Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law" - Telegraph article share

290 replies

singthing · Yesterday 07:46

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

Baroness Cass has turned against Labour’s plans for a new conversion therapy law, warning that it would have a “chilling effect” on doctors.

Lady Cass, who led a review of the treatment of children with gender dysphoria, previously backed the Conversion Practices Bill but said she had only been given an hour to read the draft legislation before providing a supportive comment for a government press release in June.

On Monday, she told MPs that she regretted backing it, and having read it through now thought it could have “serious unintended consequences”.
...

Continues at:
^Original: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/16/baroness-cass-turns-against-chilling-trans-law/^
Gift: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2
^Archive: https://archive.ph/rP3Np^

Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
ArabellaScott · Today 12:15

https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-9515/

So, no current recognition, but some moves towards it.

'Current law
No legal recognition
Non-binary genders are not recognised in UK law. The Gender Recognition Act 2004 (GRA) enables a person to change the sex recorded on their birth certificate, either from male to female or vice versa. It makes no provision for the recognition of any other gender.'

'Government position: no change to current law
The Government considers non-binary recognition to be a complex issue (PDF) with many potential knock-on implications for the law and public service provision.
The Government’s 2018 consultation on reform of the GRA (PDF) did not include proposals to extend the GRA to provide legal recognition to a third, or non‑binary, gender. However, it did ask for respondents’ initial views on non‑binary recognition as it relates to the GRA specifically. The Government referred to this as a supplement to its proposed call for evidence exercise.
The Government set out its position (PDF):
The Government wants individuals who identify as non-binary to be able to live discrimination-free lives in accordance with who they believe their true selves to be. We are working to determine what action it may be necessary for Government to take in order to achieve this. However, we are also mindful of the practical consequences for other areas of law and public-service provision referring to the gender binary, if non-binary genders were to be recognised in the GRA.
The Government has since said it does not intend to change the criteria in the GRA for legal recognition. '

Gender Recognition Act 2004

An Act to make provision for and in connection with change of gender.

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2004/7/contents

ArabellaScott · Today 12:16

'Non-binary recognition is a complex issue, though, with many potential knock-on implications for the law and public-service provision. For example, some laws provide for different legal entitlements depending on a person’s gender (e.g. the State Pension age). Public-service provision can also be different depending on a person’s gender (e.g. single-sex hospital wards). Public sector administrative and IT systems generally assume only two genders. If the Government were to recognise a gender other than male or female, it would require consideration as to how this would affect, and be affected by, those gendered laws and services. Substantial changes to legislation may be required to ensure legal and administrative coherence'

From one of the embedded links.

noblegiraffe · Today 12:17

Datun · Today 12:08

Again, I couldn't care less what they think.

It's not gender critical feminists who are sending rape and death threats.

there is no symmetry between the tactics of each side.

The fact that Cass seems to think there is, is a worry.

But that’s you characterising the two ‘sides’ as ‘mad transactivists’ versus ‘peaceful GC feminists’.

Is that a reasonable way to split the people who have opinions on this?

I mean, you have the church wading in against this bill and I’m pretty sure that religious bodies aren’t historically motivated by feminist concerns. Which of the two sides in your split to they fit into?

Another way to split the ‘sides’ is ‘people who believe that trans women are women’ and ‘people who believe that trans women are men’

There are obviously some who see the ‘sides’ that way and have joined forces with people who are definitely not feminists (see Trump) in order to fight the TRA agenda. And there are certainly some extremely unpalatable people who share the view that trans women are men.

Are your ‘sides’ and Cass’s ‘sides’ split in the same way?

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 12:17

ArabellaScott · Today 12:11

https://stonewall.org.uk/news/ban-conversion-practices-why-we-need-ban-no-exemptions-and-no-excuses

'Conversion practices in religious settings often involve a combination of processes that can range from private or public prayer, to laying of hands. The latter can include a practice described as “beating the homosexuality out of the persons”, often with the use of brooms. '

Is this happening in the UK?

'While not all forms of conversion practices involve violence, even talking therapies are a damaging and degrading practice that leave lasting scars on LGBTQ+ survivors.'

What, all therapies?! 😯

I imagine being asked to talk about what you mean when you state that you are now female, when you were born male, or vice versa (or neither) when you have been used to lemming-like affirmation, could be a bit jarring.

As would being asked to explain how exactly one becomes a cat, if you were born human.

You would have to assume you were being threatened or converted, wouldn't you, rather than being asked to answer a simple question or discuss your reasoning?

ArabellaScott · Today 12:18

If non binary became recognised, how the fuck would that affect women's rights? I already see places airily include 'non binary people' in women's services - see the GLP's latest case to include 'transwomen' and 'nonbinary people' in women's sexual assault survivor services.

ArabellaScott · Today 12:19

If they create this third category, how would it impact on the Equality Act?

Nonbinaries are classed as having the pc of gender reassignment.

BettyBooper · Today 12:25

noblegiraffe · Today 12:17

But that’s you characterising the two ‘sides’ as ‘mad transactivists’ versus ‘peaceful GC feminists’.

Is that a reasonable way to split the people who have opinions on this?

I mean, you have the church wading in against this bill and I’m pretty sure that religious bodies aren’t historically motivated by feminist concerns. Which of the two sides in your split to they fit into?

Another way to split the ‘sides’ is ‘people who believe that trans women are women’ and ‘people who believe that trans women are men’

There are obviously some who see the ‘sides’ that way and have joined forces with people who are definitely not feminists (see Trump) in order to fight the TRA agenda. And there are certainly some extremely unpalatable people who share the view that trans women are men.

Are your ‘sides’ and Cass’s ‘sides’ split in the same way?

And yet another way to split 'sides' is those who understand reality and those who don't.

Datun · Today 12:27

ArabellaScott · Today 12:18

If non binary became recognised, how the fuck would that affect women's rights? I already see places airily include 'non binary people' in women's services - see the GLP's latest case to include 'transwomen' and 'nonbinary people' in women's sexual assault survivor services.

It's a nonsense, isn't it.

You could fill up your entire work team with non-binary people, claim it's equality, and they could all be men.

I honestly can't believe anyone is even having this discussion.

Before you talk about legislating for people who are non binary you need to explain what it is.

It would be quite an interesting conversation.

There's quite a few people who would agree that it would be nice to opt out of being stereotyped. I'd like to see the discussion of exactly how that happens if you become non-binary.

Because it doesn't. Everyone still knows that you're male or female.

noblegiraffe · Today 12:27

BettyBooper · Today 12:25

And yet another way to split 'sides' is those who understand reality and those who don't.

I think that is covered by ‘trans women are women’ versus ‘trans women are men’.

Datun · Today 12:27

BettyBooper · Today 12:25

And yet another way to split 'sides' is those who understand reality and those who don't.

Or hair splitters, and get out of my space please.

ScrollingLeaves · Today 12:29

ArabellaScott · Today 12:11

https://stonewall.org.uk/news/ban-conversion-practices-why-we-need-ban-no-exemptions-and-no-excuses

'Conversion practices in religious settings often involve a combination of processes that can range from private or public prayer, to laying of hands. The latter can include a practice described as “beating the homosexuality out of the persons”, often with the use of brooms. '

Is this happening in the UK?

'While not all forms of conversion practices involve violence, even talking therapies are a damaging and degrading practice that leave lasting scars on LGBTQ+ survivors.'

What, all therapies?! 😯

There should have been a full follow up investigation of all these allegations, case by case, with prosecutions through existing law, if warranted, before any bill was proposed.

Presumably all these gay people and trans identifying people are religious otherwise they would not be involved.

What proportion of the gay and of the trans population do those who are religious represent? Are the conversion practices by force of religion carried out more often on certain ethnic groups and is it for being gay or for identifying as trans, or either? Which churches are involved? Where are they?

Are churches/religious parents who are against people being gay, actually converting them by pressure to be trans instead? If so, which ‘conversion’ will the law choose to prosecute?

ArabellaScott · Today 12:32

Datun · Today 12:27

It's a nonsense, isn't it.

You could fill up your entire work team with non-binary people, claim it's equality, and they could all be men.

I honestly can't believe anyone is even having this discussion.

Before you talk about legislating for people who are non binary you need to explain what it is.

It would be quite an interesting conversation.

There's quite a few people who would agree that it would be nice to opt out of being stereotyped. I'd like to see the discussion of exactly how that happens if you become non-binary.

Because it doesn't. Everyone still knows that you're male or female.

My concern is that if nonbinary is recognised, there could be some carve out that said if a man says he's nonbinary he can go where he likes, use women's spaces, etc.

Above all, 'non binary' is completely about 'gender', because it's nothing at all to do with biological sex.

Datun · Today 12:33

ScrollingLeaves · Today 12:29

There should have been a full follow up investigation of all these allegations, case by case, with prosecutions through existing law, if warranted, before any bill was proposed.

Presumably all these gay people and trans identifying people are religious otherwise they would not be involved.

What proportion of the gay and of the trans population do those who are religious represent? Are the conversion practices by force of religion carried out more often on certain ethnic groups and is it for being gay or for identifying as trans, or either? Which churches are involved? Where are they?

Are churches/religious parents who are against people being gay, actually converting them by pressure to be trans instead? If so, which ‘conversion’ will the law choose to prosecute?

Apparently, according to the statistics spouted by TRAs, this would mean that church leaders are performing more exorcisms/conversion practices then they are marriage ceremonies.

It's a load of bollocks.

Datun · Today 12:35

ArabellaScott · Today 12:32

My concern is that if nonbinary is recognised, there could be some carve out that said if a man says he's nonbinary he can go where he likes, use women's spaces, etc.

Above all, 'non binary' is completely about 'gender', because it's nothing at all to do with biological sex.

Exactly. It's the whole fluidity argument. Ladies spaces today, gents tomorrow.

nicepotoftea · Today 12:36

ArabellaScott · Today 12:18

If non binary became recognised, how the fuck would that affect women's rights? I already see places airily include 'non binary people' in women's services - see the GLP's latest case to include 'transwomen' and 'nonbinary people' in women's sexual assault survivor services.

As women who identify as non binary are already included, the goal can only be to increase access for men.

ScrollingLeaves · Today 12:45

@ArabellaScott 12:11
What, all therapies?!😯

re Stonewall statement,
'While not all forms of conversion practices involve violence, even talking therapies are a damaging and degrading practice that leave lasting scars on LGBTQ+ survivors.'
—————————-

From Sex Matters May 2022
“Conversion” therapy or just therapy?

On 23rd May 2022 an article appeared in the i news stating that Dr Az Hakeem was under investigation for attempting to “practise transgender conversion therapy”.

Dr Az Hakeem is a psychiatrist now in private practice after more than 15 years working in the NHS. He is Fellow of the Royal College of Psychiatrists and Honorary Associate Clinical Professor at University College London (UCL) Medical School. He is also gay.

Nancy Kelley, the CEO of Stonewall – the organisation leading the campaign to criminalise gender therapists like Dr Hakeem who take a cautious exploratory approach to therapy with people who want to transition – said: “This is why we need to #BanConversionTherapy”.

Sex Matters sent a summary briefing on the case to MPs on 23rd May, together with a letter and links to other resources, to highlight that Stonewall labels ordinary exploratory therapy as “conversion therapy”.

The article in the i news, in which Dr Hakeem is described as having deployed “coercive strategies”, tells the story of a young woman who suddenly identified as a man at the age of 17. Following an initial Zoom consultation, the patient complained that Dr Hakeem had raised doubts about their male identity and invited reflection on the long-term consequences of medical transition. Specifically, the article states that he:

  • did not restrict the session to the things the patient wanted to talk about
  • tried to explore the reasons for gender dysphoria “and would not accept that it’s because I’m trans”
  • asked the patient to consider whether these recent, intense feelings about gender might be part of a youth subculture, and might fade
  • asked the patient to consider potential negatives and drawbacks to transitioning and the possibility of future change of mind or regret
  • implied it was naïve to say there wouldn’t be “much of a problem” with future relationships.

Dr Hakeem ended the Zoom call after roughly 25 minutes, saying he could not take on the patient because of closed-mindedness.

Activists campaigning to criminalise forms of talk therapy condemned Dr Hakeem’s practice as “torture” and “abuse”. They also condemned the organisation Transgender Trend, which they said recommended him to the patient’s mother when she contacted them with her concerns.

The GMC has now confirmed the complaint is not being investigated. There is nothing in the description of Dr Hakeem’s practice that is abusive or currently against the law. But the “Ban” campaigners want to change this. They say “conversion therapy is torture and has no place in modern Britain”.

sex-matters.org/posts/healthcare/conversion-therapy-or-just-therapy/

ScrollingLeaves · Today 12:50

Datun · Today 12:33

Apparently, according to the statistics spouted by TRAs, this would mean that church leaders are performing more exorcisms/conversion practices then they are marriage ceremonies.

It's a load of bollocks.

Edited

I think the public needs to see real debunking though or it is all believed.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Today 13:05

Janet Murray in the Telegraph:

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/17/baroness-cass-trans-be-kind/

https://archive.ph/OdXkD

SchoolOfCool · Today 13:10

ScrollingLeaves · Today 12:45

@ArabellaScott 12:11
What, all therapies?!😯

re Stonewall statement,
'While not all forms of conversion practices involve violence, even talking therapies are a damaging and degrading practice that leave lasting scars on LGBTQ+ survivors.'
—————————-

From Sex Matters May 2022
“Conversion” therapy or just therapy?

On 23rd May 2022 an article appeared in the i news stating that Dr Az Hakeem was under investigation for attempting to “practise transgender conversion therapy”.

Dr Az Hakeem is a psychiatrist now in private practice after more than 15 years working in the NHS. He is Fellow of the Royal College of Psychiatrists and Honorary Associate Clinical Professor at University College London (UCL) Medical School. He is also gay.

Nancy Kelley, the CEO of Stonewall – the organisation leading the campaign to criminalise gender therapists like Dr Hakeem who take a cautious exploratory approach to therapy with people who want to transition – said: “This is why we need to #BanConversionTherapy”.

Sex Matters sent a summary briefing on the case to MPs on 23rd May, together with a letter and links to other resources, to highlight that Stonewall labels ordinary exploratory therapy as “conversion therapy”.

The article in the i news, in which Dr Hakeem is described as having deployed “coercive strategies”, tells the story of a young woman who suddenly identified as a man at the age of 17. Following an initial Zoom consultation, the patient complained that Dr Hakeem had raised doubts about their male identity and invited reflection on the long-term consequences of medical transition. Specifically, the article states that he:

  • did not restrict the session to the things the patient wanted to talk about
  • tried to explore the reasons for gender dysphoria “and would not accept that it’s because I’m trans”
  • asked the patient to consider whether these recent, intense feelings about gender might be part of a youth subculture, and might fade
  • asked the patient to consider potential negatives and drawbacks to transitioning and the possibility of future change of mind or regret
  • implied it was naïve to say there wouldn’t be “much of a problem” with future relationships.

Dr Hakeem ended the Zoom call after roughly 25 minutes, saying he could not take on the patient because of closed-mindedness.

Activists campaigning to criminalise forms of talk therapy condemned Dr Hakeem’s practice as “torture” and “abuse”. They also condemned the organisation Transgender Trend, which they said recommended him to the patient’s mother when she contacted them with her concerns.

The GMC has now confirmed the complaint is not being investigated. There is nothing in the description of Dr Hakeem’s practice that is abusive or currently against the law. But the “Ban” campaigners want to change this. They say “conversion therapy is torture and has no place in modern Britain”.

sex-matters.org/posts/healthcare/conversion-therapy-or-just-therapy/

It is absolutely flabbergasting that UKCP and BACP ended up so captured! They're quite literally doing themselves out of employment.

ArabellaScott · Today 13:22

If this Bill goes through, unemployment will be the least of it. They'll all be for court.

ArabellaScott · Today 13:22

ScrollingLeaves · Today 12:45

@ArabellaScott 12:11
What, all therapies?!😯

re Stonewall statement,
'While not all forms of conversion practices involve violence, even talking therapies are a damaging and degrading practice that leave lasting scars on LGBTQ+ survivors.'
—————————-

From Sex Matters May 2022
“Conversion” therapy or just therapy?

On 23rd May 2022 an article appeared in the i news stating that Dr Az Hakeem was under investigation for attempting to “practise transgender conversion therapy”.

Dr Az Hakeem is a psychiatrist now in private practice after more than 15 years working in the NHS. He is Fellow of the Royal College of Psychiatrists and Honorary Associate Clinical Professor at University College London (UCL) Medical School. He is also gay.

Nancy Kelley, the CEO of Stonewall – the organisation leading the campaign to criminalise gender therapists like Dr Hakeem who take a cautious exploratory approach to therapy with people who want to transition – said: “This is why we need to #BanConversionTherapy”.

Sex Matters sent a summary briefing on the case to MPs on 23rd May, together with a letter and links to other resources, to highlight that Stonewall labels ordinary exploratory therapy as “conversion therapy”.

The article in the i news, in which Dr Hakeem is described as having deployed “coercive strategies”, tells the story of a young woman who suddenly identified as a man at the age of 17. Following an initial Zoom consultation, the patient complained that Dr Hakeem had raised doubts about their male identity and invited reflection on the long-term consequences of medical transition. Specifically, the article states that he:

  • did not restrict the session to the things the patient wanted to talk about
  • tried to explore the reasons for gender dysphoria “and would not accept that it’s because I’m trans”
  • asked the patient to consider whether these recent, intense feelings about gender might be part of a youth subculture, and might fade
  • asked the patient to consider potential negatives and drawbacks to transitioning and the possibility of future change of mind or regret
  • implied it was naïve to say there wouldn’t be “much of a problem” with future relationships.

Dr Hakeem ended the Zoom call after roughly 25 minutes, saying he could not take on the patient because of closed-mindedness.

Activists campaigning to criminalise forms of talk therapy condemned Dr Hakeem’s practice as “torture” and “abuse”. They also condemned the organisation Transgender Trend, which they said recommended him to the patient’s mother when she contacted them with her concerns.

The GMC has now confirmed the complaint is not being investigated. There is nothing in the description of Dr Hakeem’s practice that is abusive or currently against the law. But the “Ban” campaigners want to change this. They say “conversion therapy is torture and has no place in modern Britain”.

sex-matters.org/posts/healthcare/conversion-therapy-or-just-therapy/

Absolutely horrifying.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 13:23

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Today 13:05

Well, that's Cass pasted!

ArabellaScott · Today 13:25

'“It should never be appropriate for a clinician to actively dissuade a person from transitioning,” a spokesperson for the Royal College of Psychiatrists told i.
“Psychological treatments to suppress or ‘revert’ gender-diverse behaviours… are not grounded in science and therefore unethical and unacceptable forms of treatment.”'

Geeezo.

Pun GIF