Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do parents just buy their kids stuff when they ask

268 replies

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:35

All this talk about gta and people being shocked the age parents are letting their kids play it im more shocked that parents are spending £60 on their children 4 weeks before Christmas just because they've asked for it. My kids rarely get anything over a tenner outside of Christmas or birthdays unless they actually need it.

OP posts:
FurbySaysYummmm · Today 19:43

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:41

So if you spent £80 on new trainers for your kid as they needed them and then a few months later they see some £100 ones they like you would just buy them for them because they asked

That's not what I said...

If your child needed new trainers but asked for some they specifically wanted which were more expensive form what you've written you would say no because in your opinion any trainers will do and they should just appreciate being bought trainers. That's joyless.

Tiedbutchorestodo · Today 19:43

My DD17 wants GTA and she’ll have to wait for it as a Christmas present (which she’s fine with). I don’t really buy my kids much “stuff” outside needed clothes and books (I never say no to a book) at random times but I’ll normally say yes to an event, day trip, concert etc if they really want to do it and if I can afford it. Life is about the experiences.

Raindropskeepfallingon · Today 19:44

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:28

Because money needs to be earnt if I bought my kids everything they asked for what would their incentive be to get a minimum wage job at 16.

But if you buy them everything they ask for, just given as two big piles at birthday and Christmas instead of a modest pile at birthday and Christmas and the rest spread out over the year, they will value money?

This is like the sneery threads about kids getting mountains of gifts under the Christmas tree. You raise your kids how you think best, other people will raise theirs. Most of the time the kids turn out fine regardless. The faux “curiosity” is clearly just judgement in disguise.

Jellycatspyjamas · Today 19:45

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:41

So if you spent £80 on new trainers for your kid as they needed them and then a few months later they see some £100 ones they like you would just buy them for them because they asked

No, they’d have had the option of the £100 ones when they needed new ones, if they decided against that at the time they can use their allowance to buy a second pair assuming they’ve enough saved.

Frustrateddiva · Today 19:45

Depends what it is, and when. Right after a birthday or Christmas, then no. Right after a holiday or weekend away, no. But possibly at other times if I know they will actually use it, play with it etc Honestly sometimes I just buy things I know will keep my 2 year old busy for a few hours whilst I can relax for a awhile.

Tiedbutchorestodo · Today 19:45

I don’t think “incentive to get a job” is a fair reason to withhold things - my DD17 is trying to get a job but finding someone willing to take her on when she has very little free time with study and sport commitments is proving very very hard.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:46

Raindropskeepfallingon · Today 19:44

But if you buy them everything they ask for, just given as two big piles at birthday and Christmas instead of a modest pile at birthday and Christmas and the rest spread out over the year, they will value money?

This is like the sneery threads about kids getting mountains of gifts under the Christmas tree. You raise your kids how you think best, other people will raise theirs. Most of the time the kids turn out fine regardless. The faux “curiosity” is clearly just judgement in disguise.

Judgement of what everyone on this thread has explained how they do it whether thats just Christmas and birthday or buying kids whatever they ask for or making their kids earn money. I haven't said once any off them ways are right or wrong

OP posts:
Wynter25 · Today 19:47

Peachesonbeaches · Today 18:43

What is gta? I have a spare £60 to spend on my kids but no way would I buy them something that costs that just cos they ask for it. Stuff that expensive they have to wait for bday or Christmas. Like another pp said, it’s about teaching them the value of money and not bringing them up to be spoilt brats

This

Jellycatspyjamas · Today 19:47

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:43

If their not asking for things why are you buying them presents all the time. My kids get what they ask for, for Christmas im sorry your parents bought you random crap for Christmas

You’ve never been out shopping and saw something you knew your child would love, and bought it for them?

canklesmctacotits · Today 19:48

Making a child wait for two days in the year to get something ≠ teaching them the value of money. That’s a very weird idea to me. To me that’s like binge drinking but with money/toys/whatever.

