Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What would it take for your to change your mind for Transgender issues

685 replies

2021x · 15/11/2026 04:39

When I engage with (normal) people who believe in TWAW/TMAM, I try to establish what they would need to see/hear to change their mind.

I thought I would turn the tables and ask myself what I would need to see to believe that TWAW/TMAM- not females, but people who would experience life as if they were women.

  • Transwomen would have the upper-body strength in the female range. This fact is often missed off the talking points. Most studies put the strength loss at around 10-15% which is still vastly above the female range of upper body strength. For a male to be able to be in the female range and therefore not be a threat to women in single sex spaces they would have to lose 50% of their upperbody strength which has never been recorded in research.
  • Transwomen would have to demonstrate a criminal profile similar to that of women, i.e. non-violent crime
  • Transwomen employment profile would be similar to that of women i.e. poor representation in leadership compared to transmen
  • Transmen would experience the same level of physical assault and death that men experience.
  • Transmen would experience the same rates of suicide as men.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
DeanElderberry · 16/11/2026 14:39

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/11/2026 14:18

So the argument comes down to 'well VAWAG happens, so let's not put anything in the way of the inevitable because it's pointless, men are going to attack women anyway' and that's actually serious.

Not one documented case of a man using it to get into a women’s space to offend in Ireland. (Emphasis mine).

There’s no evidence that more sex-segregated societies have less violence against women; many report very high rates.

"And anyway, women in Afghanistan have it worse, so stop moaning."

Edited

In the case Paddy O'Gorman recorded, the transwoman who beat up a woman in the domestic violence shelter in Dublin would not have been documented as a man, because he self-identified as a woman.

So all the poor and battered women who are now terrified to use a space designed and built for them don't even have a record of what really happened.

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 14:39

Helleofabore · 16/11/2026 14:27

“Sex segregation just simply isn’t an evidence-based strategy for preventing violence against women. It simply isn't. It was never designed as one.”

How about you produce historical documents that support this claim?

Well first, a point about who owes whom evidence. You’re the one claiming that excluding trans women from toilets protects women from violence. That’s a safety claim, and safety claims are the kind you have to show — with incidents, rates, before-and-after, something. ‘Produce historical documents’ is not how this works. You produce the evidence that it’s an evidence-based strategy; I don’t have to prove a negative. But since you asked, I already provided the evidence that points the other way, it is:

  • violence against women overwhelmingly happens in private settings, by perpetrators known to the victim, like partners/ ex partners/ family members. Stranger assault in a public place such as a toilet or a changing room is exceptionally rare. Men and boys are significantly more at risk of being victims of violence by a stranger in public than women/ girls.
  • The one peer reviewed study that has compared matched localities with and without trans-inclusive access laws, before and after, and found no change in safety or privacy violations — incidents were in fact slightly higher in the places without trans inclusive laws. Fears of increased violations under these laws are not empirically grounded. At the national level, Ireland has had legal self-identification since 2015; a decade of government annual reports show slow, steady uptake and no evidence of abuse. Denmark, Norway, Malta and Argentina have had it as long or longer. The predicted wave of predators exploiting self-ID has not been documented anywhere it’s been tried — and critics’ own strongest point is that nobody monitored for it, which is an admission that they have nothing either.
  • Sex segregation in public doesn't protect women from violence: the WHO’s global study found the highest rates of partner violence against women in Oceania, Southern Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa (33–51%), with countries like Afghanistan and Bangladesh at the top, and the lowest in Europe (16–23%). The societies that segregate public life most rigidly by sex are the ones where women are least safe. The thing that protects women is equality, not separation.

Excluding trans women from toilets is not an evidence-based strategy for preventing violence against women, and nobody who’s looked at the data presents it as one.

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 14:41

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 14:19

evidence that not one of the female people who are there or who could be potentially there will not have identified that male person’s sex category correctly.

If that were the principle you'd have to start excluding all varieties of gender non-conforming women, in case a single woman might mistakenly perceive them to be a man.

You really should drop the idea that it's impossible to judge the sex of a woman who is gender non-conforming, as it comes across as rather misogynist.

If women were able to pass as men by simply cutting their hair and wearing trousers, the world would be a lot easier for women.

DeanElderberry · 16/11/2026 14:42

Likewise all the women in Limerick prison, afraid to report abuse by transwomen fellow-prisoners because their punishment for referring to the men as 'men' would be having to stay in Victorian-era cells instead of moving into the lightly regulated women's prison with the educational and counselling opportunities available there.

