Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law" - Telegraph article share

290 replies

singthing · Yesterday 07:46

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

Baroness Cass has turned against Labour’s plans for a new conversion therapy law, warning that it would have a “chilling effect” on doctors.

Lady Cass, who led a review of the treatment of children with gender dysphoria, previously backed the Conversion Practices Bill but said she had only been given an hour to read the draft legislation before providing a supportive comment for a government press release in June.

On Monday, she told MPs that she regretted backing it, and having read it through now thought it could have “serious unintended consequences”.
...

Continues at:
^Original: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/16/baroness-cass-turns-against-chilling-trans-law/^
Gift: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2
^Archive: https://archive.ph/rP3Np^

Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
noblegiraffe · Yesterday 23:53

BettyBooper · Yesterday 23:13

A 10 point drop in IQ! They think it's acceptable to put kids into a trial of a drug that they'll stop if... it gets to more that a 10 point drop in IQ??!

What parent would agree to this?

Fairly desperate ones I imagine.

The IQ thing is because a previous group given puberty blockers suffered a significant decline in IQ but they think that was due to the condition that caused their precocious puberty rather than the blockers.

cryupmykingdom · Today 00:15

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 13:25

Honestly, she strikes me as out of her depth.

Agreed. Dealing with trans activists who lie pretty much whenever they open their mouths, I wouldn't say anything on a topic like this in public without adequate time to read a document, think over it,and if possible, even do a deep-dive into who produced & promoted it, and their bona fides.

There's a lot of these mouth-breathers all over government, NGOs, charities . . . it's best to act as if they are around every corner, sadly.

Emilesgran · Today 06:00

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 22:09

I mean, this is all addressed in the protocol, but are you saying that when the results come out and show significant decline in IQ/impact on brain development/bone density reduction and no significant impact on anxiety/depression compared to the control, will you still be rejecting it as a junk trial with junk results?

But we don’t need to run the trial to find the harms done - those are already known.

It seems ethically very dubious to run a trial where we ALREADY know all that but where there can be no useful evidence of the hoped-for positive effects of the treatment because the protocol can’t measure these?

Emilesgran · Today 06:04

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 23:53

Fairly desperate ones I imagine.

The IQ thing is because a previous group given puberty blockers suffered a significant decline in IQ but they think that was due to the condition that caused their precocious puberty rather than the blockers.

I don’t think that’s proven - puberty itself has a huge effect on the brain and, as with language development, it seems there is a window of time during which that can take place. If puberty is stopped for long enough, it’s very likely that the brain will never become fully adult.

NecessaryScene · Today 06:38

Exactly. Puberty is the process of turning a child into an adult.

The default assumption should be that if your "puberty blocker" does what it claims and appears to do, then you will end up with an adult-aged child, or at least someone child-like.

These drugs are not specifically targetted to be cosmetic "anti-voice-breaking" or "anti-hairiness" drugs, are they? Despite the Dutch protocol using them for that. They're broad-spectrum anti-puberty - the whole package.

That is their original licensed use case - with the block being early enough - for early puberty - that the patient was expected to undergo a normal pubertal period after cessation.

To actually do this to block normal puberty - why on earth wouldn't you expect an IQ drop? (Not an absolute intelligence drop, but a failure to proceed in the normal child-to-adult path.) Along with all sorts of other failure to develop into a normal adult.

Obviously you're not going to end up as 100% child - that would be daft. But it's equally daft to claim you're going to end up 100% adult.

BunnyBunbunbun · Today 06:40

cryupmykingdom · Today 00:15

Agreed. Dealing with trans activists who lie pretty much whenever they open their mouths, I wouldn't say anything on a topic like this in public without adequate time to read a document, think over it,and if possible, even do a deep-dive into who produced & promoted it, and their bona fides.

There's a lot of these mouth-breathers all over government, NGOs, charities . . . it's best to act as if they are around every corner, sadly.

I guess since Cass got the draft bill from a government minister, and one with whom she'd been in contact, she believed the draft bill would be less shoddy. The minister, however, just copied the demands that Stonewall drafted several years ago when the trans grip was at its peak and they started pushing for this bill.

BunnyBunbunbun · Today 07:38

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 23:53

Fairly desperate ones I imagine.

