Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
TheKeatingFive · 16/11/2026 12:30

ArabellaScott · 16/11/2026 12:27

Another thing about 'passing' that I find really fascinating is the the whole premise of 'passing' is deception.

The beginning, middle and end of it is overtly and explicitly about deceiving other people.

Exactly

It shouldn’t be given the time of day.

Everyone knows what sex they are. These men need to show women some respect and stay out of their spaces.

Pingponghavoc · 16/11/2026 12:31

Over the years we have had men who claim to use the women's toilets because they pass AND they are welcomed in because women see TWAW.

They also claim that everyone knows the difference between a man dressed as a woman and a genuine TW.

GriseldaandMike · 16/11/2026 12:31

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 12:05

Right. No amount of reason or argument. Your creed is unfalsifiable.

No idea why I'm here.

No idea why I'm here

Thats what happens when you have no grasp of what sex is or what its for. A mummy (a woman, with a lady body) and a daddy (a man with a male body) had a special cuddle that grew into baby Lacksie in the mummy's tummy and low you were born.

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 12:33

It's interesting that using the criteria suggested on this thread Dr Upton should not have been using a facility for women.

RareGoalsVerge · 16/11/2026 12:33

2021x · 15/11/2026 05:26

I'm not worried about that much. It looks like, apart from a small number of Redditors, TG people accept that they cannot change sex.

What they're arguing now is that they have an X brain in a Y body. I think if that was the case, then there would be data in the behaviour of people that would back that up.

If people want to be accepted as the opposite gender, I think we should be clear about what that means within ourselves. The examples I gave are what I would think, and I am interested to hear if there is anything I have missed

If there was genuine evidence that it can actually be possible for a "male" brain to exist in a "female" body and vice versa (which there isn't - what you have got is a wide spectrum of brains, which have a lot of overlap and are impossible to define as "male" or "female" unless you use sexist stereotypes as a baseline, and which can exist in either male or female bodies) then that would certainly be enough to have some kind of reasonable legal status as having their chosen Gender if there were some kind of externally verifiable test that can detect and reliably measure someone's gender. I do not believe such a thing could possibly exist without accepting and codifying sexism at a deeply abhorent level so I am not advocating for it to happen.

However, that Gender still does exist in the body of the sex that it factually is. And a lot of the time when things are different for male and female people, it is because of the body not because of the brain. If the brain is practically, legally and emotionally female but the body is male then that male body still needs to be kept out of female spaces, and the female brain inside that body would need to accept that - obviously provision of 3rd space unisex options is important for such individuals. There is no surgery or drug treatment even theoretically that could make a male body into a female body, it will only ever be a male body that has undergone surgery or drug treatment.

The concept of TWAW and TMAM requires for this to be true from the moment someone first declares themselves to be Trans. Being trans is not a status that is earned after sufficient time and money has been spent on achieving a body that "passes". Any definitions for what makes it OK for a male to be considered female which require certain treatments to have been completed creates a pressure to railroad someone towards those treatments, even if they aren't in the best interests of the individual, so any such criteria are intrinsically unethical.

I could imagine a utopia in which all patriarchy and sexism has been eliminated, sexual predation has been eliminated, there is no more male violence against women, rape is unheard of. No one would touch someone's body without consent, it would just be "not a thing" - like trying to pick someone else's nose, no one would even try, the idea of trying would provoke disgust in anyone who you asked to do it. No employers ever make decisions about employment or promotion with the slightest amount of unconscious bias about a particular person being potentially more likely to need maternity leave, and no one struggles to get back into their professional career after a break for child rearing (obviously both male and female parents being equally likely to take such a break). In such a utopia perhaps there would be no more need for all-female spaces to protect female people. Even prisons could be fully mixed sex throughout because even criminals (of which there would be a lot fewer, if all male violence issues have been resolved) have sufficient deep respect for women that women are no more vulnerable than men. As are sometimes depicted in futureistic sci-fi tv programmes, men and women just get changed together and are spectacularly unbothered by naked bodies of the opposite sex around them, no one feels vulnerable because of this and there is no sexual banter triggered by it. In such a utopia, then yes perhaps a "man" could be considered a "woman" - insomuch as the words have any meaning really - socially in such a utopia there would be so little differences between the sexes that the words would be pretty meaningless - but you would still need a word in medicine for "the kind of body that is organised around developing a womb and ovaries (even if they didn't develop quite as standard)" and "the kind of body that is organised around producing sperm (even if the organs didn't develop quite as standard)" and it still wouldn't be possible for someone born with the first type of body to become someone who has the second type or vice versa - and perhaps that would be just a matter between the individual in question and their intended co-parent if they were trying to have a child (imagine the consultation "ah ha - I have discovered why you are having so much trouble Mr & Mrs Smith - it turns out you are both producing sperm!") and their medical caregivers (especially for diseases like heart problems and cancers which manifest differently in male and female bodies). But on a day to day level - the standard for me to change my mind would be "when there is no longer any point reserving anything just for female people because all disadvantages encountered by female people have been 100% effectively eliminated and there is no longer any advantage to being male in any circumstance".

Except that standard could never be reached in sport, not without genetically engineering the entire species.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/11/2026 12:35

The SC judgement was about the definition of terms in the EA and how they should be interpreted for understanding protections from discrimination in law, not a judgement on how access to toilets could be practically managed.

Not directly or operationally, because that's not the role of the SC. However, under the EA 2010, while it's not compulsory to provide single sex spaces, but doing so and restricting them to single sex (as defined by the SC) is legally protected as non-discriminatory.

So indirectly, they did.

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 12:35

spannasaurus · 16/11/2026 12:30

How does one make laws where the qualifying criteria is whether you pass as the opposite sex? What would be the criteria for who passes? What happens if one person says the person passes and another person says they don't?

It is managed through social convention.

However, the law already depends on judgements about passing - hence the provision to allow trans men to be excluded from female facilities, without being discriminatory.

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 12:38

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 12:35

It is managed through social convention.

However, the law already depends on judgements about passing - hence the provision to allow trans men to be excluded from female facilities, without being discriminatory.

The example they suggested was a rape crisis centre and It was not implied that it was proportionate to exclude women from toilets because of their appearance.

BlueLegume · 16/11/2026 12:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Wishesandhorses · 16/11/2026 12:55

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 12:38

The example they suggested was a rape crisis centre and It was not implied that it was proportionate to exclude women from toilets because of their appearance.

Quite.

I've never understood whether this example (which was explained thoroughly in the SCJ in quite small words, it's almost as if the judges expected this)

overchallenges comprehension too far
is wilfully misused when convenient
is waved around by someone who has never read the SCJ at all and downloads their thinking from what they read online
all of the above

It's a bit like the spousal exit clause.

But the common theme is not being able to see women as human. Or manage empathy. Or theory of mind.

BackToLurk · 16/11/2026 12:57

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 09:24

Revealing that reason and explanation and humane argument were never going to matter.

Revealing to see so many people announce that no fact, evidence or lived experience could ever reach them.

I’d been told these were ‘just reasonable concerns.’ Turns out they’re unfalsifiable. That’s not a concern; that’s a creed

Edited

Well yes. I can’t envisage anything that would convince me that some male people should use spaces, services or facilities that it has been decided should be female only, based only on how those male people identify. How is that a problem? If it helps I also can’t think of anything that would convince me to allow children access to spaces, services or facilities that have been designated as adult only.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/11/2026 13:04

Revealing to see so many people announce that no fact, evidence or lived experience could ever reach them.

If you mean that we believe in biological sex and we can't and won't believe that men can be women, correct. Because that's not a fact, it's a wish on the men's part. Ditto 'lived experience.'

BlueLegume · 16/11/2026 13:04

Reasonable people do not mess with children’s minds or bodies. That is inhumane.

Men pretending to be women should not be in rape crisis centres designated for women.

Women pretending to be men should not be presenting as a gay man. They are woman.

The whole thing is utterly ludicrous.

spannasaurus · 16/11/2026 13:05

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 12:35

It is managed through social convention.

However, the law already depends on judgements about passing - hence the provision to allow trans men to be excluded from female facilities, without being discriminatory.

That's in relation to excluding someone from a single sex services for their own sex rather than including someone in a single sex service of the opposite sex. Those are two different considerations.

You seem to want evidence that shows why someone should be excluded from the wrong category whereas I, and many other posters, require evidence to show why someone should be included in the wrong category.

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 13:07

BlueLegume · 16/11/2026 13:04

Reasonable people do not mess with children’s minds or bodies. That is inhumane.

Men pretending to be women should not be in rape crisis centres designated for women.

Women pretending to be men should not be presenting as a gay man. They are woman.

The whole thing is utterly ludicrous.

Reasonable people do not mess with children’s minds or bodies. That is inhumane.

Lol so you are against all health care and mental health support for kids then?

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/11/2026 13:08

That’s not a concern; that’s a creed

Whereas arguing over pages that TWAW and should be allowed in women's single sex spaces isn't.

Damn, I need a new irony meter.

Heggettypeg · 16/11/2026 13:08

So which is it?:

"I'm entitled to use these facilities because (I think) I look like a woman?" or

"I'm entitled to use these facilities because, whatever I look like, I feel I am a woman."

These are two entirely different positions, so what precisely are we being asked to change our minds about?

One thing is clear, as somebody pointed out up the thread: if it's about what you look like, rather than just about how you feel, none of the transwomen featured in tribunals would have a leg to stand on, because if anybody realises yo.u are trans, you haven't passed.

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 13:11

spannasaurus · 16/11/2026 13:05

That's in relation to excluding someone from a single sex services for their own sex rather than including someone in a single sex service of the opposite sex. Those are two different considerations.

You seem to want evidence that shows why someone should be excluded from the wrong category whereas I, and many other posters, require evidence to show why someone should be included in the wrong category.

That's in relation to excluding someone from a single sex services for their own sex rather than including someone in a single sex service of the opposite sex. Those are two different considerations

Sure. But it involves a judgement about passing, so no reason why that is practically able to be applied for exclusion, but not practical for inclusion. It's the same principle.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/11/2026 13:12

Reasonable people do not mess with children’s minds or bodies. That is inhumane.

Lol so you are against all health care and mental health support for kids then?

We have now reached the 'I have absolutely no argument to make that won't get taken apart bit by bit so I'm just going to make stupid comments' level of debate.

BlueLegume · 16/11/2026 13:13

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 13:07

Reasonable people do not mess with children’s minds or bodies. That is inhumane.

Lol so you are against all health care and mental health support for kids then?

Mess with their minds as in telling them that they might have been born in the wrong body by sowing seeds of misinformation. But you knew that it is the usual spin. We should help them understand it is not possible to change sex and help them to learn to love who they are. We should not peddle snake oil to them.

That is inhumane and unreasonable and any rational person would not do that. Safeguarding is clearly something some people have a very arms length relationship with.

We must safeguard children. We cannot keep pretending this trans stuff is something healthy. None of it is from the bastardised language to make it sound all lovely and kind to surgeries on healthy body parts.

The irony of all the ‘be kind’ pro trans brigade is many consider them selves ‘left leaning’ and progressive but they are playing right into the capitalist market making a fortune from the trans movement. Big pharmaceutical companies making customers for life, unethical surgeons/therapists etc etc - all making a fortune from trans.

BlueLegume · 16/11/2026 13:15

Last weeks word of the week was ‘phenotypes’ this weeks word of the week is ‘passing’ 🙄

spannasaurus · 16/11/2026 13:16

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 13:11

That's in relation to excluding someone from a single sex services for their own sex rather than including someone in a single sex service of the opposite sex. Those are two different considerations

Sure. But it involves a judgement about passing, so no reason why that is practically able to be applied for exclusion, but not practical for inclusion. It's the same principle.

Its not the same principle.

StealthTroublemaker · 16/11/2026 13:22

GriseldaandMike · 16/11/2026 12:31

No idea why I'm here

Thats what happens when you have no grasp of what sex is or what its for. A mummy (a woman, with a lady body) and a daddy (a man with a male body) had a special cuddle that grew into baby Lacksie in the mummy's tummy and low you were born.

Snort

Laugh Out Loud Laughing GIF by Linda Rey & Trevor
Lacksie · 16/11/2026 13:22

spannasaurus · 16/11/2026 13:16

Its not the same principle.

It's the same in the sense that it involves a judgement about presentation and perception to interpret how a legal rule should be applied.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · 16/11/2026 13:22

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 13:07

Reasonable people do not mess with children’s minds or bodies. That is inhumane.

Lol so you are against all health care and mental health support for kids then?

Ha ha it must be exhausting to be so dramatic all the time.

Me; oh my kid is silly, she put a sausage in her hair...
You; SO ALL KIDS ARE STUPID NOW ARE THEY???????

Me: a dog barked at me the other day
You: SO YOU HATE ALL ANIMALS NOW DO YOU?????