Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law" - Telegraph article share

290 replies

singthing · Yesterday 07:46

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

Baroness Cass has turned against Labour’s plans for a new conversion therapy law, warning that it would have a “chilling effect” on doctors.

Lady Cass, who led a review of the treatment of children with gender dysphoria, previously backed the Conversion Practices Bill but said she had only been given an hour to read the draft legislation before providing a supportive comment for a government press release in June.

On Monday, she told MPs that she regretted backing it, and having read it through now thought it could have “serious unintended consequences”.
...

Continues at:
^Original: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/16/baroness-cass-turns-against-chilling-trans-law/^
Gift: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2
^Archive: https://archive.ph/rP3Np^

Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
janeszebra · Today 08:59

Thirded

noblegiraffe · Today 09:00

Emilesgran · Today 06:04

I don’t think that’s proven - puberty itself has a huge effect on the brain and, as with language development, it seems there is a window of time during which that can take place. If puberty is stopped for long enough, it’s very likely that the brain will never become fully adult.

Which would make the brain imaging data from this trial quite important. This hasn't been looked at before.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Today 09:01

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 08:57

Seconded.

Thirded. And apologies for my earlier derail.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Today 09:02

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Today 09:01

Thirded. And apologies for my earlier derail.

Looks like that should have been fourthed.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Today 09:05

The Telegraph is continuing their push to get the bill ditched:

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/17/labour-trans-law-children-taken-parents/

https://archive.ph/fBkUK

noblegiraffe · Today 09:05

People are determined to trash Cass for supporting this trial 'oh the TRAs must have got to her' and then are surprised when she doesn't support the conversion bill 'oh she must be feeling guilty about supporting the trial' when in fact it is perfectly possible to not assign any hidden motives or shady influence and see her as a woman who is honestly representing her opinions and saying what she thinks is best.

BlueLegume · Today 09:06

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 08:57

Seconded.

Fourthed. Never start their own threads.

Never read the room.

BlueLegume · Today 09:14

noblegiraffe · Today 09:05

People are determined to trash Cass for supporting this trial 'oh the TRAs must have got to her' and then are surprised when she doesn't support the conversion bill 'oh she must be feeling guilty about supporting the trial' when in fact it is perfectly possible to not assign any hidden motives or shady influence and see her as a woman who is honestly representing her opinions and saying what she thinks is best.

Interesting that Olivia Bailey MP when she was the minister proposing the draft bill, did in fact ‘get’ to Baroness . She sold her a tale or version of the bill which when Cass investigated further proved what she had been told by OB was in fact not true. Cass had been press ganged essentially to agree with the bill on false claims by Olivia Bailey. Bailey was a mix of fury and squirming on Monday at the select committee hearing. Not to mention passive aggressive and condescending.

noblegiraffe · Today 09:18

BlueLegume · Today 09:14

Interesting that Olivia Bailey MP when she was the minister proposing the draft bill, did in fact ‘get’ to Baroness . She sold her a tale or version of the bill which when Cass investigated further proved what she had been told by OB was in fact not true. Cass had been press ganged essentially to agree with the bill on false claims by Olivia Bailey. Bailey was a mix of fury and squirming on Monday at the select committee hearing. Not to mention passive aggressive and condescending.

Cass gave her honest opinion based on what she had been told about the bill.

Then she changed her mind, gave her honest opinion on the bill and furthermore pointed out that she hadn't been given honest information previously.

This doesn't suggest a woman with a secret agenda.

BlueLegume · Today 09:25

noblegiraffe · Today 09:18

Cass gave her honest opinion based on what she had been told about the bill.

Then she changed her mind, gave her honest opinion on the bill and furthermore pointed out that she hadn't been given honest information previously.

This doesn't suggest a woman with a secret agenda.

Quite the opposite of an agenda. A very clear explanation and also some harrowing but succinct examples of real life events she is aware of. Bailey behaved appalling IMO. Clearly angry and very snippy with her ‘would that satisfy you’ snarky questioning of Cass. It was a great example of someone so puffed up on their own ego, OB, that when faced with an intelligent experienced scientist with facts, (Cass) they end up looking totally foolish.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 09:28

TwoLoonsAndASprout · Today 09:05

[Helen Joyce] said: “A parent who seeks to convince a child that they aren’t actually a member of the opposite sex or ‘non-binary’ or some other exotic gender, like demi-boy or neutrois, is committing what the bill calls a ‘conversion practice’.
^^
“If the child complains to a teacher, the teacher will have to tell the police or else risk being accused of committing a crime themselves.
[my bold]

And if that teacher is an activist?

A government spokesman said: ...
“Parents reasonably challenging their child’s identity are not abusive conversion practices and are therefore completely out of the scope of our draft bill.

Define "reasonably." Define "challenging."

Shortshriftandlethal · Today 09:32

noblegiraffe · Today 09:05

People are determined to trash Cass for supporting this trial 'oh the TRAs must have got to her' and then are surprised when she doesn't support the conversion bill 'oh she must be feeling guilty about supporting the trial' when in fact it is perfectly possible to not assign any hidden motives or shady influence and see her as a woman who is honestly representing her opinions and saying what she thinks is best.

