Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 09:31

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 09:28

Reason and evidence of course. Like any rational/ reasonable person.

So you think women don't need sex based rights?

(Sex based = a right that women depend on and that men don't need, so accesss to contraception, maternity leave, provision for dealing with periods at work etc. etc. You can argue over when spaces should be single sex, but that is only the tip of the iceberg).

BlueLegume · 16/11/2026 09:35

We have thousands of posts with Transperson/lacksie/transparentlyannoyed/howse/alcovecupboards all commenting that TWAW/TMAM etc.

We have asked time and time again ‘what rights do trans people not have’ or ‘what rights do trans people want’.

We have no real answer so we do make an assumption that what they want is access to women’s spaces. If that is not correct please let us know.

Women and girls need men out of their spaces and sport. It isn’t really a huge ask is it?

oviraptor21 · 16/11/2026 09:36

A change of the Y chromosome to another X.
Complete remodelling of body to remove male physical characteristics and replace with female, including naturally occurring periods, gynaecological conditions, childbirth and menopause.
Deleting all memory of being a man and replacing with a woman.
Removal of any advantage gained through being brought up male.
I'm sure there's some other bits and bobs needed.

spannasaurus · 16/11/2026 09:38

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 09:28

Reason and evidence of course. Like any rational/ reasonable person.

I would require proven medical evidence that people could be born 'in the wrong body" or have the opposite sex brains, or change sex, i would then need a test to prove that the person qualifies as the opposite sex and a way to legislate so that only those who qualify as the opposite sex can use opposite sex single sex facilities.

What type of evidence would you require?

GriseldaandMike · 16/11/2026 09:38

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 09:28

Reason and evidence of course. Like any rational/ reasonable person.

But there is a whole mass of evidence that men can't be women, that humans can't change sex and that males and females are different so there is need for separation by sex in certain limited circumstances and you haven't changed your mind.

TheHereticalOne · 16/11/2026 09:47

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 09:28

Reason and evidence of course. Like any rational/ reasonable person.

Yes, but could you expand as to what evidence and what reasoning you'd need, as I and others have done? Evidence that establishes what?

Otherwise it's just meaningless hand-waving. We can all claim in the abstract to be evidenced-based and reasonable.

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 09:47

spannasaurus · 16/11/2026 09:38

I would require proven medical evidence that people could be born 'in the wrong body" or have the opposite sex brains, or change sex, i would then need a test to prove that the person qualifies as the opposite sex and a way to legislate so that only those who qualify as the opposite sex can use opposite sex single sex facilities.

What type of evidence would you require?

But that's just you asking for evidence of claims that are not generally made - so it's missing the point entirely/ creating a straw man.

I would require convincing argument/ evidence of the actual claims made by pps on the other side. For example:

  1. That being transgender is caused by social contagion/ stereotypes/ driven by ideology;

  2. That being transgender is associated with misogyny and stereotypes based on sex;

  3. that trans inclusive practices are associated with elevated incidents of violence against women and girls.

  4. That being trans is a type of mental health problem/ delusion that can reliably be cured/ helped through therapeutic/ psychological intervention.

Etc.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 16/11/2026 09:49

GriseldaandMike · 16/11/2026 09:38

But there is a whole mass of evidence that men can't be women, that humans can't change sex and that males and females are different so there is need for separation by sex in certain limited circumstances and you haven't changed your mind.

Yes yes but not that sort of evidence! You know the type with all the facts

it's the new type of evidence based on feelings and patronising women on forums

BlueLegume · 16/11/2026 09:53

BlueLegume · 16/11/2026 09:40

Probably the most eminent biologist of our time. Clear explanation from a reasonable and rational man. Not enough @Lacksie ? What do you know about science that Sir Robert Winston does not?

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 09:58

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 09:47

But that's just you asking for evidence of claims that are not generally made - so it's missing the point entirely/ creating a straw man.

I would require convincing argument/ evidence of the actual claims made by pps on the other side. For example:

  1. That being transgender is caused by social contagion/ stereotypes/ driven by ideology;

  2. That being transgender is associated with misogyny and stereotypes based on sex;

  3. that trans inclusive practices are associated with elevated incidents of violence against women and girls.

  4. That being trans is a type of mental health problem/ delusion that can reliably be cured/ helped through therapeutic/ psychological intervention.

Etc.

Edited

That being transgender is caused by social contagion/ stereotypes/ driven by ideology

Some of this is in the Cass report and some of this is just what trans people have said about themselves. There are many different reasons why people identify as trans. In a tolerant society, that isn't a problem as long as that doesn't affect the rights of others (or in the case of children, their own right to be protected from harm such as un-evidenced medical treatment).

That being transgender is associated with misogyny and stereotypes based on sex

Evidence provided by people on these very boards from posters who say they do identify as trans. Aside from that writers like Andrea Long Chu have been quite clear about their understanding of femaleness.

that trans inclusive practices are associated with elevated incidents of violence against women and girls.

I think here you mean 'mixed sex' provision, given that the only practical choices are single sex and mixed sex. There is evidence that this does lead to more reports of incidents such as voyeurism and abuse. It isn't relevant whether the perpetrator identifies as trans. It's the removal of the boundary that makes abuse more likely.

Meanwhile, women still need sex based rights for reasons that have nothing to do with single sex spaces.

TheKeatingFive · 16/11/2026 10:00

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 09:47

But that's just you asking for evidence of claims that are not generally made - so it's missing the point entirely/ creating a straw man.

I would require convincing argument/ evidence of the actual claims made by pps on the other side. For example:

  1. That being transgender is caused by social contagion/ stereotypes/ driven by ideology;

  2. That being transgender is associated with misogyny and stereotypes based on sex;

  3. that trans inclusive practices are associated with elevated incidents of violence against women and girls.

  4. That being trans is a type of mental health problem/ delusion that can reliably be cured/ helped through therapeutic/ psychological intervention.

Etc.

Edited

I don’t see the relevance of any of this.

Women's single sex spaces are for biological women only. Why would we make any exceptions, for any group of men?

So unless you can prove to us that these men are changing sex, on what grounds are you making a claim?

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 10:03

That being trans is a type of mental health problem/ delusion that can reliably be cured/ helped through therapeutic/ psychological intervention.

Define 'trans' - it's clearly linked to co-morbidities linked to poor mental health and people do change their feelings about their gender.

I don't think anyone suggests that all mental health problems can 'reliably be cured', but therapeutic and psychological intervention has certainly been shown to help.

But what is your argument here? It is still not possible to change sex.

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 10:07

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 09:58

That being transgender is caused by social contagion/ stereotypes/ driven by ideology

Some of this is in the Cass report and some of this is just what trans people have said about themselves. There are many different reasons why people identify as trans. In a tolerant society, that isn't a problem as long as that doesn't affect the rights of others (or in the case of children, their own right to be protected from harm such as un-evidenced medical treatment).

That being transgender is associated with misogyny and stereotypes based on sex

Evidence provided by people on these very boards from posters who say they do identify as trans. Aside from that writers like Andrea Long Chu have been quite clear about their understanding of femaleness.

that trans inclusive practices are associated with elevated incidents of violence against women and girls.

I think here you mean 'mixed sex' provision, given that the only practical choices are single sex and mixed sex. There is evidence that this does lead to more reports of incidents such as voyeurism and abuse. It isn't relevant whether the perpetrator identifies as trans. It's the removal of the boundary that makes abuse more likely.

Meanwhile, women still need sex based rights for reasons that have nothing to do with single sex spaces.

I think here you mean 'mixed sex' provision, given that the only practical choices are single sex and mixed sex. There is evidence that this does lead to more reports of incidents such as voyeurism and abuse. It isn't relevant whether the perpetrator identifies as trans. It's the removal of the boundary that makes abuse more likely.

This drives me particularly nuts.

Put theoretical definitions aside.

There is a practical difference between:

a) a facility that is in practice used by everyone equally regardless of sex

And

b) a facility that is in practice used by women/ girls and occasionally trans women/ girls, with separate facilities used by cisgender men (and occasionally transgender men).

What we need is evidence that arrangements b) result in elevated incidents of VAWG.
There is no evidence of this, the evidence we do have says the opposite.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 16/11/2026 10:14

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 10:07

I think here you mean 'mixed sex' provision, given that the only practical choices are single sex and mixed sex. There is evidence that this does lead to more reports of incidents such as voyeurism and abuse. It isn't relevant whether the perpetrator identifies as trans. It's the removal of the boundary that makes abuse more likely.

This drives me particularly nuts.

Put theoretical definitions aside.

There is a practical difference between:

a) a facility that is in practice used by everyone equally regardless of sex

And

b) a facility that is in practice used by women/ girls and occasionally trans women/ girls, with separate facilities used by cisgender men (and occasionally transgender men).

What we need is evidence that arrangements b) result in elevated incidents of VAWG.
There is no evidence of this, the evidence we do have says the opposite.

Edited

What we need is evidence that arrangements b) result in elevated incidents of VAWG.

No we don't. It's sufficient that some women don't want to get undressed or pee next to men. There is plenty of evidence that a majority of women don't want men in their intimate single sex spaces.

BlueLegume · 16/11/2026 10:17

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 10:07

I think here you mean 'mixed sex' provision, given that the only practical choices are single sex and mixed sex. There is evidence that this does lead to more reports of incidents such as voyeurism and abuse. It isn't relevant whether the perpetrator identifies as trans. It's the removal of the boundary that makes abuse more likely.

This drives me particularly nuts.

Put theoretical definitions aside.

There is a practical difference between:

a) a facility that is in practice used by everyone equally regardless of sex

And

b) a facility that is in practice used by women/ girls and occasionally trans women/ girls, with separate facilities used by cisgender men (and occasionally transgender men).

What we need is evidence that arrangements b) result in elevated incidents of VAWG.
There is no evidence of this, the evidence we do have says the opposite.

Edited

Why do we need evidence of VAWG. We as women do not want to put ourselves in a vulnerable situation hence we do not want biological men in our spaces. Why can you not respect that we are protecting our selves - we learn as women to do this from a very young age.

I am aware interaction with you is pointless as your view is ‘sod women’ I want things my way.

oldtiredcyclist · 16/11/2026 10:19

"When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind."

From the first post, I think the OP is coming from a very unrealistic stance. From what I can see from reading social media posts and speaking to others, I think the vast majority still believe transwomen are men and the majority of women do not want transwomen in their single sex spaces.

spannasaurus · 16/11/2026 10:22

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 09:47

But that's just you asking for evidence of claims that are not generally made - so it's missing the point entirely/ creating a straw man.

I would require convincing argument/ evidence of the actual claims made by pps on the other side. For example:

  1. That being transgender is caused by social contagion/ stereotypes/ driven by ideology;

  2. That being transgender is associated with misogyny and stereotypes based on sex;

  3. that trans inclusive practices are associated with elevated incidents of violence against women and girls.

  4. That being trans is a type of mental health problem/ delusion that can reliably be cured/ helped through therapeutic/ psychological intervention.

Etc.

Edited

The Claim is that people should be treated as if they were the opposite sex in relation to single sex spaces and services.

I would require evidence that a trans identified man had a medical condition that meant that they should be treated as if they were women. That evidence for me would be some kind of gene or similar that made them akin to " a woman trapped in a man's body"

What is the basis for you believing that some people should be treated as the opposite sex for the purposes of single sex spaces and services?

GriseldaandMike · 16/11/2026 10:25

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 10:07

I think here you mean 'mixed sex' provision, given that the only practical choices are single sex and mixed sex. There is evidence that this does lead to more reports of incidents such as voyeurism and abuse. It isn't relevant whether the perpetrator identifies as trans. It's the removal of the boundary that makes abuse more likely.

This drives me particularly nuts.

Put theoretical definitions aside.

There is a practical difference between:

a) a facility that is in practice used by everyone equally regardless of sex

And

b) a facility that is in practice used by women/ girls and occasionally trans women/ girls, with separate facilities used by cisgender men (and occasionally transgender men).

What we need is evidence that arrangements b) result in elevated incidents of VAWG.
There is no evidence of this, the evidence we do have says the opposite.

Edited

And how is this to be policed? How can we identify which males walking into the female facilities are trans and which are pushing the boundaries because there is a loop hole?

It comes right back to what is trans and how can we identify it, test it and ensure that only those who really really 'are' trans lay claim to that identity. Noone can give a coherent answer to any of this, no-one can ask for a GRC so any man can declare that he is trans so by let TiMs into female space you let any one in.

