Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
solerolover · Yesterday 11:08

Helleofabore · Yesterday 07:09

I was rereading this today and thought it was appropriate.

https://x.com/thearbourist/status/2034625446784958710?s=46

“When one group’s ‘rights’ require another group to surrender privacy, fairness, or conscience, the conflict is no longer about equality. It is about power.”

”The smartest move activists made was rhetorical: they stopped arguing for contested demands and started calling them “rights.” After that, dissent could be recoded as cruelty, and ordinary objections could be treated as moral failure.”

“Female spaces were not built out of bigotry. They were built because sex differences are real, and privacy, safety, and fairness matter. Calling those boundaries hateful does not refute them. It just bullies people into silence.”

“A demand for equality says: leave me free. A demand for compliance says: you must affirm, yield, and rearrange your world around me. Too much of this debate is presented as the first when it is plainly the second.”

This is part of a longer read.

deadwildroses.com/2026/03/19/boundary-violations-rebranded-as-rights/

I've said this to you before, but I really appreciate you sharing this essay, it gets to the heart of the genderist issue. I always share it when I can.

BackToLurk · Yesterday 11:09

Lacksie · Yesterday 10:59

given that the majority of trans people are not perceived as the opposite sex

Since this is the premise on which your claim is built, do you have a source/ evidence for it?

If you're going to get hung up on that assertion, let's just go for "your argument is that any transperson that at least one other person perceives as their birth sex should use the facilities for their sex". Or is there a critical mass of others who should perceive them as their birth sex? 51%?

(Have we had a definition of transperson yet BTW?)

Perenelle · Yesterday 11:09

Lacksie · Yesterday 10:58

As a male you can not identify as having a female body.

There are so many assumptions here - for a start, this isn't about 'identity', it's about a type of pre-reflective body recognition. Body recognition is pre-reflective - see the neuro-psychological literature on how it works. (How you recognise your face in the mirror, etc.)

Then of course there are your assumptions about the categories 'male' and 'female' - which takes us back to the point that sex is not a single, unitary measure, but a complex process of development with multiple parts/ components (again, this is simply science).

Women are more than boobs and estrogen.

Absolutely!!! Just as women are more than large immobile gametes. Right?

As a male you can not feel as being a women. Women are more than a feeling.
As a male you can perform any stereotype and interpret your own feelings. But that is not of any consequence other than your own satisfaction

None of this has anything to do with "feelings" or "stereotypes".

Edited

There are so many assumptions here - for a start, this isn't about 'identity', it's about a type of pre-reflective body recognition. Body recognition is pre-reflective - see the neuro-psychological literature on how it works. (How you recognise your face in the mirror, etc.)

So you say theory of mind actually is not regularly developed in trans persons - they just don't want to or can't accept the red dot on their face when they look in the mirror. Even if its existence can be observed (not assigned 😉) in reality.

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 11:10

Lacksie · Yesterday 10:59

given that the majority of trans people are not perceived as the opposite sex

Since this is the premise on which your claim is built, do you have a source/ evidence for it?

For a start, from the last census a third of people who identify as trans aren't even trying to identify as the opposite sex and identify as non binary or gender fluid. They cannot be said to 'pass', because what are they passing as?

Most people tend to assume at first glance that anyone with a beard is male, so it is easier for women to pass as men. However, where are the men who pass as women?

Lacksie · Yesterday 11:23

theilltemperedmonster · Yesterday 11:07

every person can be reliably and objectively sorted into one of two types, and [that] society should be organised around that sorting

You misrepresent the views of most PP here by conflating us with religious conservatives.

Yes, every person can be reliably and objectively sorted into one of two types. That's just a fact. (A tiny number born with ambiguous genitalia make choices about whether to have treatment and/or retroactively correct their original birth registration: they are not trans.)

However, feminists do not believe that society should be organised around that sorting. Men and women should be treated as equals. Nobody should be forced to adopt arbitrary gender norms. Literally the only time to discriminate between men and women at all is when the physiological differences between them give rise to the necessity in the interests of safety, fairness, or decency.

So you don't need to convince me that sex is complicated (it really isn't) or that gender identity exists (I don't care). Just show me why, if a man says 'I'm a woman', it's safe for him to play women's rugby, or fair for him to take a place on an all-women shortlist, or decent for him to undress alongside naked women.

And while you're at it, explain why you think women (and men, gay men, and lesbians) shouldn't be allowed at least sometimes to have a thing (club or service) that's just for them, no opposite-sex people, thanks, just because they want to.

Yes, every person can be reliably and objectively sorted into one of two types. That's just a fact. (A tiny number born with ambiguous genitalia make choices about whether to have treatment and/or retroactively correct their original birth registration: they are not trans.)

This is not accurate at all. There's nothing 'factual' or scientific about your claims here.

Lacksie · Yesterday 11:24

Perenelle · Yesterday 11:09

There are so many assumptions here - for a start, this isn't about 'identity', it's about a type of pre-reflective body recognition. Body recognition is pre-reflective - see the neuro-psychological literature on how it works. (How you recognise your face in the mirror, etc.)