I think she's caught in a bind of her own creation. She knows of the failings and the issues with what went on the Tavistock, but she still wants to believe that there are still a few 'genuine trans' children for whom the harms caused by blocking their natural puberty are outweighed by the short term boost to mental health, and their propsect of living as 'the other gender' for the rest of their life ( never mind that pronouns are not compulsory and that 'trans' people cannot legally use facilities that are intended for the other sex); yet she is also still clinically experienced and professional and can see the obvious pitfalls in the draft legislation.

ArabellaScott · Today 09:33

KTheGrey · Today 08:38

And it would have to include those whose co-morbidities have worsened, and who have gone on to end their lives or died as a consequence of medical interventions.

We cannot know without tracking the data and so far this has been avoided.

Not so much avoided as hidden, really. Given that the existing follow up data may still be held by adult clinics who just refused to share it. For some reason.

*edited for use of insensitive term given context

womendeserveequalhumanrights · Today 09:33

It's good Cass has been honest, she has some integrity.

It's not great to think people paid a lot of money from the public purse only look at something for 15 minutes before pronouncing publicly on it. But she's admitted her failure here, which is important and good and sunlight.

However, I'm sick of the 'both sides' aspect. That's like saying there's 'both sides' to the treatment of women and girls in Afghanistan. Women just want their sex-based rights, there is no-one with any influence whatsoever who is against anyone with a gender identity having equal human rights to everyone else and perpetuating this myth that both sides are as bad as each other is causing harm. It's not GC women who are sending death threats, it's only from one side and it's about time she was honest about that too.

But, presumably she likes her nice influential job and the perks. It's interesting also that the focus is the impact on doctors (I know that's her area of expertise) - the upper class - rather than the often already very disadvantaged children who will suffer from this the most. After all, doctors can just not work in this area, as can therapists and even teachers can essentially go 'low contact' with anyone where they believe there's a risk of denunciation if they put a foot wrong (like normal pronouns). If the bill goes through, no teacher will now befriend them, children will be scared to befriend them, no adult will be willing to have those difficult conversations that are needed sometimes to safeguard children including their parents who love them the most. Parental alienation will be encouraged by the state - it's truly dystopian and, as usual, it'll affect the already worst off and most vulnerable the most.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 09:38

womendeserveequalhumanrights · Today 09:33

It's good Cass has been honest, she has some integrity.

It's not great to think people paid a lot of money from the public purse only look at something for 15 minutes before pronouncing publicly on it. But she's admitted her failure here, which is important and good and sunlight.

However, I'm sick of the 'both sides' aspect. That's like saying there's 'both sides' to the treatment of women and girls in Afghanistan. Women just want their sex-based rights, there is no-one with any influence whatsoever who is against anyone with a gender identity having equal human rights to everyone else and perpetuating this myth that both sides are as bad as each other is causing harm. It's not GC women who are sending death threats, it's only from one side and it's about time she was honest about that too.

But, presumably she likes her nice influential job and the perks. It's interesting also that the focus is the impact on doctors (I know that's her area of expertise) - the upper class - rather than the often already very disadvantaged children who will suffer from this the most. After all, doctors can just not work in this area, as can therapists and even teachers can essentially go 'low contact' with anyone where they believe there's a risk of denunciation if they put a foot wrong (like normal pronouns). If the bill goes through, no teacher will now befriend them, children will be scared to befriend them, no adult will be willing to have those difficult conversations that are needed sometimes to safeguard children including their parents who love them the most. Parental alienation will be encouraged by the state - it's truly dystopian and, as usual, it'll affect the already worst off and most vulnerable the most.

If the bill goes through, no teacher will now befriend them,

There will be plenty of adults ready and willing to "befriend" these vulnerable children. And no sensible, safe adults will be around to help, because, as you say, they'll be staying well clear of the whole thing.

Shortshriftandlethal · Today 09:43

At the end of the day what is a 'genuine' trans person and how can that be measured and determined?

  1. Does it depend on the length of time one maintains a trans identity? ( and can that ever be realistically measured by a study that is meant to inform future practice?)

  2. Does it depend on a short term boost to mental health and accompanyng feelings of euphoria?

  3. Are those that de-transition or experience continuing mental distress not 'genuinely trans'? (After all we keep getting told how poor the mental health is of trans people and how much they find life to be a terrible struggle; how vulnerable they are. Can people be 'happily trans' in a world which doesn't recognise their correct pronouns or permit them entry into opposite sex categories?)

noblegiraffe · Today 09:46

It's not GC women who are sending death threats, it's only from one side and it's about time she was honest about that too.

Thing is, there are definitely transphobes out there. I've seen some fairly horrendous comments on twitter (and on MN too tbh) targeting trans people. There was that video of that guy harassing that trans woman who was just sat on a bench (condemned on MN but that doesn't mean it didn't happen). Are you sure that there aren't any transphobes aren't out there sending death or rape threats? It seems vanishingly unlikely to me given how many death and rape threats are sent to women for merely existing in a public space.

