Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these A Level choices are actually fine?

170 replies

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 12:57

Also posted on Education board but know there's more traffic here.

DS is applying to 6th forms and these are his choices.

English Lit
Drama
Film Studies
Dance

He originally wanted to do English Lit, Drama, History and Politics but the option blocks at his preferred school don't allow it.

He was really disappointed at first but has since been to presentations on Dance and Film studies and is excited about both.

He has done Drama at GCSE.

The only other one he would consider is religious studies.

He is predicted mostly 7s and 8s for GCSE for all subjects.

I'm coming across quite a lot of snobbery from family on these A Level choices though.

Are they that bad?

Any suggestions of possible degree paths?

All he fancies at the moment is something in publishing.

Thanks ☺️

OP posts:
GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 13:10

These choices will rule out many careers and Russell Group unis.
Take more traditional subjects.
It's not snobbery. It's good sense.

Octavia64 · Yesterday 13:12

Very theatre focused.

if he wants that fine, but kids who want to go into performing arts generally know that is what they are aiming for.

MatildaTheCat · Yesterday 13:13

That’s very arts heavy especially if he isn’t interested in pursuing a career in that area.

I might encourage him to take history and drop film studies. Film can be watched, learned about and enjoyed at any time.

lizzyBennet08 · Yesterday 13:13

It would be a no from me as well, Too limiting as this stage when he is not 100% sure what he would like to do.

LividClouds · Yesterday 13:15

MatildaTheCat · Yesterday 13:13

That’s very arts heavy especially if he isn’t interested in pursuing a career in that area.

I might encourage him to take history and drop film studies. Film can be watched, learned about and enjoyed at any time.

And history can't?

Fieldmiceears · Yesterday 13:16

English Lit, Drama, History and Politics

What were the blocks?

This is a good combo.

He can pick 1 of drama, dance and film.
If he switches the drama does that open up the history and politics?

And, there are plenty of extracurriculars in dance and drama, would you fund and taxi him to those?

BirdLandedonmyHead · Yesterday 13:17

What does the school advise about the workload for the combination?

BusyGreySnail · Yesterday 13:18

Well unless he is very focused on a career in performing arts then this seems like a career limiting choice of subjects.

twinkletwinkleatthebar · Yesterday 13:19

Im assuming he’ll drop one of those at the end of yr12. Do you know which one that’s likely to be?

ZippyKoala · Yesterday 13:20

These choices are totally fine if they are what he wants to do and leads down a career path he is interested in (and can realistically pursue).

But English Lit, History, Politics and Drama (substituting film studies or dance for drama as preferred) is definitely a broader choice with one more options going forward and will make getting a university place easier. If he wants to try publishing for example, other essay based subjects will be a real advantage.

It should be his choice but I would be looking for ways to make his original options work if at all possible.

EmuCrossing · Yesterday 13:20

What does he /really/ want to do in the future? He says publishing - which is where my friend with an art degree ended up - but have him think more widely too.

if he is essentially a creative/arts/theatre kid and wants to go down that pathway - fine.

if he wants a more ‘serious’ career/degree he will struggle to get a place without swapping one of the film/drama/dance for a more academic option.

And ask him iIf he really does want to go to uni anyway. If he wants to dive straight into work instead, then it’s not likely to matter quite as much and he is more able to do whatever he’d find interesting.

HeddaGarbled · Yesterday 13:20

I know two young people who did English & Drama combined degrees at a Russell group uni. One now works as a copywriter and the other in digital journalism.

I understand PPs’ concerns, but I think the Eng Lit keeps this pathway open.

HardShoulders · Yesterday 13:21

It’s not ‘snobbery’, it’s common sense! Those choices are needlessly restrictive. If his preferred school won’t let him do the subject combination he actually wants, then choose another school that does.

TheTortiePuffinNeedsHerBreakfast · Yesterday 13:22

So he's replaced history and politics, 2 well respected academic subjects, with dance and film studies.
That's a huge compromise just for timetabling reasons. If he's interested in publishing, history and politics are way better choices.

Bushmillsbabe · Yesterday 13:22

What would he like to do career wise?
English lit, plus one of the other 3, plus another more traditional subject would be better I think. How about Geography, or a language?

English lit, drama and film studies
have a lot of overlap, with English lit covering theory/analysis of plays and drama being the practical side of the plays, and film studies being close to drama. It doesn't show a breadth of skill and knowledge.

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:22

He is focused on a career in the arts, not necessarily performance based.

He has no desire to do anything Maths or Science related.

English Literature degree at York (7th in the country) for example has entry requirements of AAA or A*AB. Needs A in English Lit but no other subject requirements.

He already does performing arts outside school and yes we taxi him everywhere 😅

English Lit and History are in the same block
Drama and Politics are in the same block.

English Lit and Drama are his top predicted GCSE grades so it's a no trainer on that front.

OP posts:
Mushypeasandchipstogo · Yesterday 13:22

It would be a no from me too. (I’m a retired 6th form tutor.) I’m afraid that most good universities would not consider him with those A’level choices. Could he swap Film Studies for History?

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:23

*brainer (ironic)

OP posts:
BirdLandedonmyHead · Yesterday 13:24

Does he have dance lessons?

twinkletwinkleatthebar · Yesterday 13:26

The other thing to consider is, is he a skilled dancer so likely to have the ability to achieve high grades?

If he’s confident that he wants to do English / English and drama at uni then English Lit, Drama and film or dance would be fine.

witheringrowan · Yesterday 13:26

Unless there is a huge difference in teaching quality, wouldn't it make more sense to look for a 6th form where he could take his preferred subject combination?

I would have thought there would usually be a fair amount of overlap in students wanting to do History & English Lit, it seems very odd not to be able to do both.

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:27

EmuCrossing · Yesterday 13:20

What does he /really/ want to do in the future? He says publishing - which is where my friend with an art degree ended up - but have him think more widely too.

if he is essentially a creative/arts/theatre kid and wants to go down that pathway - fine.

if he wants a more ‘serious’ career/degree he will struggle to get a place without swapping one of the film/drama/dance for a more academic option.

And ask him iIf he really does want to go to uni anyway. If he wants to dive straight into work instead, then it’s not likely to matter quite as much and he is more able to do whatever he’d find interesting.

By serious career what do you mean? The only things that springs to mind for me would be medicine.

He is definitely an arts kid.

He definitely wants to go to uni.

He has applied to a performing arts college as a back up but would prefer to do A Levels and should get the grades to do so.

OP posts:
RNApolymerase · Yesterday 13:28

Why has he picked four when unis only need 3?

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:28

BirdLandedonmyHead · Yesterday 13:24

Does he have dance lessons?

Yes. He's been doing Ballroom, Latin, Street and Commercial since he was 5. The lack of ballet is apparently not an issue for this A Level according to several teachers at different schools.

OP posts:
Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:29

RNApolymerase · Yesterday 13:28

Why has he picked four when unis only need 3?

Quite standard to pick 4 and drop one

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread