Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do parents just buy their kids stuff when they ask

273 replies

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:35

All this talk about gta and people being shocked the age parents are letting their kids play it im more shocked that parents are spending £60 on their children 4 weeks before Christmas just because they've asked for it. My kids rarely get anything over a tenner outside of Christmas or birthdays unless they actually need it.

OP posts:
SuddenDaredJelly · Today 19:59

The only things i buy my kids outside of christmas/birthday is:

  • books. I want them to read a lot so i make sure books are freely available. The local library is poor.
  • things needed for hobbies - eg sports/music equipment
  • clothes & shoes that are needed eg outgrown, school uniform. Not "i want the latest football shirt".

I would not buy gta for a child ever, and i would not buy any computer game 6 weeks before Christmas, they would have to wait & have it as a gift.

Raindropskeepfallingon · Today 19:59

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:54

Thats interesting getting a job at 16 was a non negotiable in this house

It’s a non negotiable they won’t get a job in my house. I want them studying, studying some more, playing sport and spending time with friends not working, especially given how few jobs will actually take on a 16 year old these days.

TorroFerney · Today 19:59

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:53

But surely no matter how much money you had if my kid turned round and said I want this its only £60 you would be saying only

Why are you equating being bought things with the child being rude and demanding and saying it's "only" £x. You are making up a story to fit your narrative.

SuddenDaredJelly · Today 20:00

TwattyMcFuckFace · Today 19:18

It's also interesting how some parents who are adamant no-one gets anything outside of Christmas and birthdays because 'spoilt', can change their tune if they come into money.

A friend of mine was very much like this when she was on benefits, but this completely changed after receiving a large inheritance.

So these 'principals' aren't always set in stone.

I dont buy gifts outside of birthday/christmas, despite having tons of money. On principal.

Velumental · Today 20:00

My 8 yr old saves his pocket money, he gets it weekly, started because he was constantly asking for things and I found I was saying no just to not always say yes and it was very ablrbitrary. Now of he wants something he saves. He spent £22 of saved funds on Pokemon cards and a new book today. Other times he's saved for ages and bought computer games.

We will buy books usually but he wanted a book today having recently being bought several and having a small bundle he's working his way through so I said it could wait so he spent his 'own money'. It's handy because once it's gone it's gone but also means I can say yes to things I personally think are pointless like Pokemon cards because the value to him is clear because he is happy to save.

My 5 yr old gets pocket money too and saves for outfits for her dolls, sylvanian family sets etc.

Sometimes though I do just treat them, because it's nice, the other week I took them each out for a couple of hours just me and them and got hot chocolate and treat at the shops. It's a great way to get th chatting about things that might be bothering them and well worth the odd treat. We have a no toys/big gifts after Halloween rule though. If they want something we take a photo for the Xmas list.

I don't think it actually does any harm unless it's all the time and they never have to wait for anything.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:01

Bababear987 · Today 19:58

Why? Again id value things like studying, playing sport/hobbies, even doing work experience but getting a job in something irrelevant just for the sake of it seems a waste of time.

Because teens/young adults learn so much from going to work and working with a range off age groups its just not skills you can learn hanging out with friends or around the house

OP posts:
Velumental · Today 20:01

SuddenDaredJelly · Today 20:00

I dont buy gifts outside of birthday/christmas, despite having tons of money. On principal.

What about books, crafts etc? To me those are different to toys but I'm never quite sure how other parents approach them

Bababear987 · Today 20:01

Raindropskeepfallingon · Today 19:59

It’s a non negotiable they won’t get a job in my house. I want them studying, studying some more, playing sport and spending time with friends not working, especially given how few jobs will actually take on a 16 year old these days.

I agree with this, let young people enjoy life, they'll be working for the rest of their lives. Whats the benefit to a teenager of getting a job over studying and doing hobbies?

MCF86 · Today 20:02

Bababear987 · Today 19:53

My kids are only toddlers but I do buy them stuff all the time cause why not?
They also have birthdays close to xmas so they definitely get stuff throughout the year as well.
I think it depends on affordability and age. Like if I think itll keep them busy and they'll get something out of it then we all win and its money well spent. I think if theyre generally good kids and you can afford it why not?
There is no value in money anymore, everything costs a fortune. I also dont think id be fussed on them getting a minimum wage job at 16 (except if its relevant to their career path or in some other way beneficial) but just to teach the value of money, no.

I think with younger children especially, you shouldn't wait for birthdays/xmas. They don't know anyway, and it makes much more sense to spread purchases out whenever they are age and stage appropriate.

I said earlier I do sometimes buy games "just because" but you saying that made me think more, and actually I'll still buy books and little things that relate to a new interest or things that'll support what he's learning at school. I'll also often get him a small gift that I think will keep him busy during the school holidays.

canklesmctacotits · Today 20:03

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:54

Thats interesting getting a job at 16 was a non negotiable in this house

How do your DC have time for jobs if they’re studying as much as necessary for top grades and doing extra curriculars and getting enough sleep and spending time with family and maybe even, heck, going out with friends occasionally?! Bloody hell!

MostlyPeaceful · Today 20:03

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:35

All this talk about gta and people being shocked the age parents are letting their kids play it im more shocked that parents are spending £60 on their children 4 weeks before Christmas just because they've asked for it. My kids rarely get anything over a tenner outside of Christmas or birthdays unless they actually need it.

YANBU OP. Late 60's, I got money for my November birthday. We took a special trip to town to buy a very special doll. When we arrived at the counter I realised that it cost more money than I had. Did my parents buy it for me anyway, they could see how disappointed I was? No.

