Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend with two estranged children

210 replies

Whattodooing · Today 10:42

I have a friend who I have known for many years. She has a bit of a tendency to be a bit dramatic but other than that she is a nice person. Her health is very bad.

Without going into too much detail she has 4 children and is estranged from two. She has been estranged from her daughter for many years. She became estranged from her son about a year ago. The two had nothing to do with each other. Completely separate situations. She blames his wife for the estrangement. Her son has recently announced he’s having a baby and she’s very upset.

I’ve tried hard not to comment too much on the situation or get too involved but I feel like it’s what most of our convos revolve around now. On one hand she is in and out of hospital and I feel awful for her because she doesn’t have anyone. She still has other children who aren’t no contact but they don’t live near and offer her no support. On the other hand I think if she has two children who have cut her off there must be a reason and she needs to look deeper than blaming everyone else.

I really want to support my friend and her son announcing a pregnancy has made her so focused on this that I don’t know how to help her through it or what to say. She has no support health wise and has been essentially left to rot.

OP posts:
ToKittyornottoKitty · Today 10:46

She hasn’t ’been left to rot’, and that’s unfair on her children, they don’t owe her anything and have their own lives. If her circle is that small that she only has you, that’s on her to some extent isn’t it. It’s great you are able to support her, but don’t give more than you can, if she’s too much try changing the subject or maybe back away from being that shoulder to cry on a bit. I know it’s hard when she doesn’t have anyone else but you need to look after yourself first. I wouldn’t try and point out it might be her fault, she likely will just be upset at you, but distancing yourself if you need to is a good idea.

Whattodooing · Today 10:48

ToKittyornottoKitty · Today 10:46

She hasn’t ’been left to rot’, and that’s unfair on her children, they don’t owe her anything and have their own lives. If her circle is that small that she only has you, that’s on her to some extent isn’t it. It’s great you are able to support her, but don’t give more than you can, if she’s too much try changing the subject or maybe back away from being that shoulder to cry on a bit. I know it’s hard when she doesn’t have anyone else but you need to look after yourself first. I wouldn’t try and point out it might be her fault, she likely will just be upset at you, but distancing yourself if you need to is a good idea.

I said she has no support health wise.

I don’t mean her children. I mean she needs professional support in my opinion but social services push her back. I want to help support her with her health and getting her out and about but difficult when I know her relationship with her children isn’t not her fault and it’s taking over everything.

She has a few acquaintances but no real support anywhere and I think people are scared to get involved. Especially because she can be very full on, I think she is lonely too.

OP posts:
HardShoulders · Today 10:49

You can’t help because you don’t have anywhere near all the information. You may think your friend is a ‘nice person’, but you didn’t experience her as a parent. None of her children are supporting her, and two are estranged. Perhaps with good reason.

My mother is invariably described as ‘lovely’. She presents as a sweet, desperate-to-please elderly woman who would give you her last penny. Yet she knew two of her children were being sexually abused in childhood (one of them told her) and not only did nothing to stop it at the time because it would have involved ‘making a fuss’, but has never acknowledged it since or apologised. Both children have suffered lifelong impact, and have tried to raise the subject gently in their 40s /50s, but she thinks ‘it wasn’t that bad’.

I offer this as an example.

Princessfluffy · Today 10:50

I think if you have certain health conditions the NHS does indeed often feel like you have been left to rot. Health conditions can also make it hard to maintain relationships. Maybe she can access counselling to help her deal with the estrangements. Phone counselling may be easier to access?

SkateHaddockCod · Today 10:50

She hasn't been left to rot, she's dealing with the consequences of past actions.

You have no right to judge her children as you really don't know their side of the story.

Using such hyperbole is buying into the victim narrative. Suggest you dial that down or you'll be sucked in to the situation more than you might like.

Wishimaywishimight · Today 10:52

Been 'left to rot' is ridiculously over-dramatic. How do you think people with no children living nearby (or indeed at all) manage?

It's up to you how little or how much support you offer but I do think it sounds like she is the problem (rather than ALL of her children so I would be wary of getting sucked in too close.

Barney16 · Today 10:53

It's tricky because the person she is with you isn't necessarily the person she was or is with her children. I'm not minimising her distress but as pp have said counselling may help her come to terms with her situation.

Whattodooing · Today 10:55

SkateHaddockCod · Today 10:50

She hasn't been left to rot, she's dealing with the consequences of past actions.

You have no right to judge her children as you really don't know their side of the story.

Using such hyperbole is buying into the victim narrative. Suggest you dial that down or you'll be sucked in to the situation more than you might like.

She has absolutely been left to rot. The way she is being treated by services and by her children are two separate issues. Among many things she often falls over and is left on the floor of her home for hours. She ended up hospitalised for over a week with dehydration because nobody found her recently.

I haven’t included any issues of her health so I’m not sure how you can argue that that the NHS haven’t done this?

My post agrees she isn’t innocent in the estrangement of her children. I’m asking for advice in navigating the two issues separately. I want to support her in her health and as a friend but the estrangement is taking over everything and I don’t want to enable that either.

OP posts:
KeepTellingYourselfThat · Today 10:56

Whattodooing · Today 10:48

I said she has no support health wise.

I don’t mean her children. I mean she needs professional support in my opinion but social services push her back. I want to help support her with her health and getting her out and about but difficult when I know her relationship with her children isn’t not her fault and it’s taking over everything.

She has a few acquaintances but no real support anywhere and I think people are scared to get involved. Especially because she can be very full on, I think she is lonely too.

Edited

You don’t know the estrangement isn’t her fault, you’ve only heard her side of the situation.

However, estrangement no matter whose fault it is, is devastating for both parties.

I would say though that new babies tend to bring families together, so this may be an ideal opportunity for her to reach out to her son and his wife to congratulate them and tell them how much she misses them both and that she would love to be part of their lives and the new babies life, if they could find it in their hearts to let her and forgive any wrongdoing.

Whattodooing · Today 10:57

Princessfluffy · Today 10:50

I think if you have certain health conditions the NHS does indeed often feel like you have been left to rot. Health conditions can also make it hard to maintain relationships. Maybe she can access counselling to help her deal with the estrangements. Phone counselling may be easier to access?

I have suggested counselling to her but she seems reluctant to access it because she thinks she’s done nothing wrong so doesn’t need it. I’ve explained it can help her accept it.

OP posts:
Whattodooing · Today 10:59

KeepTellingYourselfThat · Today 10:56

You don’t know the estrangement isn’t her fault, you’ve only heard her side of the situation.

However, estrangement no matter whose fault it is, is devastating for both parties.

I would say though that new babies tend to bring families together, so this may be an ideal opportunity for her to reach out to her son and his wife to congratulate them and tell them how much she misses them both and that she would love to be part of their lives and the new babies life, if they could find it in their hearts to let her and forgive any wrongdoing.

She’s hounded her poor son and his wife since they announced the pregnancy and they haven’t replied. I’m worried they are going to block her and set off a whole new set off issues if I’m being honest.

I’m finding it really difficult because I still want to support her because I feel bad for her health and she’s been a nice and good friend to me. But I don’t know how to deal with her behaviour around her estranged children.

I think you may have misread what I said in the post you quoted. I didn’t said the estrangement wasn’t her fault. I’m well aware that there are two sides to every story.

OP posts:
rainingsnoring · Today 11:03

Your friend sounds like a difficult person who has made a lot of mistakes and also has no insight. It's unusual for children to completely withdraw from a parent and for the other two to not offer her support. There will be reasons for this behaviour.
When you say she has been 'left to rot' by services, are you referring to social services not offering her as much care as you think she needs? Has she no money to pay for some care? How involved is her GP? Is she able to access her GP herself? I agree that some online counselling might be worthwhile.

Just seen your last post, wrt her behaviour towards her estranged children, I think you will need to be blunt and tell her that her behaviour is unfair and that she is likely to be upsetting them.

KeepTellingYourselfThat · Today 11:05

Whattodooing · Today 10:55

She has absolutely been left to rot. The way she is being treated by services and by her children are two separate issues. Among many things she often falls over and is left on the floor of her home for hours. She ended up hospitalised for over a week with dehydration because nobody found her recently.

I haven’t included any issues of her health so I’m not sure how you can argue that that the NHS haven’t done this?

My post agrees she isn’t innocent in the estrangement of her children. I’m asking for advice in navigating the two issues separately. I want to support her in her health and as a friend but the estrangement is taking over everything and I don’t want to enable that either.

She should get a ‘personal alarm’ plan set-up and a key safe to be used by those coming to assist, this will ensure she’s not left stranded.

Also if she’s falling a fair bit maybe she needs a walker / rollator for support.

Her local mobiity shop will be able to point her in the right direction for both the alarm and walker, or she can just google these products.

Whattodooing · Today 11:06

rainingsnoring · Today 11:03

Your friend sounds like a difficult person who has made a lot of mistakes and also has no insight. It's unusual for children to completely withdraw from a parent and for the other two to not offer her support. There will be reasons for this behaviour.
When you say she has been 'left to rot' by services, are you referring to social services not offering her as much care as you think she needs? Has she no money to pay for some care? How involved is her GP? Is she able to access her GP herself? I agree that some online counselling might be worthwhile.

Just seen your last post, wrt her behaviour towards her estranged children, I think you will need to be blunt and tell her that her behaviour is unfair and that she is likely to be upsetting them.

She doesn’t have a penny. She was living in a council house that was unfit for her to be discharged to from the hospital so the hospital helped her to get a social worker who helped set up a bungalow for her but other than that she’s had very little support. They did a carer assessment on her but they fobbed her off and said oh she’s got children to help her.

It’s quite complicated but I don’t want to get involved with ringing services on her behalf because I had quite strong boundaries and I currently give her all I can.

I will have a Google about self referral for therapy though because I do think it’s the only way forward for her

OP posts:
HorseandHeron · Today 11:08

Many people who are 'wonderful' to their friends are nighmarish parents - utterly self-absorbed, controlling and unable to see their children, even in adulthood, as anything other than an extension of themselves. If the children have gone no contact, that is likely to be why.

I have a lovely friend whose daughter is no contact. My friend's version make the daughter seem insane. But I can read between the lines. Much as I love her, I would hate to have my friend as a mother. Endless digs about weight to to a daughter with endometriosis and CPOS - both of which cause massive weight increase that no amount of starvation dieting can undo, while my friend is a very beautiful, tiny size 6.

KeepTellingYourselfThat · Today 11:09

Whattodooing · Today 11:06

She doesn’t have a penny. She was living in a council house that was unfit for her to be discharged to from the hospital so the hospital helped her to get a social worker who helped set up a bungalow for her but other than that she’s had very little support. They did a carer assessment on her but they fobbed her off and said oh she’s got children to help her.

It’s quite complicated but I don’t want to get involved with ringing services on her behalf because I had quite strong boundaries and I currently give her all I can.

I will have a Google about self referral for therapy though because I do think it’s the only way forward for her

Edited

How old is she and does she claim PIP or DLA?

Whattodooing · Today 11:10

KeepTellingYourselfThat · Today 11:09

How old is she and does she claim PIP or DLA?

She’s in her late 50’s. She claims PIP but I have no idea what level of award she gets.

OP posts:
Everlygreen · Today 11:12

A child’s bond with a parent is the hardest one to break. No other relationship will come close. For all FOUR of her children to have very little or nothing to do with her- she must have been a very bad mother.
Do not get involved in her issues, as she is probably giving you the best and most false version of herself. Sit down and think about it. Children who she raised well, showed love to and been a good mother - do they cut you off for no reason? The answer is right there.

CarlyMarley · Today 11:12

My mum has an acquaintance whose children are NC with her.

my mum talks about how sorry she feels for her.

However I remind my mum that I’m pretty certain if she talked to them I’m sure their story would be very different to their mother’s as to what their relationship was like.

In my opinion it’s a very severe move to go NC with a parent and I don’t imagine many people do it without good reason.

KeepTellingYourselfThat · Today 11:13

Whattodooing · Today 11:10

She’s in her late 50’s. She claims PIP but I have no idea what level of award she gets.

Oh wow! She’s still young. I was going to suggest ‘Attendance Allowance’ but she’s already claiming PIP plus I think she’s too young for it anyhow.

If she’s not on the higher level, maybe ask them to reassess due to her regular falling leading to hospital stays etc.. the extra money could be used for mobility aids to help her day-day living.

Everlygreen · Today 11:14

HorseandHeron · Today 11:08

Many people who are 'wonderful' to their friends are nighmarish parents - utterly self-absorbed, controlling and unable to see their children, even in adulthood, as anything other than an extension of themselves. If the children have gone no contact, that is likely to be why.

I have a lovely friend whose daughter is no contact. My friend's version make the daughter seem insane. But I can read between the lines. Much as I love her, I would hate to have my friend as a mother. Endless digs about weight to to a daughter with endometriosis and CPOS - both of which cause massive weight increase that no amount of starvation dieting can undo, while my friend is a very beautiful, tiny size 6.

I also knew someone like this. Cut her off immediately when I knew she had children who was estranged. It told me what the person SHE is to have her own children having nothing to do with her. I was right in the end too.

Netcurtainnelly · Today 11:18

KeepTellingYourselfThat · Today 10:56

You don’t know the estrangement isn’t her fault, you’ve only heard her side of the situation.

However, estrangement no matter whose fault it is, is devastating for both parties.

I would say though that new babies tend to bring families together, so this may be an ideal opportunity for her to reach out to her son and his wife to congratulate them and tell them how much she misses them both and that she would love to be part of their lives and the new babies life, if they could find it in their hearts to let her and forgive any wrongdoing.

You don't know the estrangement isn't their fault, or both of theirs.
More to the point why get involved. Keep things light.
Lots of people have family problems. Why get sucked into it. Just have fun.

KeepTellingYourselfThat · Today 11:20

CarlyMarley · Today 11:12

My mum has an acquaintance whose children are NC with her.

my mum talks about how sorry she feels for her.

However I remind my mum that I’m pretty certain if she talked to them I’m sure their story would be very different to their mother’s as to what their relationship was like.

In my opinion it’s a very severe move to go NC with a parent and I don’t imagine many people do it without good reason.

There are usually problems over a number of many years and then one-day ‘snap!’ the straw that breaks the camel’s back and they can take no more. It’s devastating for both sides and takes years of grieving to overcome the lost relationship.

Both sides can be felt sorry for, as neither party ever wanted NC.

herbetta · Today 11:20

It's very difficult. She will be getting PIP, UC & council tax benefit and her housing paid. She will also be entitled to social tariffs for all her utilities plus her prescriptions paid. She can apply for a free bus pass too - some of these benefits are applied for separately, so suggest She goes to CAB for a check.

Unfortunately when people are like your friend (and with no insight etc) they often alienate themselves with the medical services as well.

The best thing you can do for her is to let her know she can help herself and improve her life immensely by being willing to accept her part in this and undergo counselling.

Arthurnewyorkcity · Today 11:23

As someone estranged, the insane amount of trauma i went through before ever cutting contact. Its not a light move. Secondly, if she qualifies for social care support as outlined in the care act, she must have declined it. You have a tonne of third party information and very little factual