Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do parents just buy their kids stuff when they ask

268 replies

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:35

All this talk about gta and people being shocked the age parents are letting their kids play it im more shocked that parents are spending £60 on their children 4 weeks before Christmas just because they've asked for it. My kids rarely get anything over a tenner outside of Christmas or birthdays unless they actually need it.

OP posts:
Happyindevon · Today 20:41

TorroFerney · Today 20:08

Snap, I want mine to have time to study albeit she volunteers at the library so she is developing work skills. Her job during term time is to study. However we are fortunate to be able to give her a decent allowance for various reasons, she's an only child , we had her later when our careers were established.

I think this is a mistake, for many reasons.

Crushed23 · Today 20:42

Waitingfordoggo · Today 20:34

No, I don’t go in for buying myself stuff, because I don’t enjoy buying items for myself, whereas I genuinely enjoy putting money into my savings, or putting money towards holidays and gigs. I buy clothes when I need them. I’m not interested in fashion at all so I buy gym clothes and practical clothes when the old ones wear out, and have always bought clothes for the DCs when they needed them (but not fashion items that they didn’t need, though they could have those sorts of things as birthday and Xmas gifts if they wanted). I do get my hair cut and coloured twice a year so that I can maintain some sort of (minimal) professional standard at work. But I am also happy to pay for my DCs haircuts. Not nails or waxing or other treatments because I don’t buy them for myself. If the DCs want those, they can pay for it themselves. (Or get a voucher for Xmas)

I count going to gigs as spending money on yourself! It’s where most of my disposable income goes. Do you take your children to the gigs with you?

Greenmouldycheese · Today 20:43

I buy my kids what they ask for apart from the month before Christmas.

Happyindevon · Today 20:44

I’m amazed at so many parents simply buying their kids whatever they ask for. It’s quite sad in a way too.

TheIntricaciesOfHarpUpkeepAndMaintenance · Today 20:44

Happyindevon · Today 20:41

I think this is a mistake, for many reasons.

Such as? It’s how both DH and I were raised (and all of our siblings) and we’ve all turned out pretty well. It’s how we are raising our kids.

TheIntricaciesOfHarpUpkeepAndMaintenance · Today 20:44

Happyindevon · Today 20:44

I’m amazed at so many parents simply buying their kids whatever they ask for. It’s quite sad in a way too.

Why?

jumpingjohnny · Today 20:45

As the game is rated 18, surely the only 'kids' old enough will either have saved money of their own, understand the value of money or understand an early Christmas present means less on the day itself?

Overthebow · Today 20:45

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:47

Can't i be curious. Myself and parents i know would never just buy their kids expensive things but it doesn't mean others don't. Thats the good thing about mumsnet you get the opinions off parents from all different walks of life.

What do you define as expensive? Mine are too young for GTA but I don’t really think a £60 game that has been long awaited is particularly expensive so yes I probably would buy it for my DC.

seahorsessky · Today 20:45

It is a fact that some parents buy their kids anything (and it's not necessarily the richer ones, just as we know that the Silicon Valley types are less likely to allow their screens, and spend a far less amount, relative to their wealth, on non educational toys/games for their kids).
Some parents only care about being their kid's best friend, and don't care about paying any other bills/keeping their child away from real danger, and let them on screens all the time, and don't care if they grow up out of control and with no respect for any other person.

underthehawthorntree · Today 20:45

Crushed23 · Today 20:22

Those of you who don’t buy your children things they want outside of Christmas and birthdays, do you spend money on yourself throughout the year?

I’ve just come back from the salon which was filled to the brim with customers, most of whom were over 40. Assuming some of them are mothers, they are spending considerably more than £60 on themselves (my cut and blow dry came to double that). I would find it very hypocritical if any of them were to share the views expressed on this thread.

So I’m curious if those against random presents deny themselves any treats throughout the year, or it’s one rule for adults in the family and another for children. (Just curious I promise).

I don't think these things are even vaguely comparable. I get my children's hair cut whenever it is needed. I see this as basic self care not a treat. When times are hard I forgot expensive highlights for myself but when I don't see a hair cut/highlights as being the equivalent for an adult as toys are for children. On the odd occasion I've bought my kids something because they asked for it e.g. in a supermarket it tends to get played with a couple of times and then forgotten about. Children ask for toys when they see them because children don't have (a) impulse control (b) the concept of money (c) long term thinking etc etc. So it would be bizarre to buy them stuff just because I also spend money on myself. I'm an adult who has a broader grasp on life than my child. They don't get bought stuff just because I also buy myself e.g. make up when it runs out.

mincepye · Today 20:46

Happyindevon · Today 20:44

I’m amazed at so many parents simply buying their kids whatever they ask for. It’s quite sad in a way too.

Why, I buy myself whatever I want when I want it, not everyone makes a big thing of spending money?

Happyindevon · Today 20:46

TheIntricaciesOfHarpUpkeepAndMaintenance · Today 20:44

Such as? It’s how both DH and I were raised (and all of our siblings) and we’ve all turned out pretty well. It’s how we are raising our kids.

Because the world isn’t like it was when you were young. If she gets a degree and can’t get a job (like so many on here), she won’t have any ground level skills to break into basic employment.

Happyindevon · Today 20:47

mincepye · Today 20:46

Why, I buy myself whatever I want when I want it, not everyone makes a big thing of spending money?

They should because most of the stuff bought is landfillcore or just more crap. Why not make a donation to charity?

AlphabetMole · Today 20:49

Happyindevon · Today 20:47

They should because most of the stuff bought is landfillcore or just more crap. Why not make a donation to charity?

Because they want to buy something?

We do donate to charity, but I don't wander past a new jumper or book I want and think, 'you know what, I'll sponsor a donkey instead'. Bonkers.

TheIntricaciesOfHarpUpkeepAndMaintenance · Today 20:49

Happyindevon · Today 20:46

Because the world isn’t like it was when you were young. If she gets a degree and can’t get a job (like so many on here), she won’t have any ground level skills to break into basic employment.

You have no idea how old I am. And my children are highly unlikely to ever need to ‘break into basic employment’.

mincepye · Today 20:49

Happyindevon · Today 20:47

They should because most of the stuff bought is landfillcore or just more crap. Why not make a donation to charity?

I disagree, if I want some new books then I am going to buy them, I’m helping the economy.

Happyindevon · Today 20:49

AlphabetMole · Today 20:49

Because they want to buy something?

We do donate to charity, but I don't wander past a new jumper or book I want and think, 'you know what, I'll sponsor a donkey instead'. Bonkers.

But you’re just buying endless stuff. And then there will be something else you want. Surely you hit a ceiling where just buying more stuff isn’t needed?

Happyindevon · Today 20:50

TheIntricaciesOfHarpUpkeepAndMaintenance · Today 20:49

You have no idea how old I am. And my children are highly unlikely to ever need to ‘break into basic employment’.

Oh go on tell me why!

Crushed23 · Today 20:50

underthehawthorntree · Today 20:45

I don't think these things are even vaguely comparable. I get my children's hair cut whenever it is needed. I see this as basic self care not a treat. When times are hard I forgot expensive highlights for myself but when I don't see a hair cut/highlights as being the equivalent for an adult as toys are for children. On the odd occasion I've bought my kids something because they asked for it e.g. in a supermarket it tends to get played with a couple of times and then forgotten about. Children ask for toys when they see them because children don't have (a) impulse control (b) the concept of money (c) long term thinking etc etc. So it would be bizarre to buy them stuff just because I also spend money on myself. I'm an adult who has a broader grasp on life than my child. They don't get bought stuff just because I also buy myself e.g. make up when it runs out.