We returned home empty handed. I waited until Christmas Day hoping to get more money to enable me to buy the doll. But, Father Christmas bought it for me! It was sitting at the bottom on my bed on Christmas morning. I still remember my absolute delight to this day.

Agen · Today 20:04

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:38

Its not about whether you can afford it or not its about teaching kids the value of money

I find that trope so vague. Kids can receive the stuff they want and need AND know the 'meaning of money.'g The two things can co-exist.

We give our children more or less what they ask for, because we can generally afford it and they don't really ask for much. The older ones have access to our bank accounts in case they need something (they both commute) and never take advantage of it.

Jellycatspyjamas · Today 20:04

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:54

Thats interesting getting a job at 16 was a non negotiable in this house

It was in my house growing up too - in fact I had a Saturday job aged 14. Both my kids want to work, and I’ll encourage them to find a job when they’re old enough, but more for the intrinsic benefits of starting out in the workplace than what they’ll earn. They’re my responsibility while they’re in education, they’re my kids for all of time. I love them and want good things for them, that includes a new nail polish, or a new hoodie or even - gasp - a new video game, outside of gift giving times.

whatacroc · Today 20:05

MJagain · Today 18:39

Some kids have access to their own money. Mine has paper round & other funds. He could easily buy it himself for £60 (but he knows he’s not allowed for non-monetary reasons)

A paper round in 2026? do people still have newspapers delivered? ive not seen a paper delivery boy/girl for many years in my area.
Fantastic though that your dc is out earn their own money at a young age.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:05

Ok im now less shocked at people who buy their kids whatever they want and now more shocked at the amount of people who don't think their late teens/young adults should get a job

OP posts:
Endorewitch · Today 20:06

Well,we are all different. Doesn't mean you are right and others wrong. We all spend what we think appropriate at Xmas and inbetween.

Bababear987 · Today 20:07

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:01

Because teens/young adults learn so much from going to work and working with a range off age groups its just not skills you can learn hanging out with friends or around the house

But those things are things they can learn at any time. As teenagers their times is better spent out doing sports or hobbies or studying towards a career path? Getting a minimum wage job teaches them nothing apart from maybe a few interpersonal skills? But if they play sports or do hobbies outside of scholl they will be interacting with all sorts of people too.
For example your teen could spend sat at work on a till or stacking shelves or they could do rugby/football training which is healthy, teamwork, stamina, then do a few hours studying or learning another skill or spending time with family/ friends or..... the list is endless.
I think a PT minimum wage job is literally the biggest waste of time for a young person. I remember wasting my time doing similar and would never want that for my kids.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:07

Endorewitch · Today 20:06

Well,we are all different. Doesn't mean you are right and others wrong. We all spend what we think appropriate at Xmas and inbetween.

That is exactly what I have said throughout

OP posts:
G1ngerbread · Today 20:07

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:27

I have a job and work for my money. If my kids want to earn money and save up for things then thats great but life isn't free

I find this to be so strange. They’re your kids? It’s like you’re saying you work so can buy yourself things, but they must wait until two specific dates a year. Of course they don’t work and earn their own money, they’re kids. No kids asked to be here. As a parent it’s your job to provide for them until they grow up and earn their own money. Of course within reason, but this feels quite harsh.

TorroFerney · Today 20:08

TheIntricaciesOfHarpUpkeepAndMaintenance · Today 19:38

I don’t particularly want my kids to get a minimum wage job at 16, so that’s fine.

I didn’t get a job until I was 23 and had a Masters. The whole ‘one must begin earning money as soon as possible’ thing you’ve got going on isn’t universal. We don’t all believe that.

Snap, I want mine to have time to study albeit she volunteers at the library so she is developing work skills. Her job during term time is to study. However we are fortunate to be able to give her a decent allowance for various reasons, she's an only child , we had her later when our careers were established.

Moonnstarz · Today 20:08

This is why people then say they don't spend much at Christmas. There are a number of threads where people who have money available seen to take pride in how little they spend at Christmas. But when you ask further questions they do give their children things throughout the year, therefore of course they don't need or want to spend big at Christmas time as the kids already have the items they want.

Endorewitch · Today 20:10

G1ngerbread · Today 20:07

I find this to be so strange. They’re your kids? It’s like you’re saying you work so can buy yourself things, but they must wait until two specific dates a year. Of course they don’t work and earn their own money, they’re kids. No kids asked to be here. As a parent it’s your job to provide for them until they grow up and earn their own money. Of course within reason, but this feels quite harsh.

Agree. But some parents give the impression that giving their kids presents away from xmas and birthdays is decadent.

localnotail · Today 20:11

I buy stuff for my DC because I was always "that kid" that never had anything - my parents had money but wanted to teach me a lesson. I remember going to school in winter wearing thin denim jacket and school uniform that was too small. They never even bought me a toy I wanted for several years - not because they could not afford it, but because it was a "waste of money". (The toy was a stuffed animal)

I dont want to spoil my DC but I want him to have stuff all his peers have - for example, a games console; a good bed, a good bike, clothes that are not all Primark. I have a good laptop, I dont wear cheap crap so why should he? He is my child after all.

He never asks for stupidly expensive stuff. But I will but him GTA - together with his dad. Why not?

umathepuma · Today 20:11

No I wouldn't spend that on something just because they've asked for it, we could afford it but if DD wants something she saves her pocket money for it. If she doesn't want to do that then I put it on her birthday/Christmas list and she waits to see if she gets it. Kids don't know the meaning of money these days imo

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:12

I've lost track off whos said what but are the people who are saying they buy their kids what they want the same people who don't want their teens/young adults getting a job

OP posts: