Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
PermanentTemporary · 15/11/2026 16:44

BlueLegume · 15/11/2026 16:15

Whilst I was always sceptical about the explosion in trans I definitely started to pay more attention once I realised the extent to which children had been used. I say used because I see it now as a way the bad faith actors such as Sam Hall and Helen Webberly and the GIDs staff and Tavistock Clinic saw kids as a way to legitimately change societies view of trans. Bringing it in their minds as some wholly natural and to be celebrated. The reality is this whole movement is dark and no where near healthy or natural.

Going for the children shone and continues to shine a light on how nefarious a movement this is.

As for Lacksie - we are telling you nothing new on here as we have not on other threads and there are many new posters who will not be familiar with your work.

You must see most people are not hating on the trans movement they simply believe it is a fictitious and dark concept.

Edited

I’m sorry to do this but imo it is important to recognise that it was GIDS staff whistleblowing that resulted in some of the most significant changes, principally the Cass report and Hannah Barnes’ reporting - naming them as a unified Borg on the TRA side is wrong. It took years of pressure by them to get there, to the point that some were (shockingly to me) individually named by Mermaids as not keen enough on transitioning in communications to parents. Not surprisingly, as there were individuals there with very deep knowledge of child development and psychology, and with enough previous experience to know that things were going very wrong within the service.

Perenelle · 15/11/2026 16:45

Trans people existing doesn't affect your life in the slightest.

How do you know? How would you know how many of us have or had trans-identifying partners or parents? How many of us met "passing" males exposing in a womens only spaces? How many had to dismiss reality to not lose their jobs? How many were called bigots and worse for standing up for their own human rights?

The problem is not the existence. There are of course many benign and well-intentioned trans persons. It is the behaviour of the others. The transgressions, the demands and the violation of other persons who will not or just can not consent to being directly affected by an internal belief that is dissociated so far from reality.

Pingponghavoc · 15/11/2026 16:47

The idea that we are strawmanning trans ideology because they dont claim to change sex is bonkers.

They use terms such as male to female, claim to have periods, hope its only a matter of time before surgery allows a man to give birth. Men have said on here that they have experienced menopause.

These men use female biology to describe themselves, then when challenged, say they are describing gender.

They want to be in female spaces, with female people, but when challenged, say these spaces are gendered. If all wonen decided to identify as a new cunty gender and make our own space yet again, these men would identify as cunts because its the female sex that matters not the 'woman' gender.

DialSquare · 15/11/2026 16:47

It’s just so Illogical to me. As we’ve been saying for years, it’s The Emperor’s New Clothes. There is nothing that could ever make me change my mind. I’d feel totally embarrassed to be going along with it.

CassOle · 15/11/2026 16:50

I'd like the TRAs to explain what would change their minds on transgender issues.

Maybe @TransParentlyAnnoyed @Lacksie @Devonshireteas etc. would like to do that? I look forward to reading the answers.

BlueLegume · 15/11/2026 16:53

PermanentTemporary · 15/11/2026 16:44

I’m sorry to do this but imo it is important to recognise that it was GIDS staff whistleblowing that resulted in some of the most significant changes, principally the Cass report and Hannah Barnes’ reporting - naming them as a unified Borg on the TRA side is wrong. It took years of pressure by them to get there, to the point that some were (shockingly to me) individually named by Mermaids as not keen enough on transitioning in communications to parents. Not surprisingly, as there were individuals there with very deep knowledge of child development and psychology, and with enough previous experience to know that things were going very wrong within the service.

Absolutely agree and also acknowledge the importance of the whistle blowers. Sorry if that didn’t come across in my post. I wholeheartedly believe some of the staff and whistleblowers are heroes.

Wishesandhorses · 15/11/2026 17:02

Trans people existing doesn't affect your life in the slightest.

This is about as mad as turning to someone who's objecting that you're repeatedly and deliberately stamping on their feet and declaring tragically 'you don't want me to exist!'

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 15/11/2026 17:27

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 15/11/2026 13:06

Fairly simple: you'd have to stop seeing trans people as entities, and get to know them as individual human beings.

Same way a child gets to see a stranger, brought into their lives as their mum's boyfriend, as their dad.

