Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Lacksie · 17/11/2026 20:00

StealthTroublemaker · 17/11/2026 19:42

But hold on, you have said TIM should be excluded from some women’s sports and spaces. If you believe TIM are women ,why would you exclude some women from Women’s spaces and sports? Either TIM are women and belong in all spaces women are allowed, or they are not women and do not belong in any female spaces. Which is it?

Nah, very few things are absolutely always or absolutely never , life is just way more complicated than that.
And where have I made any statements about trans women in sport etc?

Coatsoff42 · 17/11/2026 20:03

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 20:00

Nah, very few things are absolutely always or absolutely never , life is just way more complicated than that.
And where have I made any statements about trans women in sport etc?

Edited

when do you think sex matters? Actually definitely, not might or maybe.

GriseldaandMike · 17/11/2026 20:05

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 20:00

Nah, very few things are absolutely always or absolutely never , life is just way more complicated than that.
And where have I made any statements about trans women in sport etc?

Edited

So male v female in a boxing ring is a-okay?

GriseldaandMike · 17/11/2026 20:07

Coatsoff42 · 17/11/2026 20:03

when do you think sex matters? Actually definitely, not might or maybe.

Kindly Lacksie will allow medical staff to not perform treatment on body parts people don't have. They are all heart.

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 20:09

Coatsoff42 · 17/11/2026 20:03

when do you think sex matters? Actually definitely, not might or maybe.

Sex matters.

Sex is also complicated and diverse.

It's the second bit that you don't want to accept and why we can't have a meaningful conversation on this topic.

GriseldaandMike · 17/11/2026 20:11

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 20:09

Sex matters.

Sex is also complicated and diverse.

It's the second bit that you don't want to accept and why we can't have a meaningful conversation on this topic.

Sex isn't diverse - there are two, only two and every human being ever is/was one or the other and no mammal has ever changed sex.

CassOle · 17/11/2026 20:13

It's very simple in mammals. There are those with small gametes (male) and those with large gametes (female). There are no further gamete types.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 17/11/2026 20:14

It's the second bit that you don't want to accept and why we can't have a meaningful conversation on this topic.

It must be so hard for you, poor Lacksie. Dealing with all these muddled thinkers who just won't see it your way and agree that you're right!

Coatsoff42 · 17/11/2026 20:14

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 20:09

Sex matters.

Sex is also complicated and diverse.

It's the second bit that you don't want to accept and why we can't have a meaningful conversation on this topic.

So never then. Realistically. Never. There’s always a caveat or a sub clause for you?

DeanElderberry · 17/11/2026 20:35

CassOle · 17/11/2026 20:13

It's very simple in mammals. There are those with small gametes (male) and those with large gametes (female). There are no further gamete types.

you deny the spegg?

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues
CassOle · 17/11/2026 20:41

I do not subscribe to the sex-is-a-spectrum religion and do I not believe in the Holy Sperg and Spegg. Thanks for asking though Dean. 😀

StealthTroublemaker · 17/11/2026 21:07

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 20:09

Sex matters.

Sex is also complicated and diverse.

It's the second bit that you don't want to accept and why we can't have a meaningful conversation on this topic.

So if sex is sooooooo complicated and diverse, how come there are only MTF and FTM transpeople? How does a MTF person know he is transitioning from male to female if no one can say what a male or a female is? If no one knows what a male or a female is, no one can transition into them so you’ve just eliminated transpeople. Literal Geoncide!!!!!

Wishesandhorses · 17/11/2026 21:22

I'm not remotely interested in 'understanding' why a man wants to be in my single sex space. Any more than he's interested in me or why I don't want him there. It makes no difference to a woman how individual men feel or perceive themselves or what their oh so complicated genetics may be when he's a man wanting to provide her with rape crisis services or to get in a changing room and undress with her. It really doesn't.

Women's realities aren't predicated on what individual men say they're feeling. They're separate independent humans.

AlexandraLeaving · 17/11/2026 21:36

I was so excited when my notifications told me there were a kazillion new posts on this thread. Surely one of them, I thought, must be some definitions or some explanations of the differences between 'man' and 'adult human male'. Alas, I'm still waiting. Genuinely interested. I want to understand. @Lacksie can you help?

BackToLurk · 17/11/2026 21:43

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 19:30

Lacksie has said that they do not believe TWAW

I have never said this. What I have said- which you don't seem able to accept for some reason - is that it's an entirely semantic question.

In terms of trans people "knowing what sex they are", what I have said is that trans people are well aware of what anatomy they have, and the sex they were registered at birth. they are not deluded about those things. However, despite that knowledge, to be trans is to have a persistent, consistent, (pre-reflective) recognition of self as being other than the sex one was registered at birth.

I appreciate this is not intuitive or easy to understand, but it really ought to be possible to understand it.
However, as this thread demonstrates, of course, people are quite determined not to understand it.

Edited

Ah yes, I confused you with another similar poster.

If a woman (a female person) requests same sex care and understands that to mean that the person providing that care will be a woman (because woman and female are interchangeable terms to them) then who turns up to provide that care is far from just ‘semantic’. It’s also irrelevant to the person receiving the care how the individual providing care ‘recognises themselves’.

You can continue to sneer at other people because they have reasons for requesting same sex care or you think you’re smarter than them and they just can’t ‘understand’, but people do understand. They just don’t think believing you are a woman makes you one, even if you believe real hard.

Pingponghavoc · 17/11/2026 22:00

This discussion is demonstrating the limitations of trans ideology.

Its basically people who want to present as the opposite sex. There is nothing more to it than that. But that is not enough, they want to be treated as if they are the opposite sex in law and by everyone around them.

Law can issue new documentation, but individuals cannot be made to see a man as a woman. This legal fiction cannot be forced onto a population, in large part because its important for everyones safety to know who is a man.

When men attempt to hide their sex, our instinct is to be wary around him and be more allert. We dont feel the same about drag queens, who aren't hiding their sex, or trans identifying women. Even if these people cause problems in other ways.

And this is the spiral we are in. Its natural to be aware of and wary of men, but these men react to this in ways that make us sure that our initial feelings were correct.

Claiming a woman isnt female, our reproductive biology is insignificant, women spaces arent needed, they are women because woman is only a presentation- all insult women. And then these men are shocked when they arent getting what they want.

cryupmykingdom · 17/11/2026 23:18

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 19:30

Lacksie has said that they do not believe TWAW

I have never said this. What I have said- which you don't seem able to accept for some reason - is that it's an entirely semantic question.

In terms of trans people "knowing what sex they are", what I have said is that trans people are well aware of what anatomy they have, and the sex they were registered at birth. they are not deluded about those things. However, despite that knowledge, to be trans is to have a persistent, consistent, (pre-reflective) recognition of self as being other than the sex one was registered at birth.

I appreciate this is not intuitive or easy to understand, but it really ought to be possible to understand it.
However, as this thread demonstrates, of course, people are quite determined not to understand it.

Edited

No one cares. And the reason no one cares is that you're putting forward the equivalent say, of me idolising John F Kennedy and Robert Kennedy and deciding I will live as a Kennedy and believe myself to be one, and act to the world as if I were a Kennedy.

Where this falls down is that the desire to be a Kennedy versus the 'thusness' of actually being a Kennedy, as experiences go, are about the furthest two things apart that can be imagined.

As such, my chances of entering and living in the Kennedy compound based on holding this desire are ummm, zero. And everyone knows that chance is zero.

No one would assist me to attain it (not without a lot of money and a guarantee of protection from prosecution) and most people would think I - and anyone I convinced of the rightness of this belief - were utterly insane.

BettyBooper · 17/11/2026 23:47

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 19:30

Lacksie has said that they do not believe TWAW

I have never said this. What I have said- which you don't seem able to accept for some reason - is that it's an entirely semantic question.

In terms of trans people "knowing what sex they are", what I have said is that trans people are well aware of what anatomy they have, and the sex they were registered at birth. they are not deluded about those things. However, despite that knowledge, to be trans is to have a persistent, consistent, (pre-reflective) recognition of self as being other than the sex one was registered at birth.

I appreciate this is not intuitive or easy to understand, but it really ought to be possible to understand it.
However, as this thread demonstrates, of course, people are quite determined not to understand it.

Edited

So 'trans people know' which sex they are but also 'recognise' themselves as the opposite sex? Mmmhmmm. Did you actually come down in the last shower?

If they know which sex they are, they are perfectly capable of knowing which toilets to use. Thanks for clarifying.

2021x · Yesterday 03:34

MyusernameforMumnet · 17/11/2026 09:30

My point about upper body strength is not incorrect. Consider the following:

  • In the firm "The Machinist" in 2004, the 6-foot-tall actor Christian Bale dieted down to 120 pounds (8 stone 8 pounds in old money) and was not hospitalised
  • Trans women going through an anorexic/bulimic period in their teens or twenties happens so often it's a cliche, and are not hospitalised

Regarding your point about "misunderstanding all your arguments": well possibly (I genuinely don't know) but my argument is that it is perfectly possible for an individual trans woman to meet your criteria.

Was Chistian Bales strength within the female or the male range.

OP posts:
Dontevenlookatme · Yesterday 04:35

IME it’s almost always about what they’re not, rather than what they are. And when it is what they are, it’s always about how they dress.

