swimster- hello and welcome to the loveliest smelling thread on MN!
I have Coromandel, which I adore, and samples of 31 Rue Cambon, 22, Cuir de Russie and Bel Respiro.
Coromandel is definitely my favourite, because to me, it is unique! 31 is a powerhousey flowery chypre. Grown up, think of ladies dressed in Armani and Gucci shoes.
Cuir de Russie (IMO) is not nearly as nice a leather as Cuir Cordoba by Keiko Mecheri (but I am v biased as that is on my desert island top 10) Bel Respiro is nice enough, fresh, sunny. Bit underwhelming and I wouldn't be paying £££s for a FB. 22 is a minger.
Again, personal opinion, but it was one of very few perfumes that had me running for the scouring pad shrieking "geditoffmenow!"
I have a dupe (Perfume Parlour) of Sycomore and love it. Bit masculine, you do get a bit of an aftershavey whiff. But more sophisticated and woody.
I don't think as many perfumes go off as salespeople would have us believe tbh. I suppose it depends how it's been kept, but in the past few years of sourcing vintage from ebay etc I've only had to chuck one, an 80s Ysatis, which was actually fine when I got it, but because it had a stopper didn't last very long.
Am just getting rid of my sinusy early morning snotfest and then I shall make a sotd decision. Back later!