£60 isn’t a lot for us in the sense that we can spend it without noticing. But, now that I’m thinking about it, my DC don’t actually ask for “things” like toys (video games aren’t a thing in our household). DD for example will need new clothes after growing/ things getting holes in them. I’ll tell her to send me a list of what she wants, I’ll go through it and say “too short, no. This is fine. Not spending £80 on a pair of ballet slippers. This is fine but I’d rather spend more on the thicker one that will keep you warm and last two winters” etc. DS will ask for Eg a new basketball - he’ll get it if his current one doesn’t hold air any more, but not just on a whim.

So yes I suppose my kids get what they ask for when they ask for things, but only if they need them and are value for money. GTA could be free and I still wouldn’t be getting it.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:48

FurbySaysYummmm · Today 19:43

That's not what I said...

If your child needed new trainers but asked for some they specifically wanted which were more expensive form what you've written you would say no because in your opinion any trainers will do and they should just appreciate being bought trainers. That's joyless.

But someone further down said they would so thats the point off the thread some will some won't neither is right or wrong just different

OP posts:
TwattyMcFuckFace · Today 19:48

Jellycatspyjamas · Today 19:47

You’ve never been out shopping and saw something you knew your child would love, and bought it for them?

Not if it's over a tenner apparently.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:50

Jellycatspyjamas · Today 19:47

You’ve never been out shopping and saw something you knew your child would love, and bought it for them?

I've been out shopping and thought thats nice il put that away for Christmas

OP posts:
monymonymony · Today 19:50

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:38

Its not about whether you can afford it or not its about teaching kids the value of money

Your idea of value might differ from that of people with actual wealth. I think you confuse poverty for moral value

Itsbeenalongtimeincoming · Today 19:51

Yeah we do. But and that’s a big but my kids are spoiled but they aren’t brats. If there is any slight hint of brat behaviour it stops.

Our kids are polite, loving good kids. Don’t talk back and respect us as parents. But I wouldn’t buy that game on principal.

They know the value of money. My eldest is earning now (football scholar) and saves 80% of what he earns.

mtobrokeme · Today 19:52

Mine wouldn’t ask me to buy it him, but I’m fully aware of what things he likes and what he’s interested in and id certainly buy it him if I asked and he said yes! He never ever asks for things though.

As it happened he’d saved up his own money and bought it himself. My son absolutely knows the value of things but I am also fully aware that life is valuable and life is short and if I want to buy my son expensive things throughout the year and I can afford it then I absolutely will!

Bababear987 · Today 19:53

My kids are only toddlers but I do buy them stuff all the time cause why not?
They also have birthdays close to xmas so they definitely get stuff throughout the year as well.
I think it depends on affordability and age. Like if I think itll keep them busy and they'll get something out of it then we all win and its money well spent. I think if theyre generally good kids and you can afford it why not?
There is no value in money anymore, everything costs a fortune. I also dont think id be fussed on them getting a minimum wage job at 16 (except if its relevant to their career path or in some other way beneficial) but just to teach the value of money, no.

swingingbackwardsandforwards · Today 19:54

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:50

I've been out shopping and thought thats nice il put that away for Christmas

I do understand this.

But I also think one of the problems with Christmas is that all the gifts can be overwhelming, especially for younger children, and it means some potentially really good gifts never get looked at.

Just an example but last year my DD got some Bear Hunt jigsaw puzzles. In terms of longevity they were a brilliant gift but did not get the wow factor on the day and could easily have ended up gathering dust on a shelf. A few months later she saw some similar puzzles with a different theme (hungry caterpillar) and I bought them. I could have kept them until her birthday but we wanted them then and now. And that’s OK too.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:54

Bababear987 · Today 19:53

My kids are only toddlers but I do buy them stuff all the time cause why not?
They also have birthdays close to xmas so they definitely get stuff throughout the year as well.
I think it depends on affordability and age. Like if I think itll keep them busy and they'll get something out of it then we all win and its money well spent. I think if theyre generally good kids and you can afford it why not?
There is no value in money anymore, everything costs a fortune. I also dont think id be fussed on them getting a minimum wage job at 16 (except if its relevant to their career path or in some other way beneficial) but just to teach the value of money, no.

Thats interesting getting a job at 16 was a non negotiable in this house

OP posts:
Raindropskeepfallingon · Today 19:55

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:46

Judgement of what everyone on this thread has explained how they do it whether thats just Christmas and birthday or buying kids whatever they ask for or making their kids earn money. I haven't said once any off them ways are right or wrong

If you really think your comments on this thread have been neutral then you need to read back and reconsider. It’s dripping with judgement on people who spend money on their kids at a time or of an amount you consider doesn’t teach them “the value of money”. Which is a subjective value anyway - a £100 pair of trainers or £60 game is loose change to some people and an unachievable fortune to someone else.

BertieBotts · Today 19:55

I know what you mean OP, it wasn't normal for me growing up either. If we wanted something expensive then it would be birthday or Christmas only, and we absolutely would not have been bought things so close to Christmas. In fact my mum even discouraged us from buying things for ourselves before Christmas "in case somebody buys it for you!"

I am very much not an instant gratification person possibly for this reason and in fact tend towards the opposite extreme whereby I will procrastinate everything for so long I miss the opportunity!

DH OTOH doesn't seem to have any of these unwritten rules and buys stuff as and when whenever he wants to, basically. He can barely resist instant gratification and when I've spoken with him about his childhood he just said he didn't get pocket money and his parents would just buy him things if he wanted them. I can't get my head around this because I feel like how do they learn the value of money?

We haven't got the game. Our DC are little so have no interest and we wouldn't let them play it at their ages anyway (5 and 8). My eldest might have it or play it but he's 18 and tends to buy games as digital versions online. He wouldn't let them play it as he knows we don't let them access age-inappropriate stuff.

However I do think that these days with release dates being hyped so much before the date it does feel a bit different - I can remember a handful of things that when I was younger I wanted on the exact day they released. The Harry Potter books #4 and later, and The Sims 2 computer game. Just looking at the release dates of these, none of them were shortly before my birthday/Christmas, so maybe it didn't come up, but I know I would have been so upset to have had to wait over a month to get access to any of these because I was SO excited to play/read them and especially for the books, I wanted to avoid any spoilers and join in with the general excitement and hype around them. For the later HP books and the Sims game, I was also older (15+) and had access to the internet where I'd look up discussions, screenshots, etc. So I can see that for today's children and teenagers if they have access to youtube, forums, tiktok etc then they're going to feel even more like they are missing out if they don't have the latest thing on the day it releases.

Bababear987 · Today 19:56

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:50

I've been out shopping and thought thats nice il put that away for Christmas

But why? Like why wait to xmas, its just a day? Does there have to be a once yearly occasion to buy your kids something to bring them joy?

lessglittermoremud · Today 19:56

Apparently my son (13) has friends that play it, I won’t be buying it for him before Christmas/at Christmas and he won’t be spending his own money on it, because unless the age rating has changed it’s always been an 18?

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:56

swingingbackwardsandforwards · Today 19:54

I do understand this.

But I also think one of the problems with Christmas is that all the gifts can be overwhelming, especially for younger children, and it means some potentially really good gifts never get looked at.

Just an example but last year my DD got some Bear Hunt jigsaw puzzles. In terms of longevity they were a brilliant gift but did not get the wow factor on the day and could easily have ended up gathering dust on a shelf. A few months later she saw some similar puzzles with a different theme (hungry caterpillar) and I bought them. I could have kept them until her birthday but we wanted them then and now. And that’s OK too.

Absolutely no way is wrong or right. Im certainly not saying how we do it is right and others are wrong

OP posts:
Bababear987 · Today 19:58

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:54

Thats interesting getting a job at 16 was a non negotiable in this house

Why? Again id value things like studying, playing sport/hobbies, even doing work experience but getting a job in something irrelevant just for the sake of it seems a waste of time.