Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Pingponghavoc · 15/11/2026 20:32

People call their step father Dad, to recognise the role he plays - 'hes not my biological father, but hes Dad to me , he took me to all of my hockey matches'. He's a father because he parents a child.

Does that follow for woman? 'Hes not a biological woman, but hes a woman to me, because he ???' What role is 'woman'?

toomanytrees · 15/11/2026 21:19

The OP's argument seems to be that if transwomen at population level have upper body strength, rates of criminality and rates of suicidality in the female range then all transwomen are women gender. This is a weak argument because individuals can vary within the population.

What is interesting is that the argument doesn't mention physical attributes. Arguing that a man who cuts off his genitals and wears lipstick must be a woman, no longer works. (The "phenotypically female" argument was quickly rejected). The lady brain argument has got a lot of push back. The OP has acknowledged she/he is talking about gender, not sex.

So the arguments are getting more and more convoluted and but no more convincing.

ArabellaScott · 15/11/2026 21:26

BlueLegume · 15/11/2026 18:55

This, completely.

The need to get into women’s spaces is sickening. We have repeatedly said live as you wish. We tolerate your costume version of woman because we have no choice. But please stay out of women’s spaces and for goodness sakes realise some of your movement have been messing with children.

It is purely males with power and privilege taking the rights that women fought for in order to achieve a more equitable society.

Wild how 'cultural appropriation' became verboten at exactly the same time as women's culture became something that was to be handed over to men for their gratification.

And among all the endless whanging on about power and hierarchy and privilege, we were told over and over that this subset of men were not actually privileged but were the most marginalised. Based on their inner feelings. And we were the bastards for questioning it.

TempestTost · 15/11/2026 22:02

That there was some real sense, medically, in which people were really the opposite sex.

And that transitioning had positive outcomes for those people.

WaterThyme · 15/11/2026 23:13

I already did change my mind.

Although I’m a solid second wave feminist, I was mildly sympathetic and curious while not thinking through the implications. Then an old friend came out to me as transgender. He assured me he had felt like that since he was a child. I listened as his accounts of how he felt never sounded like a woman at all. Things like “ you know, those evenings on your own when you just want to put on a bit of slap”. No, I don’t know, and if he’d ever bothered to look at me he’d have noticed I never wore makeup.

The one time I did see him in “woman” mode put the tin lid on it. Made up, flicking his hair and wearing clothes from his mother’s generation. A costume. Still behaving just like a man.

I started thinking more, reading more and realised that the word Woman belongs to biological women and mustn’t be blurred.

What changed my mind was knowing a man who claimed to be trans.

PeachyDaisy · 16/11/2026 05:34

I think it is a little closed minded to say there is nothing could possibly change your mind. For me, If science was able to change a man into a woman in every single way then I would change my mine.

I know everyone talks about safety but to me that is only part of the equation. The other part is the comfort and dignity of knowing you are sharing a same with someone of your own sex, which is equally as important.

Dragonasaurus · 16/11/2026 06:36

PeachyDaisy · 16/11/2026 05:34

I think it is a little closed minded to say there is nothing could possibly change your mind. For me, If science was able to change a man into a woman in every single way then I would change my mine.

I know everyone talks about safety but to me that is only part of the equation. The other part is the comfort and dignity of knowing you are sharing a same with someone of your own sex, which is equally as important.

Edited

For me, science would have to change a man into a woman in every single way, including all of his memories, experience and socialisation. At that point, philosophically speaking, is he even the same person he was before?

Pingponghavoc · 16/11/2026 07:17

Even if a 50 year old man could change his body in such a way to be 'female', he still has all of the advantages of a man up to that point and non of experiences of being a girl or young woman.

Its still, in many ways, a cosmetic and external change. He'd be a man in a womans body, (rather than the woman in a mans body he might have claimed before his transition)

Helleofabore · 16/11/2026 07:22

Dragonasaurus · 16/11/2026 06:36

For me, science would have to change a man into a woman in every single way, including all of his memories, experience and socialisation. At that point, philosophically speaking, is he even the same person he was before?

I know, right.

That is where my Star Trek transporter style answer shows up the next level of incoherency. Because for a man to truly be able to change sex, including removing every stimuli that formed his reactions to the world around him as a male person, would he then grow up happy as that female person he said he always was?

It will never be possible to achieve.

But apparently, all it is supposed to take (as per our experts on MN FWR) is a male person recognising themselves as being ‘female’.

And we all witnessed a male poster who spent thread upon thread telling us about being ‘phenotypically’ female while never once explaining how or posting any usable paper that explained how that happened. He ended up like another male poster earlier in the year did in making statements about being ‘near enough’ to female to claim being female. As if that was not hugely fucking misogynistic to see two men agree on FWR that being ‘near enough’ to being female is ‘good enough’ to claim being female.

And then you get the existential quagmire of ‘recognising that you are female ‘ when that expert cannot then give any credible explanation how that is even possible? How the fuck does that male person know that what they are describing as being the source of being ‘female’ is not just another variation of male, which is more possible than the amorphous and impossible ‘recognition of being female’ when you are male.

It cannot be explained. So it takes on a spiritual aspect.

2021x · 16/11/2026 07:33

toomanytrees · 15/11/2026 21:19

The OP's argument seems to be that if transwomen at population level have upper body strength, rates of criminality and rates of suicidality in the female range then all transwomen are women gender. This is a weak argument because individuals can vary within the population.

What is interesting is that the argument doesn't mention physical attributes. Arguing that a man who cuts off his genitals and wears lipstick must be a woman, no longer works. (The "phenotypically female" argument was quickly rejected). The lady brain argument has got a lot of push back. The OP has acknowledged she/he is talking about gender, not sex.

So the arguments are getting more and more convoluted and but no more convincing.

That is not my argument at all.

I am examining my own reasoning as to why I believe that transgender people cannot not opt into a gender as gender is a social expressing of sex determined by the culture.

None of what I have said is to use in a debate but I am challenging my own assumptions and seeing if I am on the right path.

Tim Minchin said to take your opinions on to the verandah and hit them around with a cricket bat to see how strong they are. The most frustrating conversations I have are with people who haven't done that which is how we have ended up in this mess.

OP posts:
nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 07:42

My core belief is that women need sex specific rights.

If humans evolve into a different species that no longer reproduces sexually, those rights won’t be necessary, but that would take a while and we would all be dead.

2021x · 16/11/2026 07:44

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 15/11/2026 13:09

Until you stop seeing trans people in the abstract and setting conditions for them to be allowed to exist, you won't view them as human individuals.

Trans people owe you nothing.

I honestly don’t understand what that means.

Transgender people are existing openly more in the last 10 years in western society more than they ever have.

The brainwashing in the community is appalling.

OP posts:
Igneococcus · 16/11/2026 08:04

2021x · 16/11/2026 07:33

That is not my argument at all.

I am examining my own reasoning as to why I believe that transgender people cannot not opt into a gender as gender is a social expressing of sex determined by the culture.

None of what I have said is to use in a debate but I am challenging my own assumptions and seeing if I am on the right path.

Tim Minchin said to take your opinions on to the verandah and hit them around with a cricket bat to see how strong they are. The most frustrating conversations I have are with people who haven't done that which is how we have ended up in this mess.

If this is about gender not sex, why is your very first point (upper body strength) all about a characteristic that is down to sex not gender?

Pingponghavoc · 16/11/2026 08:10

As a forum, we've discussed every aspect of trans ideology and the impacts on women and girls, none of it isnt thought out and examined.

The idea of a man being able to be socially a woman was discussed here in 2013. We understand how therapy works, the legal process, how its taught in schools, why women and girls are damaged in ways men arent, both as trans identifying people and feminists.

Many women have been sympathetic in thf past, but have analysed their way into being GC.

cryupmykingdom · 16/11/2026 08:15

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 15/11/2026 13:14

Trans people existing doesn't affect your life in the slightest.

Minorities don't owe you an obedient, grateful performance before you grant them basic respect.

Trans people - every one of them an individual with a different background, a tiny minority among a huge global cis population - will keep being born, living, getting jobs, having kids and enduring violence for simply being themselves. Without needing to consult you first.

Stop trying to enter spaces for the sex that you'll never be, and we'll be good, fam.

Unisex loos are there for a reason.

Pingponghavoc · 16/11/2026 08:21

The orginal list assumes we can determine which men are not a physical threat to women, and allow those men to be women.

I dont think thats possible, it also means that women are forced to trust the process, not their eyes or experience.

Emilesgran · 16/11/2026 08:31

Pingponghavoc · 16/11/2026 08:21

The orginal list assumes we can determine which men are not a physical threat to women, and allow those men to be women.

I dont think thats possible, it also means that women are forced to trust the process, not their eyes or experience.

And nor does it consider WHY we should be expected to do that anyway. Because sone men want it? Lots of people want stuff.

If I want to be African because I like their hair, I can get my hair curled but I can’t (reasonably) tell African people they’re bigots if they don’t agree to count me as an African woman.

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 08:33

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 15/11/2026 13:06

Fairly simple: you'd have to stop seeing trans people as entities, and get to know them as individual human beings.

Same way a child gets to see a stranger, brought into their lives as their mum's boyfriend, as their dad.

Edited

That is a very odd comparison.

teawamutu · 16/11/2026 09:06

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 08:33

That is a very odd comparison.

As the old legal adage goes: "If you have the facts on your side, pound the facts; if you have the law on your side, pound the law; if you have neither the facts nor the law, pound the table."

cryupmykingdom · 16/11/2026 09:23

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 08:33

That is a very odd comparison.

Six tubby, pasty-looking autism case-studies screaming in an adult playpen in Oxford Street ?

You prove why I should want to get to know them.

Then she'll be sweet!

*and while we're at it, half the world never sees their mum's boyfriend as their dad

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 09:24

DeanElderberry · 15/11/2026 15:53

Good - I hope that means you have learned something.

Revealing that reason and explanation and humane argument were never going to matter.

Revealing to see so many people announce that no fact, evidence or lived experience could ever reach them.

I’d been told these were ‘just reasonable concerns.’ Turns out they’re unfalsifiable. That’s not a concern; that’s a creed

spannasaurus · 16/11/2026 09:26

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 09:24

Revealing that reason and explanation and humane argument were never going to matter.

Revealing to see so many people announce that no fact, evidence or lived experience could ever reach them.

I’d been told these were ‘just reasonable concerns.’ Turns out they’re unfalsifiable. That’s not a concern; that’s a creed

Edited

What would it take to change your mind?

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 09:28

spannasaurus · 16/11/2026 09:26

What would it take to change your mind?

Reason and evidence of course. Like any rational/ reasonable person.

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 09:29

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 09:24

Revealing that reason and explanation and humane argument were never going to matter.

Revealing to see so many people announce that no fact, evidence or lived experience could ever reach them.

I’d been told these were ‘just reasonable concerns.’ Turns out they’re unfalsifiable. That’s not a concern; that’s a creed

Edited

What am I supposed to be changing my opinion on?

As I said before, aside from some kind of evolutionary leap that enables humans to reproduce asexually (which I think would be a new species), women will always need sex based rights and these will always need to be protected in law.

What are you suggesting instead?

bellinisurge · 16/11/2026 09:30

Crybullying didn’t work. Then I woke up to the misogyny and homophobia. Nothing is going to put me back to sleep