Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do parents just buy their kids stuff when they ask

268 replies

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:35

All this talk about gta and people being shocked the age parents are letting their kids play it im more shocked that parents are spending £60 on their children 4 weeks before Christmas just because they've asked for it. My kids rarely get anything over a tenner outside of Christmas or birthdays unless they actually need it.

OP posts:
MrEdwardElizabethHitler · Today 18:52

BirdLandedonmyHead · Today 18:45

Most likely the parents want it themselves!

I would think that also explains a lot of the teens who currently have access to it!

TwattyMcFuckFace · Today 18:52

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:47

Can't i be curious. Myself and parents i know would never just buy their kids expensive things but it doesn't mean others don't. Thats the good thing about mumsnet you get the opinions off parents from all different walks of life.

But 'expensive' is subjective, as you know.

titchy · Today 18:53

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:47

Can't i be curious. Myself and parents i know would never just buy their kids expensive things but it doesn't mean others don't. Thats the good thing about mumsnet you get the opinions off parents from all different walks of life.

What makes you think most parents have bought it? Most kids get pocket money don’t they, and a lot would have known when it was coming out and saved for it.

That’s the very definition of teaching them the value of money!

AttitudeAdjuster · Today 18:53

I think the point is it's not that expensive these days, we aren't high earners and we spend more on a takeaway or 60 minute trampoline park for 3 kids. It's not the sort of game my kids like but I think if it is the price is ok in comparison to other things, they'll get a lot of entertainment out it.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:53

TwattyMcFuckFace · Today 18:52

But 'expensive' is subjective, as you know.

But surely no matter how much money you had if my kid turned round and said I want this its only £60 you would be saying only

OP posts:
MrEdwardElizabethHitler · Today 18:54

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:53

But surely no matter how much money you had if my kid turned round and said I want this its only £60 you would be saying only

No, of course not. £60 isn't enough of a sum for everyone to think it's significant, and some of those for whom it is a lot will nonetheless think it does actually represent value for money.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:55

AttitudeAdjuster · Today 18:53

I think the point is it's not that expensive these days, we aren't high earners and we spend more on a takeaway or 60 minute trampoline park for 3 kids. It's not the sort of game my kids like but I think if it is the price is ok in comparison to other things, they'll get a lot of entertainment out it.

I do agree with the amount of entertainment you get out off it £60 isn't horrific. Maybe I'm just tight making my kids wait or earn their money

OP posts:
rollietollie · Today 18:55

Hello yes I buy stuff for my daughter all year round. My parents were fantastically mean throughout my childhood (famously took my birthday money for themselves on one occasion). They had no need of it and are millionaires. But interestingly my DD is very good with money and utterly unspoiled. In a toy shop once a lady approached me to ask how I’d managed to raise a child who didn’t ask for anything and had to be encouraged to choose a toy. I don’t think restricting stuff necessarily helps kids manage money or their desires. That said I’d never buy or sanction any violent game for her.

FurbySaysYummmm · Today 18:56

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:53

But surely no matter how much money you had if my kid turned round and said I want this its only £60 you would be saying only

Do you not take your children to trampoline parks, escape rooms, bowling, mini golf the cinema or any other child centered trip out? All will likely leave you not much change out of £60 for much less entertainment value.

herewegoagainonwednesday · Today 18:57

Depends what it is. A random toy or game? Absolutely not.
My oldest just got new trainers, his old ones were too small or had a hole (second pair). He got the nice ones he wanted (not super expensive, £60). I’m not buying a cheap pair now, and a second pair for christmas.
Youngest got new headphones (£80, ouch). His broke, and they are something he uses every day. Similarly, buying cheap now would be a waste of money .

JustFrustrated · Today 18:57

I will. If I have the money.

My teens are absolutely not spoilt in anyway. But I don’t make myself wait for two random dates in the year for nice things so why would I make them?

They do plenty of chores, work incredibly hard at school, will drop anything to help me/come visit family. My eldest made it through her entire school career without a single late mark, or detention. My youngest is a wonderful human being.

So yes, if I can afford it. I will.

For reasons like today, I got back this morning after a night out last night, my eldest had started the laundry, my youngest had cleaned the bathroom and hall way. The cats were fed and played with. The eldest was doing her college work unprompted.

Tomorrow they’ll both come do the grocery shopping, and because last week I wanted to get something from a specific store that was cash only and I had none, my eldest has said she’ll drive us there as part of her driving lesson (in the car we gifted her) and at some point she will sit with the youngest and help with their homework….

All that to say that buying your children gifts of things they want, randomly through the year, does not inevitably turn them into “spoilt brats” as per a PP. Poor parenting does.

TwattyMcFuckFace · Today 18:58

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:53

But surely no matter how much money you had if my kid turned round and said I want this its only £60 you would be saying only

No, YOU would be but you're not all parents, are you 😳

The wide-eyed innocence here is so strange.

You wouldn't get much change out of £60 if a parent took their child out for a meal.

Is that 'wrong' too before Christmas?

SnipSnipMrBurgess · Today 18:58

I wouldn't buy them a big ticket item like a console or a phone or a horse on a whim, but if we were in the shops and they spotted a new game, or a slime kit or book or outfit or lego set etc then yes I would buy it. I can afford to and they are appreciative.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:59

FurbySaysYummmm · Today 18:56

Do you not take your children to trampoline parks, escape rooms, bowling, mini golf the cinema or any other child centered trip out? All will likely leave you not much change out of £60 for much less entertainment value.

Its not the amount its the attitude if my kid said I want that its only £60 I wouldn't be happy with them. Whether you're rich or not surely kids need to learn £60 is still a lot of money otherwise their going to be very disappointed when they get their job

OP posts:
mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:00

TwattyMcFuckFace · Today 18:58

No, YOU would be but you're not all parents, are you 😳

The wide-eyed innocence here is so strange.

You wouldn't get much change out of £60 if a parent took their child out for a meal.

Is that 'wrong' too before Christmas?

Edited

You're not understanding what im writing

OP posts:
WouldLikeToKnow92 · Today 19:00

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:41

I genuinely curious how normal it is for kids to ask for things randomly throughout the year and their parents just buy it for them. Or whether more parents say no wait for Christmas or birthday or give them jobs to earn money for things

Yeah I've always done the same - Christmas or birthdays or jobs to earn the money..they get small amounts of pocket money too.

Quite annoyingly though Christmas and birthday are within 2 weeks of each other so occasionally there would mid-year gifts when younger and the gap between birthdays felt longer like they'd aged out of stuff between birthdays.

The oldest is 17 now and would love GTA but hasn't asked for it. I assume he knows the answer already !

It came up when I was asking for Christmas present ideas.

Apparently all his mates have GTA, but I get the impression they've got a gaming parent and the type to need to get things when they first come out.

FurbySaysYummmm · Today 19:01

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:59

Its not the amount its the attitude if my kid said I want that its only £60 I wouldn't be happy with them. Whether you're rich or not surely kids need to learn £60 is still a lot of money otherwise their going to be very disappointed when they get their job

Well if your child is saying they want stuff and doesn't see the value of money that's a parenting problem you've created and completely different to the question you asked.

Canape · Today 19:02

We bought our DS it for his birthday, he is mid 30s though, we always ask what he wants, though it was more than £60 it was about £90, we gave him the money to buy it as he said it was digital and it seemed easier that way, I would have probably cocked up the purchase. We usually spend about that for his present.

TwattyMcFuckFace · Today 19:02

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:00

You're not understanding what im writing

Oh I am.

And it's oozing judgement wrapped up in 'But I'm just curious'.

Maisymouse2 · Today 19:02

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:38

Its not about whether you can afford it or not its about teaching kids the value of money

Well it is.
Some of us choose to buy things for our children becajse we can afford it and do not see it as only bday or xmas.
I think that is stingy and mean.
Clothing only twice a year? Get real.
We craft and I rather spend on my family or nice sruff for the house than be out drinking it away like some parents.
People who game are gamers I pay for a subscription for my child..it is called living.
Enjoy your life Op have a happy day.

Tulipsriver · Today 19:03

Mine are far too young for GTA (and I know nothing about video games so I'm not sure whether it's appropriate for kids etc.), but if I had a child who had a keen interest in something that was being released for less than £100, I'd probably just buy it 🤷‍♀️

I wouldn't just buy them anything they said they wanted, but if it was something they were truly excited for, why not? If it was close to a birthday or Christmas I'd probably tell them it was an early present, but I don't think treating your children occasionally for no particular reason 'spoils' them.

theprincessthepea · Today 19:03

I don’t wait until Christmas for everything.

Firstly I don’t think Christmas and birthdays are the only time you should “have something”. Within reason I would buy what mine want if there is a benefit to it. I wouldn’t buy random junk, but there are some items I buy, but there are other things I say “it’s not urgent, you can either save up with your own money or maybe your birthday”.

I think games are different. Thankfully mine isn’t into GTA, but I can see why some parents would buy it.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:04

FurbySaysYummmm · Today 19:01

Well if your child is saying they want stuff and doesn't see the value of money that's a parenting problem you've created and completely different to the question you asked.

My kids would never ask me for a £60 computer game as they would know the answer. Im asking what other families do. Does your get just walk up to you and say i want gta its only £60 or do they say i want to earn some extra money as there is something i want to buy

OP posts:
BeanUiTayto · Today 19:04

A blanket 'no you can't have that' outside of birthdays and Christmas just seems really arbitrary and cheap to me, I don't buy my kid anything they ask for but also they have no means of getting something outside of through me. I don't think it's weird or greedy to want things and I don't think kids won't learn the meaning of money if they, from time to time, get something they want. I certainly don't wait till Christmas to get myself things I want and I don't think my kids are so different than me that it would spoil them if they got a video game (granted, not GTA)

ThatJadeLion · Today 19:04

I used to think exactly like this before I had kids