Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend with two estranged children

206 replies

Whattodooing · Today 10:42

I have a friend who I have known for many years. She has a bit of a tendency to be a bit dramatic but other than that she is a nice person. Her health is very bad.

Without going into too much detail she has 4 children and is estranged from two. She has been estranged from her daughter for many years. She became estranged from her son about a year ago. The two had nothing to do with each other. Completely separate situations. She blames his wife for the estrangement. Her son has recently announced he’s having a baby and she’s very upset.

I’ve tried hard not to comment too much on the situation or get too involved but I feel like it’s what most of our convos revolve around now. On one hand she is in and out of hospital and I feel awful for her because she doesn’t have anyone. She still has other children who aren’t no contact but they don’t live near and offer her no support. On the other hand I think if she has two children who have cut her off there must be a reason and she needs to look deeper than blaming everyone else.

I really want to support my friend and her son announcing a pregnancy has made her so focused on this that I don’t know how to help her through it or what to say. She has no support health wise and has been essentially left to rot.

OP posts:
MsPrufrockk · Today 11:47

Whattodooing · Today 11:06

She doesn’t have a penny. She was living in a council house that was unfit for her to be discharged to from the hospital so the hospital helped her to get a social worker who helped set up a bungalow for her but other than that she’s had very little support. They did a carer assessment on her but they fobbed her off and said oh she’s got children to help her.

It’s quite complicated but I don’t want to get involved with ringing services on her behalf because I had quite strong boundaries and I currently give her all I can.

I will have a Google about self referral for therapy though because I do think it’s the only way forward for her

Edited

"They did a carer assessment on her but they fobbed her off and said oh she’s got children to help her."

Did she tell you this? Having experience of this with my own parents, it doesn't sound right. My parents have me and my sister to help them, but they still get/got a lot of support from Adult Social Care. Your friend sounds like a difficult person who struggles with the truth, so I wonder if she TOLD the assessors she didn't need any help because of her children, with the intention of using it as a stick to beat her kids/get sympathy from other people.

EdgyNewt · Today 11:51

@Whattodooing being estranged from one child is really sad. Being estranged from two children is a pattern.

As a friend all you can do is be a listening ear, but with her medical issues and family issues, then the role of friend is going to be quite draining for you.

People don't just stop speaking to their parents for no reason. It is a HUGE decision to go NC with a parent, and very stressful for both parties, so to have two children do this means that there is something not right here.

Perhaps she was expecting far too much from her children and instead of being a mum, she was bombarding them with her health woes?

It's likely you'll never find out. You could meet with the the son if you think it would help you try and help your friend to explain why he doesn't want contact? But make it clear to the son you are not doing this to try and reconcile them - just to try and help his mum understand where she want wrong.

mindutopia · Today 11:51

My guess is that her lack of insight that is preventing her from accessing proper support and is pushing friends, including you, away is part of a longstanding behavioural pattern that impacted her children tremendously.

If she is in this state with so little support and such a mess in her 50s, imagine the childhood that her children had. I suspect it was probably quite traumatic and it’s no wonder they have all distanced themselves from it. If you are reaching out for help because you’re struggling to deal with her, can you imagine if your whole childhood was like this?

suburberphobe · Today 11:51

I’ve tried hard not to comment too much on the situation or get too involved

Apart from shouting it out to the world by posting it on Mumsnet.

Does she know this?

Don't tell her....

Octavia64 · Today 11:52

I’m disabled.

I’m not 50 yet and I have falls that take me a while to get up from. (I was in an accident and have physical injuries plus brain problems as a result),

realistically, with respect to health she’s been rehoused in a presumably suitable accommodation.

falls alarms are not as commonly used anymore as they often need a landline. Ambulances won’t generally come to a fall as they are low priority (unless you’ve obviously broken something and even then my friend fell in Sainsbury’s and broke her hip and she was told ambulance would be hours so relatives got her in a car and got her to a and e).

some local authorities have falls teams that will go out and help people.

realistically these days you’re on your own, and that is the way it is.

those people who accept it and get wheelchairs/zimmer frames/rollators and try bloody hard not to fall do fairly well, those who have family living close or in the house also do well.

most villages or towns have Facebook group where you can ask for a rollator or wheelchair. Nhs occasionally provides these but mostly doesn’t.

I just lent my manual wheelchair to my friend who fell in Sainsbury’s because she was desperate to get out of hospitsl but needed a toilet frame and a wheelchair and a rollator so we rallied round and have lent her the stuff.

realistically if this woman does not have family who are prepared to help, or friends who are prepared to help or help herself then yes she will rot.

Netcurtainnelly · Today 11:54

AnnaBelIa · Today 11:31

You can be a supportive friend without becoming an unpaid therapist, social worker and family mediator.

Exactly why you would have this level of interest in a friend's family situation is insane.
Sounds deeply heavy and no fun either.

marbIes · Today 11:56

Whattodooing · Today 11:34

She had one but she said she needed to pay for it as it was a subscription and she couldn’t afford it so gave it back?

This is exactly why she gets PIP. To pay for things needed for her care.

She sent it back because she doesnt want it and likes playing the victim - thats why nothing in her story is ever her fault and why she's spun you the line of not being able to afford it- poor her.

I dont believe a word of anything your friend says here. Everything is other people's fault and nothing is her own apparently.

VickyEadie · Today 11:57

Princessfluffy · Today 10:50

I think if you have certain health conditions the NHS does indeed often feel like you have been left to rot. Health conditions can also make it hard to maintain relationships. Maybe she can access counselling to help her deal with the estrangements. Phone counselling may be easier to access?

The OP says her friend has been "in and out of hospital" - hardly "left to rot" by the NHS.

Netcurtainnelly · Today 11:57

nearlylovemyusername · Today 11:43

I wonder why it's always assumed that estranged children mean parents at fault.

Sometimes it's as simple as children being shits.

I remember a poster here asking how much to charge and which chores to give to her very elderly father who came to live with her. And hundreds of posters commented how much and which tasks and how she should maintain her boundaries.Her dad died a few days after moving in. She didn't have heart to feel that he came to die with her, not at home alone.

People are born with own personalities, some are great, some are shit. Upbringing can only do so much, as proven by extremely different outcomes of siblings, even twins. And yes, some parents really are awful, but equally many children need to look in the mirror.

This as I've already said.
Also if you estranged from your parents because your a shit, you are teaching any kids if yours to do the same to you.

Absobeautely · Today 11:58

Netcurtainnelly · Today 11:54

Exactly why you would have this level of interest in a friend's family situation is insane.
Sounds deeply heavy and no fun either.

Exactly.

Definitely do not be a flying monkey as @EdgyNewt suggested.

The woeful tales of 'wehhh, I tried X, Y and Z, but everyone is so mean to me and here's a few lies about how I was failed and no one likes me.' are very familiar to those of us with abusers for parents.

GrandmasCat · Today 12:00

Whattodooing · Today 11:06

She doesn’t have a penny. She was living in a council house that was unfit for her to be discharged to from the hospital so the hospital helped her to get a social worker who helped set up a bungalow for her but other than that she’s had very little support. They did a carer assessment on her but they fobbed her off and said oh she’s got children to help her.

It’s quite complicated but I don’t want to get involved with ringing services on her behalf because I had quite strong boundaries and I currently give her all I can.

I will have a Google about self referral for therapy though because I do think it’s the only way forward for her

Edited

Unlikely. If she gets help to pay for the bungalow, universal credit will cover other things and she may also be receiving financial help to support her with her disability just choosing not to spend it.

This reminds me a lot of a woman I met through a befriending service… she needed help, she wanted someone to call services for her, sort benefits and take her out to the park at the end of the road. She couldn’t manage the stairs to leave her flat, his children had deserted her and she was rotting in her house… she said.

Obviously, when you hear all these things you raise a safeguarding concern and on checking on detail… her children were hearing the same story every time they dropped by (several times a week), she didn’t qualify to be referred for free help from other charities because she was getting more than in benefits specifically to pay for carers, the medical service that had abandoned her… I bumped with them often during visits and with regards to be a prisoner in her flat… my boss just said, how often do you find her walking frame downstairs by the outside doors? Half the bloody time, was the answer. Some people just cry wolf to get attention.

Uricon2 · Today 12:01

We have an emergency alarm for my DH ( he's bedbound and these days it's mainly so he can get help if I fall off my twig) and it is fully adapted for digital. Yes, there is a cost and she could look at any schemes to offset this for people on low incomes. A PPs idea of a full benefits check is a good one as is contacting any charity that focuses on whatever medical condition she has.

Social services won't refuse to help someone just because they've given birth. If it is made clear to them that she has no support at all from family, it will be taken into account on assessment.

I might be being very unfair but I'm getting a mental picture of somone who is not really focused on helping themselves and while unwell, she's not old and no cognitive isssues have been mentioned. I think all you can do OP is try to get her to engage with things that will actually help her, rather than what she's doing currently, whichis fixating on the estrangements.

Isittimeformynapyet · Today 12:02

Netcurtainnelly · Today 11:18

You don't know the estrangement isn't their fault, or both of theirs.
More to the point why get involved. Keep things light.
Lots of people have family problems. Why get sucked into it. Just have fun.

Yes, but I really don't think there's an awful lot of fun to be had here. I'd be off.

bigboykitty · Today 12:03

OP your idea of getting your friend into therapy is a complete fantasy. She has zero insight and there is no chance she wants to develop any. She just thinks that if she falls over enough then her children should help her. It's interesting that you say she is completely penniless. That obviously isn't true if she gets benefits including PIP. Is this what she tells you? It seems to me that she presents herself as utterly helpless and with zero support. I can hear that you are trying to hold some boundaries, but the other side of that coin is that she is trying to shift 100% responsibility on literally anyone else who will listen. People who literally won't do anything to help themselves are very hard to help and usually manage to alienate everyone. The PIP money is literally to buy aids or support to enable her to live with her health issues. What does she do with this money? I think you're going to have to give her some tough love if you really want to help her. Ask her what she's willing to do to start to help herself. It sounds like her whole approach to life is about manipulating others and doggedly refusing to take any responsibility for herself or her choices.

AnswerIsNo · Today 12:03

nearlylovemyusername · Today 11:43

I wonder why it's always assumed that estranged children mean parents at fault.

Sometimes it's as simple as children being shits.

I remember a poster here asking how much to charge and which chores to give to her very elderly father who came to live with her. And hundreds of posters commented how much and which tasks and how she should maintain her boundaries.Her dad died a few days after moving in. She didn't have heart to feel that he came to die with her, not at home alone.

People are born with own personalities, some are great, some are shit. Upbringing can only do so much, as proven by extremely different outcomes of siblings, even twins. And yes, some parents really are awful, but equally many children need to look in the mirror.

while what you say is true from a meta and philosophical standpoint, humans are hardwired against purposeful estrangement from family

therefore, its not the first choice and in many cases, its the last, after many years of normalising their situaiton

its clearly nuanced, but it would be Socratically dishonest to broadly infer "its often just as much the children too"

In terms of nature nurture, I would wager a higher percentage of kids who end up as delinquents, then into the prison system, have been far more impacted by nurture than nature...

The bulk of the aetiological contribution for the common mental health and personality disorders listed in either DSM-V or NICE are from the early formative years to around age 6 or so, the remainder are contributions genetic/pre-birth

...which throws the responsibility back to the root cause which exists in many family trees - a sickness of varying severity - oft passed down from the previous generation, where ignorance in the 21st Century is no self-defence and wasn't even a valid reason in the 20th.

Tree surgeons may lop off an ailing branch to preserve the tree,

sometimes the tree is terminally sick, but a branch or 2 remain relatively healthy by comparison

KeepTellingYourselfThat · Today 12:05

Whattodooing · Today 11:34

She had one but she said she needed to pay for it as it was a subscription and she couldn’t afford it so gave it back?

They are usually either a one-off payment or about £11 pm. That’s what she gets PIP for, to use on things to help her.

Surely being stranded on the floor and in hospital for a week dehydrated would make her re-prioritise what she needs to have and what she could do without.

Maybe she wants to play the victim. Hoping her kids will come back if she can’t cope. Tbh, they are more likely to come back if they see she can cope.

Worktillate · Today 12:06

Whattodooing · Today 10:55

She has absolutely been left to rot. The way she is being treated by services and by her children are two separate issues. Among many things she often falls over and is left on the floor of her home for hours. She ended up hospitalised for over a week with dehydration because nobody found her recently.

I haven’t included any issues of her health so I’m not sure how you can argue that that the NHS haven’t done this?

My post agrees she isn’t innocent in the estrangement of her children. I’m asking for advice in navigating the two issues separately. I want to support her in her health and as a friend but the estrangement is taking over everything and I don’t want to enable that either.

If they're two separate issues, why raise them together?

Your post is titled about the two children, your narrative is about the two children and then you add 'left to rot' on the end which would therefore seem to be about the two children. You state afterwards it isn't about them but by the construct of your OP it doesn't seem to be so.

I agree with PP though, you have only been her friend, not one of her children. And if 50% of her children have gone NC for different reasons at different points in time it is most likely going to be on her. You say her circle is small - there's likely a reason for that that extends beyond her illness.

It's sad that her son's news has focussed her mind, but ultimately that's not your issue to deal with. Maybe if she took some ownership of the issues things might change, but it doesn't seem likely

TigerFrogs · Today 12:06

I’d be very cautious of getting to involved with someone who’s own children don’t want to be involved with. I have a parent like this who claims endless health issues to gain sympathy from others. She’s constantly finding some new naive person to play carer for a while before they realise what she is actually like. Estrangement is normally not just from childhood issues, but because there is ongoing issues with how she is treating them (disrespect, manipulation, controlling etc). You’ll likely find her treating you the same at some point. Get her to challenge the social care assessment and state that she doesn’t have anyone to help.

marbIes · Today 12:10

Worktillate · Today 12:06

If they're two separate issues, why raise them together?

Your post is titled about the two children, your narrative is about the two children and then you add 'left to rot' on the end which would therefore seem to be about the two children. You state afterwards it isn't about them but by the construct of your OP it doesn't seem to be so.

I agree with PP though, you have only been her friend, not one of her children. And if 50% of her children have gone NC for different reasons at different points in time it is most likely going to be on her. You say her circle is small - there's likely a reason for that that extends beyond her illness.

It's sad that her son's news has focussed her mind, but ultimately that's not your issue to deal with. Maybe if she took some ownership of the issues things might change, but it doesn't seem likely

Exactly- if her two children are not the issue then why is the thread entitled "friend with two estranged children" rather than "my friend is being failed by health services- how can I help her?"

Something very fishy here

AnswerIsNo · Today 12:11

TigerFrogs · Today 12:06

I’d be very cautious of getting to involved with someone who’s own children don’t want to be involved with. I have a parent like this who claims endless health issues to gain sympathy from others. She’s constantly finding some new naive person to play carer for a while before they realise what she is actually like. Estrangement is normally not just from childhood issues, but because there is ongoing issues with how she is treating them (disrespect, manipulation, controlling etc). You’ll likely find her treating you the same at some point. Get her to challenge the social care assessment and state that she doesn’t have anyone to help.

exactly

"why can't you forgive your mother/or your father???, wHaT hApPeNeD wAs YeArS aGo, you're so petty and vindictive, forgive and forget, YOLO"

except, trauma does not work like that

and

"yes, but my parents are still treating me like shit in the present day, as an adult and the bank account of forgiveness is so far in the red that I've reluctantly called in the administrators to wind up the arrangement - I'm done, YOLO"

