Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
BlueLegume · Yesterday 09:40

Lacksie · Yesterday 09:35

A biological fact is not a creed. The creed is the idea built on top of it: that sex is simple, that every person can be reliably and objectively sorted into one of two types, and that society should be organised around that sorting. Those are claims, not facts — and the fact that they can’t be questioned on this board (regardless of reason, explanation or evidence) without being called ‘post-factual’ is what makes them a creed.

What point are you actually trying to make @Lacksie ?

It is pretty clear from this thread the majority of posters disagree with your stance. Frankly many of us are utterly fatigued with the whole trans and gender ideology debate.

Surely better if you start a thread of your own and make some sensible reasonable and rational points about how you came to your conclusions about gender identity etc. Otherwise you are simply swimming against the tide. You must be able to see how few posters back you up?

BackToLurk · Yesterday 09:44

I’m not really sure what Lacksie is aiming to demonstrate with the argument that sex is diverse. There is diversity within males and females, sure, but people are still male or female. Just as there is diversity within humans, but all people are still human.

Lacksie · Yesterday 09:45

BackToLurk · Yesterday 09:38

What are the other sexes called and how are they relevant to transpeople?

It's not that there are "other sexes", it's that sex is a complex biological system with multiple parts/ components (no scientist disputes this). There are various possible developmental trajectories within this system that complicate classification of every individual into one of two simple categories.

The relevance to trans people is that they are among the people whose bodies and identities defy the expectation that biology neatly produces two clean categories. ‘Sex is simple, objective and binary, end of story’ isn’t the fact you keep calling it. It’s an oversimplification — a useful one most of the time, but a creed when it’s treated as universally True and beyond any question or evidence.

GriseldaandMike · Yesterday 09:52

to be trans is to have a persistent, consistent, (pre-reflective) recognition of self as being other than the sex one was registered at birth.

So is Eddie-Su Izzard trans or not if the feeling of womanly-ness must be consistent where does that leave him and his girl mode boy mode? Why is he allowed into the ladies when he doesn't even identify as female all the time?

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 10:00

Lacksie · Yesterday 09:45

It's not that there are "other sexes", it's that sex is a complex biological system with multiple parts/ components (no scientist disputes this). There are various possible developmental trajectories within this system that complicate classification of every individual into one of two simple categories.

The relevance to trans people is that they are among the people whose bodies and identities defy the expectation that biology neatly produces two clean categories. ‘Sex is simple, objective and binary, end of story’ isn’t the fact you keep calling it. It’s an oversimplification — a useful one most of the time, but a creed when it’s treated as universally True and beyond any question or evidence.

Edited

There are certainly many, many things that we still don't understand about reproduction, hence unexplained miscarriages.

That does not mean that we are confused about the sex of the people who might have a miscarriage.

There are various possible developmental trajectories within this system that complicate classification of every individual into one of two simple categories.

The classification system is so simple and adaptable that it covers plants and species that are hermaphrodite and sequential hermaphrodites and species where the male gives birth and species that have completely different chromosomes to humans.

The relevance to trans people is that they are among the people whose bodies and identities defy the expectation that biology neatly produces two clean categories.

Identity is not relevant to sex classification. Ask a holly bush.

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 10:06

GriseldaandMike · Yesterday 09:52

to be trans is to have a persistent, consistent, (pre-reflective) recognition of self as being other than the sex one was registered at birth.

So is Eddie-Su Izzard trans or not if the feeling of womanly-ness must be consistent where does that leave him and his girl mode boy mode? Why is he allowed into the ladies when he doesn't even identify as female all the time?

People who are included under the trans umbrella but get thrown under the bus on this board:

Those with fluid identities

Those who don't pass

People who identify as non-binary.

Statistically, this is a majority of the trans community.

GriseldaandMike · Yesterday 10:12

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 10:06

People who are included under the trans umbrella but get thrown under the bus on this board:

Those with fluid identities

Those who don't pass

People who identify as non-binary.

Statistically, this is a majority of the trans community.

And then that poster calls me ridiculous for calling them transphobic. Even though they are denying a trans identity to probably the nations most famous trans person (yeah sorry Indie it was never you).

Perenelle · Yesterday 10:26

The thing is, you can't identify into a bodily existence that differs from your actual one. You are what you are.

Societal stereotypes and individual feelings are different in this regard. Your feelings do exist. You absolutely do not have to perform to any stereotypes.

But feelings or stereotypes have no relevance in situations where our bodies matter.

DeanElderberry · Yesterday 10:27

wrt the OP's question What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues, I find it interesting that several of us on this thread have already changed our minds from easy-going 'be kind' tolerance and acceptance, imagining trans was in some way like homosexuality, to 'hell no, this is damaging' after we got to know trans people, often young women whose quite usual female adolescent distress at physical changes had led them into self-harm.

What would it take for me to change back? I don't think anything would.