Where do you stand on sport? It is clearly demonstrable that in almost all sports there is male advantage do you think that as trans women are women they should be allowed into female sporting categories? If so why don't women deserve safe, fair sport. If not then you know that transwomen are not actually women at all. In short should someone male be allowed into a boxing ring with a woman?

Perenelle · 16/11/2026 10:29

What we need is evidence that arrangements b) result in elevated incidents of VAWG.
There is no evidence of this, the evidence we do have says the opposite.

This is not true, there acutally is evidence for increased violence and misuse. Another problem is that the doors are opened for everybody no questions asked.

Also, there are other reasons for single sex spaces, for example the need for privacy, which quite frankly should be sufficient already.

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 10:30

spannasaurus · 16/11/2026 10:22

The Claim is that people should be treated as if they were the opposite sex in relation to single sex spaces and services.

I would require evidence that a trans identified man had a medical condition that meant that they should be treated as if they were women. That evidence for me would be some kind of gene or similar that made them akin to " a woman trapped in a man's body"

What is the basis for you believing that some people should be treated as the opposite sex for the purposes of single sex spaces and services?

I would require evidence that a trans identified man had a medical condition that meant that they should be treated as if they were women.

This is reasonable.

That evidence for me would be some kind of gene or similar that made them akin to " a woman trapped in a man's body"

Why a gene specifically? And what would you consider equivalent of "a gene"? There are lots of medical conditions that are important and real for which we don't have evidence of a specific gene.

BlueLegume · 16/11/2026 10:31

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 10:30

I would require evidence that a trans identified man had a medical condition that meant that they should be treated as if they were women.

This is reasonable.

That evidence for me would be some kind of gene or similar that made them akin to " a woman trapped in a man's body"

Why a gene specifically? And what would you consider equivalent of "a gene"? There are lots of medical conditions that are important and real for which we don't have evidence of a specific gene.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/pFHVV_GcykI?si=5nuDwCS03QCFPnsH

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 10:34

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 10:07

I think here you mean 'mixed sex' provision, given that the only practical choices are single sex and mixed sex. There is evidence that this does lead to more reports of incidents such as voyeurism and abuse. It isn't relevant whether the perpetrator identifies as trans. It's the removal of the boundary that makes abuse more likely.

This drives me particularly nuts.

Put theoretical definitions aside.

There is a practical difference between:

a) a facility that is in practice used by everyone equally regardless of sex

And

b) a facility that is in practice used by women/ girls and occasionally trans women/ girls, with separate facilities used by cisgender men (and occasionally transgender men).

What we need is evidence that arrangements b) result in elevated incidents of VAWG.
There is no evidence of this, the evidence we do have says the opposite.

Edited

This drives me particularly nuts.

Because it's true?

Neither have any boundaries. What is the difference?

What is a cisgender man? How much nail varnish or front does a man need to convince women that they are bigots if they exclude him from a women's facility?

What we need is evidence that arrangements b) result in elevated incidents of VAWG.

So we just wait to see what happens? Voyeurism and indecent exposure are overwhelmingly male crimes, but most incidents are not reported or discovered, but what do you call it when a man strips naked in a changing room full of women because he is allowed to be there?

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 10:39

If the sign says 'use the toilet where you feel most comfortable' and I am desperate for the loo, what is to stop me from using the men's toilets? What complaint would a man have if he would rather urinate in a single sex environment?

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 10:44

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 10:34

This drives me particularly nuts.

Because it's true?

Neither have any boundaries. What is the difference?

What is a cisgender man? How much nail varnish or front does a man need to convince women that they are bigots if they exclude him from a women's facility?

What we need is evidence that arrangements b) result in elevated incidents of VAWG.

So we just wait to see what happens? Voyeurism and indecent exposure are overwhelmingly male crimes, but most incidents are not reported or discovered, but what do you call it when a man strips naked in a changing room full of women because he is allowed to be there?

What is the difference?

The difference is:

a) everyone equally uses the toilet, regardless of sex.

b) toilets are separated by men and women. Women/ girls (+ odd trans woman/girl) uses girls. Men/ boys (+odd trans man) use mens.