Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do parents just buy their kids stuff when they ask

273 replies

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:35

All this talk about gta and people being shocked the age parents are letting their kids play it im more shocked that parents are spending £60 on their children 4 weeks before Christmas just because they've asked for it. My kids rarely get anything over a tenner outside of Christmas or birthdays unless they actually need it.

OP posts:
Boreded · Today 20:24

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:38

Its not about whether you can afford it or not its about teaching kids the value of money

If it is the only thing they ask for all year…what’s the problem?

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · Today 20:24

Peachesonbeaches · Today 18:43

What is gta? I have a spare £60 to spend on my kids but no way would I buy them something that costs that just cos they ask for it. Stuff that expensive they have to wait for bday or Christmas. Like another pp said, it’s about teaching them the value of money and not bringing them up to be spoilt brats

Lots of kids have money saved from birthday and Christmas, pocket money etc. Maybe they are spending that and learning the value of money rather than being a spoilt brat

Velumental · Today 20:25

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:12

I've lost track off whos said what but are the people who are saying they buy their kids what they want the same people who don't want their teens/young adults getting a job

I grew up poor and worked from 12 years old, fruit farm, potato gathering, babysitting, shops, kitchen porter, high street retain, call centre in that order.

I worked because of I didn't I didn't have any money to live. And I worked to give money into the house. Rarely did I spend any earnings on myself as a teenager, I got paid and I gave the money to mummy. Or it was taken. I'm 43.

Money comes and money goes is what I learnt. Money is there to pay for life. If you're lucky you'll earn more than you need. Absolute luxury for me has always been my direct debits pinging out of my account each month without me having to think about it.

Will my kids work? Not if I can help it, not out with summer holidays and I til they finish school. Life is absolutely too short. I could have never had a job until I was 20 and learnt the same as I did working throughout my childhood. What I was taught was I was less than the people in charge. I went o a grammar school with the children fo the people who owned the fruit farm I worked on at 12. We'd be on the same school bus, in the same uniform, both get off at their massive farmhouse, they'd go inside and we'd go get changed in an outhouse into tracksuit bottoms and get started. We weren't allowed to use the indoor toilet.

I'll never look down my nose at anyone because I know the meaning of that phrase form the other side. Anyway I digress, if kids can be soared work until adulthood great, we all only live once, we get one childhood, happiness is important, socialising' is important, I loved and was amazing at drama, couldn't take parts in the school play as noone would pick me up late from school and anyway, I had to be at work by the time rehearsals finished.

I'm a happy world. Whose life has served them well and I have a great career and the most wonderful family but those things stay with you.

Thecatspantaloons · Today 20:25

Restlessdreams1994 · Today 20:20

I buy my son things from time to time but it’s usually as a reward for good behaviour, doing well at school etc.

I would never buy him GTA 6 though and I am shocked how many parents of primary/early teen kids are letting their kids play a game where players can watch the main characters having sex!

This 👆 all day long - a reward bribe for good behaviour. I don't have kids so I can only speak from my own ancient childhood and friends and relatives kids, but you can have xyz, once you've cleaned your room/ washed up.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:25

canklesmctacotits · Today 20:23

What do they need jobs for, on top of a child’s actual “job” of studying? Do you hold down a FT job and go to night school? I’m a little amused that you have such fixed ideas about young people that you can be shocked by such a thing as a 16yo not having a job!

In fact, in your daily life, how many 16 and 18 yos do you see working? As in, holding down jobs?

Loads both my daughters for a start. People i work with.

OP posts:
GoodkneeBadKnee · Today 20:26

We used to buy ours things we knew they'd love throughout the year. Sometimes things they hadn't asked for, shock! Yes they know the value of money, no they weren't spoilt or materialistic, because we brought them up not to be. Some people on here are so rigid in their thinking. Lighten up people!

mathanxiety · Today 20:26

Bababear987 · Today 20:07

But those things are things they can learn at any time. As teenagers their times is better spent out doing sports or hobbies or studying towards a career path? Getting a minimum wage job teaches them nothing apart from maybe a few interpersonal skills? But if they play sports or do hobbies outside of scholl they will be interacting with all sorts of people too.
For example your teen could spend sat at work on a till or stacking shelves or they could do rugby/football training which is healthy, teamwork, stamina, then do a few hours studying or learning another skill or spending time with family/ friends or..... the list is endless.
I think a PT minimum wage job is literally the biggest waste of time for a young person. I remember wasting my time doing similar and would never want that for my kids.

I disagree.

My DCs did sports and had part time jobs/ did lots of babysitting.

When the time came to get jobs to fund their university lifestyles, they had no difficulties with references. Then when they had graduated and were embarking on their careers, they had even more references. Their career trajectories have been upward all the way.

I never gave them pocket money, so it behoved them to earn their walking-around money. I saw to it that they had enough to get a taxi home if they were heading out with friends, or enough to pay for a meal if that was the plan for the evening, and they were low on funds/ coming up to payday, etc. But the expectation was that they would generally fund their own social lives and learn to manage their own time and the various demands on it.

Their sports were done through school, and they often didn't get home until 10pm from meets/games on school nights. Practices were early in the morning and after school. I rarely saw them before 6pm during their sports seasons.

The advantage to such a demanding schedule was to demonstrate ability to keep multiple plates spinning while still achieving excellent grades, all of which was necessary for university admission in the US.

TheNinkyNonkyIsATardis · Today 20:26

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:04

My kids would never ask me for a £60 computer game as they would know the answer. Im asking what other families do. Does your get just walk up to you and say i want gta its only £60 or do they say i want to earn some extra money as there is something i want to buy

Ugh, I was a kid who "knew the answer" to questions like that.

Took me forever to unlearn denying myself things I could well afford, and years of buying shit quality things because cheaper was better. Oh, and sometimes spending a lot on a big item that wasn't just what I wanted because it fit the niche criteria my parents valued.

It's better to teach your kids to make their own decisions and arguments, not to be too rigid that they won't even ask you.

ByRedBee · Today 20:26

Yes mostly I buy what they want when they want it
They don’t really ask for a lot though

Happyindevon · Today 20:28

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:41

I genuinely curious how normal it is for kids to ask for things randomly throughout the year and their parents just buy it for them. Or whether more parents say no wait for Christmas or birthday or give them jobs to earn money for things

My kids get the odd little thing, certainly under £10, maybe once a month or less. Books they’re allowed with no restrictions really because I think reading is educational and valuable. Anything over £20 and it’s waiting for birthday or Christmas.

And it works because they spend hours playing with toys and can actually entertain themselves. They’re really excited to get a new special toy, it’s not just an everyday thing.

Wincher · Today 20:28

In my house DH bought it because he wanted to play it himself, having played all the previous versions as they came out. DS16 had some friends round today to play it together, as not everyone has bought it so far.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:28

TheNinkyNonkyIsATardis · Today 20:26

Ugh, I was a kid who "knew the answer" to questions like that.

Took me forever to unlearn denying myself things I could well afford, and years of buying shit quality things because cheaper was better. Oh, and sometimes spending a lot on a big item that wasn't just what I wanted because it fit the niche criteria my parents valued.

It's better to teach your kids to make their own decisions and arguments, not to be too rigid that they won't even ask you.

Really I never felt like that i buy nice things as I earn the money I work for

OP posts:
Notgoodatchoosingnames · Today 20:29

My son kept his birthday money from June and bought it on preorder. I wouldn't just buy it for him so he knows to keep birthday money for things he really wants.

Canape · Today 20:30

This thread has turned into a boasty thread with posters all wanting to say how much they can afford to shower on their DC as they have so much money.

Velumental · Today 20:31

Canape · Today 20:30

This thread has turned into a boasty thread with posters all wanting to say how much they can afford to shower on their DC as they have so much money.

I don't really think that's the case actually, it seems to be people saying they see no need to wait for a special occasion or they do wait for a special occasion and why

GoodkneeBadKnee · Today 20:31

Canape · Today 20:30

This thread has turned into a boasty thread with posters all wanting to say how much they can afford to shower on their DC as they have so much money.

You're seeing what you want to see.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:31

Well that was interesting but its Christmas film time any suggestions?

OP posts:
SnipSnipMrBurgess · Today 20:33

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:31

Well that was interesting but its Christmas film time any suggestions?

The Grinch?

mincepye · Today 20:34

My DC are grown up now, when they were younger I bought things whenever they wanted them. My DH and I often went to a toy shop on the weekend and bought them lots of toys or gaming stuff.
We always had a thing where they could have any books they wanted too, we still do this to a certain extent.
For example if we weren’t going away in the Easter holidays I’d buy them new PlayStation games or upgrade one of the DC’s consoles if it needed replacing.
They are now grown up, really good with money, enjoy saving and spending a sensible amount and are generous and thoughtful.

Greycheck · Today 20:34

If the kids ask for something and I can afford it then generally we'll buy it for them. They are fine with being told no if it's inappropriate/expensive and they save their pocket money for most things they want. If it's close to Christmas or their birthday it will be bought for that but they aren't the only times a year they get stuff.

Waitingfordoggo · Today 20:34

Crushed23 · Today 20:22

Those of you who don’t buy your children things they want outside of Christmas and birthdays, do you spend money on yourself throughout the year?

I’ve just come back from the salon which was filled to the brim with customers, most of whom were over 40. Assuming some of them are mothers, they are spending considerably more than £60 on themselves (my cut and blow dry came to double that). I would find it very hypocritical if any of them were to share the views expressed on this thread.

So I’m curious if those against random presents deny themselves any treats throughout the year, or it’s one rule for adults in the family and another for children. (Just curious I promise).

No, I don’t go in for buying myself stuff, because I don’t enjoy buying items for myself, whereas I genuinely enjoy putting money into my savings, or putting money towards holidays and gigs. I buy clothes when I need them. I’m not interested in fashion at all so I buy gym clothes and practical clothes when the old ones wear out, and have always bought clothes for the DCs when they needed them (but not fashion items that they didn’t need, though they could have those sorts of things as birthday and Xmas gifts if they wanted). I do get my hair cut and coloured twice a year so that I can maintain some sort of (minimal) professional standard at work. But I am also happy to pay for my DCs haircuts. Not nails or waxing or other treatments because I don’t buy them for myself. If the DCs want those, they can pay for it themselves. (Or get a voucher for Xmas)

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:36

SnipSnipMrBurgess · Today 20:33

The Grinch?

Watched it a couple off days ago

OP posts:
GoodkneeBadKnee · Today 20:38

mincepye · Today 20:34

My DC are grown up now, when they were younger I bought things whenever they wanted them. My DH and I often went to a toy shop on the weekend and bought them lots of toys or gaming stuff.
We always had a thing where they could have any books they wanted too, we still do this to a certain extent.
For example if we weren’t going away in the Easter holidays I’d buy them new PlayStation games or upgrade one of the DC’s consoles if it needed replacing.
They are now grown up, really good with money, enjoy saving and spending a sensible amount and are generous and thoughtful.

Pretty much exactly the same here.

TheIntricaciesOfHarpUpkeepAndMaintenance · Today 20:38

TorroFerney · Today 20:08

Snap, I want mine to have time to study albeit she volunteers at the library so she is developing work skills. Her job during term time is to study. However we are fortunate to be able to give her a decent allowance for various reasons, she's an only child , we had her later when our careers were established.

Exactly. I want mine to study, play sports, volunteer, try out hobbies. They’ll get on the work wheel eventually and won’t get off for decades. I feel absolutely no need to hasten that.

Raindropskeepfallingon · Today 20:39

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:13

Does that include college and uni being in full time education

That will depend. On what they’re studying, whether it’s actually full time hours or they have some time they could be working, whether they’re doing something worthwhile but unpaid in the holidays… completely depends. If they don’t want to go to university we’d also support them with whatever training is needed to get into the career they have in mind or help them start a business.

We won’t be subsidising them forever or allowing them to just do nothing though - I’ll happily support them through an unpaid summer holiday internship scheme while at university but not just a couple of months dossing around doing nothing all summer.