We’re not talking about a toddler impulsively wanting a toy at the supermarket that will be discarded after a couple of hours. Most of the discussion has been about a hotly anticipated computer game (literally years in the making), or a pair of trendy trainers before the old ones have completely worn out. These to me are comparable to buying yourself gig tickets (as per PP’s reply to my post) or getting highlights.

Canape · Today 20:51

TheIntricaciesOfHarpUpkeepAndMaintenance · Today 20:38

Exactly. I want mine to study, play sports, volunteer, try out hobbies. They’ll get on the work wheel eventually and won’t get off for decades. I feel absolutely no need to hasten that.

I'm sure they won't want to sully themselves with GTA then.

justasmalltownmum · Today 20:53

It has been a very much anticipated game so on this occasion I can understand.

TreacherousPissFlap · Today 20:54

I wouldn't normally buy things (DS is an adult now but in the day) but I think something like GTA is time sensitive. The hype is around the release date and making a child wait until Christmas removes some of the pleasure from it.

As a PP says, it's easy to spunk £60 on a mediocre day out and a game will be much longer lasting.

I cannot recall the game now but we did this for DS on one occasion. It's wouldn't be a big deal to me but he was thrilled with it.

Tinaforshort · Today 20:55

No. I wouldn’t buy my DC a £60 game just before Christmas because they wanted it, they could have it as part of their Christmas presents early - they are 17 on 28/12 and 14 - to play on the day but neither of mine would want to do that.

I would say we’re 50/50 on buying stuff throughout the year it would depend on what it is and how much tbh.

My eldest DD has a job in our local shop, she started a paper round with them initially when she was 13/14 and then worked somewhere else for a bit then started working in the shop. She is studying A levels. It’s always been her choice to work, she wants the extra money to do exactly what she wants. At the moment she’s saving towards driving lessons. DD2 doesn’t work, but equally doesn’t ask for much outside of Christmas and her birthday either.

TheIntricaciesOfHarpUpkeepAndMaintenance · Today 20:55

Canape · Today 20:51

I'm sure they won't want to sully themselves with GTA then.

From one of my previous comments: I wouldn’t buy GTA, specifically, as it’s very problematic, but I don’t think a £60 request is unreasonable.

ElleintheWoods · Today 20:58

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:59

Its not the amount its the attitude if my kid said I want that its only £60 I wouldn't be happy with them. Whether you're rich or not surely kids need to learn £60 is still a lot of money otherwise their going to be very disappointed when they get their job

It really depends.

I find it a little difficult to understand what you do and do not spend money on for your children outside birthday and Christmas. Whether clothes, days out etc count to the max £10 limit or not.

However in my world birthday and Christmas are total non-events. A child might get a couple of presents and a party, but they’re not big-spend or an excuse to spend lots of money.

Most parents I know just buy their children things as/when appropriate. Eg if a new toy comes out in September, they would get it roughly in line with everyone else, not 4 months later.

Also things like theatre trips, cinema, new clothes they like/ need, electronics, concert tickets etc are not tied to any particular occasion. They’re just bought when needed and suitable.

To give you an example, let’s say parents are on holiday with 15-yo DD. She spots an absolutely gorgeous dress on a shop window and looks amazing in it. They’d buy it then and there, not say ‘wait til Christmas’.

It’s about moments that bring joy and experiences together or experiences with friends. You can’t only have 2 occasions in the entire year and do/spend nothing the rest.

Also, I don’t want children buying lots of cheap £10 tat. They need to learn that people’s labour is also worth something, and if someone has spent time making something, it can’t be bought for £10, it’ll have to cost more. You can’t get a good pair of comfortable, orthopedically designed leather shoes for £10. You can’t get a main course in a restaurant for £10 as you have to pay for people’s wages. You can’t go to the theatre for £10 as all these people on stage need to earn a fair wage.

Also many children I know manage their own money from quite a young age, so that teaches them the value of money.

I had my uni first year living expenses saved up by the time I was 18. I also had some really nice clothes that I paid for myself through wages.