The IQ thing is because a previous group given puberty blockers suffered a significant decline in IQ but they think that was due to the condition that caused their precocious puberty rather than the blockers.

That presupposition could easily be tested by comparing children with precocious puberty on puberty blockers with children with precocious puberty who never took puberty blockers. And it appears that children with precocious puberty who do not take puberty blockers tend to have a higher or normal IQ for their age group. So, it appears that precocious puberty does not lower IQ. It must have been the puberty blockers then.

What Google AI results say:
"Average or higher verbal IQ. Several clinical studies have found that children with idiopathic (no known medical cause) precocious puberty often have normal full-scale IQs and significantly higher verbal IQ scores compared to their peers. Researchers suggest this may be due to early exposure to sex hormones or increased social interaction with older children."

Datun · Today 07:52

Iirc part of the IQ issue was because they tested them on sheep.

They affected their long-term memory permanently, they had altered emotional and stress responses, and postmortem they found that their brains had been significantly changed.

ArabellaScott · Today 08:00

Precocious puberty is just delayed with blockers. The aim of them in gender medecine appears to be to remove puberty altogether. The risible idea that exogenous hormones will put a child through the same.puberty as the opposite sex is just so absurd I dont know where to start.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Today 08:02

For the benefit of those who are entering in good faith into discussions about the puberty blocker trial, please note that noblegiraffe has stated previously that they disagree with children being medicalised for gender dysphoria, but that they don’t think that anyone will stop medicalising until there is good enough data to prove that it is harmful. Noblegiraffe is convinced that the current puberty blocker trial will provide this data, despite many, many people explaining all the ways that the trial is not, in fact, designed in such a way that it will provide such data.

Datun · Today 08:07

ArabellaScott · Today 08:00

Precocious puberty is just delayed with blockers. The aim of them in gender medecine appears to be to remove puberty altogether. The risible idea that exogenous hormones will put a child through the same.puberty as the opposite sex is just so absurd I dont know where to start.

Something that Helen Webberley keeps saying. I've heard her claim several times now that these children go through the puberty of the opposite sex.

It's unbelievable

ArabellaScott · Today 08:08

DrBlackbird · Yesterday 18:34

All too often our ambitious MPs look to find ‘their’ campaigning issue to make a name for themselves. The ambition can easily override any critical thinking. Especially for a hard of thinking MP of which we seem to have an annoying surplus.

Perhaps this was meant to be Olivia’s moment in the sun hence really pushing Baroness (?) Cass hard for a supportive statement. Though the fact that Cass was given so little time to read it suggests Bailey knew it was a poisoned chalice.

I did wonder if it was the potential trouble for doctors specifically that has led to her speaking out ie other medics have spoken to her, but I don’t care about the motivation as long as this helps either kill or permanently stall the bill.

Possibly inevitable due to the make up of the witness groups, but the focus was very much on how the Bill would affect medics. Parents - and indeed children - were barely mentioned.

Nobody seems to be considering the impact on children at all. Its tacitly accepted that the bill will help them.

The basic assertion is that if they get what they want they'll be happier. Its the pester power bill.

Shortshriftandlethal · Today 08:32

Emilesgran · Today 06:00

But we don’t need to run the trial to find the harms done - those are already known.

It seems ethically very dubious to run a trial where we ALREADY know all that but where there can be no useful evidence of the hoped-for positive effects of the treatment because the protocol can’t measure these?

And for any such trial to be meaningful you would have to have a long follow up period...because many don't de-transition or express regret until after about 10 years.

Shortshriftandlethal · Today 08:34

ArabellaScott · Today 08:08

Possibly inevitable due to the make up of the witness groups, but the focus was very much on how the Bill would affect medics. Parents - and indeed children - were barely mentioned.

Nobody seems to be considering the impact on children at all. Its tacitly accepted that the bill will help them.

The basic assertion is that if they get what they want they'll be happier. Its the pester power bill.

Cass thankfully did give a few examples of how parents could be implicated, with real life examples of parents she or her colleagues had encountered.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 08:35

ArabellaScott · Today 08:08

Possibly inevitable due to the make up of the witness groups, but the focus was very much on how the Bill would affect medics. Parents - and indeed children - were barely mentioned.

Nobody seems to be considering the impact on children at all. Its tacitly accepted that the bill will help them.

The basic assertion is that if they get what they want they'll be happier. Its the pester power bill.

The basic assertion is that if they get what they want they'll be happier.

Children are always happier at first, if you say yes to everything they want.

The politicians seem to be blissfully (or willfully) unaware that if you cut up the pear, and the child doesn't want it anymore, you can't put the pear back together again.

noblegiraffe · Today 08:37

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Today 08:02

For the benefit of those who are entering in good faith into discussions about the puberty blocker trial, please note that noblegiraffe has stated previously that they disagree with children being medicalised for gender dysphoria, but that they don’t think that anyone will stop medicalising until there is good enough data to prove that it is harmful. Noblegiraffe is convinced that the current puberty blocker trial will provide this data, despite many, many people explaining all the ways that the trial is not, in fact, designed in such a way that it will provide such data.

Edited

I'm not sure who the fuck you think you are deciding to post my opinions on my behalf as if that somehow means I'm not discussing in good faith?

Please note that you were one of the people trying to tell me that the trial is incorrectly designed but you thought that the comparator group didn't have gender dysphoria so have a little think about why I might be disregarding your opinion.

Some people on FWR really can't handle being disagreed with.

KTheGrey · Today 08:38

Shortshriftandlethal · Today 08:32

And for any such trial to be meaningful you would have to have a long follow up period...because many don't de-transition or express regret until after about 10 years.

And it would have to include those whose co-morbidities have worsened, and who have gone on to end their lives or died as a consequence of medical interventions.

We cannot know without tracking the data and so far this has been avoided.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Today 08:43

noblegiraffe · Today 08:37

I'm not sure who the fuck you think you are deciding to post my opinions on my behalf as if that somehow means I'm not discussing in good faith?

Please note that you were one of the people trying to tell me that the trial is incorrectly designed but you thought that the comparator group didn't have gender dysphoria so have a little think about why I might be disregarding your opinion.

Some people on FWR really can't handle being disagreed with.

I am a random person on the internet with access to the advanced search feature on MN.

I am also a person who apologised to you above when you corrected me.

I’m not convinced it’s me that can’t handle being disagreed with.

noblegiraffe · Today 08:43

Shortshriftandlethal · Today 08:32

And for any such trial to be meaningful you would have to have a long follow up period...because many don't de-transition or express regret until after about 10 years.

Well, that's why they're planning a long-term extension study. But you can't have a follow-up study without an original study.

noblegiraffe · Today 08:45

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Today 08:43

I am a random person on the internet with access to the advanced search feature on MN.

I am also a person who apologised to you above when you corrected me.

I’m not convinced it’s me that can’t handle being disagreed with.

I absolutely can handle being disagreed with. However you deciding to post my opinions on my behalf and trying to tell other people not to talk to me is extremely rude.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Today 08:45

noblegiraffe · Today 08:43

Well, that's why they're planning a long-term extension study. But you can't have a follow-up study without an original study.

Planning. Not yet approved or funded.

The Tavistock planned long term studies too.

The Tavistock started out as a small trial study too.

noblegiraffe · Today 08:51

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Today 08:45

Planning. Not yet approved or funded.

The Tavistock planned long term studies too.

The Tavistock started out as a small trial study too.

"Trial study" and "trial" are not the same thing. Tavistock was a study, this one is a trial. You don't appear to know the difference between a study and a trial.

DrBlackbird · Today 08:56

For the love of god, could the PB study debate please go back to the original thread and not clutter up this one on the conversion bill.

Shortshriftandlethal · Today 08:57

noblegiraffe · Today 08:43

Well, that's why they're planning a long-term extension study. But you can't have a follow-up study without an original study.

The obvious issue with the whole thing is that such a 'study' has already been conducted and many of the harms are already known about ( testimony from clinicians at the Tavistock and from young people who had been through the service)...and there have already been cautionary voices coming out of the U.S from gender clinicians themselves, as well as from past 'patients' who are taking legal actions against their doctors.

The 'harms' that seem to be of most concern for the proponents of the trail are the supposed harms to the feelings and mental health of children not given puberty blockers - as if short term relief from emotional distress is the primary objective. The harms of blocking natural puberty are already known.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 08:57

DrBlackbird · Today 08:56

For the love of god, could the PB study debate please go back to the original thread and not clutter up this one on the conversion bill.

Seconded.