Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 13:23

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 13:11

That's in relation to excluding someone from a single sex services for their own sex rather than including someone in a single sex service of the opposite sex. Those are two different considerations

Sure. But it involves a judgement about passing, so no reason why that is practically able to be applied for exclusion, but not practical for inclusion. It's the same principle.

Your problem is the lack of examples of men who identify as trans and pass.

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 13:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I think the actual social convention incited is that a woman should not say no to a man if this would upset him.

That has obviously led to all sorts of problems, and now we are saying no.

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 13:29

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · 16/11/2026 13:22

Ha ha it must be exhausting to be so dramatic all the time.

Me; oh my kid is silly, she put a sausage in her hair...
You; SO ALL KIDS ARE STUPID NOW ARE THEY???????

Me: a dog barked at me the other day
You: SO YOU HATE ALL ANIMALS NOW DO YOU?????

I'm not being dramatic. I'm just holding pps feet to the fire asking them to be specific about what they actually mean.

Of course we accept that children need healthcare, which involves physical medical interventions. The question is - is the intervention being discussed the best available option considering the risks of the condition, not treating it, and the risks and benefits of the intervention proposed. For that you need evidence, not just a rhetorical wail that it is immoral to intervene in children's bodies. That is the point.

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 13:29

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 13:07

Reasonable people do not mess with children’s minds or bodies. That is inhumane.

Lol so you are against all health care and mental health support for kids then?

Healthcare should be evidenced based and should not 'mess with' anyone.

You should be concerned at the lack of ethics displayed by organisations such as the Tavistock and WPATH.

Helleofabore · 16/11/2026 13:31

Are we going to get that link to the test for who is and isn’t someone with a transgender identity to enable this to be verified?

That would be great! I have been looking forward to that and I just know that the medical boards in some countries would like this too. Whoever has this definitive test will likely win a science prize!!

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 13:36

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 13:29

Healthcare should be evidenced based and should not 'mess with' anyone.

You should be concerned at the lack of ethics displayed by organisations such as the Tavistock and WPATH.

Agree that healthcare should be evidence based

Helleofabore · 16/11/2026 13:36

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 12:35

It is managed through social convention.

However, the law already depends on judgements about passing - hence the provision to allow trans men to be excluded from female facilities, without being discriminatory.

That wasn’t to do with ‘passing’. That was to do with the female person who might have some male body cues, not necessarily that that pass.

Not all female people will be able to correctly identify a person’s sex category.

Helleofabore · 16/11/2026 13:38

Wishesandhorses · 16/11/2026 12:55

Quite.

I've never understood whether this example (which was explained thoroughly in the SCJ in quite small words, it's almost as if the judges expected this)

overchallenges comprehension too far
is wilfully misused when convenient
is waved around by someone who has never read the SCJ at all and downloads their thinking from what they read online
all of the above

It's a bit like the spousal exit clause.

But the common theme is not being able to see women as human. Or manage empathy. Or theory of mind.

It really is.

Helleofabore · 16/11/2026 13:45

Social convention is not appropriate as a measure to assess safeguarding risk.

It has proven to be a disaster in the past, hence no special sub groups of male people over the age of around 8 yrs old should be accessing female single sex provisions. There should never have been any expectation that a male person should have a reward of access to those provisions for choosing to have extreme body modification.

No amount of body modification, no amount of claims to need protection should have been considered compatible with female people’s needs for single sex provisions. Those provisions are not a reward for male people and no female person is either a therapeutic or security device for male people who don’t wish to use male single sex provisions.

GailBlancheViola · 16/11/2026 13:55

Trans women, however, occasionally do use female services, especially if they pass, because they understand themselves to be women, and also are aware that others reliably perceive them to be women.

Others DO NOT reliably perceive them to be women.

The overwhelming majority of transwomen do not pass, they fool themselves that they do.

Their 'understanding' of themselves is irrelevant they are requiring everyone else to validate the lie that they are women, they are not and no-one else should be required to go along with this falsehood.

