Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do parents just buy their kids stuff when they ask

268 replies

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 18:35

All this talk about gta and people being shocked the age parents are letting their kids play it im more shocked that parents are spending £60 on their children 4 weeks before Christmas just because they've asked for it. My kids rarely get anything over a tenner outside of Christmas or birthdays unless they actually need it.

OP posts:
Waitingfordoggo · Today 20:58

Crushed23 · Today 20:42

I count going to gigs as spending money on yourself! It’s where most of my disposable income goes. Do you take your children to the gigs with you?

Yes! They’re young adults. Going to gigs and festivals is one of our favourite things to do together as a family. The kids’ main present for Xmas this year is a family present- the four of us are going to see a show in London in January. We’ll make a day of it and have dinner in Covent Garden and a wander round the shops.

When they were younger, it wasn’t gigs but musicals, cinema, theatre etc. Maybe once or twice a year.

TheNinkyNonkyIsATardis · Today 21:00

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 20:28

Really I never felt like that i buy nice things as I earn the money I work for

Right, and what access do your kids have to money outside of you? Nothing.

They're not learning anything much by being told not until Christmas or birthday.

My 3yo knows that sometimes he can have some money. Sometimes he can take some money and treat his Nana to a coffee. Sometimes he can choose a present for mummy and think about what she likes for her birthday. He has five pounds, should he get one big toy or two little ones? Notes go in the piggy bank to save or can be swapped for pounds to take to the farm shop.

That's so much more to appreciating money than can be achieved by just a "not until Christmas" approach.

Bababear987 · Today 21:00

If you have the money why not? Life's for living, you spend a hell of a long time in life working and being unwell. So enjoy the time youve got.
I personally dont like games like GTA BUT if I have the money to pay bills, put extra into savings then surely the rest of your money is for enjoying/ recreation etc so why not give my kids something to make them happy? Its why we work surely?

Happyindevon · Today 21:01

TheNinkyNonkyIsATardis · Today 21:00

Right, and what access do your kids have to money outside of you? Nothing.

They're not learning anything much by being told not until Christmas or birthday.

My 3yo knows that sometimes he can have some money. Sometimes he can take some money and treat his Nana to a coffee. Sometimes he can choose a present for mummy and think about what she likes for her birthday. He has five pounds, should he get one big toy or two little ones? Notes go in the piggy bank to save or can be swapped for pounds to take to the farm shop.

That's so much more to appreciating money than can be achieved by just a "not until Christmas" approach.

Like a 3 year old is ‘appreciating money’ because of that 😆

Happyindevon · Today 21:04

Bababear987 · Today 21:00

If you have the money why not? Life's for living, you spend a hell of a long time in life working and being unwell. So enjoy the time youve got.
I personally dont like games like GTA BUT if I have the money to pay bills, put extra into savings then surely the rest of your money is for enjoying/ recreation etc so why not give my kids something to make them happy? Its why we work surely?

We often talk on here about kids with mental health issues and a lack of resilience and confidence, and how the framework that enabled them to develop these in the past has been whittled away.

So if they’re endlessly bought whatever they ask for, pandered to, driven to school, tracked via AirTag, waited on hand and foot, and have their parents intervene in every minutiae of their friendships and school life, how will they develop these qualities?

It seems everyone THINKS they should develop independence and resilience in a roundabout way but don’t actually want to DO anything that builds it because there’s always some excuse not to, and dismissiveness that ‘this 1 thing won’t lead to X or Y’ when it’s clearly part of a bigger picture.

TheNinkyNonkyIsATardis · Today 21:04

Happyindevon · Today 21:01

Like a 3 year old is ‘appreciating money’ because of that 😆

If you need it spelling out for you, these are steps and habits you build over time. I'm starting with a 3yo because I have a 3yo. I'm not waiting til he's older because kids don't magically acquire this stuff with age.

And since I explain to him that if he's, say, taking out all the tissues, that we will need to take some of his pound coins to replace them instead of spending them at the farm, and he immediately apologises and tidied the tissues up, yes, in his own tiny 3yo way he is getting it.

FKAT · Today 21:07

Some people's attitudes to their children are weird. "I will have four babies and love and nurture and want the best for them BUT THEY MUST ONLY HAVE NEW THINGS IN THE WINDOW DICTATED BY THE CHRISTIAN CALENDAR."

TiredShadows · Today 21:07

It's fairly normal for many kids to ask for things to ask for things throughout the year, especially if they are small. Some rarely do.

Mine lean towards the latter these days. When they were little, I would say 'should we add that to your wishlist' regularly though would buy or let them pick something out occasionally. Now, except for my youngest, they're fairly content and rarely ask - I have to remind them to update their wishlists now Even my youngest usually asks for particular occasions.

Only one of them has asked for something expensive that I've asked them to do housework in exchange for earning it, and that was because they asked how to earn it when they were 13 and their pocket money meant it would take them several months to get it.

I'm not against spending that much on my kids at any time of year, I can't think of any specific examples that aren't school or work related -- might have done it on books or craft gear. 18+ video games like GTA 6 are generally in the 'you can buy that for yourself if you want it' category. My kids who are old enough could afford that if they wanted to do so.

Its not about whether you can afford it or not its about teaching kids the value of money

I don't see how giving gifts only at particular times teaches the value of money. The value of time, of delayed gratification, of those traditions and how we prioritise them, very much so, but spending a lot on gifts only on birthdays or Christmas doesn't really teach anything about the value of money.

AlphabetMole · Today 21:08

Happyindevon · Today 20:49

But you’re just buying endless stuff. And then there will be something else you want. Surely you hit a ceiling where just buying more stuff isn’t needed?

Why shouldn't we buy some things we want? Tbh, I find the boundary between 'wants' and 'needs' blurred in many cases.

If I want to read a particular book, then yes, I suppose I could survive without reading it. I could survive in life without reading any books. But that would be a fairly impoverished life for me, given that I read a fair amount. So even though I don't 'need' new books, I don't view buying them as just 'buying endless stuff' either.

Both my DC are into certain crafts. They like buying new kits and materials for these. Again, strictly speaking a 'want' not a 'need'. But I'd be a poor parent imo not to encourage their creativity by buying them what they need when I can afford it. And you never know, they might turn their creative hobbies into a job later on in life.

If the baseline is simply food and a couple of sets of clothes, bills paid and a roof over our heads, then yes, I suppose we don't actually 'need' that much. But most of us aspire to some degree of self-actualisation beyond that (and the same for our children) and this will take different forms for different people. For some people, owning pets or horses, for others, playing boardgames and, for others, gaming or similar. Some people may simply express themselves through having lots of nice clothes. We are all wired differently.

Bababear987 · Today 21:10

Happyindevon · Today 20:46

Because the world isn’t like it was when you were young. If she gets a degree and can’t get a job (like so many on here), she won’t have any ground level skills to break into basic employment.

But thats the point surely.... kids who are capable should be studying for professional careers and doing things that might contribute to that.
What if youve a kid that is capable of being a doctor if they put a few more hours studying in or maybe a few hours volunteering in a nursing home etc but instead mum thinks they need to learn the value of money so she has you at the local supermarket instead 🤔

Now im not saying everyone is capable or even wants a professional career BUT its better to work towards something like that surely? Why put a kid of 16 to work earning minimum wage, what's the benefit? Get them to uni first then maybe worry about a minimum wage job for pocket money? But at 16 or so, focus should be on studying and enjoying life.

Happyindevon · Today 21:10

AlphabetMole · Today 21:08

Why shouldn't we buy some things we want? Tbh, I find the boundary between 'wants' and 'needs' blurred in many cases.

If I want to read a particular book, then yes, I suppose I could survive without reading it. I could survive in life without reading any books. But that would be a fairly impoverished life for me, given that I read a fair amount. So even though I don't 'need' new books, I don't view buying them as just 'buying endless stuff' either.

Both my DC are into certain crafts. They like buying new kits and materials for these. Again, strictly speaking a 'want' not a 'need'. But I'd be a poor parent imo not to encourage their creativity by buying them what they need when I can afford it. And you never know, they might turn their creative hobbies into a job later on in life.

If the baseline is simply food and a couple of sets of clothes, bills paid and a roof over our heads, then yes, I suppose we don't actually 'need' that much. But most of us aspire to some degree of self-actualisation beyond that (and the same for our children) and this will take different forms for different people. For some people, owning pets or horses, for others, playing boardgames and, for others, gaming or similar. Some people may simply express themselves through having lots of nice clothes. We are all wired differently.

Consumerism. Materialism. So much of it will just go in the landfill. It takes energy to create and transport. Do we NEED more tat shops? I say no.

underthehawthorntree · Today 21:11

@Crushed23I don't have teenagers so I can't really comment on what I would do for my own teenagers but I do think I would buy them the odd pair of trainers so that they fit in with their friends. I would also consider buying them a hotly anticipated computer game but probably not one which normalises misogyny and violence like GTA does...but thats a whole different thread.

FWIW though that's not the only discussion that's been had on this thread.

Happyindevon · Today 21:11

Bababear987 · Today 21:10

But thats the point surely.... kids who are capable should be studying for professional careers and doing things that might contribute to that.
What if youve a kid that is capable of being a doctor if they put a few more hours studying in or maybe a few hours volunteering in a nursing home etc but instead mum thinks they need to learn the value of money so she has you at the local supermarket instead 🤔

Now im not saying everyone is capable or even wants a professional career BUT its better to work towards something like that surely? Why put a kid of 16 to work earning minimum wage, what's the benefit? Get them to uni first then maybe worry about a minimum wage job for pocket money? But at 16 or so, focus should be on studying and enjoying life.

The doctors I know all had Saturday jobs!

Being clever and getting a respected degree isn’t enough any more. If that’s all you have at 22 or 23, you’re buggered really, unless it’s in a very specific industry like medicine.

Redpaisley · Today 21:11

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 19:04

My kids would never ask me for a £60 computer game as they would know the answer. Im asking what other families do. Does your get just walk up to you and say i want gta its only £60 or do they say i want to earn some extra money as there is something i want to buy

How do you know other people's children are saying 'it's only £60?'

IglesiasPiggl · Today 21:12

I buy my DC things as treats, especially, say, for Feb half-term when the weather is rubbish, or during the summer holidays. I wouldn't get them a big expensive thing like a bike or PC, but smaller stuff up to about £50 I do. Both their birthdays are in December so we don't do the whole "only for birthday or Christmas" thing - that leaves the whole year empty!

SunnyWasp · Today 21:14

Growing up my mum and dad were quite generous with things each week/ month. Like I could get a new book most weeks and we would go shopping every couple of months for a few new seasonal clothes. When I turned 13 my mum would give me my child benefit as pocket money and I had to budget that to buy my clothes and do things with friends like cinema etc.

but come Christmas/ birthday I wouldn’t get loads of stuff compared to friends. I remember noticing that difference but also realising it was because we had things spread out more throughout the year.

I do similar with my children now. They are only 4 and 18 months but I’ve only spent about £30 on my eldest for Christmas and it’s all second hand. Even less on my youngest as he will mainly get her hand me down toys etc. they will get bits from family etc too. I spend more on them on a monthly basis on days out, clubs, seasonal clothes etc.

I’m sure it will change as they start asking for more specific things but I hope to continue this way for a while as growing up I preferred that spreading out of ‘stuff’ than two massive events and nothing in between.

Sparklebutt321 · Today 21:15

My kid asks for stuff in museums or expensive places and I'll just take a photo and say we will buy it for their birthday/Xmas. Sometimes I go home and find it on vinted! If we are in a charity shop then I'll usually say yes to books or a random teddy/toy. Yes to a random nice t shirt for £5 in Asda once in a while or a small toy/craft set in the works. If there is something wanted badly it's normally a hobby type thing not just random buying. I will buy stickers/pens/colouring books and paint etc on a regular basis without being asked. Also sometimes spontaneously buy new board games for £2 on vinted for us to play with.

Crushed23 · Today 21:15

underthehawthorntree · Today 21:11

@Crushed23I don't have teenagers so I can't really comment on what I would do for my own teenagers but I do think I would buy them the odd pair of trainers so that they fit in with their friends. I would also consider buying them a hotly anticipated computer game but probably not one which normalises misogyny and violence like GTA does...but thats a whole different thread.

FWIW though that's not the only discussion that's been had on this thread.

Then we’re in agreement. 😊

I just can’t imagine buying myself gig tickets or getting my hair highlighted, but having a “Christmas and birthdays only” rule with my kids.

(I don’t actually have kids but, you know, hypothetically!)

New posts on this thread. Refresh page