Howabout, I am out of touch with education in scotland and my own is a dim distant memory. But I'd wager it beats schools down here - not all, I think many primary schools do well and a fair number of secondaries - but I think theres something to be said for knowing there is no question that all your children will be going to your local school, it terms of stability for the family. And the school knows it is serving its local, settled community who will call it out if required.
I had a helluva shock when my sons nursery asked me, when he was just four, what school he was going to. I said, oh it'll be next September. She looked at me like I was mad but thats what happened when i went to school, you got a letter from the Council and started in the September at your local school after you turned five.
What a scrabble then to get him a place somewhere.