Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do parents just buy their kids stuff when they ask

273 replies

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:35

All this talk about gta and people being shocked the age parents are letting their kids play it im more shocked that parents are spending £60 on their children 4 weeks before Christmas just because they've asked for it. My kids rarely get anything over a tenner outside of Christmas or birthdays unless they actually need it.

OP posts:
GoodkneeBadKnee · Today 20:12

Wynter25 · Today 19:47

This

Nah.

Everlygreen · Today 20:12

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:43

If their not asking for things why are you buying them presents all the time. My kids get what they ask for, for Christmas im sorry your parents bought you random crap for Christmas

They didn’t buy random crap, they bought what they could afford. Why do I buy my kids things all the time? Because I can afford to and I want to? You seem to think taking such a hard line is going to teach them something. Working at 16, never getting anything nice except twice a year, just so hard. You seem to think you will reach them something- to never do anything for you later in your life I’m sure!
how miserable to just never to buy your kids anything nice just because.

GreenLemonade · Today 20:12

Yes, I buy them things throughout the year. 10 months feels like forever to a child (winter birthday). I think only buying gifts for birthday and Christmas would put too much pressure on those two days to get it right. I also find that my children get overwhelmed with big present hauls and appreciate individual things more if they get fewer things more frequently. Their interests also change throughout the year, I get it might be less of an issue for teenagers.

Do you honestly only buy yourself things twice a year? I don’t, so I can’t justify applying different standards to my kids.

mathanxiety · Today 20:12

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:53

But surely no matter how much money you had if my kid turned round and said I want this its only £60 you would be saying only

I'm just guessing where you were going with that, but surely you can understand that £60 means nothing to some people?

People spend that much on their nails every two weeks. Or a family takeaway every week.

The fact that they're spending it on a game for teen children doesn't alter the fact that £60 is £60, not a penny more and not a penny less.

Raindropskeepfallingon · Today 20:12

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:05

Ok im now less shocked at people who buy their kids whatever they want and now more shocked at the amount of people who don't think their late teens/young adults should get a job

I expect my young adults to get a job. To me 16 is not a young adult - they can’t drive, very few proper jobs exist for that age group and I very much intend they’ll be in full time education. That is their “job”.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:13

Raindropskeepfallingon · Today 20:12

I expect my young adults to get a job. To me 16 is not a young adult - they can’t drive, very few proper jobs exist for that age group and I very much intend they’ll be in full time education. That is their “job”.

Does that include college and uni being in full time education

OP posts:
mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:14

mathanxiety · Today 20:12

I'm just guessing where you were going with that, but surely you can understand that £60 means nothing to some people?

People spend that much on their nails every two weeks. Or a family takeaway every week.

The fact that they're spending it on a game for teen children doesn't alter the fact that £60 is £60, not a penny more and not a penny less.

Anyone paying £60 on nails every 2 weeks is being ripped off

OP posts:
localnotail · Today 20:16

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:12

I've lost track off whos said what but are the people who are saying they buy their kids what they want the same people who don't want their teens/young adults getting a job

Nope. I want my DC to get a job, I would actually prefer him to get into some trade and have his own business rather than go to Uni.

I earn enough to treat him for now, and I can't see why I should not. Why the fuck I work hard to earn money, if not to spend it on my child? If I could I would leave a mortgage free house for him to live in. I think its only natural to want your offspring to have a better life than you did!

Thecatspantaloons · Today 20:16

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:54

Thats interesting getting a job at 16 was a non negotiable in this house

I had 2 little jobs at this age and my brother who is 12 years younger than me did too. But I think it's not as easy as it was in our day. We collected glasses in our local pubs that are all shut now and we had loads more shops for Saturday jobs etc.
Sorry to derail your thread.

Waitingfordoggo · Today 20:17

I haven’t read all the replies so maybe someone has already mentioned it, but I just really dislike the general obsession with buying stuff as if it’s what makes people happy. It doesn’t make people really happy from what I can see, it just makes them want more stuff. Materialism isn’t it? It’s really rubbish for the planet for one thing. I’m just not a fan of rampant capitalism but I realise I’m in the minority 😂 I’m glad that my young adult DCs have absorbed our values. They don’t value stuff over people/time/experiences. They don’t covet stuff. Their grandparents asked them for Xmas requests last week and both asked for something quite inexpensive. IL’s tried to insist they choose additional items up to a specific value (because that is what had been spent on the other GDCs) but both declined.

They both had jobs from age 15. It wasn’t a ‘non-negotiable’ from us, but both were keen to earn their own money so we didn’t stand in their way. Given the current job market for youngsters, I’m quite glad they’ve had plenty of experience and shown that they don’t mind a bit of hard graft. They recognise that they’re lucky to have jobs and are prepared to work hard at them. It’s stood them in good stead for getting into better jobs over the years.

Canape · Today 20:17

mathanxiety · Today 20:12

I'm just guessing where you were going with that, but surely you can understand that £60 means nothing to some people?

People spend that much on their nails every two weeks. Or a family takeaway every week.

The fact that they're spending it on a game for teen children doesn't alter the fact that £60 is £60, not a penny more and not a penny less.

