Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these A Level choices are actually fine?

170 replies

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 12:57

Also posted on Education board but know there's more traffic here.

DS is applying to 6th forms and these are his choices.

English Lit
Drama
Film Studies
Dance

He originally wanted to do English Lit, Drama, History and Politics but the option blocks at his preferred school don't allow it.

He was really disappointed at first but has since been to presentations on Dance and Film studies and is excited about both.

He has done Drama at GCSE.

The only other one he would consider is religious studies.

He is predicted mostly 7s and 8s for GCSE for all subjects.

I'm coming across quite a lot of snobbery from family on these A Level choices though.

Are they that bad?

Any suggestions of possible degree paths?

All he fancies at the moment is something in publishing.

Thanks ☺️

OP posts:
Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:30

Just to confirm we have been to all the 6th form open evenings and he is set on this school. He wasn't keen on others for various reasons.

I think he has genuinely gone off History (politics to a lesser extent) and would now prefer these choices.

OP posts:
WearingBeautifulShoes · Yesterday 13:31

Presumably he will drop one at the end of year 12. Otherwise I think that would be A LOT of course work which might impact on his actual grades, which are more important than the actual subjects.

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 13:31

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:27

By serious career what do you mean? The only things that springs to mind for me would be medicine.

He is definitely an arts kid.

He definitely wants to go to uni.

He has applied to a performing arts college as a back up but would prefer to do A Levels and should get the grades to do so.

What if he wants to do law? Many people who want a creative career change their minds later. Too early to narrow your choices so much
Baffling that he can't do History and English Lit or Geography.

Mosaic123 · Yesterday 13:34

He needs to do another traditional subject . English is one. Religious Studies may be seen as more intellectually rigorous. Can he drop one of dance or drama in its favour?

BirdLandedonmyHead · Yesterday 13:35

He knows what HE wants then. Despite what orhers nay think, they are proper qualifications. (As are T Levels, V Levels and BTECs).

RNApolymerase · Yesterday 13:35

WearingBeautifulShoes · Yesterday 13:31

Presumably he will drop one at the end of year 12. Otherwise I think that would be A LOT of course work which might impact on his actual grades, which are more important than the actual subjects.

That was my thought. The coursework load could be huge.

oviraptor21 · Yesterday 13:36

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:22

He is focused on a career in the arts, not necessarily performance based.

He has no desire to do anything Maths or Science related.

English Literature degree at York (7th in the country) for example has entry requirements of AAA or A*AB. Needs A in English Lit but no other subject requirements.

He already does performing arts outside school and yes we taxi him everywhere 😅

English Lit and History are in the same block
Drama and Politics are in the same block.

English Lit and Drama are his top predicted GCSE grades so it's a no trainer on that front.

I'd be changing sixth form if English Lit and History are only in one and the same block. That's ridiculous.

C8H10N4O2 · Yesterday 13:36

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:22

He is focused on a career in the arts, not necessarily performance based.

He has no desire to do anything Maths or Science related.

English Literature degree at York (7th in the country) for example has entry requirements of AAA or A*AB. Needs A in English Lit but no other subject requirements.

He already does performing arts outside school and yes we taxi him everywhere 😅

English Lit and History are in the same block
Drama and Politics are in the same block.

English Lit and Drama are his top predicted GCSE grades so it's a no trainer on that front.

English and History is such a common combination (and accepted by good unis) that it seems odd to have them in one block. Does the school offer more than one syllabus with the second being in a different block? Its not snobbery to recommend at least two trad subjects if going for an RG.

York may not specify the subjects outside of English Lit but check what they actually accepted in recent years - they may be simply making their offers to more traditional subject combinations. York used to have a good rep for media studies and related but don't know about it in recent years.

Publishing is still largely the domain of the wealthy and connected - do you have connections? If not keep him looking at a wide range of options. I know at least one young adult who found their way into performing arts via the business route - being able to run a business with knowledge of arts organisations opened a few doors.

AlexandraCarrington · Yesterday 13:38

I would have thought there would usually be a fair amount of overlap in students wanting to do History & English Lit, it seems very odd not to be able to do both.

Agree, it does seem odd. History and Eng Lit were by far the two subjects I was best suited to. I don't know what I would have done if I couldn't do both.

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:39

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 13:31

What if he wants to do law? Many people who want a creative career change their minds later. Too early to narrow your choices so much
Baffling that he can't do History and English Lit or Geography.

So I keep using Uni of York as an example but for Law there the entry requirement is AAA - No specified subjects.

I really do think that apart from some obvious Maths or Science based degrees Unis, even the good ones look more at Grades than subjects. Things have changed.

Better to get an A in dance than a D in Spanish for example.

OP posts:
ElizaSchuyler · Yesterday 13:39

I think that Film Studies doesn't add anything and woud suggest that one was dropped as too much overlap but other than that it is fine.

