Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these A Level choices are actually fine?

170 replies

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 12:57

Also posted on Education board but know there's more traffic here.

DS is applying to 6th forms and these are his choices.

English Lit
Drama
Film Studies
Dance

He originally wanted to do English Lit, Drama, History and Politics but the option blocks at his preferred school don't allow it.

He was really disappointed at first but has since been to presentations on Dance and Film studies and is excited about both.

He has done Drama at GCSE.

The only other one he would consider is religious studies.

He is predicted mostly 7s and 8s for GCSE for all subjects.

I'm coming across quite a lot of snobbery from family on these A Level choices though.

Are they that bad?

Any suggestions of possible degree paths?

All he fancies at the moment is something in publishing.

Thanks ☺️

OP posts:
Genevieva · Yesterday 17:02

ColinISabirthdaycake · Yesterday 16:58

I also don't understand why people look down on politics and media studies.

We'd be in a much better place if more people did them!

Politics isn’t looked down on, but Media Studies is seen as a bit easy. That said, I don’t think most universities care. I know a child studying for a traditional heavy weight essay based degree at a Russell Group university with A levels in English, Media Studies and Business Studies.

ColinISabirthdaycake · Yesterday 17:03

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 14:42

He doesn't want to do the STEM subjects and would therefore drop them or not get a good grade.

How is that a better bet than doing subjects he enjoys and should get good grades in?

That's what I don't get.

Is there any Uni or employer out there who would think a D in Maths is better than an A In film studies.

I'm with you on that, the emphasis on STEM makes no sense - we can't all be good at Maths and science and I'm not!

cantkeepawayforever · Yesterday 17:05

It is worth looking at the college’s results across all the subjects being considered, and compare them with other local offerings. Are you in the sort of area where everyone leaves school for 6th form colleges that offer both vocational and academic pathways? Or is there a mix of ‘school 6th forms’ (usually more academic) and colleges (usually more vocational)?

It sounds as if your DS is a smart, reasonably academic boy. It can be that options like dance, and sometimes drama, can be taken by students who are slightly less academic, and thus the staff are used to teaching to the ‘mid / lower’ grades rather than having a group who are pushing for the highest A / A* grades. That can be limiting to someone who has the potential to reach that grade.

While one if my DC’s did their ‘performance’ subject for A level (granted, theirs was a subject that is also regarded as ‘academically hard), the other did theirs to a very, very high extracurricular level (vocational school standard) but did not take it as a school exam subject, mostly because it tended to be targeted at lower academic attainers and thus would have been hard to get a great grade in.

Blackcat2026 · Yesterday 17:06

ExOptimist · Yesterday 13:47

Law always has many more applications than places, from pupils who will attain the highest grades.

Do you really believe that admissions staff will view someone predicted all As in Eng Lit, Dance and Film Studies in exactly the same way as someone doing Eng Lit, History and French for example? Answer - they won't.

Even if they do, good luck getting a job in law afterwards!

One vocational subject is fine, I think, but I wouldn't focus on three!

Glowingup · Yesterday 17:06

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 17:02

It's unis who do. Not us 'snobby' people. They may say ' we accept any a- levels". on their websites. In reality, many prefer traditional subjects, or at least two traditional subjects. That's all some of us are saying.

Most don't care really. Once you have a degree, employers don't tend to give a shit either (grades, yes, for some jobs, subjects, no).

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 17:10

Glowingup · Yesterday 17:06

Most don't care really. Once you have a degree, employers don't tend to give a shit either (grades, yes, for some jobs, subjects, no).

I couldn't disagree more. That's not to say OPs son has to do maths or physics.

But just one more slightly traditional arts subject will keep options open. Most 16- year-olds can't see their whole futures.

BusMumsHoliday · Yesterday 17:10

I teach a humanities subject in a university - not RG but research focussed, top 30 for English, History, similar.

Film studies and Drama both require written essays so I'd have no issues admitting a student who had those. It's an absolute buyers' market even for RG universities at the moment: universities are dropping offer grades all over the shop because they need students through the door. If he's aiming for Oxbridge or Durham English then maybe he'd want another traditional subject, but even then, I wouldn't be really concerned. Most English lecturers have a higher opinion of Film Studies than most Mumsnet posters who think because it's about a popular media form then it's easy.

Your DS should do subjects he's talented at and enjoys. We literally have no idea what skills will be valuable in ten years time.

Glowingup · Yesterday 17:11

Also, just saying, most unis are currently suffering from a major funding crisis and are focusing heavily on undergraduate recruitment. Subjects like law are taking up to 750 students per cohort when in the past this used to be about 300. The days of most RGs being overly picky about subject choices are gone. At my RG, nobody from law even looks at the applications. It is all handled by a central admissions team.

Mossyfox · Yesterday 17:12

I don't think that is a good choice at all. He needs to do 2 serious subjects.

Glowingup · Yesterday 17:13

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 17:10

I couldn't disagree more. That's not to say OPs son has to do maths or physics.

But just one more slightly traditional arts subject will keep options open. Most 16- year-olds can't see their whole futures.

You think that someone who eg has a first in Law from York and AAA at A-level will be rejected on the basis that their A-level subjects weren't the right ones?

BusMumsHoliday · Yesterday 17:14

taxi4ballet · Yesterday 16:09

How is he going to read literature, watch films, dance works and plays, interpret the creator's intentions and the meanings behind them, and then use that knowledge to creat his own original works if he's not interested in the human condition and why people think and behave the way they do?

It's a pretty different skill set! Psychology is about setting up experiments to test hypotheses and analysing data that result from them. Or I guess at A level about learning how other people do this. It's not the same as learning about the human condition through works of literature, which involves the analysis of texts in dialogue with their contexts. It's why psychologists don't tend to teach in English depts.

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 17:14

Glowingup · Yesterday 17:11

Also, just saying, most unis are currently suffering from a major funding crisis and are focusing heavily on undergraduate recruitment. Subjects like law are taking up to 750 students per cohort when in the past this used to be about 300. The days of most RGs being overly picky about subject choices are gone. At my RG, nobody from law even looks at the applications. It is all handled by a central admissions team.

Well, that's true, I guess.

Jigsawfun · Yesterday 17:16

Too similar. What degree would they work for? Find out now not when it is too late.

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 17:16

Glowingup · Yesterday 17:13

You think that someone who eg has a first in Law from York and AAA at A-level will be rejected on the basis that their A-level subjects weren't the right ones?

I think Dance is unlikely to help anyone get a first in Law at York. History or Geography or even Sociology will.

Glowingup · Yesterday 17:20

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 17:16

I think Dance is unlikely to help anyone get a first in Law at York. History or Geography or even Sociology will.

Edited

What do you mean? They'd get AAA in their A-levels. Then they would attend York.

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 17:22

Glowingup · Yesterday 17:20

What do you mean? They'd get AAA in their A-levels. Then they would attend York.

Edited my post.

Inthemiddleofthenightagain · Yesterday 17:22

Many universities these days will automatically make offers without looking at the subjects, by accumulating the predicted UCAS points and basing the decision on the total. All A levels subjects obviously have the same number of points each. (One of the reasons I know this is because I worked in kne and had to specify the code to do this).
I say many, it's possible some are more nuanced but most don't have the time and staff to dissect each application individually to that extent.
You could try asking asking them but might not get a proper reply due to staffing (again) or them needing to allow to look at individual applications in detail if they really want or need to soothe won't commit to a 100% reply.

BusMumsHoliday · Yesterday 17:26

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 17:16

I think Dance is unlikely to help anyone get a first in Law at York. History or Geography or even Sociology will.

Edited

But this student is also doing English and Drama, both of which involve analysing text, synthesizing research across sources, taking a position and finding evidence to support it, and writing argumentative essays. All the skills for a law degree. So they actually don't need another subject that does the same.

I know several barristers who have Drama A levels. Dance is also about telling stories. Law is sometimes about putting the facts into the most compelling story, and convincing someone else of that. I don't understand how Geography helps with that.

Glowingup · Yesterday 17:28

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 17:16

I think Dance is unlikely to help anyone get a first in Law at York. History or Geography or even Sociology will.

Edited

I can promise you that what subjects you study at A level have little to no correlation to how well you are likely to do in your degree. I have seen people from a range of backgrounds including those with no A-levels at all do very well in a law degree.

PrincessRG · Yesterday 17:35

It’s a shame the way they work the actual blocks for him here.
Sorting this out for students is my DH’s actual job and he will make the blocks fit whatever the students want to do, not the students fit the blocks, and work silly hours to do so. I think there’s been about half a dozen in 10 years he hasn’t been able to let the student do what they want.

godmum56 · Yesterday 17:38

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 12:57

Also posted on Education board but know there's more traffic here.

DS is applying to 6th forms and these are his choices.

English Lit
Drama
Film Studies
Dance

He originally wanted to do English Lit, Drama, History and Politics but the option blocks at his preferred school don't allow it.

He was really disappointed at first but has since been to presentations on Dance and Film studies and is excited about both.

He has done Drama at GCSE.

The only other one he would consider is religious studies.

He is predicted mostly 7s and 8s for GCSE for all subjects.

I'm coming across quite a lot of snobbery from family on these A Level choices though.

Are they that bad?

Any suggestions of possible degree paths?

All he fancies at the moment is something in publishing.

Thanks ☺️

would there be a business focussed option he could do maybe instead of film studies? There are lots of film and stage focussed jobs that are not acting and something businessy (or maybe tech) could be a better option for a profession?

twinkletwinkleatthebar · Yesterday 17:38

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 17:16

I think Dance is unlikely to help anyone get a first in Law at York. History or Geography or even Sociology will.

Edited

“Even sociology”. Why did that require an “even”?

taxi4ballet · Yesterday 17:48

BusMumsHoliday · Yesterday 17:14

It's a pretty different skill set! Psychology is about setting up experiments to test hypotheses and analysing data that result from them. Or I guess at A level about learning how other people do this. It's not the same as learning about the human condition through works of literature, which involves the analysis of texts in dialogue with their contexts. It's why psychologists don't tend to teach in English depts.

Presumably the study of psychology involves learning about why society and individuals think and behave the way they do. I didn't say it was the same as learning about the human condition through works of literature.

What I meant was that an understanding of psychology would be a useful asset to have when you are creating your own works of literature, dance, drama or film, and would also help you to understand and interpret the works of others.

Botheredbewildered26 · Yesterday 17:48

GartredGrenvile · Yesterday 13:10

These choices will rule out many careers and Russell Group unis.
Take more traditional subjects.
It's not snobbery. It's good sense.

Edited

That’s crap- I know a kid who went to Oxbridge with Lit and Film. To do a Lit degree at a ‘Russell group’ university these would be fine.
also, ‘Russell group’ universities- such a load of rubbish. My DS went to one where he had black mould on his halls walls, hundreds of kids in his lectures. They’re sacking lecturers left right and centre

Wanttobeok · Yesterday 18:03

Stepped away for a bit as I was getting a bit stressed thinking I'm doing him a disservice by letting him make these choices but have come back to a few more people thinking these choices are absolutely fine. I feel a bit better now so thanks 😊

I never made a connection between psychology and the others but basically any science even social sciences just don't interest him in terms of a subject to study at a level.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread