tried it. She needs a reality check.

Bababear987 · Today 14:03

What is causing this low weight? Is she deliberately making herself sick and frail to try and get sympathy and family back?

Whattodooing · Today 14:04

bigboykitty · Today 14:01

@Whattodooing Seeing her twice a week is A huge amount of support! I don't imagine you come away feeling lifted or that you've done a good thing. Have you ever tried having a firm word with her? Not advocating that you do this, just wondering if you've tried it. She needs a reality check.

I have tried telling her that her behaviour is very counter productive and she isn’t helping the situation. She just ends up getting upset and saying she is confused.

I am finding the situation very draining to be honest and I’m finding my visits beginning to get shorter and shorter and I’m beginning to feel guilty about it.

I know I shouldn’t but I do. She’s still been my friend and she was a good one. I’ve been able to separate the estrangement from our friendship and keep my opinions on that separate but she’s making it incredibly difficult to do so and I’m not sure what to to anymore. Obviously her unreasonable behaviour isn’t towards me; but she’s still telling me and it’s dominating all of our conversations.

OP posts:
Whattodooing · Today 14:06

Bababear987 · Today 14:03

What is causing this low weight? Is she deliberately making herself sick and frail to try and get sympathy and family back?

It’s part of her condition. She’s been on and off nasal feeding for years but it doesn’t seem to work.

Her weight picked up when she was fed directly into her stomach (? sorry if that’s not correct term) but she had several complications with that which led to her needing emergency surgery to have it removed.

OP posts:
bigboykitty · Today 14:13

Whattodooing · Today 14:04

I have tried telling her that her behaviour is very counter productive and she isn’t helping the situation. She just ends up getting upset and saying she is confused.

I am finding the situation very draining to be honest and I’m finding my visits beginning to get shorter and shorter and I’m beginning to feel guilty about it.

I know I shouldn’t but I do. She’s still been my friend and she was a good one. I’ve been able to separate the estrangement from our friendship and keep my opinions on that separate but she’s making it incredibly difficult to do so and I’m not sure what to to anymore. Obviously her unreasonable behaviour isn’t towards me; but she’s still telling me and it’s dominating all of our conversations.

I think you have the patience of a saint. Anyone would struggle. I think it's okay to say 'I'm going to head home now. I don't like hearing you talk like this about other people and I don't think it's helping you at all to dwell on things and blame others. I'll see you on Friday'.

Bababear987 · Today 14:13

Whattodooing · Today 14:04

I have tried telling her that her behaviour is very counter productive and she isn’t helping the situation. She just ends up getting upset and saying she is confused.

I am finding the situation very draining to be honest and I’m finding my visits beginning to get shorter and shorter and I’m beginning to feel guilty about it.

I know I shouldn’t but I do. She’s still been my friend and she was a good one. I’ve been able to separate the estrangement from our friendship and keep my opinions on that separate but she’s making it incredibly difficult to do so and I’m not sure what to to anymore. Obviously her unreasonable behaviour isn’t towards me; but she’s still telling me and it’s dominating all of our conversations.

Classic. She suddenly gets confused when shes confronted with her bad behaviour, so manipulative.

I think this woman sounds like she massively plays on her illnesses and downright lies about things because she likes to be the victim. She's had multiple hospital stays and been moved house so she hasnt been abandoned.

If you cant spend more time with her then dont. She helped you but it doesnt mean you become her carer emotional or otherwise forever. You could try saying "I dont think we should talk about your children anymore, ive told you my thoughts which you dont take on board so lets not go round in circles."
Or sat youve joined an exercise class so wont be able to come as much anymore

Pearlstillsinging · Today 14:14

Whattodooing · Today 11:06

She doesn’t have a penny. She was living in a council house that was unfit for her to be discharged to from the hospital so the hospital helped her to get a social worker who helped set up a bungalow for her but other than that she’s had very little support. They did a carer assessment on her but they fobbed her off and said oh she’s got children to help her.

It’s quite complicated but I don’t want to get involved with ringing services on her behalf because I had quite strong boundaries and I currently give her all I can.

I will have a Google about self referral for therapy though because I do think it’s the only way forward for her

Edited

Ss would only say that she has children to help her if she told them that is the case. If she had told the truth about her situation, that she is only in contact with 2 of her children and they live miles away they would have put her in touch with whatever service they feel she needs.

Snorlaxo · Today 14:15

You can not do anything about the situation with her kids because she can’t see how her behaviour has led to the current situation. 4 kids being NC or being distant suggests that she’s not a “nice” mum at all.

I can’t comment on practical help from the services but is it possible that she is declining help? TO put things politely she sounds very stubborn and might not agree that she needs the help that she’s been offered. I admittedly don’t know how these things work but could it be that engaging with one service unlocks help from other services? I realise that you going down this road risks you becoming more entangled with this messy situation where there are no solutions if you’re determined to remain in her life.

JustaSongAboutPingPong · Today 14:15

Whattodooing · Today 10:57

I have suggested counselling to her but she seems reluctant to access it because she thinks she’s done nothing wrong so doesn’t need it. I’ve explained it can help her accept it.

My “D”M has tried counselling but if you have no powers of self reflection, it’s very difficult to engage with therapy.

If she’s falling a lot, has she got a SW? Does she have a falls alarm and does she attend the Falls Clinic?

The SW can help with the falls alarm. The GP can refer her to SS.