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 14:09

Helleofabore · 16/11/2026 13:45

Social convention is not appropriate as a measure to assess safeguarding risk.

It has proven to be a disaster in the past, hence no special sub groups of male people over the age of around 8 yrs old should be accessing female single sex provisions. There should never have been any expectation that a male person should have a reward of access to those provisions for choosing to have extreme body modification.

No amount of body modification, no amount of claims to need protection should have been considered compatible with female people’s needs for single sex provisions. Those provisions are not a reward for male people and no female person is either a therapeutic or security device for male people who don’t wish to use male single sex provisions.

Safeguarding is neither here nor there. Separate sex facilities is about dignity and privacy, not safety.

The overwhelming majority of violence against women and girls is committed by partners, ex-partners and men the victim already knows, in homes and private spaces - not toilets and changing rooms. The one peer-reviewed study of police records on this (Hasenbush et al., 2018) found reported incidents in these spaces ‘exceedingly rare

A policy justified by women’s safety that concentrates on toilets is aimed at the place the danger isn’t — against a perpetrator who was never going to be stopped by a sign anyway. There’s no evidence that more sex-segregated societies have less violence against women; many report very high rates. Meanwhile, Ireland has had self-identification since 2015 — ten years, around a thousand certificates, and not one documented case of a man using it to get into a women’s space to offend. Denmark, Norway, Malta and Argentina tell the same story. The predicted wave of predators exploiting self-ID was predicted loudly and hasn’t happened anywhere it’s been tried.

Finally, if the concern really is violence in public, actually men and boys are considerably more likely than women to be attacked by a stranger in public.

This isn't about safeguarding, it's about social norms around "decency", privacy and dignity.

Helleofabore · 16/11/2026 14:12

“also are aware that others reliably perceive them to be women.”

This is now delving into myth.

Whoever claims that all female present at the same time a male person is using a female single sex provision should produce the evidence that not one of the female people who are there or who could be potentially there will not have identified that male person’s sex category correctly.

And if they cannot evidence it, we can assume it is an over generalisation being used as a cognitive distortion instead of discussing evidence based information.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/11/2026 14:18

So the argument comes down to 'well VAWAG happens, so let's not put anything in the way of the inevitable because it's pointless, men are going to attack women anyway' and that's actually serious.

Not one documented case of a man using it to get into a women’s space to offend in Ireland. (Emphasis mine).

There’s no evidence that more sex-segregated societies have less violence against women; many report very high rates.

"And anyway, women in Afghanistan have it worse, so stop moaning."

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 14:19

Helleofabore · 16/11/2026 14:12

“also are aware that others reliably perceive them to be women.”

This is now delving into myth.

Whoever claims that all female present at the same time a male person is using a female single sex provision should produce the evidence that not one of the female people who are there or who could be potentially there will not have identified that male person’s sex category correctly.

And if they cannot evidence it, we can assume it is an over generalisation being used as a cognitive distortion instead of discussing evidence based information.

evidence that not one of the female people who are there or who could be potentially there will not have identified that male person’s sex category correctly.

If that were the principle you'd have to start excluding all varieties of gender non-conforming women, in case a single woman might mistakenly perceive them to be a man.

Helleofabore · 16/11/2026 14:20

”Separate sex facilities is about dignity and privacy, not safety.”

Well. That is a real surprise.

It is about managing safety. No publicly accessed provision can ever be made completely safe. No person has ever claimed those provisions were. It is about minimising risk of harm. All harms.

Your introduction of domestic / intimate violence is simply a distraction. Yes. We understand where the most violence happens. That doesn’t mean that single sex provisions are not there for safety as well as privacy and dignity for the female people who are accessing them.

Just because male people are more likely to attack other male people doesn’t mean that female single sex provisions are not there for female safety as well as privacy and dignity.

Your points are inaccurate and shows a lack of understanding about safeguarding principles and why policies were created in the first place.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · 16/11/2026 14:22

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 13:29

I'm not being dramatic. I'm just holding pps feet to the fire asking them to be specific about what they actually mean.

Of course we accept that children need healthcare, which involves physical medical interventions. The question is - is the intervention being discussed the best available option considering the risks of the condition, not treating it, and the risks and benefits of the intervention proposed. For that you need evidence, not just a rhetorical wail that it is immoral to intervene in children's bodies. That is the point.

Physically altering a child's body because adults around them have told them they're in the wrong body is immoral...

Helleofabore · 16/11/2026 14:23

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 14:19

evidence that not one of the female people who are there or who could be potentially there will not have identified that male person’s sex category correctly.

If that were the principle you'd have to start excluding all varieties of gender non-conforming women, in case a single woman might mistakenly perceive them to be a man.

No. We wouldn’t have to exclude gender non-conforming female people. That is just more distraction from you.

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 14:23

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/11/2026 14:18

So the argument comes down to 'well VAWAG happens, so let's not put anything in the way of the inevitable because it's pointless, men are going to attack women anyway' and that's actually serious.

Not one documented case of a man using it to get into a women’s space to offend in Ireland. (Emphasis mine).

There’s no evidence that more sex-segregated societies have less violence against women; many report very high rates.

"And anyway, women in Afghanistan have it worse, so stop moaning."

Edited

Sex segregation just simply isn’t an evidence-based strategy for preventing violence against women. It simply isn't. It was never designed as one.

The Equality Act exceptions for single-sex spaces aren’t framed as safeguarding — they rest on things like privacy, effectiveness of provision, and the fact that people may reasonably prefer the company of their own sex in shared or intimate settings. And the Supreme Court judgment turned on what the word ‘sex’ means in that Act, not on any finding that trans women are a danger to anyone.

Privacy, dignity, social norms: that’s what the law is about. Safeguarding is the thing people bolt on afterwards to make the exclusion sound urgent

Helleofabore · 16/11/2026 14:27

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 14:23

Sex segregation just simply isn’t an evidence-based strategy for preventing violence against women. It simply isn't. It was never designed as one.

The Equality Act exceptions for single-sex spaces aren’t framed as safeguarding — they rest on things like privacy, effectiveness of provision, and the fact that people may reasonably prefer the company of their own sex in shared or intimate settings. And the Supreme Court judgment turned on what the word ‘sex’ means in that Act, not on any finding that trans women are a danger to anyone.

Privacy, dignity, social norms: that’s what the law is about. Safeguarding is the thing people bolt on afterwards to make the exclusion sound urgent

“Sex segregation just simply isn’t an evidence-based strategy for preventing violence against women. It simply isn't. It was never designed as one.”

How about you produce historical documents that support this claim?

Coatsoff42 · 16/11/2026 14:28

You say safeguarding is not an issue, I say it is. The fact that teenage girls are assaulted in school toilets by boys they “know” does not make mixed sex toilets safe. I was assaulted in the toilets. Exceedingly rare is not good enough. Being struck by lightning is exceedingly rare but people still take precautions in a thunder storm. It’s exceedingly rare that you would win the lottery, but that enough for most people to play it. Exceedingly rare metabolic disorders are tested for in newborn heel prick tests on all babies. “Exceedingly rare” given the current situation that men do stay out of female spaces, is not enough to declare them open to all every Tom, Dick and Harry who fancies going in.

It is about safeguarding.

CassOle · 16/11/2026 14:32

Is Elizabeth Fry being forgotten about already?

Heggettypeg · 16/11/2026 14:35

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 14:09

Safeguarding is neither here nor there. Separate sex facilities is about dignity and privacy, not safety.

The overwhelming majority of violence against women and girls is committed by partners, ex-partners and men the victim already knows, in homes and private spaces - not toilets and changing rooms. The one peer-reviewed study of police records on this (Hasenbush et al., 2018) found reported incidents in these spaces ‘exceedingly rare

A policy justified by women’s safety that concentrates on toilets is aimed at the place the danger isn’t — against a perpetrator who was never going to be stopped by a sign anyway. There’s no evidence that more sex-segregated societies have less violence against women; many report very high rates. Meanwhile, Ireland has had self-identification since 2015 — ten years, around a thousand certificates, and not one documented case of a man using it to get into a women’s space to offend. Denmark, Norway, Malta and Argentina tell the same story. The predicted wave of predators exploiting self-ID was predicted loudly and hasn’t happened anywhere it’s been tried.

Finally, if the concern really is violence in public, actually men and boys are considerably more likely than women to be attacked by a stranger in public.

This isn't about safeguarding, it's about social norms around "decency", privacy and dignity.

Edited

Under equality law, the default starting position is that everything is for everyone. Mixed sex.

However, it is recognised that there are some situations where separation by sex is appropriate and therefore allowed. If it is appropriate, it should be single sex. If not, it should be for everyone.

There is no justification for what amounts to pseudo "single sex" provision with a select coterie of the opposite sex allowed to break the rules.

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 14:36

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 14:09

Safeguarding is neither here nor there. Separate sex facilities is about dignity and privacy, not safety.

The overwhelming majority of violence against women and girls is committed by partners, ex-partners and men the victim already knows, in homes and private spaces - not toilets and changing rooms. The one peer-reviewed study of police records on this (Hasenbush et al., 2018) found reported incidents in these spaces ‘exceedingly rare

A policy justified by women’s safety that concentrates on toilets is aimed at the place the danger isn’t — against a perpetrator who was never going to be stopped by a sign anyway. There’s no evidence that more sex-segregated societies have less violence against women; many report very high rates. Meanwhile, Ireland has had self-identification since 2015 — ten years, around a thousand certificates, and not one documented case of a man using it to get into a women’s space to offend. Denmark, Norway, Malta and Argentina tell the same story. The predicted wave of predators exploiting self-ID was predicted loudly and hasn’t happened anywhere it’s been tried.

Finally, if the concern really is violence in public, actually men and boys are considerably more likely than women to be attacked by a stranger in public.

This isn't about safeguarding, it's about social norms around "decency", privacy and dignity.

Edited

Separate sex facilities is about dignity and privacy, not safety.

And you don't get that either if you are forced to share with men just because their ego tells them that they have a right to share women's space.

However, one also has to take into account

  1. the disproportionate number of men who commit crimes like voyeurism and indecent exposure, which are effectively legalised if they do these things in a place where they are allowed to be naked or see women who are naked.

  2. the number of women who would be excluded from a facility that they had to share with men. You are heading into sex discrimination territory.

You are just going to have to get used to the idea that women are allowed to set boundaries and say No.

There’s no evidence that more sex-segregated societies have less violence against women; many report very high rates.

Well, yes, I am sure that countries like Afghanistan have very high rates of violence against women. We should not be randomly segregating some men from some women with no purpose, which is what you are advocating.

Meanwhile, Ireland has had self-identification since 2015 — ten years, around a thousand certificates, and not one documented case of a man using it to get into a women’s space to offend.

The obvious example in Ireland is Barbie Kardashian.

More recently in the UK a man kidnapped and attempted to strangle a woman he saw on the street and his lawyer argued in court that he was a vulnerable woman.

Finally, if the concern really is violence in public, actually men and boys are considerably more likely than women to be attacked by a stranger in public.

Men beat each other up so women shouldn't be able to set boundaries? That is rather a strange argument.

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 14:38

CassOle · 16/11/2026 14:32

Is Elizabeth Fry being forgotten about already?

If only somebody had told her that

"Sex segregation just simply isn’t an evidence-based strategy for preventing violence against women. It simply isn't. It was never designed as one."

But what did she know, hey?

Swipe left for the next trending thread