Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law" - Telegraph article share

320 replies

singthing · 17/11/2026 07:46

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

Baroness Cass has turned against Labour’s plans for a new conversion therapy law, warning that it would have a “chilling effect” on doctors.

Lady Cass, who led a review of the treatment of children with gender dysphoria, previously backed the Conversion Practices Bill but said she had only been given an hour to read the draft legislation before providing a supportive comment for a government press release in June.

On Monday, she told MPs that she regretted backing it, and having read it through now thought it could have “serious unintended consequences”.
...

Continues at:
^Original: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/16/baroness-cass-turns-against-chilling-trans-law/^
Gift: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2
^Archive: https://archive.ph/rP3Np^

Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law

Doctor who led gender services review says legislation could have ‘serious unintended consequences’

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/85511695057ccef2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Ereshkigalangcleg · Yesterday 20:03

I’d like to see Stonewall asked to defend Nancy Kelley comparing lesbians who don’t want to sleep with men to racists, because that sure does sound like a potentially “harmful conversion practice” under this Bill.

https://gendercriticalwoman.blog/2022/08/14/nancy-kelley-womans-hour/

Nancy Kelley: Woman’s Hour

As promised this is a record of Nancy Kelley’s interview with Emma Barnett. You can listen to it here: Nancy Kelley Here is a transcript. Nancy Kelley WH interview 18th Nov 2021 The interview opens…

https://gendercriticalwoman.blog/2022/08/14/nancy-kelley-womans-hour/

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 20:04

CassOle · Yesterday 19:46

I don't know why, but I have a vague memory that it was a set-up, and that the patient who accused Dr H had gone there with the express intention of gaining evidence to submit a complaint.

That surely would come under the category of Things That Would Never Happen.

womendeserveequalhumanrights · Yesterday 20:06

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 18:37

No, I’m saying that the ‘side’ that Cass is referring to is bigger than just GC feminists.

But when she talks about 'sides' it's pretty clearly in terms of affirmative / trans women are literally women vs non-purely-affirmative/ reality matters / trans women are biological males.

Those are the two sides in relation to this bill and the reason it's a problem is because only one side will weaponise it, so it's not 'both sides'. Ever heard of someone sacked merely for thinking 'trans' is a thing and for stating that out loud? Nope, there isn't one.

CassOle · Yesterday 20:06

Yep, definitely could never, ever happen.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 20:06

ScrollingLeaves · Yesterday 20:02

In her position I’d be angry at that stealing what I’d said, and repeating it out of context.

Maybe she'll sue. 🍿

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 20:09

Ereshkigalangcleg · Yesterday 20:03

I’d like to see Stonewall asked to defend Nancy Kelley comparing lesbians who don’t want to sleep with men to racists, because that sure does sound like a potentially “harmful conversion practice” under this Bill.

https://gendercriticalwoman.blog/2022/08/14/nancy-kelley-womans-hour/

Oh, yes. If the Bill does pass, I can see many of us on FWR using the new law to its fullest extent. We have our protected beliefs, after all, just as those who believe they have changed sex do.

I am making a list of all the things I will not be converted into.

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 20:11

womendeserveequalhumanrights · Yesterday 20:06

But when she talks about 'sides' it's pretty clearly in terms of affirmative / trans women are literally women vs non-purely-affirmative/ reality matters / trans women are biological males.

Those are the two sides in relation to this bill and the reason it's a problem is because only one side will weaponise it, so it's not 'both sides'. Ever heard of someone sacked merely for thinking 'trans' is a thing and for stating that out loud? Nope, there isn't one.

If the other side aren't considering 'weaponising' it to shut down organisations who try to groom children into thinking that they're trans, then they'd be missing a trick, wouldn't they?

womendeserveequalhumanrights · Yesterday 20:12

Ereshkigalangcleg · Yesterday 20:03

I’d like to see Stonewall asked to defend Nancy Kelley comparing lesbians who don’t want to sleep with men to racists, because that sure does sound like a potentially “harmful conversion practice” under this Bill.

https://gendercriticalwoman.blog/2022/08/14/nancy-kelley-womans-hour/

Well, yes.

The problem is that we know lesbians who don't want to consider men who identify as trans as potential partners will get shown the door if they report to police. Violent men who are cross their wives won't enthusiastically embrace their new enforced lesbian identity on the other hand tend to get a more sympathetic hearing.

Everyone's already been scared to speak up for years, Forstater and particularly FWS has turned that around a bit. This is an attempt to scare people anew.

womendeserveequalhumanrights · Yesterday 20:19

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 20:11

If the other side aren't considering 'weaponising' it to shut down organisations who try to groom children into thinking that they're trans, then they'd be missing a trick, wouldn't they?

Name the amount of public money 'trans' organisations get vs sex realist organisations. It's Goliath vs David.

Even now, even now the importance of sex for safeguarding is recognised in KCSIE.

Children have been harmed. The fact this bill did not listen to detransitioners tells you everything you need to know about those promoting it. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/08/trans-people-who-regret-decision-shut-out-debate-bill/
Trans people who regret decision shut out of debate on bill

ScrollingLeaves · Yesterday 20:26

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 20:11

If the other side aren't considering 'weaponising' it to shut down organisations who try to groom children into thinking that they're trans, then they'd be missing a trick, wouldn't they?

Well I don’t think they, the ‘other side’, are organising to shut down places that groom children into thinking they are trans. Think of all the schools, the PSHE providers, the publishers, and drag queens being hired for story telling. People in the government itself wanting all this.

How stupid [of me at least] to have been lulled into thinking Stonewall had been debunked and was more or less a thing of the past with a more reasonable head in charge.

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 20:38

womendeserveequalhumanrights · Yesterday 20:19

Name the amount of public money 'trans' organisations get vs sex realist organisations. It's Goliath vs David.

Even now, even now the importance of sex for safeguarding is recognised in KCSIE.

Children have been harmed. The fact this bill did not listen to detransitioners tells you everything you need to know about those promoting it. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/08/trans-people-who-regret-decision-shut-out-debate-bill/
Trans people who regret decision shut out of debate on bill

Tbf I think JK Rowling has quite deep pockets.

But, in terms of David and Goliath, the 'sex realist' side had something incredibly powerful in their favour - the law. And while the trans organisations had the money, that didn't help overturn the legal definition of 'woman', despite their best efforts.

Groups have certainly mobilised to enforce that law, haven't they?

womendeserveequalhumanrights · Yesterday 20:42

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 20:38

Tbf I think JK Rowling has quite deep pockets.

But, in terms of David and Goliath, the 'sex realist' side had something incredibly powerful in their favour - the law. And while the trans organisations had the money, that didn't help overturn the legal definition of 'woman', despite their best efforts.

Groups have certainly mobilised to enforce that law, haven't they?

JKR is one person and she's not funded by the state. The trans side has been funded by taxpayer money.

Lots of people and organisations have totally ignored FWS. Did you not notice that nurses were still being compelled to undress in front of males? That they had to go to court to get their right, in law, to a single sex changing room upheld? Post FWS?

Also, this is the harm Four-year-old boy allowed to join school as a girl is no Grimm fairytale but a real-life nightmare

This 'trans' child has been harmed along with his friends, and all of them have lost friends because of the lie forced on to them - all of them - by adults. All of them emotionally and mentally harmed. By adults who should know better about child development.

And yet this Bill would mean that any children over 10 (so primary aged children in years 5 and 6) who spoke up at all about the fact there is a child with a penis in what is supposed to be a single sex female toilet could be prosecuted.

womendeserveequalhumanrights · Yesterday 20:47

Until FWS, which only happened 2 years ago (ish), everyone was assuming any man who said the magic words had access to women's spaces and sports and staying overnight with the girl guides if he volunteered (without parents being informed).

So no, sex realists haven't always had the courts and the weight of the law on their side because everyone was ignoring the law or pretending it was different to reality (funny that) and even now they do, lots are ignoring it anyway.

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 20:55

Hard to believe women are having to explain on a parenting site that the trans lobby has been excessively funded (so much from the public purse) to pursue their campaign to remove women's rights and facilitate child transition. Isn't it odd how some wilfully ignore the stream of concrete evidence of intimidation, bullying and threats along with endless women and some men who've lost careers, opportunities for work and been vilified by the bullies.

Thank heavens for one wealthy woman who already funds so much good in the world, being prepared to help try to redress the balance.

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 21:29

womendeserveequalhumanrights · Yesterday 20:47

Until FWS, which only happened 2 years ago (ish), everyone was assuming any man who said the magic words had access to women's spaces and sports and staying overnight with the girl guides if he volunteered (without parents being informed).

So no, sex realists haven't always had the courts and the weight of the law on their side because everyone was ignoring the law or pretending it was different to reality (funny that) and even now they do, lots are ignoring it anyway.

Sure they have been ignoring the law, and some are continuing to ignore the law.

But the law isn't on their side. How is it going in countries where the law is on their side? All I'm saying is that it's pretty important.

potterypieces · Yesterday 21:45

The trans lobby is a global campaign with global funders.

BiologicalRobot · Yesterday 21:47

I read that as global fuckers.

TempestTost · Yesterday 23:40

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 21:29

Sure they have been ignoring the law, and some are continuing to ignore the law.

But the law isn't on their side. How is it going in countries where the law is on their side? All I'm saying is that it's pretty important.

Yeah, it's huge. Here in Canada we are fucked, it's really debatable whether any legal progress can be made.

ScrollingLeaves · Today 00:12

womendeserveequalhumanrights · Yesterday 20:42

JKR is one person and she's not funded by the state. The trans side has been funded by taxpayer money.

Lots of people and organisations have totally ignored FWS. Did you not notice that nurses were still being compelled to undress in front of males? That they had to go to court to get their right, in law, to a single sex changing room upheld? Post FWS?

Also, this is the harm Four-year-old boy allowed to join school as a girl is no Grimm fairytale but a real-life nightmare

This 'trans' child has been harmed along with his friends, and all of them have lost friends because of the lie forced on to them - all of them - by adults. All of them emotionally and mentally harmed. By adults who should know better about child development.

And yet this Bill would mean that any children over 10 (so primary aged children in years 5 and 6) who spoke up at all about the fact there is a child with a penis in what is supposed to be a single sex female toilet could be prosecuted.

That is a horrible story, and enraging.

It is good the parents have spoken about the very harmful psychological and emotional effects this lying had on the lied-to children.

Inclusive seems to mean excluding all the normal children because they don’t matter as much as one trans child
This is true. What’s more, that one ‘trans’ child has been abused by his parents. He is like the hypothetical child Dr Cass mentioned.

What has happened to the Church of England? This is apparently their guidance:

“The protected characteristic of gender reassignment only works one way – not being transgender is not a protected characteristic. Consequently, schools can make adjustments to meet the needs of a trans pupil without being accused of discriminating against non-trans pupils.”

I think ‘Not being transgender is a protected characteristic in the Equality Act. The one called Sex.

womendeserveequalhumanrights · Today 00:58

TempestTost · Yesterday 23:40

Yeah, it's huge. Here in Canada we are fucked, it's really debatable whether any legal progress can be made.

But the point of this bill is to overturn those legal advances in the UK. That's the point of it. To go back to what went before, denunciation and struggle session.

Those invested in undermining safeguarding will be able to report a conversation as a crime - that carries far more weight than anything EA2010 or even safeguarding related. And will have a chilling effect on safeguarding because this relies on people raising concerns and they won't if it risks a 5 year prison sentence / the threat of this. It's already the case that people don't speak up on safeguarding for fear of losing their job often. This is worse.

It's happened already here to some extent - listen to Julie Bindels Julie in Genderland for what parents were put through by schools and social services before a bit of sanity returned with the new KCSIE etc

None of the proposed bill is in children's best interests, it totally ignores the facts of child development and safeguarding guidance and law. It adultifies children. Deliberately so IMO.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page