Yes it is specialising but it's no different than doing an Extended Btec in Performing Arts.

Choices of degree may be limited but let's face it, he's never going to apply for a maths or science degree is he? (though to be fair my dancer daughter is now studying sports science after doing a foundation year to catch up on the science.)

ElizaSchuyler · Yesterday 13:40

Several years ago someone did a FOI request and for law the ost common A level for those accepted to a course in Russell group universities was drama. Many universities will specify at least one essay or humanities subject, English Lit fulfuls that requirement.

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 13:41

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:39

So I keep using Uni of York as an example but for Law there the entry requirement is AAA - No specified subjects.

I really do think that apart from some obvious Maths or Science based degrees Unis, even the good ones look more at Grades than subjects. Things have changed.

Better to get an A in dance than a D in Spanish for example.

Even if they don't specify subjects, Russell Group unis prefer traditional essay based subjects for law.

Law is very competitive. They will not take someone who has done film studies. It's an unspoken preference.

twinkletwinkleatthebar · Yesterday 13:42

Mushypeasandchipstogo · Yesterday 13:22

It would be a no from me too. (I’m a retired 6th form tutor.) I’m afraid that most good universities would not consider him with those A’level choices. Could he swap Film Studies for History?

Edited

I’ve just had a look at entry requirements for Manchester, Warwick and Birmingham for English literature. Just like York, English literature + any others would be fine. It’s the grades that are important.

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:43

He will drop either Film Studies or Dance by Christmas of Y12.

OP posts:
twinkletwinkleatthebar · Yesterday 13:43

ElizaSchuyler · Yesterday 13:40

Several years ago someone did a FOI request and for law the ost common A level for those accepted to a course in Russell group universities was drama. Many universities will specify at least one essay or humanities subject, English Lit fulfuls that requirement.

But you’re not going to convince people by using facts!

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 13:44

twinkletwinkleatthebar · Yesterday 13:42

I’ve just had a look at entry requirements for Manchester, Warwick and Birmingham for English literature. Just like York, English literature + any others would be fine. It’s the grades that are important.

Many unis do not ask for FM for Economics. In practice, they prefer students who have taken FM.

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:44

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 13:41

Even if they don't specify subjects, Russell Group unis prefer traditional essay based subjects for law.

Law is very competitive. They will not take someone who has done film studies. It's an unspoken preference.

Can't see him wanting to do Law. It's just not him.

OP posts:
Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:45

And to echo a previous poster one thing I do know is that Law degrees LOVE drama A Level.

OP posts:
witheringrowan · Yesterday 13:45

Has he looked at this https://www.informedchoices.ac.uk/start which should help to think about if his choices would narrow university options too much? Academic rigour aside, there is a lot of overlap between his four choices which will limit him if he has a change of heart about his direction later.

Universities no longer publish their "Facilitating Subjects" list, which were supposed to be those that keep the widest range of options open, but top tier of subjects were Maths, English Lit & Lang, Physics, Chemistry, Biology, Geography, History, and any Language. Next step down would be things like Economics, Politics, Religious Studies, Philosophy, Art, Music, Classical Civilisation - still fairly traditional. If he has too many subjects outside of these groupings, he will find his university choices are narrower. This guide might also be useful: https://www.kes.net/files/cms/7_Considering-university-courses-when-choosing-A-Level-options.pdf

What was it that attracted him to History & Politics in the first place? Has he looked at options for Philosophy or ClassCiv instead?

Pick a route | Informed Choices

What you study at sixth form or college can affect your options at university and your future career. Use Informed Choices to help you understand which subjects open up different degrees, particularly at Russell Group universities.

https://www.informedchoices.ac.uk/start

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 13:46

Publishing these days employs economics and history grads too. And as a pp said, is mostly through connections. Those will be his competitors.

ExOptimist · Yesterday 13:47

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 13:39

So I keep using Uni of York as an example but for Law there the entry requirement is AAA - No specified subjects.

I really do think that apart from some obvious Maths or Science based degrees Unis, even the good ones look more at Grades than subjects. Things have changed.

Better to get an A in dance than a D in Spanish for example.

Law always has many more applications than places, from pupils who will attain the highest grades.

Do you really believe that admissions staff will view someone predicted all As in Eng Lit, Dance and Film Studies in exactly the same way as someone doing Eng Lit, History and French for example? Answer - they won't.

Autumnallaround · Yesterday 13:47

I have a DC who wants to be in film. Writing screenplays, acting, directing etc.
He is doing BTEC theatre arts (2 ALevels equiv) and film studies.

But he does have a planned career path of sorts from it.

ElizaSchuyler · Yesterday 13:47

twinkletwinkleatthebar · Yesterday 13:43

But you’re not going to convince people by using facts!

York was actually one of the universities surveyed as well.

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 13:47

I think you might want to move this to Higher Education which has many posters who actually work in unis. And more specific advice.

Swipe left for the next trending thread