Edited

The point of this thread is that there are immovable differences between the sexes that prevent people from agreeing that a man is actually a woman if he says so.

That barrier is considerably more significant (and insurmountable) than a relationship firming where someone you don’t know becomes someone you do know.

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 15/11/2026 17:35

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 15/11/2026 13:09

Until you stop seeing trans people in the abstract and setting conditions for them to be allowed to exist, you won't view them as human individuals.

Trans people owe you nothing.

That’s an interesting point.

Unfortunately you have it the wrong way round. We see the immovable reality of people’s sex, including trans people’s.

It is the claims of ‘self identifying’ as something one is not that are the abstract concept.

And ditto, we don’t owe trans people anything. That sounds fair.

ReturnOfTheReal · 15/11/2026 17:43

I don't think this will be possible but if the following did become possible, I'm willing to change my mind....

A time machine that can reverse a person's life back to conception so that the Y chromosome can be swapped out for an X. The person would have to restart their life from age zero. All past memories and social conditioning would have to be erased.

Emilesgran · 15/11/2026 17:49

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:56

The theory that transgender people are X brain in Y body would be borne out in the data. So I selected a group of well-known differences between males and females as examples.

Men die by suicide at a higher rate than women. Therefore, it would be expected that the demographic of fatal suicide attempts among transmen would be the same as that of men.

  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
The problem is that suicide has multiple factors, and you can’t just pick two groups with the same rate of suicide and say “Aha, this means they are the same!”

For instance old people and alcoholics have a high suicide rate. If they - or a sub group of either - turn out to have the same rate of suicide, does that really mean that therefore alcoholic men of 40 are in fact old people - or vice versa?

And how close would the two rates have to be, by the way? I don’t expect they’re identical even among different groups of women - age, class, ethnic/societal/religious differences etc will all come into play. So what are the chances that all trans women’s rates of suicide are the same as all women generally? So why pick on that criterion as being significant? What about TW rates of committing violent crimes - those track male rates, not female ones. Is that not rather better evidence of which sex TW really are, given how might tighter the association is between violent crimes and sex (or gender, if you prefer) than between sex and suicide rates?

Cheese55 · 15/11/2026 18:07

SockPlant · 15/11/2026 16:21

not only is it a social construct, it is a construct that varies by society. And i feel completely free to ignore it.

And that is good, some feel they have to 'turn into' the oppo sex to fit in.

ArabellaScott · 15/11/2026 18:46

At root I suppose what would make me change my mind is if there were no power imbalances between men and women.

If men could not and did not rape and abuse women. If men did not openly enjoy the power imbalance, as seen in 'sissy' fantasies. If women could opt out of the patriarchy.

Mixedberrygenderfluidmuffin · 15/11/2026 18:54

When we can do brain transplants.
Then trans people can swap bodies with other trans people of the opposite sex.

BlueLegume · 15/11/2026 18:55

ArabellaScott · 15/11/2026 18:46

At root I suppose what would make me change my mind is if there were no power imbalances between men and women.

If men could not and did not rape and abuse women. If men did not openly enjoy the power imbalance, as seen in 'sissy' fantasies. If women could opt out of the patriarchy.

This, completely.

The need to get into women’s spaces is sickening. We have repeatedly said live as you wish. We tolerate your costume version of woman because we have no choice. But please stay out of women’s spaces and for goodness sakes realise some of your movement have been messing with children.

GailBlancheViola · 15/11/2026 18:56

Trans people existing doesn't affect your life in the slightest.

It does when they are trying to get laws changed and remove the rights of the female half of the population on the basis of a lie.

Trans people can lie to themselves until the cows come home, what they cannot do, nor be enabled to do, is to force, bully or coerce anyone else to believe or go along with that lie.

Be trans, be proud to be so, be part of the rich and varied tapestry of your sex class but don't lie that you are anything other than the sex you were born and respect the rights of those of the opposite sex, particularly women.

whiteroseredrose · 15/11/2026 18:58

If a man could wake up with a woman’s body including XX chromosomes and a woman’s anatomy and physiology without taking and drugs or supplements. Also complete with heavy periods that leak, saggy boobs, stretch marks and PMT. Then I would accept that the man had become a woman.