Additup · Today 12:12

AnswerIsNo · Today 12:03

while what you say is true from a meta and philosophical standpoint, humans are hardwired against purposeful estrangement from family

therefore, its not the first choice and in many cases, its the last, after many years of normalising their situaiton

its clearly nuanced, but it would be Socratically dishonest to broadly infer "its often just as much the children too"

In terms of nature nurture, I would wager a higher percentage of kids who end up as delinquents, then into the prison system, have been far more impacted by nurture than nature...

The bulk of the aetiological contribution for the common mental health and personality disorders listed in either DSM-V or NICE are from the early formative years to around age 6 or so, the remainder are contributions genetic/pre-birth

...which throws the responsibility back to the root cause which exists in many family trees - a sickness of varying severity - oft passed down from the previous generation, where ignorance in the 21st Century is no self-defence and wasn't even a valid reason in the 20th.

Tree surgeons may lop off an ailing branch to preserve the tree,

sometimes the tree is terminally sick, but a branch or 2 remain relatively healthy by comparison

That's a big helping of word salad to tell @nearlylovemyusername you disagree with her.

@nearlylovemyusername I agree with you. Some children just grow up to be awful for whatever reason so I wouldn't automatically blame the parent for estrangement either. Also the issue with her son is more to do with the DIL and OP said her friend gets on well with her other 2 children but they live far away.

VickyEadie · Today 12:14

marbIes · Today 12:10

Exactly- if her two children are not the issue then why is the thread entitled "friend with two estranged children" rather than "my friend is being failed by health services- how can I help her?"

Something very fishy here

She isn't being failed by health services, though. She might be being failed by social services, but we only have the OP's account of her friend's word for that. We know she isn't spending her PIP on the things that could help her.

The NHS appears to me to have treated her when she's needed treating. They were even instrumental in getting her re-houses in more suitable accommodation. It's not down to them to get her care support.

Netcurtainnelly · Today 12:14

Worktillate · Today 12:06

If they're two separate issues, why raise them together?

Your post is titled about the two children, your narrative is about the two children and then you add 'left to rot' on the end which would therefore seem to be about the two children. You state afterwards it isn't about them but by the construct of your OP it doesn't seem to be so.

I agree with PP though, you have only been her friend, not one of her children. And if 50% of her children have gone NC for different reasons at different points in time it is most likely going to be on her. You say her circle is small - there's likely a reason for that that extends beyond her illness.

It's sad that her son's news has focussed her mind, but ultimately that's not your issue to deal with. Maybe if she took some ownership of the issues things might change, but it doesn't seem likely

It's not necessarily on her just because two have. You could say if two haven't then it's the fault of the ones who have.
Best not to get involved.

I know someone estranged from.kids and I have never probed why it's none of my business. I'm not interested in her kids either. I don't know them. It's how she is a person and to me that counts.

marbIes · Today 12:14

Additup · Today 12:12

That's a big helping of word salad to tell @nearlylovemyusername you disagree with her.

@nearlylovemyusername I agree with you. Some children just grow up to be awful for whatever reason so I wouldn't automatically blame the parent for estrangement either. Also the issue with her son is more to do with the DIL and OP said her friend gets on well with her other 2 children but they live far away.

Did you miss this part:

She’s hounded her poor son and his wife since they announced the pregnancy and they haven’t replied.

She doesnt sound like some innocent victim here at all. Not even slightly.

Whattodooing · Today 12:15

marbIes · Today 12:10

Exactly- if her two children are not the issue then why is the thread entitled "friend with two estranged children" rather than "my friend is being failed by health services- how can I help her?"

Something very fishy here

Because I’ve been supporting her for years. Her behaviour around the estrangement is impacting how much I feel I can support her and is pushing me away. I don’t want to take a step back because she is being failed. But I don’t know how to handle her behaviour.

OP posts: