Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law" - Telegraph article share

290 replies

singthing · Yesterday 07:46

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

Baroness Cass has turned against Labour’s plans for a new conversion therapy law, warning that it would have a “chilling effect” on doctors.

Lady Cass, who led a review of the treatment of children with gender dysphoria, previously backed the Conversion Practices Bill but said she had only been given an hour to read the draft legislation before providing a supportive comment for a government press release in June.

On Monday, she told MPs that she regretted backing it, and having read it through now thought it could have “serious unintended consequences”.
...

Continues at:
^Original: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/16/baroness-cass-turns-against-chilling-trans-law/^
Gift: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2
^Archive: https://archive.ph/rP3Np^

Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Shortshriftandlethal · Today 10:17

noblegiraffe · Today 10:06

I didn't say it was.

But there are definitely people out there throwing abuse at trans people, so to suggest that only 'one side' (GC women) are receiving death threats and only one side (TRAs) are sending them is probably incorrect.

It is not prominent women's rights activists that are sending such messages - it will mostly be men. On the otherhand we have male trans activists openly posting threats of violence and explicit, sexualised imagery.

It is wrong of Cass to try to find equivalence between those who are campaigning to stop the puberty blocker trial etc with trans activists who threaten to report women to the police or call them hateful and ban them from their trade unions and constituency Labour parties etc.

Dragonasaurus · Today 10:17

noblegiraffe · Today 10:06

I didn't say it was.

But there are definitely people out there throwing abuse at trans people, so to suggest that only 'one side' (GC women) are receiving death threats and only one side (TRAs) are sending them is probably incorrect.

OK, I’ll rephrase:
In the disagreement between GC people and trans activists, trans activists are regularly and publicly threatening rape, violence and murder. I have never seen an equivalent from GC people. Obviously both women and trans people may regularly receive abuse which is outwith this disagreement.

clearer?

Shortshriftandlethal · Today 10:22

noblegiraffe · Today 10:06

I didn't say it was.

But there are definitely people out there throwing abuse at trans people, so to suggest that only 'one side' (GC women) are receiving death threats and only one side (TRAs) are sending them is probably incorrect.

When you have MPs and even the chair of the 'Women and Equalities Committee' referring to opponents as "hateful transphobes and bigots" then you really don't have equivalence. It has been seen as totally acceptable and normal for prominent trans activists to call for people to be banned and thrown out of organisations.

noblegiraffe · Today 10:26

Dragonasaurus · Today 10:17

OK, I’ll rephrase:
In the disagreement between GC people and trans activists, trans activists are regularly and publicly threatening rape, violence and murder. I have never seen an equivalent from GC people. Obviously both women and trans people may regularly receive abuse which is outwith this disagreement.

clearer?

Are there extremes on both sides? Yes.

Is Cass wrong to say this? No

Does the existence of a large group of people who aren't extreme change anything? No.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 10:30

MrsOvertonsWindow · Today 09:54

Have a look at the leader in the Times about the bill. It's furious:

"The bill is a sinister, shoddy and unnecessary piece of work, a Trojan horse for the widely discredited cause of the extreme trans lobby"

https://archive.ph/0suqo

https://www.thetimes.com/comment/the-times-view/article/conversion-practices-bill-sledgehammer-nut-wd670qdqh

Edited

Is The Times also running a campaign against the Bill, does anyone know?

pontefractals · Today 10:35

singthing · Today 10:02

An interesting sidenote about this report. I have direct experience with this very company. They are a report factory who will produce research on anything you like, and in their marketing blurb, they mention how they will add "10% customisation" according to your wishes. Essentially that means they will add in content that suits your narrative as the purchaser. That add-on worked very well for my then-employer in our sales and marketing efforts!

So the existence of this report means someone somewhere wanted an official-looking piece of research that explicitly showed how large and fast-growing the market was, and how financially lucrative it is. Quite an odd thing to want to peacock about, I would have thought. Unless you have a vested interest in keeping the production line of bodies coming.

Thank you, this is a fascinating insight, and says a lot about the commissioners of the report, none of it good.

Shortshriftandlethal · Today 10:37

noblegiraffe · Today 10:26

Are there extremes on both sides? Yes.

Is Cass wrong to say this? No

Does the existence of a large group of people who aren't extreme change anything? No.

She was drawing a false equivalence in the minds of the committee, even though her own examples revealed that the "malign actors" were those who were reporting or threatening to report people/doctors/ therapists/parents to the police or other authorities for non compliance with demands.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 10:46

Shortshriftandlethal · Today 10:37

She was drawing a false equivalence in the minds of the committee, even though her own examples revealed that the "malign actors" were those who were reporting or threatening to report people/doctors/ therapists/parents to the police or other authorities for non compliance with demands.

Edited

I still maintain that Cass is either uninformed, misguided, blinkered, indifferent, or partial, one or all of these things.

I'd rather not think she is an activist or being driven by threats.

She often does make me think of a rabbit in headlights.

I just don't think she cares enough about all the drawbacks of these issues. Until she does, because it's likely to affect her and her reputation. Then she looks like the rabbit.

Datun · Today 11:29

noblegiraffe · Today 10:26

Are there extremes on both sides? Yes.

Is Cass wrong to say this? No

Does the existence of a large group of people who aren't extreme change anything? No.

They aren't extremes on both sides. If you're going to add homophobic, aggressive men threatening cross-dressers to the ledger, I can add three women a week killed by male murderers.

nicepotoftea · Today 11:32

Datun · Today 11:29

They aren't extremes on both sides. If you're going to add homophobic, aggressive men threatening cross-dressers to the ledger, I can add three women a week killed by male murderers.

If you're going to add homophobic, aggressive men threatening cross-dressers to the ledger

Also not clear how these people are on the same side as feminists.

ArabellaScott · Today 11:41

BMJ

https://www.bmj.com/content/395/bmj-2026-101493

noblegiraffe · Today 11:44

Datun · Today 11:29

They aren't extremes on both sides. If you're going to add homophobic, aggressive men threatening cross-dressers to the ledger, I can add three women a week killed by male murderers.

Unclear what the opinion those male murderers have about trans rights before deciding which ‘side’ of the debate they’re on?

Also unclear why you have decided that homophobic men are threatening ‘cross-dressers’ rather than trans people unless you think trans people are all merely cross-dressers?

Datun · Today 11:46

nicepotoftea · Today 11:32

If you're going to add homophobic, aggressive men threatening cross-dressers to the ledger

Also not clear how these people are on the same side as feminists.

Indeed. They're not.

Transactivists milk the victim narrative to bloody death. And a lot of people buy it, because they remember how violent homophobia became. They don't want to get caught napping.

None of it is born out by evidence.

But irrespective, it's nothing to do with the 'side' who is objecting to the conversion therapy bill.

The only reason anyone thinks it is is because TRA's claim it is. Another issue really with Cass's naivety.

Datun · Today 11:52

noblegiraffe · Today 11:44

Unclear what the opinion those male murderers have about trans rights before deciding which ‘side’ of the debate they’re on?

Also unclear why you have decided that homophobic men are threatening ‘cross-dressers’ rather than trans people unless you think trans people are all merely cross-dressers?

Edited

Haha! I'm really not going to devote even a nanosecond to contemplating whether men threatening other men make a distinction between cross-dressers and trans.

What they are not are women's rights activists.

They're not on any 'side' of this debate.

BiologicalRobot · Today 11:55

I still maintain that Cass is either uninformed, misguided, blinkered, indifferent, or partial, one or all of these things.

Hence my post earlier. Considering she is supposedly an intelligent and educated person, talking about things she's spent her professional life looking at, she does seem rather unthinking and dumb. I'm not that educated, I'm not that intelligent, I haven't had a career, and yet even I know not to endorse anything without reading or basic questioning. How does someone get to her lofty heights without common sense? It really is quite worrying especially when you realise half our MPs are similar.

ArabellaScott · Today 12:01

Put it bluntly, we know who the death threats are coming from.

BashBack still crowing about forcing the EHRC to move offices? Posters of men in balaclavas with clawhammers?

noblegiraffe · Today 12:02

Datun · Today 11:52

Haha! I'm really not going to devote even a nanosecond to contemplating whether men threatening other men make a distinction between cross-dressers and trans.

What they are not are women's rights activists.

They're not on any 'side' of this debate.

You were the one who brought up cross dressers 🤷‍♀️

If someone is repeatedly shouting ‘you’re a man’ at a trans person, do you suppose it matters to them whether that person is a feminist or not?

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 12:04

... aaand suddenly we are not discussing the draft Conversion Practices Bill again...

Datun · Today 12:08

noblegiraffe · Today 12:02

You were the one who brought up cross dressers 🤷‍♀️

If someone is repeatedly shouting ‘you’re a man’ at a trans person, do you suppose it matters to them whether that person is a feminist or not?

Again, I couldn't care less what they think.

It's not gender critical feminists who are sending rape and death threats.

there is no symmetry between the tactics of each side.

The fact that Cass seems to think there is, is a worry.

ArabellaScott · Today 12:08

https://stonewall.org.uk/get-involved/campaign-with-us/ban-conversion-practices

'The Draft Bill adds protections for individuals who identify “as neither male nor female or as not solely male or female” and people who do not have a sexual orientation. This would be the first instance of legal protections for non-binary and asexual people in England and Wales.'

This to me looks extra dodgy. Nobody has looked at it properly, have they?

Is this the first time non binary identity would be put into law?

Ban conversion practices | Stonewall UK

https://stonewall.org.uk/get-involved/campaign-with-us/ban-conversion-practices

noblegiraffe · Today 12:08

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 12:04

... aaand suddenly we are not discussing the draft Conversion Practices Bill again...

We are discussing what Cass said, yes?

Datun · Today 12:11

ArabellaScott · Today 12:08

https://stonewall.org.uk/get-involved/campaign-with-us/ban-conversion-practices

'The Draft Bill adds protections for individuals who identify “as neither male nor female or as not solely male or female” and people who do not have a sexual orientation. This would be the first instance of legal protections for non-binary and asexual people in England and Wales.'

This to me looks extra dodgy. Nobody has looked at it properly, have they?

Is this the first time non binary identity would be put into law?

It's this term 'identify as'.

As we know from here, you never get an actual explanation of what it means.

I can remember being shocked when gender identity was accepted in Canadian legislation without the term gender ever being described or explained. How can you have something in law that isn't defined??

And it baffles me that people are still never nailed down over this. They are never asked to explain exactly what it means. What does it actually mean if you think you're neither a male or a female?

ArabellaScott · Today 12:11

https://stonewall.org.uk/news/ban-conversion-practices-why-we-need-ban-no-exemptions-and-no-excuses

'Conversion practices in religious settings often involve a combination of processes that can range from private or public prayer, to laying of hands. The latter can include a practice described as “beating the homosexuality out of the persons”, often with the use of brooms. '

Is this happening in the UK?

'While not all forms of conversion practices involve violence, even talking therapies are a damaging and degrading practice that leave lasting scars on LGBTQ+ survivors.'

What, all therapies?! 😯

Ban Conversion Practices: Why we need a ban with no exemptions and no excuses | Stonewall UK

https://stonewall.org.uk/news/ban-conversion-practices-why-we-need-ban-no-exemptions-and-no-excuses

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 12:11

ArabellaScott · Today 12:08

https://stonewall.org.uk/get-involved/campaign-with-us/ban-conversion-practices

'The Draft Bill adds protections for individuals who identify “as neither male nor female or as not solely male or female” and people who do not have a sexual orientation. This would be the first instance of legal protections for non-binary and asexual people in England and Wales.'

This to me looks extra dodgy. Nobody has looked at it properly, have they?

Is this the first time non binary identity would be put into law?

I think so. And without definitions, of course.

BiologicalRobot · Today 12:11

I would say so Arabella. The last time non-binary was mentioned was when that American wanted to be legally recognised as such in the UK. Was it for a passport marker?