The men's actions victimising women will have been documented as women's actions. Self ID is an attack on women.

ArabellaScott · 16/11/2026 14:43

TheKeatingFive · 16/11/2026 12:30

Exactly

It shouldn’t be given the time of day.

Everyone knows what sex they are. These men need to show women some respect and stay out of their spaces.

It's equivalent to suggesting that nobody should ever ask to see ID to buy alcohol, it's offensive and possibly even a criminal offense to ask to see ID, and that we should base the law on people who 'appear old enough' rather than those who are old enough.

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 14:44

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 14:39

Well first, a point about who owes whom evidence. You’re the one claiming that excluding trans women from toilets protects women from violence. That’s a safety claim, and safety claims are the kind you have to show — with incidents, rates, before-and-after, something. ‘Produce historical documents’ is not how this works. You produce the evidence that it’s an evidence-based strategy; I don’t have to prove a negative. But since you asked, I already provided the evidence that points the other way, it is:

  • violence against women overwhelmingly happens in private settings, by perpetrators known to the victim, like partners/ ex partners/ family members. Stranger assault in a public place such as a toilet or a changing room is exceptionally rare. Men and boys are significantly more at risk of being victims of violence by a stranger in public than women/ girls.
  • The one peer reviewed study that has compared matched localities with and without trans-inclusive access laws, before and after, and found no change in safety or privacy violations — incidents were in fact slightly higher in the places without trans inclusive laws. Fears of increased violations under these laws are not empirically grounded. At the national level, Ireland has had legal self-identification since 2015; a decade of government annual reports show slow, steady uptake and no evidence of abuse. Denmark, Norway, Malta and Argentina have had it as long or longer. The predicted wave of predators exploiting self-ID has not been documented anywhere it’s been tried — and critics’ own strongest point is that nobody monitored for it, which is an admission that they have nothing either.
  • Sex segregation in public doesn't protect women from violence: the WHO’s global study found the highest rates of partner violence against women in Oceania, Southern Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa (33–51%), with countries like Afghanistan and Bangladesh at the top, and the lowest in Europe (16–23%). The societies that segregate public life most rigidly by sex are the ones where women are least safe. The thing that protects women is equality, not separation.

Excluding trans women from toilets is not an evidence-based strategy for preventing violence against women, and nobody who’s looked at the data presents it as one.

You’re the one claiming that excluding trans women from toilets protects women from violence.

Excluding men.

As covered previously, there is no way to tell what any man thinks about his gender identity, so it's not relevant.

The thing that protects women is equality, not separation.

Which is why we completely reject your suggestion of random segregation for absolutely no purpose.

Leafstamp · 16/11/2026 14:44

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 14:39

Well first, a point about who owes whom evidence. You’re the one claiming that excluding trans women from toilets protects women from violence. That’s a safety claim, and safety claims are the kind you have to show — with incidents, rates, before-and-after, something. ‘Produce historical documents’ is not how this works. You produce the evidence that it’s an evidence-based strategy; I don’t have to prove a negative. But since you asked, I already provided the evidence that points the other way, it is:

  • violence against women overwhelmingly happens in private settings, by perpetrators known to the victim, like partners/ ex partners/ family members. Stranger assault in a public place such as a toilet or a changing room is exceptionally rare. Men and boys are significantly more at risk of being victims of violence by a stranger in public than women/ girls.
  • The one peer reviewed study that has compared matched localities with and without trans-inclusive access laws, before and after, and found no change in safety or privacy violations — incidents were in fact slightly higher in the places without trans inclusive laws. Fears of increased violations under these laws are not empirically grounded. At the national level, Ireland has had legal self-identification since 2015; a decade of government annual reports show slow, steady uptake and no evidence of abuse. Denmark, Norway, Malta and Argentina have had it as long or longer. The predicted wave of predators exploiting self-ID has not been documented anywhere it’s been tried — and critics’ own strongest point is that nobody monitored for it, which is an admission that they have nothing either.
  • Sex segregation in public doesn't protect women from violence: the WHO’s global study found the highest rates of partner violence against women in Oceania, Southern Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa (33–51%), with countries like Afghanistan and Bangladesh at the top, and the lowest in Europe (16–23%). The societies that segregate public life most rigidly by sex are the ones where women are least safe. The thing that protects women is equality, not separation.

Excluding trans women from toilets is not an evidence-based strategy for preventing violence against women, and nobody who’s looked at the data presents it as one.

@Lacksie do you accept that excluding men, including TW from women’s toilets preserves women’s privacy and dignity then?

ArabellaScott · 16/11/2026 14:44

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 14:39

Well first, a point about who owes whom evidence. You’re the one claiming that excluding trans women from toilets protects women from violence. That’s a safety claim, and safety claims are the kind you have to show — with incidents, rates, before-and-after, something. ‘Produce historical documents’ is not how this works. You produce the evidence that it’s an evidence-based strategy; I don’t have to prove a negative. But since you asked, I already provided the evidence that points the other way, it is:

  • violence against women overwhelmingly happens in private settings, by perpetrators known to the victim, like partners/ ex partners/ family members. Stranger assault in a public place such as a toilet or a changing room is exceptionally rare. Men and boys are significantly more at risk of being victims of violence by a stranger in public than women/ girls.
  • The one peer reviewed study that has compared matched localities with and without trans-inclusive access laws, before and after, and found no change in safety or privacy violations — incidents were in fact slightly higher in the places without trans inclusive laws. Fears of increased violations under these laws are not empirically grounded. At the national level, Ireland has had legal self-identification since 2015; a decade of government annual reports show slow, steady uptake and no evidence of abuse. Denmark, Norway, Malta and Argentina have had it as long or longer. The predicted wave of predators exploiting self-ID has not been documented anywhere it’s been tried — and critics’ own strongest point is that nobody monitored for it, which is an admission that they have nothing either.
  • Sex segregation in public doesn't protect women from violence: the WHO’s global study found the highest rates of partner violence against women in Oceania, Southern Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa (33–51%), with countries like Afghanistan and Bangladesh at the top, and the lowest in Europe (16–23%). The societies that segregate public life most rigidly by sex are the ones where women are least safe. The thing that protects women is equality, not separation.

Excluding trans women from toilets is not an evidence-based strategy for preventing violence against women, and nobody who’s looked at the data presents it as one.

Men commit 99% of all sexual assaults.

This is the only stat we need for this situation.

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 14:45

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 14:41

You really should drop the idea that it's impossible to judge the sex of a woman who is gender non-conforming, as it comes across as rather misogynist.

If women were able to pass as men by simply cutting their hair and wearing trousers, the world would be a lot easier for women.

I never said "it is impossible to judge the sex of a woman who is gender non-conforming" lol,
I said that sometimes it happens that a gender non-conforming woman's sex is wrongly perceived.
This is an empirically verifiable claim - not something I've invented. we have various threads on mumsnet where women have posted saying this has happened to them.

A pp said the standard is - trans women must be excluded if a single woman might possibly perceive their sex as male. If that is the standard then it follows that we would have to exclude not only many trans men, but also some gender non-conforming women from female toilets etc., if there could be a single user who might perceive them to be male.

DeanElderberry · 16/11/2026 14:46

Paddy O'Gorman of course, apologies for confusion.

A rare person, prepared to listen and prepared to speak truth.

paddyspodcast.ie/

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 14:46

ArabellaScott · 16/11/2026 14:43

It's equivalent to suggesting that nobody should ever ask to see ID to buy alcohol, it's offensive and possibly even a criminal offense to ask to see ID, and that we should base the law on people who 'appear old enough' rather than those who are old enough.

Certainly I should be entitled to a freedom pass in London without anyone questioning my age or where I live. The question, is do I look like somebody who might be entitled to a freedom pass and lives in London?

spannasaurus · 16/11/2026 14:48

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 14:45

I never said "it is impossible to judge the sex of a woman who is gender non-conforming" lol,
I said that sometimes it happens that a gender non-conforming woman's sex is wrongly perceived.
This is an empirically verifiable claim - not something I've invented. we have various threads on mumsnet where women have posted saying this has happened to them.

A pp said the standard is - trans women must be excluded if a single woman might possibly perceive their sex as male. If that is the standard then it follows that we would have to exclude not only many trans men, but also some gender non-conforming women from female toilets etc., if there could be a single user who might perceive them to be male.

Edited

You're the only one who is suggesting passing should be the qualifying criteria the rest of us are saying sex is the qualifying criteria.

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 14:53

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 14:45

I never said "it is impossible to judge the sex of a woman who is gender non-conforming" lol,
I said that sometimes it happens that a gender non-conforming woman's sex is wrongly perceived.
This is an empirically verifiable claim - not something I've invented. we have various threads on mumsnet where women have posted saying this has happened to them.

A pp said the standard is - trans women must be excluded if a single woman might possibly perceive their sex as male. If that is the standard then it follows that we would have to exclude not only many trans men, but also some gender non-conforming women from female toilets etc., if there could be a single user who might perceive them to be male.

Edited

This is an empirically verifiable claim - not something I've invented. we have various threads on mumsnet where women have posted saying this has happened to them.

We certainly have posts from women saying that it happens very occasionally and it's a bit embarrassing but that the confusion ends with a second glance and as soon as they open their mouth.

People really aren't that bad at judging sex. Again, if they were. women would have used it to their advantage long before now.

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 14:55

spannasaurus · 16/11/2026 14:48

You're the only one who is suggesting passing should be the qualifying criteria the rest of us are saying sex is the qualifying criteria.

Yes I'm saying passing should be the criteria as it fits with the purposes for which the EA provides for separate spaces - social convention, privacy, dignity, etc.

This should be managed through social convention not externally policed.

A pp said this wasn't possible as we couldn't have laws that differentiate between people based on "passing", I pointed out that we already do - the EA and the SC judgment provide for the exclusion of trans men based on gender presentation/ perceived sex.

A pp then said that wasn't about 'passing' it was because there might be the odd woman who perceived them inaccurately - not everyone can judge sex accurately (true) - and that the same couldn't be applied for including trans women as in order to do so you would have to show that there wasn't a single woman who might perceive them as male.
I pointed out if that were the standard we would have to enforce the exclusion of many trans men and also some gender non-conforming women who might be mistaken by individuals to be male.

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 14:58

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 14:55

Yes I'm saying passing should be the criteria as it fits with the purposes for which the EA provides for separate spaces - social convention, privacy, dignity, etc.

This should be managed through social convention not externally policed.

A pp said this wasn't possible as we couldn't have laws that differentiate between people based on "passing", I pointed out that we already do - the EA and the SC judgment provide for the exclusion of trans men based on gender presentation/ perceived sex.

A pp then said that wasn't about 'passing' it was because there might be the odd woman who perceived them inaccurately - not everyone can judge sex accurately (true) - and that the same couldn't be applied for including trans women as in order to do so you would have to show that there wasn't a single woman who might perceive them as male.
I pointed out if that were the standard we would have to enforce the exclusion of many trans men and also some gender non-conforming women who might be mistaken by individuals to be male.

Just to be clear, your argument is that Dr Beth Upton should not have been using a changing area designated for women?

Tears0fTheMushroom · 16/11/2026 14:59

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 10:55

They can, but they wouldn't because of social convention.

Cisgender men don't use women's facilities, because it would be deeply inappropriate and embarrassing to do so. that is the social convention.

Trans women, however, occasionally do use female services, especially if they pass, because they understand themselves to be women, and also are aware that others reliably perceive them to be women.

This is the difference.

It is because of this difference that the EA and SC judgment provide for the exclusion of trans men from female services.

So... no difference then?.
Let's face it. The vast majority of TIMs who force their way into women's single sex spaces not only do not pass as women (because none of them do under real life scrutiny) but aren't even trying to pass as women.

But the real thing you're missing here is: it doesn't matter if they do pass - they're still men!
Being effectively "invisible" while creeping on women doesn't make it ok. It makes it worse!

The idea that there might be a man in the women's changing room with you that you can't see is a deeply unsettling thought for most women and absolutely terrifying to women who are traumatised from sexual abuse/rape. We need to KNOW there are no men in there. Which is exactly why decent men stay out.

Furthermore, choosing to dress "feminine" and/or take hormones/have surgery is a CHOICE these men have made. They need to learn to live with the consequences of that choice. It's not women's job to mitigate that for them.
Their decision, their problem.

UnoriginalPoster · 16/11/2026 15:09

I would change my mind if there were evidence that a person could change the DNA in every cell of his/her body by an act of will.

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 15:09

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 14:58

Just to be clear, your argument is that Dr Beth Upton should not have been using a changing area designated for women?

DU specifically asked for permission from her employer, so she did the right thing.

As for the decisions made by NHS Fife, the tribunal found that they did not handle the situation properly, given SP's complaint. I accept that conclusion.

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 15:12

If I'm getting this right the suggestion seems to be that most men who identify as trans should not be able to use women's spaces, another tranche of men should be uncertain which space they should use, and that only a tiny vanishingly small number of men who actually pass (if they exist) should have confidence in provision.

Meanwhile women are supposed to do what - tell men that they don't pass? Put up with men who don't pass?

And who is supposed to be supporting this idea?

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 15:13

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 15:09

DU specifically asked for permission from her employer, so she did the right thing.

As for the decisions made by NHS Fife, the tribunal found that they did not handle the situation properly, given SP's complaint. I accept that conclusion.

But we are talking about your suggested policy, and according to this the employer was wrong, and should have refused Dr Upton permission. Are you standing by this?

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 15:19

nicepotoftea · 16/11/2026 15:13

But we are talking about your suggested policy, and according to this the employer was wrong, and should have refused Dr Upton permission. Are you standing by this?

I'm not making any judgment about whether DU generally passes or not - I haven't met DU.

SP knew DU was trans, whether that's because she doesn't pass, or whether that's because she is open about being trans I don't know.

SP was the only nurse who made a complaint, and we heard no evidence from others having an issue at the tribunal.

DU specifically asked permission to use the changing rooms from her employer - she didn't just waltz on in there , she did the right thing. How NHS Fife should have initially responded, I can't say. However, given that SP did complain, NHS fife did not subsequently handle the situation properly - either for the best interests of SP or for DU - as found by the tribunal.

Furthermore, it's been clarified in law that the workplace regs follow the SC definition of sex - meaning that NHS Fife did have a legal obligation to ensure SP had a private, single -birth sex place to change. This could have been an addition - e.g. a private user room, but there needed to be an appropriate space available.

Hopefully this answers your question and you are not going to do the thing you like to do of asking me the same question over and over again.

Finally , please note , I have repeatedly clarified that under my "suggested policy" (which is again simply what we've always had until very recently), these spaces should not be externally policed, but rather managed by user access/ provider judgement through social convention. So DU did the right thing in asking since she was aware that people knew she was trans.

TheKeatingFive · 16/11/2026 15:22

@Lacksie

2 questions

Who decides whether a man ‘passes’ or not and therefore is allowed to use women’s spaces?

What should a woman do if she sees what she knows to be a man in her single sex space?

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/11/2026 15:27

these spaces should not be externally policed, but rather managed by user access/ provider judgement through social convention.

Social convention is that biological women use the ladies, biological men use the mens.

So DU did the right thing in asking since she was aware that people knew she was trans.

DU was aware that he's a man larping as a woman and was trespassing where he had no right to be and causing distress. That was the point.

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 15:28

TheKeatingFive · 16/11/2026 15:22

@Lacksie

2 questions

Who decides whether a man ‘passes’ or not and therefore is allowed to use women’s spaces?

What should a woman do if she sees what she knows to be a man in her single sex space?

  1. I've repeatedly answered this - it should be individually managed through social convention - depending on the circumstances/ context. People - even those nefarious trans one - naturally want privacy and to avoid drawing inappropriate attention to themselves.
  1. It's not "her space" it's a facility owned by a service user. If a customer/ user feels uncomfortable she should take that up with the service provider - not harass other service users. Even the EHRC code says this.
CorvusPurpureus · 16/11/2026 15:28

Lacksie · 16/11/2026 15:09

DU specifically asked for permission from her employer, so she did the right thing.

As for the decisions made by NHS Fife, the tribunal found that they did not handle the situation properly, given SP's complaint. I accept that conclusion.

So with regard to Upton’s presence in a female single sex space, you agree - with his employers, to be fair - he shouldn’t have been there?

Would that just be because he’s a hulking great balding 6’ non passing Carry On Nurse sort of chap, or would you see it differently if he happened to be a slightly built delicate lad?

You seem to be basing your latest argument around ‘passing’?

Seems a bit unfair to Upton. He might not come across as likeable or professional, but it’s not his fault that his physical build means he can’t meet your ‘passing’ standards.

(& meanwhile, obviously, the majority of women would prefer single sex spaces regardless of how any man presents/looks).

Swipe left for the next trending thread