I'm not saying that it's GC women who are sending them, but if there are 'two sides' in this debate, then there is clearly poor behaviour on 'both sides' even if a subgroup condemns and distances itself from that behaviour.

Datun · Today 09:47

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Today 09:28

[Helen Joyce] said: “A parent who seeks to convince a child that they aren’t actually a member of the opposite sex or ‘non-binary’ or some other exotic gender, like demi-boy or neutrois, is committing what the bill calls a ‘conversion practice’.
^^
“If the child complains to a teacher, the teacher will have to tell the police or else risk being accused of committing a crime themselves.
[my bold]

And if that teacher is an activist?

A government spokesman said: ...
“Parents reasonably challenging their child’s identity are not abusive conversion practices and are therefore completely out of the scope of our draft bill.

Define "reasonably." Define "challenging."

Quite. It's infuriating that they think people can't see this.

ItsCoolForCats · Today 09:49

The bill will be discussed on Politics Live on BBC 2 at 11.15 today. Sonia Sodha will be on the panel. I don't know who else. Hopefully not Samantha Niblett 🤣

Datun · Today 09:52

noblegiraffe · Today 09:46

It's not GC women who are sending death threats, it's only from one side and it's about time she was honest about that too.

Thing is, there are definitely transphobes out there. I've seen some fairly horrendous comments on twitter (and on MN too tbh) targeting trans people. There was that video of that guy harassing that trans woman who was just sat on a bench (condemned on MN but that doesn't mean it didn't happen). Are you sure that there aren't any transphobes aren't out there sending death or rape threats? It seems vanishingly unlikely to me given how many death and rape threats are sent to women for merely existing in a public space.

I'm not saying that it's GC women who are sending them, but if there are 'two sides' in this debate, then there is clearly poor behaviour on 'both sides' even if a subgroup condemns and distances itself from that behaviour.

Men sending death threats are not gender critical women.

There are plenty of aggressive people who object to cross-dressing men in public. They're generally not the people trying to maintain women's rights.

MrsOvertonsWindow · Today 09:54

Have a look at the leader in the Times about the bill. It's furious:

"The bill is a sinister, shoddy and unnecessary piece of work, a Trojan horse for the widely discredited cause of the extreme trans lobby"

https://archive.ph/0suqo

https://www.thetimes.com/comment/the-times-view/article/conversion-practices-bill-sledgehammer-nut-wd670qdqh

Verifying Device

https://www.thetimes.com/comment/the-times-view/article/conversion-practices-bill-sledgehammer-nut-wd670qdqh

ArabellaScott · Today 09:56

A sledgehammer to crack a non existent nut, frankly.

Although all nut cracking analogies risk being too close to the bone. So to speak.

Shortshriftandlethal · Today 09:58

noblegiraffe · Today 09:46

It's not GC women who are sending death threats, it's only from one side and it's about time she was honest about that too.

Thing is, there are definitely transphobes out there. I've seen some fairly horrendous comments on twitter (and on MN too tbh) targeting trans people. There was that video of that guy harassing that trans woman who was just sat on a bench (condemned on MN but that doesn't mean it didn't happen). Are you sure that there aren't any transphobes aren't out there sending death or rape threats? It seems vanishingly unlikely to me given how many death and rape threats are sent to women for merely existing in a public space.

I'm not saying that it's GC women who are sending them, but if there are 'two sides' in this debate, then there is clearly poor behaviour on 'both sides' even if a subgroup condemns and distances itself from that behaviour.

Random people on -line sending abusive messages is in the nature of internet culture - but it is not inherent in the nature of 'gender critical' perspectives.

singthing · Today 10:02

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 16:50

The trouble, I would say, is that 'the medical world' includes the plastic surgery industry, which sees 'gender affirming care' as a fantastic money spinner and a growth market.

https://www.researchandmarkets.com/reports/6168609/gender-reassignment-surgery-market-report

'The gender reassignment surgery market size has grown strongly in recent years. It will grow from $1.93 billion in 2025 to $2.11 billion in 2026 at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 9.3%. The growth in the historic period can be attributed to increasing recognition of gender dysphoria, expansion of specialized surgical expertise, growing acceptance of gender-affirming healthcare, availability of advanced surgical techniques, rising awareness through advocacy and education.'

An interesting sidenote about this report. I have direct experience with this very company. They are a report factory who will produce research on anything you like, and in their marketing blurb, they mention how they will add "10% customisation" according to your wishes. Essentially that means they will add in content that suits your narrative as the purchaser. That add-on worked very well for my then-employer in our sales and marketing efforts!

So the existence of this report means someone somewhere wanted an official-looking piece of research that explicitly showed how large and fast-growing the market was, and how financially lucrative it is. Quite an odd thing to want to peacock about, I would have thought. Unless you have a vested interest in keeping the production line of bodies coming.

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · Today 10:06

Shortshriftandlethal · Today 09:58

Random people on -line sending abusive messages is in the nature of internet culture - but it is not inherent in the nature of 'gender critical' perspectives.

Edited

I didn't say it was.

But there are definitely people out there throwing abuse at trans people, so to suggest that only 'one side' (GC women) are receiving death threats and only one side (TRAs) are sending them is probably incorrect.