Pingponghavoc · 15/11/2026 18:59

ArabellaScott · 15/11/2026 18:46

At root I suppose what would make me change my mind is if there were no power imbalances between men and women.

If men could not and did not rape and abuse women. If men did not openly enjoy the power imbalance, as seen in 'sissy' fantasies. If women could opt out of the patriarchy.

Yes, if it were as significant as changing star sign.

But I think its the power imbalance and male sexuality that is at the heart of the ideology. Without either, trans as it is wouldnt exist.

Its mens sexuality that drives the ideology. Their individual need to push boundaries and the power they have in society, means its normalised and excused, until they go too far.

Igneococcus · 15/11/2026 19:05

Helleofabore · 15/11/2026 16:31

Indeed.

The number of new posters who have joined in the discussion and rejecting the claim that a male can be a female because of those threads was heartening to see. It is was a live demonstration of the discussion style and the misinformation being claimed as accurate.

Not just new posters who joined in the discussion, there were also considerably more reactions to posts (at least to mine) which made me have a look and there were many usernames I didn't recognize at all.

JustSpeculation · 15/11/2026 19:39

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues?

A coherent, empirically supported explanation of why sex has nothing to do with reproduction would be a start.

Tears0fTheMushroom · 15/11/2026 19:52

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 15/11/2026 13:06

Fairly simple: you'd have to stop seeing trans people as entities, and get to know them as individual human beings.

Same way a child gets to see a stranger, brought into their lives as their mum's boyfriend, as their dad.

Edited

My mother has been married to my stepdad for 40 years - covering a good percentage of my childhood. He's still not my dad. I'm not biologically related to him in any way. And I think my actual dad would have been pretty pissed off if I had tried to say he was.
I have a half brother. He's not and never can be my full brother and he definitely can't ever be my sister.

Do you see how this works?

Tears0fTheMushroom · 15/11/2026 20:01

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 15/11/2026 13:09

Until you stop seeing trans people in the abstract and setting conditions for them to be allowed to exist, you won't view them as human individuals.

Trans people owe you nothing.

ALL groups of people can be viewed in the abstract for certain purposes. And ALL humans have certain conditions set for them to exist in society. That's what laws are for (and all the unwritten rules of society and moral imperatives we learn as children).

So called "trans" people are not exempt from this.

Tears0fTheMushroom · 15/11/2026 20:18

BlueLegume · 15/11/2026 13:43

This is what I never get an answer to. Trans rights are covered under general human rights aren't they? I am coming to assume the trans rights they seek are free access to affirmative medical treatment such as getting a double mastectomy which presumably they feel they have aright to on the NHS (first do no harm) or through medical insurance.

Trans rights activists-please spell out what rights you seek.

They have, in numerous "trans manifestos" including the frankly hilarious "Trans Health Manifesto" by Edinburgh Action for Trans Health. In which they demand the right to be trained in gender affirming surgery so they can operate on each other.

edinburghath.tumblr.com/post/163521055802/trans-health-manifesto/amp

Coatsoff42 · 15/11/2026 20:20

Tears0fTheMushroom · 15/11/2026 19:52

My mother has been married to my stepdad for 40 years - covering a good percentage of my childhood. He's still not my dad. I'm not biologically related to him in any way. And I think my actual dad would have been pretty pissed off if I had tried to say he was.
I have a half brother. He's not and never can be my full brother and he definitely can't ever be my sister.

Do you see how this works?

Yes, you might love him dearly, but if you needed a kidney donation you wouldn’t put your step father down as your actual genetic dad, because you aren’t stupid.

Tears0fTheMushroom · 15/11/2026 20:29

Wishesandhorses · 15/11/2026 14:26

No matter how much I like a person as an individual, I will not agree that reality is something that it isn't to 'humour them' because it's 'kind' - I don't think it is. Why would I do that to someone I cared about?

I am absolutely not using my personal feelings for one person as a reason to harm, use and oppress others. Because it's very, very wrong.

Exactly. All of this. This is why we have social "rules" as well as actual laws that cover EVERYONE in that society. No exceptions because
"I like you so you can do what you want"
We cannot run a society based on individuals' desires, beliefs or delusions. No matter how "nice" or "safe" or "vulnerable" that person is.

Swipe left for the next trending thread