So you say theory of mind actually is not regularly developed in trans persons - they just don't want to or can't accept the red dot on their face when they look in the mirror. Even if its existence can be observed (not assigned 😉) in reality.

No idea what this means.

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 11:24

Lacksie · Yesterday 11:23

Yes, every person can be reliably and objectively sorted into one of two types. That's just a fact. (A tiny number born with ambiguous genitalia make choices about whether to have treatment and/or retroactively correct their original birth registration: they are not trans.)

This is not accurate at all. There's nothing 'factual' or scientific about your claims here.

There's nothing 'factual' or scientific about your claims here.

Which bit are you disputing?

GriseldaandMike · Yesterday 11:25

Absolutely!!! Just as women are more than large immobile gametes. Right?

Correct of course women aren't just eggs it is all the differences between the bodies that make sperms and bodies that release eggs that make us male or female from the major (the ability to gestate and give birth, periods, differences in average height, strength etc) and all the minor ones, the little tells like mouth shape and wrists bone alignment. That why men can't be women just cause they have breaststroke.

babyproblems · Yesterday 11:25

There is nothing that would make me reconsider what I think a man or woman is. They are fixed by birth and cannot be changed. To me, your question is like ‘what would it take to make you think your left and right hand could be labelled the other way round?’ Or something like swapping your mouth and eyes round. It’s a biologically fixed human characteristic. So nothing because it’s just ridiculous.

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 11:25

Lacksie · Yesterday 11:24

No idea what this means.

You seem to be suggesting that trans people have a problem recognising themselves in a mirror.

Lacksie · Yesterday 11:26

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 11:24

There's nothing 'factual' or scientific about your claims here.

Which bit are you disputing?

Each one of the claims I quoted:

"Yes, every person can be reliably and objectively sorted into one of two types.

That's just a fact.

(A tiny number born with ambiguous genitalia make choices about whether to have treatment and/or retroactively correct their original birth registration: they are not trans.)"

None of these are factual or scientific claims, and the part in brackets is not only wrong, but also incoherent.

PleaseDontStepOnTheDaisies · Yesterday 11:27

To answer the original question in the OP: What would change my mind?

If the political pursuit of trans rights had been less aggressive and frankly, totalitarian. If the whole "TWAW, get over it", "No Debate" "Die TERF" stuff, plus sending death threats to JK Rowling had simply never happened - and they had simply gone with "Hayley from Corrie" - I think I'd have had sympathy.

In fact, I did have sympathy back in the early 2000s - I remember when the Big Brother audience shouted "Nadia's a man" - and at the time I thought that was nasty. I hadn't thought deeply about it, and I would've accepted Nadia as "a woman." I never would have batted an eyelid back then at Nadia using women's spaces.

What changed was the movement towards 'self ID' and the realisation that this would mean the end of all women's spaces, and even the meaning of the word "woman" in law. The trans movement shot itself in the foot - by doing everything they did. From violently resisting women-only groups like A Woman's Place, to belittling and denying that women had been sexually assaulted in prisons & hospital wards. Everything the TRAs did from about 2015 onwards just confirms the fact that trans women are men, and that most behave exactly like men.

Nothing can change my mind on the fact that humans cannot change their sex, because they can't, and now nothing can change my mind that trans activists are aggressive & violent - because they have been for the past decade.

MarieDeGournay · Yesterday 11:28

The trans lobby have veered all over the road with their arguments, from

'TWAW and how dare you suggest that a TW is in any way less than 100% a woman the same as any other woman'
to
'Well of course nobody can actually change sex, it's all about self-perception and social presentation'
to
'I have actually become a biological woman'
to
'Sex isn't just about biological sex, there's social/phenotypes/etc etc'

Now they are getting tangled up because if it's phenotype and presentation and passing, where does that leave transwomen who do not present as women, either because they just can't lose their male physical appearance, or they say 'we don't owe you femininity' and keep their male genitalia and voices and beards?

I understand that confusing the issue is a TRA tactic, but it's backfiring, because TRAs and their allies seem to be confusing themselves.

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 11:29

Lacksie · Yesterday 11:26

Each one of the claims I quoted:

"Yes, every person can be reliably and objectively sorted into one of two types.

That's just a fact.

(A tiny number born with ambiguous genitalia make choices about whether to have treatment and/or retroactively correct their original birth registration: they are not trans.)"

None of these are factual or scientific claims, and the part in brackets is not only wrong, but also incoherent.

Edited

Who are the people whose sex is unclear?

Lacksie · Yesterday 11:30

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 11:25

You seem to be suggesting that trans people have a problem recognising themselves in a mirror.

No, I am saying that recognition of one's face in the mirror is a type of pre-reflective cognition/ recognition that takes place in a different part of the brain than that associated with conscious reasoning.
We do not look in the mirror and reason that it must be our face we are seeing. This is not how the neurocognition of facial recognition works.
Same with all types of body recognition.