So I would want them to be able to articulate what specifically makes them a man/woman that doesn’t relate to how they want to present themselves.

Helleofabore · Yesterday 06:06

2021x · Yesterday 03:34

Was Chistian Bales strength within the female or the male range.

Th studies have shown that those male people who weaken themselves can train and see a return to strength.

Not only that, they still retain grip strength over 160% above female people combined with larger hands. They have male skeletal proportions in their arms giving them better leverage and they have many other male advantages that are not changed if they have weakened themselves.

Their decision to weaken themselves is a choice. And it has been shown to be no -permanent.

Helleofabore · Yesterday 06:31

Wishesandhorses · 17/11/2026 17:13

I think Lacksie is demonstrating very well that there is no possibility ever of agreement on this. There is no point to the argument, it is never resolvable.

Where activists insist that men are women and are absolutely blind to the realities of sex and the needs of women, gender critical women who want single sex spaces will never see a man as anything other than a man, and expect single sex spaces to not permit entry to him. Only one of these is based on actual fact, but whatever. If there was any real truth to this, no one would know what 'trans' meant and the word wouldn't matter. In this sense, it literally means 'man who identifies as' or 'is not actually a'.

The obvious only possible solution is to provide accessible spaces for men who believe they are women, and for women who require spaces free of any and all men. An accessible space for all, an agreement to disagree and to live in parallel. And this requires men accepting that not everything is for them.

Edited

Indeed, the only way that the support of a male who demands he should be treated as if his subjective belief about his identity that does not reflect the material reality of his body’s sex category can considered is through philosophical theorising.

And philosophical theorising becomes irrelevant in the determination of who accesses female single sex provisions which is based on the material reality of what biological factors categorise female people.

That previous generations of law makers never expected that at some point in the future a group of people would seek to destabilise the definitions of the common use terms of female and male has caused major issues. But Whodathunkit that we would be in this situation?

OldCrone · Yesterday 06:33

Lacksie · 17/11/2026 19:30

Lacksie has said that they do not believe TWAW

I have never said this. What I have said- which you don't seem able to accept for some reason - is that it's an entirely semantic question.

In terms of trans people "knowing what sex they are", what I have said is that trans people are well aware of what anatomy they have, and the sex they were registered at birth. they are not deluded about those things. However, despite that knowledge, to be trans is to have a persistent, consistent, (pre-reflective) recognition of self as being other than the sex one was registered at birth.

I appreciate this is not intuitive or easy to understand, but it really ought to be possible to understand it.
However, as this thread demonstrates, of course, people are quite determined not to understand it.

Edited

to be trans is to have a persistent, consistent, (pre-reflective) recognition of self as being other than the sex one was registered at birth.

How is it possible to "have a recognition" of something which is untrue?

I appreciate this is not intuitive or easy to understand, but it really ought to be possible to understand it.

I understand this as a delusion. I can't understand how such a "recognition" of something which is untrue can be anything other than a delusion.

Helleofabore · Yesterday 06:44

BackToLurk · 17/11/2026 18:26

Lacksie demonstrates something else. The absolute mental gymnastics and faux (presumably) ignorance needed to hold some kind of 'inclusive' position.

Lacksie has said that they do not believe TWAW. They have also said, I believe, that transpeople know what sex they are. Therefore they know that a transwoman is neither a woman or female. Yet when the question is "if a woman asks for a woman to examine her can she mean a woman or should she accept a man who believes himself to be a woman?", rather than just answer the very obvious substance of the question - i.e. "is it appropriate for a transwoman to provide intimate care to a woman who has asked for a woman clinician" - they come back with the "A patient can request a different health provider for any reason". They know that wasn't the question. Then move to examining the minutiae of the phrasing "Obviously I reject your muddled use of language blahdiblah".

Lacksie could have just said "I wouldn't phrase it as a 'man pretending to be a woman' , but if you mean is it appropriate for a transwoman to provide intimate care to a woman who has asked for a woman clinician, then no", (because that is surely their position given their previous statements). Or alternatively maybe they would say "yes" because their position has no consistency or coherency. Who knows at this stage. Maybe they're just another of those debate perverts.

yes.

And the very same poster insists that the reference terms female people use for themselves have not become meaningless in communication, while thread after thread the crux of their arguments rests on destabilisation of language to a point where communication is meaningless.

The word ‘consent’ is rendered meaningless because we are to believe that one person’s personal definition of female that is not the commonly use definition is considered that doctor, the person with the power in that relationship does not then negate the consent of a female patient using the most commonly understood meaning. I believe if it was tested in court, that Upton would be in considerable legal trouble if he used that argument.

There is a reasonable feeling of gaslighting when we are told the language has not been made meaningless when we see on thread after thread just how meaningless the reference terms have been made.