Lacksie · Yesterday 10:28

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 10:06

People who are included under the trans umbrella but get thrown under the bus on this board:

Those with fluid identities

Those who don't pass

People who identify as non-binary.

Statistically, this is a majority of the trans community.

There's nothing in my account that "throws under the bus" those who are non-binary or do not pass.

BackToLurk · Yesterday 10:29

Lacksie · Yesterday 09:45

It's not that there are "other sexes", it's that sex is a complex biological system with multiple parts/ components (no scientist disputes this). There are various possible developmental trajectories within this system that complicate classification of every individual into one of two simple categories.

The relevance to trans people is that they are among the people whose bodies and identities defy the expectation that biology neatly produces two clean categories. ‘Sex is simple, objective and binary, end of story’ isn’t the fact you keep calling it. It’s an oversimplification — a useful one most of the time, but a creed when it’s treated as universally True and beyond any question or evidence.

Edited

Right, so you acknowledge there are no other sexes. We have male and female. Most people understand there to be diversity within these categories. Some men are smaller than some women. Some men and women are infertile. Some men have lower levels of testosterone than others. Etc, etc.

Transpeople are therefore either male or female. Are you trying to argue that transwomen are female and transmen are male?

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 10:38

Lacksie · Yesterday 10:28

There's nothing in my account that "throws under the bus" those who are non-binary or do not pass.

But have you not noticed other's doing this?

ETA: And where do you stand on those with fluid gender identities?

ETA again: But didn't you say that those who don't pass should not use opposite sex facilities?

Pingponghavoc · Yesterday 10:41

Trans identifying men arent men born with elements of femaleness, they observe women and copy what they can.

They take drugs and have surgery to give them breasts, they remove their penis, they wear womens fashion because its associated with being a woman. They even read womens experiences and pretend to have these, too.

'Passing' is nothing but appearing as if they are female.

There aren't test that indicate the trans identifying men have any innate female about them, because female is the sex that gives birth. That is all. Anything we understand and learn about biology explains the mechanisms of development, not that sex is undefined.

Lacksie · Yesterday 10:45

Perenelle · Yesterday 10:26

The thing is, you can't identify into a bodily existence that differs from your actual one. You are what you are.

Societal stereotypes and individual feelings are different in this regard. Your feelings do exist. You absolutely do not have to perform to any stereotypes.

But feelings or stereotypes have no relevance in situations where our bodies matter.

The thing is, you can't identify into a bodily existence that differs from your actual one. You are what you are.
What do you mean by "identify into a body?"

Lacksie · Yesterday 10:48

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 10:38

But have you not noticed other's doing this?

ETA: And where do you stand on those with fluid gender identities?

ETA again: But didn't you say that those who don't pass should not use opposite sex facilities?

Edited

ETA again: But didn't you say that those who don't pass should not use opposite sex facilities?

No. I said that people tend to use the facilities that correspond with their perceived sex. This is self-managed through social convention. This is because trans people, just like everyone else, are seeking to use facilities in accordance with their privacy and dignity to avoid drawing unnecessary attention to themselves.

Where do I stand regarding people with fluid identities?

What strikes me most about this question is its framing - which I think is very telling. You see your role as "taking a stance" on who other people are. For me, on the other hand, the primary goal is to understand other people experience - not to judge/ evaluate.

Lacksie · Yesterday 10:48

BackToLurk · Yesterday 10:29

Right, so you acknowledge there are no other sexes. We have male and female. Most people understand there to be diversity within these categories. Some men are smaller than some women. Some men and women are infertile. Some men have lower levels of testosterone than others. Etc, etc.

Transpeople are therefore either male or female. Are you trying to argue that transwomen are female and transmen are male?

Its not only that there there is diversity within categories, it is that there is diversity across categories.

Perenelle · Yesterday 10:54

Lacksie · Yesterday 10:45

The thing is, you can't identify into a bodily existence that differs from your actual one. You are what you are.
What do you mean by "identify into a body?"

As a male you can not identify as having a female body. No cosmetic surgery or hormones change any of that. Women are more than boobs and estrogen.

As a male you can not identify as feeling like a women. Women are more than a feeling.

As a male you can perform any stereotype and interpret your own feelings. But that is not of any consequence other than your own satisfaction.

BackToLurk · Yesterday 10:54

Lacksie · Yesterday 10:48

Its not only that there there is diversity within categories, it is that there is diversity across categories.

You acknowledge there are no other sexes. Are you suggesting that transwomen are female and transmen are male or are you suggesting something else?

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 10:55

Lacksie · Yesterday 10:48

ETA again: But didn't you say that those who don't pass should not use opposite sex facilities?

No. I said that people tend to use the facilities that correspond with their perceived sex. This is self-managed through social convention. This is because trans people, just like everyone else, are seeking to use facilities in accordance with their privacy and dignity to avoid drawing unnecessary attention to themselves.

Where do I stand regarding people with fluid identities?

What strikes me most about this question is its framing - which I think is very telling. You see your role as "taking a stance" on who other people are. For me, on the other hand, the primary goal is to understand other people experience - not to judge/ evaluate.

Edited

So, given that the majority of trans people are not perceived as the opposite sex, your argument is that most trans people use the facilities for their sex? This is at odds with what is claimed by others.

GriseldaandMike · Yesterday 10:56

Lacksie · Yesterday 10:48

ETA again: But didn't you say that those who don't pass should not use opposite sex facilities?

No. I said that people tend to use the facilities that correspond with their perceived sex. This is self-managed through social convention. This is because trans people, just like everyone else, are seeking to use facilities in accordance with their privacy and dignity to avoid drawing unnecessary attention to themselves.

Where do I stand regarding people with fluid identities?

What strikes me most about this question is its framing - which I think is very telling. You see your role as "taking a stance" on who other people are. For me, on the other hand, the primary goal is to understand other people experience - not to judge/ evaluate.

Edited

I said that people tend to use the facilities that correspond with their perceived sex. This is self-managed through social convention. This is because trans people, just like everyone else, are seeking to use facilities in accordance with their privacy and dignity to avoid drawing unnecessary attention to themselves.

We are back to Eddie- Su again. No-one perceives him as female but he uses the ladies.

Lacksie · Yesterday 10:58

Perenelle · Yesterday 10:54

As a male you can not identify as having a female body. No cosmetic surgery or hormones change any of that. Women are more than boobs and estrogen.

As a male you can not identify as feeling like a women. Women are more than a feeling.

As a male you can perform any stereotype and interpret your own feelings. But that is not of any consequence other than your own satisfaction.

Edited

As a male you can not identify as having a female body.

There are so many assumptions here - for a start, this isn't about 'identity', it's about a type of pre-reflective body recognition. Body recognition is pre-reflective - see the neuro-psychological literature on how it works. (How you recognise your face in the mirror, etc.)

Then of course there are your assumptions about the categories 'male' and 'female' - which takes us back to the point that sex is not a single, unitary measure, but a complex process of development with multiple parts/ components (again, this is simply science).

Women are more than boobs and estrogen.

Absolutely!!! Just as women are more than large immobile gametes. Right?

As a male you can not feel as being a women. Women are more than a feeling.
As a male you can perform any stereotype and interpret your own feelings. But that is not of any consequence other than your own satisfaction

None of this has anything to do with "feelings" or "stereotypes".

GriseldaandMike · Yesterday 10:58

Lacksie · Yesterday 10:48

Its not only that there there is diversity within categories, it is that there is diversity across categories.

Can you define this 'diversity across categories' are some people at bit male and a bit female? How, what are the mechanics behind that?

Lacksie · Yesterday 10:59

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 10:55

So, given that the majority of trans people are not perceived as the opposite sex, your argument is that most trans people use the facilities for their sex? This is at odds with what is claimed by others.

given that the majority of trans people are not perceived as the opposite sex

Since this is the premise on which your claim is built, do you have a source/ evidence for it?

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 11:03

Absolutely!!! Just as women are more than large immobile gametes. Right?

Yes, like men, women are also human. That is what distinguishes us from other species.

However the sex bit is pretty much just about the large immobile gametes and the consequences thereof.

No amount of identifying as a man negates the consequences of being female.

theilltemperedmonster · Yesterday 11:07

Lacksie · Yesterday 09:35

A biological fact is not a creed. The creed is the idea built on top of it: that sex is simple, that every person can be reliably and objectively sorted into one of two types, and that society should be organised around that sorting. Those are claims, not facts — and the fact that they can’t be questioned on this board (regardless of reason, explanation or evidence) without being called ‘post-factual’ is what makes them a creed.

every person can be reliably and objectively sorted into one of two types, and [that] society should be organised around that sorting

You misrepresent the views of most PP here by conflating us with religious conservatives.

Yes, every person can be reliably and objectively sorted into one of two types. That's just a fact. (A tiny number born with ambiguous genitalia make choices about whether to have treatment and/or retroactively correct their original birth registration: they are not trans.)

However, feminists do not believe that society should be organised around that sorting. Men and women should be treated as equals. Nobody should be forced to adopt arbitrary gender norms. Literally the only time to discriminate between men and women at all is when the physiological differences between them give rise to the necessity in the interests of safety, fairness, or decency.

So you don't need to convince me that sex is complicated (it really isn't) or that gender identity exists (I don't care). Just show me why, if a man says 'I'm a woman', it's safe for him to play women's rugby, or fair for him to take a place on an all-women shortlist, or decent for him to undress alongside naked women.

And while you're at it, explain why you think women (and men, gay men, and lesbians) shouldn't be allowed at least sometimes to have a thing (club or service) that's just for them, no opposite-sex people, thanks, just because they want to.