I don't think OP is poor though, if anything she sounds quite well off and could easily afford it but wants her DC to know the value of money

TheYorkshirePudding · Today 20:17

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:35

All this talk about gta and people being shocked the age parents are letting their kids play it im more shocked that parents are spending £60 on their children 4 weeks before Christmas just because they've asked for it. My kids rarely get anything over a tenner outside of Christmas or birthdays unless they actually need it.

Yep, I buy mine whatever he wants really. He’s impeccably behaved and tries very hard to learn anything or listen well. Why wouldn’t I spend my money on him? I’m also intrigued as to how you think withholding money/not spending it shows its value? I’m not sure that’s how you show the true value of money? I’d be genuinely interested on how people can demonstrate true value of money

Everlygreen · Today 20:18

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:05

Ok im now less shocked at people who buy their kids whatever they want and now more shocked at the amount of people who don't think their late teens/young adults should get a job

You seem to have some ancient sort of views of life. My parents had very little but I still only worked once I finished university and got a real job. I really appreciated that I didn’t have to have a job whilst studying a very intensive degree. Now I support my parents, and happy to do so. I did know people with parents like you though who had such a hard view of how things should work. They worked since 16, never had a penny of help, and never a break to be a child. They are the same ones who treat their parents like acquaintances now, and would never go
out of their way to help them.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:18

Thecatspantaloons · Today 20:16

I had 2 little jobs at this age and my brother who is 12 years younger than me did too. But I think it's not as easy as it was in our day. We collected glasses in our local pubs that are all shut now and we had loads more shops for Saturday jobs etc.
Sorry to derail your thread.

No i absolutely agree its significantly harder now but I certainly wouldn't be saying what other posters are saying that I don't want my teen to get a job and that its pointless and they got their first job at 23.

OP posts:
G1ngerbread · Today 20:19

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:12

I've lost track off whos said what but are the people who are saying they buy their kids what they want the same people who don't want their teens/young adults getting a job

You are being deliberately obtuse. Nobody is saying they buy their children everything they want. It isn’t just everything they want, or nothing ever at all. There is a middle ground.

Everlygreen · Today 20:19

TheYorkshirePudding · Today 20:17

Yep, I buy mine whatever he wants really. He’s impeccably behaved and tries very hard to learn anything or listen well. Why wouldn’t I spend my money on him? I’m also intrigued as to how you think withholding money/not spending it shows its value? I’m not sure that’s how you show the true value of money? I’d be genuinely interested on how people can demonstrate true value of money

Same. I have lovely well rounded children who are so thoughtful and share what they have, always complimented on their behaviour and just really good kids. They get a lot from us, no reason other than we want to. And they are very appreciative and grateful.

Restlessdreams1994 · Today 20:20

I buy my son things from time to time but it’s usually as a reward for good behaviour, doing well at school etc.

I would never buy him GTA 6 though and I am shocked how many parents of primary/early teen kids are letting their kids play a game where players can watch the main characters having sex!

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:21

G1ngerbread · Today 20:19

You are being deliberately obtuse. Nobody is saying they buy their children everything they want. It isn’t just everything they want, or nothing ever at all. There is a middle ground.

Maybe read the post above yours before making accusations

OP posts:
Youcancallmeirrelevant · Today 20:21

I buy stuff for my kids all year, but then birthday and Christmas they only get a few things not piles of stuff. Other people I know but nothing the rest of the year but birthday and Christmas is huge amounts of presents. If they need a new scooter cause they've outgrown theirs I'm not going to make them wait 6 months for christmas

Crushed23 · Today 20:22

Those of you who don’t buy your children things they want outside of Christmas and birthdays, do you spend money on yourself throughout the year?

I’ve just come back from the salon which was filled to the brim with customers, most of whom were over 40. Assuming some of them are mothers, they are spending considerably more than £60 on themselves (my cut and blow dry came to double that). I would find it very hypocritical if any of them were to share the views expressed on this thread.

So I’m curious if those against random presents deny themselves any treats throughout the year, or it’s one rule for adults in the family and another for children. (Just curious I promise).

FrankieNeverRelax · Today 20:22

maybe the kids saved up for it? My niece gets £20 a week pocket money wouldn’t take her long to save that up!

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:22

Youcancallmeirrelevant · Today 20:21

I buy stuff for my kids all year, but then birthday and Christmas they only get a few things not piles of stuff. Other people I know but nothing the rest of the year but birthday and Christmas is huge amounts of presents. If they need a new scooter cause they've outgrown theirs I'm not going to make them wait 6 months for christmas

But i would see an outgrown scooter as a need

OP posts:
Becuriousnotjudgemental1980 · Today 20:23

If my two want something big outside Xmas or bday they have to earn it, save pocket money or wait.

canklesmctacotits · Today 20:23

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:05

Ok im now less shocked at people who buy their kids whatever they want and now more shocked at the amount of people who don't think their late teens/young adults should get a job

What do they need jobs for, on top of a child’s actual “job” of studying? Do you hold down a FT job and go to night school? I’m a little amused that you have such fixed ideas about young people that you can be shocked by such a thing as a 16yo not having a job!

In fact, in your daily life, how many 16 and 18 yos do you see working? As in, holding down jobs?

QuickDryTowel · Today 20:24

We bought for ours all year round. We could afford it and never needed to restrict buying to birthday and Christmas.