The pre-reflective recognition of my face, my arm, as my own, is not the same thing as consciously knowing/ understanding those things - the two are different types of cognition.

Gtg.

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 11:34

Lacksie · Yesterday 11:30

No, I am saying that recognition of one's face in the mirror is a type of pre-reflective cognition/ recognition that takes place in a different part of the brain than that associated with conscious reasoning.
We do not look in the mirror and reason that it must be our face we are seeing. This is not how the neurocognition of facial recognition works.
Same with all types of body recognition.

The pre-reflective recognition of my face, my arm, as my own, is not the same thing as consciously knowing/ understanding those things - the two are different types of cognition.

Gtg.

No, I am saying that recognition of one's face in the mirror is a type of pre-reflective cognition/ recognition that takes place in a different part of the brain than that associated with conscious reasoning.

Is it? My dog can't recognise himself in a mirror and human existence long predates the invention of glass.

Lacksie · Yesterday 11:38

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 11:34

No, I am saying that recognition of one's face in the mirror is a type of pre-reflective cognition/ recognition that takes place in a different part of the brain than that associated with conscious reasoning.

Is it? My dog can't recognise himself in a mirror and human existence long predates the invention of glass.

Is it?

Absolutely! Some suggested reading on the basic neuroscience:

Philippe Rochat, “Five levels of self-awareness as they unfold early in life,” Consciousness and Cognition 12 (2003).

Anil Seth, Being You (2021).

V. S. Ramachandran, Phantoms in the Brain (1998) and The Tell-Tale Brain (2011).

Antonio Damasio, The Feeling of What Happens (1999).

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 11:42

Can you quote anything that contradicts the BBC article?

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 11:54

‘Phantoms in The Brain’, using a series of case histories, introduces strange and unexplored mental worlds. Ramachandran, through his research into brain damage, has discovered that the brain is continually organising itself in response to change. A woman maintains that her left arm is not paralysed, a young man loses his right arm in a motorcycle accident, yet he continues to feel a phantom arm with vivid sensation of movement. In a series of experiments using nothing more than Q-tips and dribbles of warm water the young man helped Ramachandran discover how the brain is remapped after injury. Ramachandran believes that cases such as these illustrate fundamental principles of how the human brain operates. The brain ‘needs to create a “script” or a story to make sense of the world, a unified and internally consistent belief system’.

So your argument is that trans people are brain damaged?

The relevance isn't clear. People who continue to feel a missing limb still have a missing limb.

BackToLurk · Yesterday 11:55

@Lacksie are you suggesting transwomen are a type of female and transmen are a type of male, or something else?

If you are having issues understanding the question, do let me know.

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 11:57

Lacksie · Yesterday 11:23

Yes, every person can be reliably and objectively sorted into one of two types. That's just a fact. (A tiny number born with ambiguous genitalia make choices about whether to have treatment and/or retroactively correct their original birth registration: they are not trans.)

This is not accurate at all. There's nothing 'factual' or scientific about your claims here.

So go on, explain (without using people with VSD), What is inaccurate about the statement, because at the moment you’re not covering yourself with glory here.

BackToLurk · Yesterday 11:58

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 11:54

‘Phantoms in The Brain’, using a series of case histories, introduces strange and unexplored mental worlds. Ramachandran, through his research into brain damage, has discovered that the brain is continually organising itself in response to change. A woman maintains that her left arm is not paralysed, a young man loses his right arm in a motorcycle accident, yet he continues to feel a phantom arm with vivid sensation of movement. In a series of experiments using nothing more than Q-tips and dribbles of warm water the young man helped Ramachandran discover how the brain is remapped after injury. Ramachandran believes that cases such as these illustrate fundamental principles of how the human brain operates. The brain ‘needs to create a “script” or a story to make sense of the world, a unified and internally consistent belief system’.

So your argument is that trans people are brain damaged?

The relevance isn't clear. People who continue to feel a missing limb still have a missing limb.

I've seen phantom limbs (and indeed xenomelia) used before. Surely all they illustrate is that the mind can believe things that aren't true. Like you are the opposite sex.

Perenelle · Yesterday 12:05

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 11:03

Absolutely!!! Just as women are more than large immobile gametes. Right?

Yes, like men, women are also human. That is what distinguishes us from other species.

However the sex bit is pretty much just about the large immobile gametes and the consequences thereof.

No amount of identifying as a man negates the consequences of being female.

Exactly @nicepotoftea

The difference between male and female is the different gametes. Our whole complex bodily development and experience is based on this tiny detail.

Not on any feeling, identity or self-perception.

That being said, it must be very difficult for people who are being so dissociated from their body. What Gender Critics say is basically that enforcing the disscociation seems not to help in a sustainable way, neither for the individual nor for society as a whole. Acceptance of diversity and reality on the other hand could.

Lacksie · Yesterday 12:14

BackToLurk · Yesterday 11:55

@Lacksie are you suggesting transwomen are a type of female and transmen are a type of male, or something else?

If you are having issues understanding the question, do let me know.

I am just out but will respond to this later .